Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., November 12, 2006 Cheshvan 21, 5767 | | Israel Time: 08:58 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The murder that stopped everything
By Nehemia Shtrasler

Yes, it was a political demonstration. The 100,000 people who came to Rabin Square in Tel Aviv Saturday night mourned the man, but also mourned peace, which has become a dirty word in recent years.

We can talk about disengagement and convergence - but not about peace. We can talk about walls and separations - but not about dignified, fair negotiations with the other side to bring quiet and peace to this troubled land.

The rally's organizers said it was a "non-political" gathering, but they were wrong. Yitzhak Rabin was killed because of a political plan, the Oslo plan. Every gathering in his memory has been a political gathering of peace supporters, of people who want to save this nation from its ceaseless plunging toward war, toward more victims.

Advertisement

Some people tried to belittle the rally. They said that only a few would come (after all, it's been 11 years), and even if they did come - it would only be to hear Ninette Tayeb and Aviv Gefen. But the tens of thousands, including many teenagers, stood in silence, hanging on to every word in the long and chilling speech of David Grossman. He laid before them an entire plan of action - yes to speaking to the Palestinian people, and yes to Bashar Assad's peace feelers.

Many people dismiss the entire Oslo process with astonishing levity. The more meticulous among them call the agreement's initiators "Oslo criminals." According to them, even had Rabin not been murdered, the agreement would have exploded and the confrontation with the Palestinians would have occurred - because the Palestinians want only one thing: to throw us into the sea. Consequently, we will fight by the sword and die by the sword, and there is no one to talk to.

Rabin thought otherwise. He came to the square on that Saturday night in November 1995 with deep misgivings. The rioters against the Oslo agreement pursued him wherever he went, made venomous utterances against him, and gave him no peace even on Friday outside his private Ramat Aviv residence. And the general, silent public kept still and abandoned him and the street to the rioters' mercy.

So Rabin was concerned that the square would remain empty. And this is why his heart warmed and his eyes shone when he saw the masses that arrived, waving the flags and encouraging him with enthusiasm.

The representatives of the silent majority expressed confidence in the Oslo agreement, and Rabin was happy. He received encouragement and strength to continue the process with full force - and would have done so.

On May 4, 1994, Rabin signed (with Yasser Arafat) an agreement in Cairo outlining the timetable for the final-status agreement with the Palestinians. The agreement said that on May 4, 1996, negotiations for the final-status agreement would begin, and end three years later, on May 4, 1999. Indeed, on May 4, 1996, the negotiations began, with Shimon Peres as prime minister.

Following this, Arafat undertook to handle the terror infrastructure forcefully. That was the Palestinians' "Altalena." Arafat acted against Hamas with all his power: he arrested, killed and oppressed Hamas activists. His people, headed by Mohammed Dahlan, even shaved the beards of some of the imams in the mosques - as a mark of humiliation and contempt. Arafat's rule was stronger than ever, and Hamas and terror were weaker than ever.

This was an ideal opportunity to continue the process - but Peres lost the elections, and Benjamin Netanyahu became prime minister.

Netanyahu's aim was clear: to smash the Oslo agreement; and he did so thoroughly. In September 1996, he opened the tunnel in Jerusalem (at Ehud Olmert's advice), and therefore, the two of them set Jerusalem and the territories on fire. Netanyahu invented the cliche "if they give, they'll get" to create a complete standstill. He rejected the incremental process, but instead intensified building in the settlements, Har Homa and East Jerusalem.

He did not permit safe passage between Gaza and the West Bank, and did not release Palestinian prisoners. Thus the Oslo agreement was indeed smashed. On May 4, 1999, nothing happened. The final-status agreement retreated even farther, and the second intifada started to take shape.

Had Rabin not been murdered, the Oslo agreement would have continued and the final-status agreement would have been signed. We could be living today in a completely different world, one in which the national effort would be for the good and prosperity of all of society, and not for raising the defense budget. Rabin knew that time was not on our side, that Israel was a sick society, and that only peace could win the time to heal its wounds.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Paint over the mosaic
Elana Gomel has no idea what life is like for the Israelis who support Lieberman.
On U.S. and them
The vitriolic hatred that the U.S. inspires in so many is striking chords everywhere.
  1.   How do you make peace with Hamas? 09:09  |  Ariel 07/11/06
  2.   Wasn`t it " Saint Arafat " who wore his Headdress ( keffiyeh ) 09:16  |  Klaudia 07/11/06
  3.   Shtrasler, You are a Moron 09:20  |  Tod Zuckerman 07/11/06
  4.   Only one man was never and is 09:23  |  Khalil Ishabib 07/11/06
  5.   It`s a touching article 09:28  |  Maral 07/11/06
  6.   THE ONLY MAN OF PEACE ISRAEL EVER HAD 09:29  |  Lebanese 07/11/06
  7.   ISRAEL BROKEN IT FIRST 09:29  |  indrajaya 07/11/06
  8.   Dishonest Rewriting of History 09:37  |  Ben Israel 07/11/06
  9.   Shtrasler the false messiah 09:41  |  joe 07/11/06
  10.   Self-deception 09:42  |  Israel Israeli 07/11/06
  11.   The good Israel and the bad Israel 09:45  |  Swiss 07/11/06
  12.   Till now,only Muslims reacted to this article!! 09:50  |  michael 07/11/06
  13.   Wrong Arafat never intended true peace with Israel 09:52  |  Shalom Freedman 07/11/06
  14.   Fiction 09:57  |  Dov 07/11/06
  15.   How many additional people did Rabin`s assassin kill? 10:00  |  Clickfool 07/11/06
  16.   No grass-roots push for peace 10:03  |  Andrew Watson 07/11/06
  17.   # 14, CLICKFOOL 10:24  |  indrajaya 07/11/06
  18.   Rabin wasn`t the only man of peace 10:35  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 07/11/06
  19.   BEWARE OF FALSE PROPHETS WHO CRY PEACE WHEN THERE IS NO PEACE?? 10:38  |  Bill. 07/11/06
  20.   Dino 10:39  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 07/11/06
  21.   Maral about your question 10:50  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 07/11/06
  22.   Indrajaya do you go to stupid school? 10:52  |  Jasmine Murphy 07/11/06
  23.   # 1- Ariel- Good for You ! 10:57  |  Klaudia 07/11/06
  24.   MURDERING TERRORIST ISLAM/HAMAS STRATEGY IS DESTRUCTION OF JEWS ? 11:01  |  Bill. 07/11/06
  25.   to # 12 Michael read History books please ... 11:05  |  Clickright 07/11/06
  26.   Thanks for responding, Margie 11:05  |  Maral 07/11/06
  27.   "ARAFAT REFUSED BARAK`S OFFER" : SIMPLISTIC ASSERTION 11:12  |  Lebanese 07/11/06
  28.   No Klaudia, you`re mistaken 11:13  |  Ariel 07/11/06
  29.   Rabin and peace. 11:17  |  Tony Price 07/11/06
  30.   Usual Leftie lies of Stalin worshipper 11:17  |  Absolute Sweden 07/11/06
  31.   # 20 Margie I never accused you of being Likud.... 11:19  |  Swiss 07/11/06
  32.   Leftist fantasy 11:20  |  Judith 07/11/06
  33.   RE # 1 Ariel (How Pals make peace with Israel) 11:30  |  Human rights 07/11/06
  34.   #23 11:38  |  AM 07/11/06
  35.   Human rights - you know what my problem is? 11:47  |  Ariel 07/11/06
  36.   "Arab Peace" is an excellent oxymoron 11:48  |  Zuriel 07/11/06
  37.   Maral 11:52  |  sh 07/11/06
  38.   MESSIANIC FANATIC LEFTIST - IF MY MOTHER HAD WINGS SHE`D FLY! 11:55  |  BEN 07/11/06
  39.   RABIN WAS BUYING TIME... 11:58  |  Messaoud 07/11/06
  40.   ANDREW Heard of Shalom Achsav,Yesh Gvul etc.?Arab equivalent is ? 12:00  |  PETER SM 07/11/06
  41.   Khalil Ishabib 12:04  |  sh 07/11/06
  42.   SWISS. Black(Israel) &White (Hamas). 12:06  |  PETER SM 07/11/06
  43.   delusional 12:08  |  adam 07/11/06
  44.   # 29- AM- NO ! Let`s Stick to the TRUTH for a Change ! 12:14  |  Klaudia 07/11/06
  45.   # 40 PETER SM Majority of Israelis want peace and disengagement 12:16  |  Swiss 07/11/06
  46.   strassler 12:19  |  iLetzter 07/11/06
  47.   sh, very informative 12:20  |  Maral 07/11/06
  48.   The Murder of Oslo-Maral 12:21  |  Meir Gush Etzion 07/11/06
  49.   There could have been peace without Rabin, too 12:28  |  Jonathan S 07/11/06
  50.   Swiss, most center Israelis aren`t party people 12:29  |  Richard 07/11/06
  51.   Perfect Exemple of Left Psychosis & Postmodern Fictive Narrative 12:29  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 07/11/06
  52.   RABIN, YOU ARE NOTHING BUT ASHES 12:30  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 07/11/06
  53.   # 28- Ariel 12:33  |  Klaudia 07/11/06
  54.   Well Lebanese, then one makes a counter offer 12:35  |  Richard 07/11/06
  55.   Amir deserves to rot 12:37  |  kym 07/11/06
  56.   SWISS your are not just undemocratic but anti-semite-no offenc 12:38  |  Buncha Kooks 07/11/06
  57.   To Tony Price about peace #29 12:42  |  Jonathan S 07/11/06
  58.   PS: The Palestinian Altalena was called "Karin A" 12:44  |  Ovadiah ben Avrahsm 07/11/06
  59.   Had he lived we would have had disaster 12:46  |  Dr David I. Gross 07/11/06
  60.   Maral, in responding to your open ended questions of why, why and 12:55  |  Nadav 07/11/06
  61.   What`s new here? Another depressed, despondent leftist idiot? 12:58  |  Dudu 07/11/06
  62.   complete B S 13:01  |  Menachem 07/11/06
  63.   Margie, Maral, more about your questions, Maral, and your 13:01  |  Nadav 07/11/06
  64.   To Swiss about his Unsolicited Advice 13:05  |  Jonathan S 07/11/06
  65.   Both sides need to quite assuming Rabin was an idiot 13:08  |  David Teich 07/11/06
  66.   33: Yeah, we occupy Israel. That`s the problem 13:11  |  David Teich 07/11/06
  67.   Entire conflict explained in less than 20 lines 13:14  |  MG 07/11/06
  68.   You have got to be joking 13:17  |  British academic 07/11/06
  69.   Had my aunt had a whatsit ... 13:18  |  Gerrit 07/11/06
  70.   humor 13:25  |  Yaakov 07/11/06
  71.   To Jonathan S, a correction 13:25  |  Richard 07/11/06
  72.   #43 Jonathon S . 13:27  |  Tony Price 07/11/06
  73.   Gross 13:30  |  sh 07/11/06
  74.   Then how do you explain Arafat`s rejection of Barak proposals?? 13:31  |  MG 07/11/06
  75.   #29: If Maoris were Jihadist Muslims... 13:36  |  MG 07/11/06
  76.   Rabin 13:45  |  Charles 07/11/06
  77.   cry the beloved country 13:51  |  michael 07/11/06
  78.   To the Nutty New Zealander - Tony Price 14:00  |  Richard 07/11/06
  79.   Haaretz, is my post being censored? 14:06  |  Cipora Julianna Koh 07/11/06
  80.   Woulda, Shoulda, Coulda 14:21  |  The Other Alan 07/11/06
  81.   T.PRICE King Abdulla,Anwar Sadat assasinated by MOSLEMS 14:23  |  PETER SM 07/11/06
  82.   Tony Price you are not honest 14:24  |  Jonathan S 07/11/06
  83.   To Richard about percentages #54 14:31  |  Jonathan S 07/11/06
  84.   # 48 Jonathan S You know what Jonathan.... 14:45  |  Swiss 07/11/06
  85.   Lebanese 14:48  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 07/11/06
  86.   Maral 14:49  |  Gabe1 07/11/06
  87.   Good Jew - is dead Jew 14:49  |  Gene 07/11/06
  88.   Tony Price #55 14:54  |  Gee 07/11/06
  89.   Margie of the UK #21 14:57  |  Gabe1 07/11/06
  90.   HAARETZ: Reveal us a secret-Where did you find morons Nehemia ... 14:59  |  Vittorio 07/11/06
  91.   Standing history on end! How absurd!... 15:18  |  bat yam 07/11/06
  92.   Rabin and the right 15:25  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 07/11/06
  93.   #76, Margie in Tel Aviv 15:29  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 07/11/06
  94.   Only Gorge Soros can bring peace 15:31  |  Amin Nusseibeh 07/11/06
  95.   # 50 Buncha Kooks Antisemite, or when the cheap shots are..... 15:43  |  Swiss 07/11/06
  96.   To Lebanese the victim #6 15:44  |  William 07/11/06
  97.   charles # 68 15:45  |  michael 07/11/06
  98.   To Lebanese #27 - Arafat crafty? 15:53  |  William 07/11/06
  99.   Peace with Rabin 15:57  |  Al Ramey 07/11/06
  100.   Question for Nadav 16:02  |  Peter 07/11/06
  101.   Or we may have lost Israel aready 16:02  |  David 07/11/06
  102.   The murder that stopped everything ? 16:04  |  Jo Jo 07/11/06
  103.   Tony Price on land annexation #68 16:12  |  William 07/11/06
  104.   Yitzhak Rabin 16:12  |  David Nigel Braham 07/11/06
  105.   Shtrasler, I have a bridge in Brooklyn I want to sell you 16:15  |  Maya 07/11/06
  106.   #90, Amin Nusseibeh 16:17  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 07/11/06
  107.   Amin Nusseibeh - mythlogical claims to Israel 16:22  |  Richard 07/11/06
  108.   To Margie about Rabin and the right 16:26  |  Jonathan S 07/11/06
  109.   RE#35 Ariel (Your problem is in your head, momerize real history 16:34  |  Human rights 07/11/06
  110.   A Joke 16:36  |  Jack Davis 07/11/06
  111.   Swiss is... the Antisemetic Truth 16:39  |  David 07/11/06
  112.   Ne He Mia 16:41  |  Gabe1 07/11/06
  113.   Nehemia Shtrasler misses the boat and falls in the water 16:42  |  Bimmer 07/11/06
  114.   Rabin killed because he was changing his mind 16:53  |  Melvin Schnell 07/11/06
  115.   human rights - a most inappropriate name 17:01  |  Ariel 07/11/06
  116.   #29PRICE AND THE BUTTER MOUNTAIN 17:11  |  paul harris 07/11/06
  117.   Rabin`s death didn`t stop the process 17:15  |  peter 07/11/06
  118.   # 111 David I understand that you and your extremist.... 17:24  |  Swiss 07/11/06
  119.   swiss - those in glass houses shouldn`t throw bricks 17:45  |  David 07/11/06
  120.   For David I.Gross # 59 17:51  |  Clickfool 07/11/06
  121.   # 119 David Yeah, right, David, the names that I ..... 18:12  |  Swiss 07/11/06
  122.   Peace will come when arabs struggle for it, not against it 18:13  |  David 07/11/06
  123.   What if we gave a war and nobody came? 18:15  |  Dave 07/11/06
  124.   He was a good man, but was the enough? 18:52  |  Ahmad 07/11/06
  125.   To clickfool 18:57  |  Gene 07/11/06
  126.   The Left was the first to incite against Rabin 19:01  |  Jake 07/11/06
  127.   #126, Jake 19:34  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 07/11/06
  128.   assassination was not a blow to peace 19:41  |  peter 07/11/06
  129.   95: Still with the propoganda, eh swiss? p1 19:49  |  David Teich 07/11/06
  130.   95: Still with the propoganda, eh swiss? p2 19:58  |  David Teich 07/11/06
  131.   107: Richard, more for Amin, Muslims documented the Jews 20:02  |  David Teich 07/11/06
  132.   shalom freeman 20:08  |  michael 07/11/06
  133.   Once More Spin.... 20:12  |  Abuzaglo 07/11/06
  134.   Click the Fool #120 20:13  |  Gabe1 07/11/06
  135.   Cipora #127 20:22  |  Gabe1 07/11/06
  136.   Murder 20:42  |  michaelpielet 07/11/06
  137.   94: How can you make peace with those who want you dead? 20:50  |  Bruruiah Sarah 07/11/06
  138.   # 129, 130 David Teich Who is the run-awayer here ?? 20:56  |  Swiss 07/11/06
  139.   I agree with Nehemiah Strassler 21:11  |  Rabbi David Hoffman 07/11/06
  140.   # 95 David Teich Some more antisemites for you, David ?? 21:21  |  Swiss 07/11/06
  141.   SWISS Using multiple identities to mislead on your support No`s 21:26  |  PETER SM 07/11/06
  142.   Iman Daoud Hoff Manis #133 21:28  |  Gabe1 07/11/06
  143.   A.PRICE.BASHIR Gamayel Assasinated by Moslems. 21:34  |  PETER SM 07/11/06
  144.   NUSSEBEH.A reality check for you about migration. 21:39  |  PETER SM 07/11/06
  145.   Cipora #127 21:41  |  Gabe1 07/11/06
  146.   Wishful thinking 21:44  |  Nathaniel 07/11/06
  147.   Rabbi David Hoffman??? 21:50  |  peter 07/11/06
  148.   David Teich on dino 21:55  |  peter 07/11/06
  149.   # 139 PETER SM Coming a little bit late.... 21:56  |  Swiss (Dino) 07/11/06
  150.   To Swiss, convicted of lying #138 22:12  |  Jonathan S 07/11/06
  151.   Rabin 22:24  |  Samuel 07/11/06
  152.   #145, Gabe1 22:36  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 07/11/06
  153.   @29 Mg 22:43  |  Tony Price 07/11/06
  154.   Cipora #150 00:42  |  Gabe1 08/11/06
  155.   The vision of the prominant man theory 00:48  |  Jacob Blues 08/11/06
  156.   No title necessary 01:08  |  TonyL 08/11/06
  157.   Clickfool 01:56  |  Dr David I Gross 08/11/06
  158.   Richard, Gee, Jonathon, etc 02:29  |  Tony Price 08/11/06
  159.   T.PRICE100000+call for peace on every anniversary of Rabins murde 02:37  |  PETER SM 08/11/06
  160.   OSLO WAS UNFAIR AND UNJUST 02:38  |  DD 08/11/06
  161.   ariel,another history revisonists 02:50  |  john 08/11/06
  162.   #130 David compares Israel with a lot of other countries 03:05  |  Johnboy 08/11/06
  163.   Klaudia 03:23  |  John 08/11/06
  164.   John Boy with enphasis on Boy #155 03:27  |  gabe1 08/11/06
  165.   I am not complaining 03:48  |  TonyL 08/11/06
  166.   Klaudia, from California with Love! 04:39  |  Ziad 08/11/06
  167.   # 158- Ziad..LOL...Don`t Worry My Yin is Alive and Well 06:07  |  Klaudia 08/11/06
  168.   the idiot `boy` in his own country 07:02  |  Watcher 08/11/06
  169.   Amin Nusseibeh: Arabs belong to Arabia 07:06  |  EthnicityExpert 08/11/06
  170.   #44: to Klaudia 07:13  |  Anubhav 08/11/06
  171.   Basis for beliefs? 08:01  |  Johnson 08/11/06
  172.   #95 Swiss 08:10  |  Johnson 08/11/06
  173.   Arafat never changed PLO charter - which was 1st step in Olso 09:29  |  sheri 08/11/06
  174.   140: Yup Swiss, I am 09:30  |  David Teich 08/11/06
  175.   138: Swiss, you are amusing... 09:42  |  David Teich 08/11/06
  176.   158: So John, why are you revising history? 09:48  |  David Teich 08/11/06
  177.   We might be dead but there would not be peace 22:28  |  Sam Weinstein 08/11/06
  178.   for peace 01:49  |  JIm 12/11/06
 Today Online
Why didn't we use Air Force against Qassams from Gaza?
Responses: 194
Minister: Israel must stop Iran's nuclear program at all costs
Responses: 450
Yossi Beilin: Clash of Israeli and American civilizations
Responses: 161
Abraham Foxman: Fanatical Islam is like its totalitarian forbears
Responses: 134
Editorial: It's time Bush led a convincing peace effort
Responses: 107


More Headlines
08:45 IDF division commander Hirsch resigns his post
07:46 PM ahead of Bush meeting: We can stop Iranian nukes
05:05 Most Knesset factions object to Olmert's reform initiative
06:51 Analysis / A meeting in handcuffs for Ehud Olmert, George Bush
08:47 Neo-Nazi party holds convention in Berlin amid protests
05:49 GA event draws Israel's political leaders, business chiefs
01:55 Dramatic reduction in Qassam fire as PA unity gov't deal nears
03:16 Hamas: U.S. veto of UN draft resolution backs further 'massacres'
02:34 White House calls Iran, Hezbollah a `global nexus of terrorism`
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved