Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., November 14, 2006 Cheshvan 23, 5767 | | Israel Time: 11:24 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A change of direction on Assad
By Haaretz Editorial

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and U.S. President George W. Bush will meet at the White House in Washington on Monday. Their meeting will be a good opportunity for Olmert to announce that he is calling on Syrian President Bashar Assad to begin immediate negotiations for peace with Israel. Since the cease-fire in Lebanon went into effect three months ago, Assad has repeatedly declared his intention to renew peace talks with Israel in order to return the Golan Heights to Syria. His offers were accompanied by threats from Damascus that the Golan would be liberated with violence if a deal is not reached.

Olmert outrightly rejected Assad's calls, and made the following arguments to defend his position: the Golan Heights should remain in Israel's control; Syria will not expel from its territory the Palestinian terrorist headquarters or cease arming Hezbollah, even after it gets back the Golan; talks with Assad will result in international pressure on Israel to hold talks with Hamas; if negotiations fail, and it is fair to assume that they will, the likelihood of war will increase.

Olmert is not alone in this view: a Haaretz-Dialog poll published Friday showed that only 16 percent of the public support talks with Syria. The American administration, which in the past showed great interest in a Syrian-Israeli agreement, is now boycotting Assad.

Advertisement

Accompanying these arguments is the Israel Defense Forces assessment that Syria will begin a war against Israel in the coming summer. Under such circumstances, the supreme obligation of the national leadership is to exhaust the diplomatic options and prevent war, which will have no benefit to Israel. The war will only claim lives and unnecessary destruction on both sides, and at its conclusion, deliberations on "removing the cause for war" and returning the Golan to the Syrians will be resumed.

Since coming to power, Olmert has expressed his hesitation in negotiating with Syria and the Palestinians. But his justifications regarding the Palestinians that "there is no partner" and no responsible government do not apply to Syria. The regime in Damascus is not friendly to Israel, and maintains close ties with some of its bitter enemies, but there is no doubt that it holds power in Syria and maintains with diligence the agreement over the disengagement of forces on the Golan Heights. Despite his strategic alliance with Iran, Assad is not party to calls of Israel's destruction by Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, but is calling for dialogue and an agreement.

The outright rejection of peace offers from Syria without seeking clarifications and holding an in-depth discussion is irresponsible and an invitation for the next war. The price of an agreement with the Syrians, a withdrawal from the Golan Heights, is known and difficult for Israelis to accept. But Olmert has not even carried out minimal diplomatic clarifications or presentation of Israel's legitimate demands over water arrangements, security and normalization, as was done by the five prime ministers preceding him, who negotiated with Assad's father. The prime minister's upcoming visit to the United States is a good opportunity to change his approach and take the initiative, of course, based on prior coordination with leaders of the American administration.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Whitman to Woolf
Author Michael Cunningham's new novel depicts America in a post-September 11 world.
Outside the box
The planning of a new neighborhood within an existing city is not a simple task.
  1.   SINIORA the Syrian flunky got the "goodwill" rolling by refusing. 08:58  |  PETER SM 07/11/06
  2.   King Hussein of Jordan 09:13  |  Maral 07/11/06
  3.   About that poll 09:17  |  Maral 07/11/06
  4.   Do it now before it is too late 09:29  |  Khalil Ishabib 07/11/06
  5.   http://islam-in-israel.blogspot.com 09:56  |  Islam In Israel 07/11/06
  6.   Peter SM, that`s not true! 09:56  |  Maral 07/11/06
  7.   Peace with Syria 09:56  |  An Arab Neighbor 07/11/06
  8.   PETER SM #1 10:08  |  Andrew Watson 07/11/06
  9.   To #1 Peter 10:11  |  An Arab Neighbor 07/11/06
  10.   Israel and peace don`t go together 10:13  |  Andrew Watson 07/11/06
  11.   MARAL.We will have to agree to disagree. 10:18  |  PETER SM 07/11/06
  12.   No Peter, that`s not it it means 10:29  |  Maral 07/11/06
  13.   #9, Arab neighbour 10:31  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 07/11/06
  14.   Good luck 10:34  |  Natallie Durson 07/11/06
  15.   #4 Khalil Ishabib 10:37  |  Daniel 07/11/06
  16.   Andrew Watson.1.5 million Moslems worship in Israel v`s Jews in 10:45  |  PETER SM 07/11/06
  17.   One of the 16% 10:47  |  Bracha 07/11/06
  18.   Spot on - talk! 10:59  |  Shlomissimo 07/11/06
  19.   Maral 11:02  |  PETER SM 07/11/06
  20.   it is naive to think that there can be peace with syria at this t 11:11  |  zionist forever 07/11/06
  21.   All We are Saying.... Is Give Peace a Chance... 11:17  |  Klaudia 07/11/06
  22.   Maral 11:22  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 07/11/06
  23.   Maral 11:25  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 07/11/06
  24.   Assad is proposing blackmail not peace 11:26  |  zionist forever 07/11/06
  25.   You`re right, Margie 11:43  |  Maral 07/11/06
  26.   # 19 The Wallet is not yours its mine 11:53  |  Adel 07/11/06
  27.   RETURN GOLAN NOW..... PEACE STARTS HERE 11:59  |  Messaoud 07/11/06
  28.   Syria has chance for peace every day the sun rises. 12:17  |  Bennie 07/11/06
  29.   http://mapsofwar.com/ind/imperial-history.html 12:19  |  abambam 07/11/06
  30.   YES MASOUD !!! RETURN GOLAN NOW..... 12:25  |  wadha 07/11/06
  31.   At this point, Peter... 12:26  |  Maral 07/11/06
  32.   Margie & Maral 12:33  |  northern neighbor 07/11/06
  33.   zionist forever 12:36  |  northern neighbor 07/11/06
  34.   so you`re one of those Klaudia (no. 21) 12:50  |  someone somewhere 07/11/06
  35.   And little green men from mars will patrol the borders. 12:52  |  Dr David Gross 07/11/06
  36.   Messoud...Syria lost a war, they lost the Golan 12:58  |  British academic 07/11/06
  37.   Assad should give us Land & we will give him Peace! 13:01  |  Ronny 07/11/06
  38.   the right is allways right 13:07  |  sinaiavi 07/11/06
  39.   Haaretz, finally I am calming down 13:19  |  Jonathan S 07/11/06
  40.   Maral 13:21  |  sh 07/11/06
  41.   So let`s give Klaudia a chance... 13:23  |  Michael 07/11/06
  42.   #10 Israel and Peace DO go together 13:31  |  ATLAS 07/11/06
  43.   Golan is better run by Western 13:37  |  Fred Drummer 07/11/06
  44.   Israel Does not really want Peace with syria 13:40  |  Nina 07/11/06
  45.   At this point, Peter... 13:58  |  Maral 07/11/06
  46.   More land, Ronny?? 14:00  |  Maral 07/11/06
  47.   ADDICTED TO OCCUPATION 14:13  |  Tim 07/11/06
  48.   northern neighbour (or should i say, mine?) 14:29  |  Maral 07/11/06
  49.   Israeli public right this time 14:29  |  bruce 07/11/06
  50.   British Academic#31... IT WILL REGAINED BY FORCE 14:29  |  Messaoud 07/11/06
  51.   Fred Drummer#36... DID YOU SAY WESTERN STYLE GOVERNMENT??? 14:34  |  Messaoud 07/11/06
  52.   What is Syria`s policy, it is the policy of Hamas/Hizbollah. 14:39  |  bruce 07/11/06
  53.   to wadha from arab state 14:46  |  Clucktool 07/11/06
  54.   Competition for the Golan 14:50  |  George Goldman 07/11/06
  55.   british academic 14:54  |  michael 07/11/06
  56.   What a stupid editorial 15:01  |  Gee 07/11/06
  57.   Maral`s northern neighbour :) 15:01  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 07/11/06
  58.   #41 addicted to occupation 15:07  |  SD 07/11/06
  59.   War with Syria will break out rather sooner than later 15:08  |  Jonathan S 07/11/06
  60.   absolutely not! never make `peace` with assad 15:10  |  jay 07/11/06
  61.   Messoud..every single battle you chaps say the same thing 15:13  |  British academic 07/11/06
  62.   Maral - Syria as Peace Partner? 15:17  |  Bob 07/11/06
  63.   maral - look at history you nimwit 15:18  |  jay 07/11/06
  64.   Peace with Syria - Neighbor 15:22  |  A realist 07/11/06
  65.   Messoud...could you give us a date.. 15:23  |  British academic 07/11/06
  66.   khalid 15:26  |  jay 07/11/06
  67.   to 27/28 - DO YOU THINK WE`RE THAT DUMB? 15:33  |  JAY 07/11/06
  68.   Tim - sounds like you have real addiction experience 15:38  |  jay 07/11/06
  69.   jay 15:51  |  michael 07/11/06
  70.   Michael all your wishful thinking... 15:52  |  British academic 07/11/06
  71.   Syria has opportunity for peace every day the sun rises 16:03  |  Bennie 07/11/06
  72.   British academic #59... IT WON`T HAPPEN.. 16:06  |  Messaoud 07/11/06
  73.   what will Israel get out of agreeing to Assads demands 16:06  |  zionist forever 07/11/06
  74.   Jay-walking 16:16  |  Maral 07/11/06
  75.   Assad has problems he needs something to survive 16:22  |  zionist forever 07/11/06
  76.   Why don`t we hear what the Syrians have said? 16:23  |  Gee 07/11/06
  77.   So, what is it exactly, Bob 16:29  |  Maral 07/11/06
  78.   NOBODY TO TALK TO 16:31  |  NEUTERED OBSERVER 07/11/06
  79.   zionist academic #60/#64 16:32  |  Messaoud 07/11/06
  80.   michael #69 16:46  |  Gee 07/11/06
  81.   To Michael on China n India 16:48  |  Anubhav 07/11/06
  82.   A poorly thought out editorial 16:56  |  Bimmer 07/11/06
  83.   Not at this time 17:05  |  Danite 07/11/06
  84.   Peter SM Winds of political change 17:15  |  maoriboy 07/11/06
  85.   Israel doesn`t want peace 17:18  |  Nathan 07/11/06
  86.   Thank you Jay, you perfectly illustrate my point 17:18  |  Tim 07/11/06
  87.   Give a Haaretz a boot 17:19  |  Sal 07/11/06
  88.   #71 Bennie I don`t know who you are 17:19  |  peter 07/11/06
  89.   To Bracha 17:24  |  Nathan 07/11/06
  90.   No hope for Israel 17:37  |  Nathan 07/11/06
  91.   Maral 17:41  |  northern neighbor 07/11/06
  92.   Begging for peace 17:42  |  Nathan 07/11/06
  93.   Haaretz - You Need a Change of Direction 17:48  |  Tod Zuckerman 07/11/06
  94.   We must consider returning the Golan ... and talk to the Pals 17:54  |  Adam Goldenberg 07/11/06
  95.   My neighbour :) 18:01  |  Maral 07/11/06
  96.   My neighbour :) 18:07  |  Maral 07/11/06
  97.   Assodd 18:22  |  Chaim Gorenstein 07/11/06
  98.   haaretz editorial on syria 18:36  |  ray 07/11/06
  99.   ASSAD IS THE PROBLEM NOT THE SOLUTION 1 19:02  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 07/11/06
  100.   ASSAD IS THE PROBLEM, NOT THE SOLUTION 2 19:12  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 07/11/06
  101.   Maral, See Rosner?s Domain poll. 19:34  |  Ziad 07/11/06
  102.   Messaoud the sick.... 19:38  |  Fred Drummer 07/11/06
  103.   Danite 19:42  |  Walid 07/11/06
  104.   Bob #62, Deprive Assad from his tools 19:49  |  Ziad 07/11/06
  105.   Syria is not asking for Peace, he`s threatening war 20:06  |  peter 07/11/06
  106.   maral and seniora 20:14  |  herodotus 07/11/06
  107.   maral you get away with murder 20:17  |  herodotus 07/11/06
  108.   maral wants coffee 20:29  |  herodotus 07/11/06
  109.   Assad 20:37  |  P. J. Casey 07/11/06
  110.   Syria is a Proxy of Iran 20:53  |  Bruriah Sarah 07/11/06
  111.   47 : Occupation 20:55  |  Bruriah Sarah 07/11/06
  112.   90: hOPE FOR ISRAEL 21:02  |  Bruriah Sarah 07/11/06
  113.   Syria isn`t ofering to negotiate Peace 21:38  |  peter 07/11/06
  114.   Haaretz, you don’t make peace with your enemies 22:17  |  Jonathan S 07/11/06
  115.   #105 peter he`s doing both 22:25  |  Johnboy 07/11/06
  116.   #111 Bruriah Sarah - "Occupation? What occupation?" 22:32  |  Johnboy 07/11/06
  117.   #109 P.J. Casey 22:40  |  Johnboy 07/11/06
  118.   Nathan #89 22:46  |  Ronaldinho 07/11/06
  119.   Israel and peace do not go togeyhter 22:48  |  Michael 07/11/06
  120.   to arab neighbor #7 23:06  |  citizen zero 07/11/06
  121.   Walid "Marchaba Fik" 23:23  |  Danite 07/11/06
  122.   harzion/herodotus/etc 23:25  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 07/11/06
  123.   #90 Bruriah Sarah 23:29  |  pro-Arab 07/11/06
  124.   peter 23:43  |  Danite 07/11/06
  125.   Danite and Walid, thanks for the detail and 00:24  |  Ziad 08/11/06
  126.   Peter and Danite. You are basically shutting the door. 00:47  |  Ziad 08/11/06
  127.   #122, Danite 01:01  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 08/11/06
  128.   Peace Yes , Syria`s Price For Peace NO 01:31  |  Joseph E . 08/11/06
  129.   2nd try- Response # 41- Michael 03:06  |  Klaudia 08/11/06
  130.   #125 Joseph E Then you are talking war, not peace 03:15  |  Johnboy 08/11/06
  131.   Margie of the UK #122 03:34  |  Gabe1 08/11/06
  132.   johnboy play semantics with somebody else 03:34  |  peter 08/11/06
  133.   Haaretz Editorial 04:14  |  Baruch 08/11/06
  134.   pro-arab re. bruriah sarah 05:23  |  maria 08/11/06
  135.   MAORIBOY.Lets remove any misundertandings. 05:42  |  PETER SM 08/11/06
  136.   Messaoud`s frustrations 05:53  |  Daniel 08/11/06
  137.   Maral`s neighbour 10:15  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 08/11/06
  138.   You know who... 10:17  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 08/11/06
  139.   #132 2nd try to reply to peter 12:06  |  Johnboy 08/11/06
  140.   To Briah Sarah -- G-D`s intention 18:52  |  Zeje 08/11/06
  141.   Hitler promised peace too and so does every mugger. 20:17  |  Ethan 08/11/06
  142.   zeje...they should have done that in the bible time. 21:57  |  maria 08/11/06
  143.   To british academic#36 09:39  |  Wise Syrian 10/11/06
  144.   #119 Michael, Boston 20:41  |  Boycott 11/11/06
  145.   #134 Maria 20:50  |  A. Baal 11/11/06
  146.   #142 Maria 20:56  |  Boycott 11/11/06
  147.   #143 Wise Syrian 21:06  |  Jimmy 11/11/06
  148.   Olmert`s mistake 11:06  |  k 14/11/06
 Today Online
Fury in U.S. over Olmert's comments on Iraq war
Responses: 46
Netanyahu: Iranian leader preparing another Holocaust
Responses: 39
Editorial: Is Halutz responsible for anything in the army?
Responses: 2
Jewish Agency chair: American Jews have no future in U.S.
Responses: 3
Katsav will face charges of sexual assault, not rape
Responses: 8


More Headlines
07:25 Fury in U.S. over Olmert's comments on Iraq war
10:30 Hamas: PA unity government won't recognize Israel, accept two-state solution
11:23 Shin Bet: Israel must prepare for broad IDF Gaza offensive
09:05 Report: Olmert dodges question on his support for IDF Chief Halutz
10:57 Israel opted for cheaper, unsafe cluster bombs in Lebanon war
08:00 Katsav will not face rape case, only sexual assault charges
04:54 Government rejects bill forcing kindergartens to get license
10:11 Netanyahu: It's 1938 and Iran is Germany; Ahmadinejad is preparing another Holocaust
05:07 Argentina accuses Iran of meddling in probe of 1994 Jewish center bombing
08:34 IDF denies B'Tselem claim it 'executed' 2 West Bank militants
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved