Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., May 13, 2007 Iyyar 25, 5767 | | Israel Time: 08:03 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Minister Avigdor Lieberman (Alon Ron / Archives)
Last update - 21:12 05/11/2006
Olmert: Lieberman's views on Israeli Arabs are not my own
By Haaretz Service

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert said on Sunday that he did not agree with Cabinet Minister Avigdor Lieberman's comments urging Israel to redraw its map to "exchange" part of the Arab population and create a more "homogenous Jewish state," as a solution to Israel's Arab minority "problem."

The prime minister said Lieberman's words did not reflect his or his cabinet's opinion, which he described as support for complete equal rights for Israeli Arabs.

A

Advertisement

A number of Knesset members called Sunday for Lieberman's dismissal, as the minister stood by his remarks.

MK Ahmed Tibi (Ra'am-Ta'al) told Haaretz that Israeli Arabs are the salt of the earth, while Lieberman is nothing but an invader." MK Dov Khenin (Hadash) called for the immediate dismissal of Lieberman from the government in light of what he called "racist comments."

Lieberman told Army Radio earlier Sunday, "if we want to safeguard Israel's character as a Jewish and Zionist state, there is no other solution," adding that the separation should be "consensual."

"The reason for the [Israeli-Palestinian] conflict is not territory, not occupation, not settlers or settlements, rather friction between the two peoples and the two religions.

"Everywhere, the world over, no matter if it's the former Yugoslavia or the Caucasus region in Russia, or Northern Ireland, wherever there are two peoples and two religions, there is friction."

According to Lieberman, Israel had no alternative but to move toward "exchanges of populations and territory, in order to create the most homogenously Jewish state."

Referring to the Nazi-era term Judenrein, describing an area from which all Jews have been removed, Lieberman said:

"I don't understand why the Palestinians deserve a state which is 'Judenrein' - after all, we obligated ourselves to create a Palestinian state 'clean' of all Jews, to evacuate all settlements and all the Jews from there to create a homogenous state - while we turn into a bi-national country in which more than 20 percent of those within the state of Israel are minorities."

'Cyprus is the best model'
"Minorities are the biggest problem in the world," the Sunday Telegraph quoted Lieberman as saying. Asked by the newspaper if citizens of Arab descent should be forced out through territorial redistribution, he said:

"I think separation between two nations is the best solution. Cyprus is the best model. Before 1974, the Greeks and Turks lived together and there were frictions and bloodshed and terror.

"After 1974, they constituted all Turks on one part of the island, all Greeks on the other part of the island and there is stability and security."

Told that in Cyprus thousands were forcibly driven from their homes, he replied: "Yes, but the final result was better."

The newspaper said that an aide to Lieberman later sought to expand on his remarks.

"Israeli Arabs don't have to go," the unnamed aide was quoted as saying. "But if they stay they have to take an oath of allegiance to Israel as a Jewish Zionist state."

Lieberman has often made remarks condemned as racist toward Israel's Arab minority, which numbers some one and a quarter million people.

In June, he was widely quoted as saying that Arab MKs who held contacts with Hamas should be executed.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
The Cordovas
A Peruvian family living in south Tel Aviv describes the good and bad sides of life in Israel.
Fine vines
The secret of my mother-in-law's superb stuffed grape leaves begins in a vineyard.
  1.   Legal Measures to Solve the Arab Problem 08:29  |  Harris 05/11/06
  2.   Democracy? 08:31  |  Natallie Durson 05/11/06
  3.   Lieberman 08:32  |  Cyndi 05/11/06
  4.   Lieberman, the true represant of Israel 2006 08:36  |  Swiss 05/11/06
  5.   Bring down this government 08:38  |  Jason-M 05/11/06
  6.   racist 08:41  |  steve 05/11/06
  7.   The most dangerous man in Israel 08:41  |  Niv 05/11/06
  8.   or ... 08:42  |  Ernie 05/11/06
  9.   Double standards 08:46  |  Christain 05/11/06
  10.   international shame 08:55  |  Charles 05/11/06
  11.   "Minorities are the biggest problem in the world," 08:55  |  Karam 05/11/06
  12.   about time someone speaks their mind 09:05  |  vik 05/11/06
  13.   The final result 09:06  |  sh 05/11/06
  14.   Avigdor Liberman, I think, should not be the issue; the issue 09:07  |  Nadav 05/11/06
  15.   Let the truth come forth.. 09:08  |  Benjamin 05/11/06
  16.   Lieberman Is Not Politcally Correct 09:10  |  Menahem 05/11/06
  17.   fascism by any other name 09:12  |  Londoner 05/11/06
  18.   Lieberman 09:13  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/11/06
  19.   Israeli Arabs are `problem,` require `separation` 09:23  |  alex 05/11/06
  20.   Lieberman,separation 09:25  |  Brauner Herman 05/11/06
  21.   Jews should go back 09:32  |  Ikram 05/11/06
  22.   Only Democracy in The Mideast. 09:33  |  seal 05/11/06
  23.   LIEBERMAN`S MORE DANGEROUS THAN SHARON`S PLAN:SAY NO TO DIVISION 09:42  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 05/11/06
  24.   lieberman 09:43  |  rafiq 05/11/06
  25.   Jewish State! Or Not? 09:47  |  northern neighbor 05/11/06
  26.   Hooray - the world is hearing Leiberman 09:51  |  Lebanese admirer 05/11/06
  27.   Let`s separate 09:54  |  Kris 05/11/06
  28.   Finally someone who calls a cat a cat! 09:57  |  stephane 05/11/06
  29.   to dave 10:07  |  Eman 05/11/06
  30.   Liebermans talk 10:17  |  Vital 05/11/06
  31.   Voice of the mashiah (and I, for some reason, assumed he, the 10:19  |  Nadav 05/11/06
  32.   How revealing! 10:23  |  Louis 05/11/06
  33.   Liberman,OR Hitler the second 10:24  |  Nice Man 05/11/06
  34.   Whiping out Arabs? 10:24  |  Petteri 05/11/06
  35.   Dino 10:48  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 05/11/06
  36.   reductio ad absurdum 10:48  |  raymond deane 05/11/06
  37.   Karam in Dubai 10:50  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 05/11/06
  38.   Kris - A Jewish state for ALL Jews.... 10:51  |  Lebanese admirer 05/11/06
  39.   The Arabs kicked out the Jews 10:51  |  semsem 05/11/06
  40.   Separate the Hasid 10:52  |  Laila 05/11/06
  41.   Arab/Jewish separation 10:55  |  Darius 05/11/06
  42.   Cipora voice of reason 10:56  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 05/11/06
  43.   You`re an invader who should go out of this country 10:56  |  Nada(Israeli Arab) 05/11/06
  44.   Akram #19: 50% of Israeli Jews not from Europe 10:59  |  Fortunee 05/11/06
  45.   must be very cold already over there in finland 11:00  |  to petteri ... read 05/11/06
  46.   # 12 Nadav I agree, the relation beween.... 11:01  |  Swiss 05/11/06
  47.   Lieberman and Zionism, Part one 11:07  |  Avi Yerushalmi 05/11/06
  48.   time for the leftists to leave as well 11:12  |  Haim 05/11/06
  49.   # 12 Nadav Just in case you missed my response.... 11:15  |  Swiss 05/11/06
  50.   Lieberman`s surgery 11:16  |  Esther 05/11/06
  51.   Lieberman is CORRECT and finally someone is telling the truth 11:23  |  Barak 05/11/06
  52.   Lieberman and Zionism , Part two 11:25  |  Avi Yerushalmi 05/11/06
  53.   nothing new from the ME front 11:26  |  Ernst 05/11/06
  54.   Checks and Balances 11:28  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 05/11/06
  55.   #39;Margie in Tel Aviv 11:29  |  Karam 05/11/06
  56.   lieberman 11:32  |  fats 05/11/06
  57.   terrorist 11:32  |  shiekh yacin 05/11/06
  58.   Israel on its way 11:33  |  Iymen 05/11/06
  59.   Dialogue 11:34  |  dr danielito 05/11/06
  60.   Dinoswiss 11:35  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 05/11/06
  61.   HOW CAN LIEBARMAN BE SO BLIND??!! 11:35  |  Lebanese 05/11/06
  62.   41 11:37  |  fats 05/11/06
  63.   What an Impostor 11:37  |  Andreas 05/11/06
  64.   Karam that`s very interesting 11:37  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 05/11/06
  65.   The minister for (causing) strategic threats 11:38  |  Bruno 05/11/06
  66.   NATALIE Durson.Take a look at what some Arab MK`s say and do. 11:40  |  PETER SM 05/11/06
  67.   Depressed 11:40  |  Angel 05/11/06
  68.   YES - SOMEONE HAD THE GUTS TO SPEAK THE TRUTH 11:42  |  Dr David I Gross 05/11/06
  69.   hold your horses 11:43  |  zadok the priest 05/11/06
  70.   why turn lieberman into a bogeyman 11:46  |  zadok the priest 05/11/06
  71.   lieberman does not intend to transfer anybody 11:48  |  zadok the priest 05/11/06
  72.   To # 6 - Swiss 11:50  |  french observer 05/11/06
  73.   Afterthought re surgery 11:51  |  Esther 05/11/06
  74.   lebanese and lieberman 11:51  |  zadok the priest 05/11/06
  75.   Liebermann is only the logical result of Gush Katif 11:52  |  Jew 05/11/06
  76.   Comparison with Cyprus? 11:58  |  Lebanese admirer 05/11/06
  77.   He was brought in by the Prime Minister 11:59  |  Ros 05/11/06
  78.   Arabs are the most racist, Hilter-like people on Earth. 11:59  |  pro-Lieberman 05/11/06
  79.   Nada; Your land is in Arabia! Lieberman is in his homeland! 12:00  |  pro-Lieberman 05/11/06
  80.   SWISS Your evidence for "many other Israeli MK`s" How many? 12:00  |  PETER SM 05/11/06
  81.   israel needs men with ideas 12:00  |  zadok the priest 05/11/06
  82.   Remove Lieberman out of cabinet and Israel politics. 12:01  |  H.H.M 05/11/06
  83.   Speak up Israel 12:02  |  Amsterdam 05/11/06
  84.   AND separate the Jews from their land 12:05  |  BenTemalion 05/11/06
  85.   # 55 Margie, I am afraid, if the proposals...