Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., November 16, 2006 Cheshvan 25, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:44 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Gays, Arabs and all the rest
By Avirama Golan

It seems like there is no connection between the issues: the minister for strategic affairs, Avigdor Lieberman, who shared his racist fantasies with an important British newspaper, and the ultra-Orthodox threatening violence in Jerusalem and causing the police to be ready to capitulate. Indeed, the multicultural fashion dictates that every group with its own characteristics is a "sector" (and thus gays and lesbians are also a "sector"), and so it seems that these are two separate sectarian problems.

In effect, the two phenomena - Lieberman's uncontrollable comments and the rampaging of the ultra-Orthodox - are the tip of the same iceberg. Not only because of the brutal and boorish common denominator linking the two, but also primarily because the agitators involved are suddenly accumulating enormous power. Lieberman is transparent, methodical and precise; he has never hidden his views or tried to glamorize them. Even his Cyprus dream is nothing new. In addition, similar comments and even more drastic ones have already been heard from ministers and leaders of political movements in Israel.

What is the difference between what the late minister Rehavam Ze'evi said and wrote, and Lieberman's Cyprus proposal? Only the context. Ze'evi, an unimportant minister, was active in an environment not prepared to get swept away by such hallucinations. Lieberman, who is now a senior representative of the State of Israel, is active in a supportive environment that is thirsty for his innovations and ideas. Since he excels in understanding the situation in the field, he sets off another bombshell each time - not just to shock, and certainly not just to get more votes (the voters throng to him anyway as long as the despair from Israel and Iran intensifies), but to change the discourse and insert his principles into it.

Advertisement

From the depths of the fear and confusion of the Israeli public, Lieberman brings to light the yearning for a strong man (a presidential system), the fear of becoming refugees again (the Iranian threat), and the exilic longing for ethnic purity (the Cyprus model). These ideas have rapidly acquired a solid base. One can assume that in the next elections, Lieberman will reap the fruits of a strengthened position.

The clearest proof of Lieberman's settling into the Israeli consciousness is the reaction of MK Benny Elon, who accused him of populism Sunday. Elon - who is worried that his former ally, Yisrael Beiteinu, which Lieberman heads, will swallow up his National Union party - has good reason to be jealous of Lieberman. Freed of a beard and skullcap, under cover of neo-liberal speech, the new minister will win over an increasing number of diverse populations: religious and secular, veteran Israelis and immigrants.

The ultra-Orthodox incitement against the pride parade stems from the same shady roots as the proposals put forth by Lieberman. People in Bnei Brak said yesterday that a group of newly religious idlers has dragged serious rabbis into what has turned out to be a public relations campaign for gays, and now the rabbis are having difficulty avoiding it. It's not really important which hooligan started the fire; what's important is that the ultra-Orthodox themselves were surprised to discover how much power they have. And now they are drunk on power and understand how it all began, but they, too, are unable to assess where all of this will go.

The ultra-Orthodox public in Israel has undergone several ups and downs in the last few years. It went from a position of weakness and alienation to one of excessive power, and then, when the coalition rejected it in disgust, returned to reasonable dimensions. The internal conflicts, the transfer of power from the rabbis to political activists, and the socioeconomic changes the ultra-Orthodox are undergoing have stirred up dangerous unrest within the community. A responsible leadership within the ultra-Orthodox world was supposed to make sure that the unrest did not damage the society as a whole, including the ultra-Orthodox themselves.

Had the ultra-Orthodox had responsible leadership, the leaders would have understood that the pendulum was liable to harm them with the same destructive strength, and would have been worried that the dark feelings of incitement reverberate so strongly amid a large secular population. Such a leadership would have understood that fear and hatred are a dismal and dangerous common denominator. But the ultra-Orthodox do not have a responsible leadership of this kind.

That shortcoming is nothing compared to the vacuum at the top of the ruling pyramid in Israel. Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's weak response to Lieberman's comments - "my opinion is not like his opinion" - and the hollow protest of all the ministers in response to the Cyprus hallucination and the police's highly publicized powerlessness are the abyss into which Israeli democracy is crashing. Even the most radical and frightened population would be less likely to get swept into hatred of the two "sectors" if it had an appropriate united, humanistic and civil alternative.

Amir Peretz, as head of the Labor Party, is committed to doing this. But now he and his friends - like the well-known monkeys - see nothing, hear nothing and say nothing, and primarily do nothing. And thus will they be remembered in history as those who stood on the edge of the abyss and handed out tickets for the tumble.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Kosher investments
Religious restrictions allow for some surprising flexbility for observant investors.
Not only the gifted
A committee recommends expanding programs for outstanding pupils.
  1.   Israel has become the victim of its own founding 09:26  |  Swiss 07/11/06
  2.   NOT LIEBERMAN NOR HIS PREEQUIVELLANTS 09:41  |  Khalil Ishabib 07/11/06
  3.   Leiberman: The Golden Calf 10:10  |  Natallie Durson 07/11/06
  4.   The Orthodox is drunk with power? 11:27  |  Steven 07/11/06
  5.   LIEBERMAN GUILTY OF GIVNG THIS TREACHEROUS GOVT A HAND TO SURVIVE 11:42  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 07/11/06
  6.   What Lieberman is saying 11:45  |  Ariel 07/11/06
  7.   Individual responsibility 12:45  |  sh 07/11/06
  8.   Avrima Golan - NO UNDERSTANDING AT ALL 12:59  |  Dr David I. Gross 07/11/06
  9.   To Swiss about the experiment Israel 13:46  |  Jonathan S 07/11/06
  10.   To #6 Ariel 13:53  |  f.k. 07/11/06
  11.   ISRAEL HAS NO HUMANISTIC AND CIVIL `CENTER` 13:57  |  Johan 07/11/06
  12.   What Are You, "Dr" Gross? Illiterate? 14:06  |  Rowan Berkeley 07/11/06
  13.   #6 Ariel 14:28  |  Ernst 07/11/06
  14.   the Arabs 14:35  |  Ernst 07/11/06
  15.   f.k. huh? 14:43  |  Ariel 07/11/06
  16.   # 9 Jonathan S Our "racist right wing party" has about... 15:15  |  Swiss 07/11/06
  17.   Jonathan S 15:50  |  christoph 07/11/06
  18.   #15 Ariel 16:01  |  f.k. 07/11/06
  19.   #6 Ariel 16:31  |  Wes 07/11/06
  20.   To Natalie Durson 16:40  |  Gene 07/11/06
  21.   To Christoph from Germany 16:55  |  Jonathan S 07/11/06
  22.   Swiss, lame post 16:59  |  Jake 07/11/06
  23.   "Holy Israel" 17:10  |  Nathan 07/11/06
  24.   Lieberman to Arabs , as Haredim to gays, as Avirama to common 17:21  |  Sal 07/11/06
  25.   # 22 Jake Don`t worry Jake, to apply for.... 17:30  |  Swiss 07/11/06
  26.   racism 17:41  |  fed up 07/11/06
  27.   I agree with David Gross 17:42  |  Gene 07/11/06
  28.   to Swiss 18:16  |  the pope 07/11/06
  29.   The lines are drawn 18:29  |  Michael N 07/11/06
  30.   NO difference between Lieberman and "Convergence", but borders. 20:27  |  Hal 07/11/06
  31.   swiss 22:49  |  sweis Melbourne 07/11/06
  32.   Its time to understand the Israeli mindset 23:09  |  YW 07/11/06
  33.   #26 fed up, why don`t you like this dish? 23:19  |  Bob 07/11/06
  34.   #30- a used car salesman 00:36  |  Michael N 08/11/06
  35.   In my opinion Lieberman... 00:48  |  Edith 08/11/06
  36.   Poor Swiss, he bleeds for us 00:52  |  Jacob Blues 08/11/06
  37.   #30 Hal 00:57  |  f.k. 08/11/06
  38.   Gene 01:23  |  sweis Melbourne 08/11/06
  39.   local news, global talk back 01:36  |  another swiss 08/11/06
  40.   a matter of perspective 01:47  |  another swiss 08/11/06
  41.   Would Anybody Step in Defense of Lieberman? Anyone? 02:50  |  Scientist 08/11/06
  42.   another swiss 03:52  |  sweis Melbourne 08/11/06
  43.   another swiss 03:52  |  sweis Melbourne 08/11/06
  44.   bye bye Israel 06:09  |  maoriboy 08/11/06
  45.   to fed up on Lieberman 07:20  |  Watcher 08/11/06
  46.   not Cyprus, Mr. Lieberman 07:25  |  Mendel the Mean 08/11/06
  47.   lieberman is the true face of israel! 07:38  |  sami 08/11/06
  48.   Avigdor Lieberman 16:02  |  Dr. Arthur Ide 12/11/06
  49.   Rabbis and Lieberman 17:35  |  Pavel 14/11/06
 Today Online
PA lauds European draft for new Mideast peace initiative
Responses: 107
Qassams hit Negev, day after deadly strike
Responses: 103
Noam Shalit: Gov't not doing enough to push Gilad's release
Responses: 124
Editorial: Beit Hanun and Sderot - twin towns of misery
Responses: 65
Israel Harel: You promised Gaza doves, we got Qassams
Responses: 55
Meron Benvenisti: Where is alternative leadership of the left?
Responses: 31


More Headlines
20:14 PA lauds European draft for Mideast peace plan
20:36 Peretz orders state to speed up reinforcement of Sderot schools
17:09 Palestinian FM: Iran donated $120M to Hamas-led government
18:53 Sderot residents board buses en route to rocket respite
16:36 State to compensate families of those killed in October 2000 riots
19:28 Hamas official: Abbas and Meshal to meet on unity government
16:13 Father of abducted soldier: Gov't not doing enough to free my son
17:44 Palestinian lightly wounded in clashes with IDF in Tul Karm
19:39 Czech Senate cancels deadline for return of Jewish art
19:42 Knesset opens new school to train parliamentary aides
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved