Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., November 06, 2006 Cheshvan 15, 5767 | | Israel Time: 16:14 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Palestinian masked militants carrying a homemade mine in the northern Gaza town of Beit Hanun on Saturday. (AP)
Last update - 00:16 05/11/2006
ANALYSIS / Israel helps provide legend for Palestinian struggle
By Amos Harel and Avi Issacharoff

The battles at Beit Hanoun, and especially the siege on Friday on the Al-Nassr Mosque in Beit Hanoun, will probably become another founding legend in the Palestinian narrative of the second intifada.

Children in the territories will hear in the years to come the story of the wondrous rescue operation, like the stories of the battle in the Jenin refugee camp and the siege of Bethlehem's Church of the Nativity. They will hear how dozens of women went out to the mosque, dressed the 60 militants hiding in it in dresses and veils and extracted them from the Israeli siege.

The drama will demonstrate how the civilian population can be mobilized to rescue its "protectors." Every debate on the role of the Palestinian woman in the intifada will raise the battle story as an example of the women's part in the national struggle.

Advertisement

But nobody (at least until the appearance of the first post-Palestinian historian) will ask why dozens of women risked their lives for a group of armed gunmen, who are directly responsible for the catastrophe taking place in Beit Hanoun. The problem is not merely on the Palestinian side. In Israel, too, many are asking what good the military operation is doing.

It is clear that the Qassam rocket fire is not subsiding. At best, it may be reduced. The number of Palestinian fatalities in the operation has exceeded 40, but the terror organizations' resolve to persist in firing rockets at Sderot has not wavered.

The killing in the Gaza Strip is out of proportion to any losses on the Israeli side. Perhaps these figures undermine the goal of the Israel Defense Forces, wishing to prepare the ground in a few months for a much larger operation, this time in the south of the Strip, against the arms smuggling tunnels in Rafah.

The defense minister and chief of staff took time out from their bickering over the appointments in the IDF and came together to the Gaza division's headquarters Friday to monitor the operation's achievements. Amir Peretz and Dan Halutz expressed satisfaction.

Senior Southern Command officers said the operation's main success is in the intelligence field.

Hamas had strengthened its military grip on Beit Hanoun recently, both in fortifications and in Qassam-launching networks. The operation is supposed to block this development. But in private conversations the officers admit that the chance of stopping the civilians' support for Hamas are slim.

In any case, the operation is expected to end in the next few days. The number of detainees that may be found will decrease and Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's visit to the United States, at the end of next week, will require pulling the troops out.

In the Palestinian arena, Israel managed to do for Hamas what it failed to do. The criticism from within of Ismail Haniyeh's government has died down. Hamas is once again leading the fighting, in the number of its fatalities as well. Hamas apparently led the "heroic" rescue operation from the mosque.

The IDF's operation may even end the school teachers' strike, which has been going on since September 1. Hamas was unable to stop it. The Palestinian civil war has been forgotten over the past week. Fatah's representatives in the Gaza Strip are totally busy fighting against Israel.

They repeatedly bring up the conspiracy theory - that the IDF and Hamas are cooperating by continuing the fighting. Thus, they say, Hamas remains in power, and Israel can continue to say it has no partner on the Palestinian side.

Meanwhile, 30,000 Beit Hanoun residents continue to live under siege  for the fifth day, with short respites. The IDF's liaison administration is trying to alleviate the civilians' suffering, but there is no running water in the taps because the IDF's bulldozers have damaged - perhaps by mistake - main water pipes, and the houses reek of sewage.

After more than six years of continuous fighting, neither side in the dispute appears to have given up the basic assumption at the beginning of the intifada. The Palestinians and Israelis are both still convinced that the other side understands only force.

The Gaza Strip's residents continue to protect the activists launching the Qassam rockets, although they have caused the Palestinians massive damage. They insisted on continuing the fire even after Israel withdrew from the Gaza Strip in the disengagement.

On the other hand, every senior IDF officer is certain that he will be the first to sear into the Palestinian consciousness the realization that terror doesn't pay.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Money to burn
No MK will propose ways to save money on the budget, so here are some suggestions.
'Chained women'
Rabbi Shlomo Amar canceled the conference on women who can't get divorces.
  1.   Bias 01:15  |  Sami 05/11/06
  2.   What legend? 01:19  |  Susanna/Shoshanah 05/11/06
  3.   DESPITE ONGOING IMPASSE, TAKE NOTE FROM IRA 01:22  |  Smadar 05/11/06
  4.   Interesting Article. 01:38  |  Paulo 05/11/06
  5.   Next time 01:47  |  Avrum 05/11/06
  6.   Haaretz analysys wrong in 2002 wring now 02:32  |  Boruch 05/11/06
  7.   Open War Sucks , Urban Combat Worse 02:32  |  Joseph E . 05/11/06
  8.   Playing to an Opponent`s Strengths 02:34  |  Mark of Lewiston 05/11/06
  9.   Palestinians create their own legends 02:52  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/11/06
  10.   Do you want to have an Israel or not? 03:00  |  Sam 05/11/06
  11.   Information Requested 03:01  |  chet 05/11/06
  12.   What choice does Israel have? 03:03  |  Ron 05/11/06
  13.   Israel helps provide legend 03:47  |  edifice 05/11/06
  14.   #6, Mark of Lewiston 03:52  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/11/06
  15.   Paulo`s wishful propaganda 04:20  |  MI Quacker 05/11/06
  16.   Avram`s so sorry 04:23  |  Donnybeisbol 05/11/06
  17.   Only Palis can call legend 04:25  |  John 05/11/06
  18.   Proportional response 04:28  |  Jason-M 05/11/06
  19.   To Mark of Lewiston 04:31  |  Jason-M 05/11/06
  20.   miserable palistinians 04:31  |  Landsman 05/11/06
  21.   Recognition is not necessary 04:36  |  Jason-M 05/11/06
  22.   interesting article 04:45  |  concerned 05/11/06
  23.   #19, Landsman 06:56  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/11/06
  24.   Haaretz Dumb Asses 07:13  |  Tod Zuckerman 05/11/06
  25.   it`s all about Shalit? 07:36  |  donnybeisbol 05/11/06
  26.   There will always be some phony "legend" 08:51  |  McQueen 05/11/06
  27.   so what did we get for LEAVING GAZA??? NOTHING !!! 09:03  |  amir 05/11/06
  28.   #25, that is not what concerned said 09:05  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/11/06
  29.   Palestinian self- defeating stupidity brings them suffering 09:23  |  Shalom Freedman 05/11/06
  30.   Nonsense, their legend has always been 09:36  |  Uzi 05/11/06
  31.   14 Cipora Julianna Kohn 09:43  |  Mark of Lewiston 05/11/06
  32.   I like Donny 09:53  |  Navy Vet 05/11/06
  33.   Rights should justify sacrifices 09:57  |  arab 05/11/06
  34.   Choosing a Mosque or Church of Nativity for military purposes. 10:46  |  PETER SM 05/11/06
  35.   all the Palestinians` fault???? 11:03  |  Fiona 05/11/06
  36.   No response today in the Guardian 11:08  |  Jasmine Murphy 05/11/06
  37.   Sami 11:09  |  Jasmine Murphy 05/11/06
  38.   SYMPTOMATIC OF THE GREATER PROBLEM 11:11  |  Dr David I Gross 05/11/06
  39.   IDIOTIC THINKING 11:12  |  Lebanese 05/11/06
  40.   Come now, Harel 11:20  |  Peter Dale 05/11/06
  41.   WOMEN&or children in the front line a legendary act for some 11:22  |  PETER SM 05/11/06
  42.   the problem in short 11:30  |  zadok the priest 05/11/06
  43.   normally those in poverty would try and help 11:32  |  zadok the priest 05/11/06
  44.   the solution 11:34  |  zadok the priest 05/11/06
  45.   Brainless rocket firers..give the guys an education if possible 11:49  |  British academic 05/11/06
  46.   Terrorists and Women 11:56  |  Tony Price 05/11/06
  47.   Another Palestinian Fictional Legend 12:12  |  * BEN JABO 05/11/06
  48.   Empty Gaza and move on from there! 12:14  |  * BEN JABO 05/11/06
  49.   Our legends are the best 12:26  |  Dr D 05/11/06
  50.   #25 Donkey baseball... 13:00  |  Itsik 05/11/06
  51.   Beit Hanun was indeed the stuff of legends 13:06  |  Clickfool 05/11/06
  52.   #25 donkeybaseball 13:06  |  Itsik 05/11/06
  53.   #32 Navy Vet 13:09  |  Itsik 05/11/06
  54.   Israel stole their land 13:14  |  Della 05/11/06
  55.   Cipora Julianna Kohn 13:16  |  Guy From NYC 05/11/06
  56.   #38 Peter SM 13:17  |  Itsik 05/11/06
  57.   `Post-Palestinian historian`?! 13:43  |  Johan 05/11/06
  58.   BLESSED BE THE CHILDREN AND WOMEN OF PALESTINE! 13:54  |  Messaoud 05/11/06
  59.   lack of a clear picture 13:55  |  We remember 05/11/06
  60.   THE ONLY NATION UNDER COLONIZATION 14:31  |  indrajaya 05/11/06
  61.   Zadok #41 You missed one 14:35  |  Danite 05/11/06
  62.   GA 15:06  |  cfs 05/11/06
  63.   #38, PETER SM 15:12  |  Fritz 05/11/06
  64.   Both sides need Enlightenment or Spinoza 15:21  |  BP Dipl 05/11/06
  65.   IF YOU TALK TO TERRORIST FOR 19 HOURS BEFORE 15:58  |  Robert 05/11/06
  66.   JACK AND THE BEANSTALK...... 16:04  |  Mike"SuperJew"Levy 05/11/06
  67.   Thanks Tod... 16:07  |  Zuriel 05/11/06
  68.   re: Amir #27 16:10  |  Paulo 05/11/06
  69.   Enlightenment - Secular Government 16:34  |  BP Dipl 05/11/06
  70.   "many are asking what good the military operation is doing" 17:14  |  Boris 05/11/06
  71.   Israel applied no lesson from Gaza to Lebanon, and in the reverse 18:04  |  Tosefta 05/11/06
  72.   Israeli options in Gaza 18:18  |  Tosefta 05/11/06
  73.   Chet #11 18:19  |  Gee 05/11/06
  74.   Zadok you missed one 18:54  |  Danite 05/11/06
  75.   #49 SOFETA, YOUR POINTS WHICH ARGUED REPEATEDLY, CORRECT 19:07  |  Smadar 05/11/06
  76.   Avrum 19:17  |  Walid 05/11/06
  77.   cipora julianna cohn 19:24  |  quizzical 05/11/06
  78.   Jason-M 19:26  |  Walid 05/11/06
  79.   peter sm re honor 19:27  |  quizzical 05/11/06
  80.   Of course this is the stuff of legend 19:37  |  Clickfool 05/11/06
  81.   Fritz what kind of German hypocrite you are #48 19:38  |  Jonathan S 05/11/06
  82.   Danite on political victory 19:58  |  peter 05/11/06
  83.   Smadar 60: Sherlockian Canadians 19:59  |  Tosefta 05/11/06
  84.   Tod Zuckerman # 27, another big mouth for Israel 20:01  |  Clickfool 05/11/06
  85.   #45 indrajaya 20:04  |  Adrian de Klerk 05/11/06
  86.   #62, quizzical 20:04  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/11/06
  87.   our/their similar legends 20:06  |  Shelley 05/11/06
  88.   Why is Beit Hanoun, an illegal "settlement," still standing? 20:15  |  Yaakov K. 05/11/06
  89.   Beit Hanoun ain`t no alamo 20:36  |  peter 05/11/06
  90.   Itsik . 21:34  |  PETER SM 05/11/06
  91.   Click...FOOL for sure... 21:37  |  Zuriel 05/11/06
  92.   61 Danite - Heresy 21:42  |  Mark of Lewiston 05/11/06
  93.   The Military as Whipping Boy 21:55  |  Mark of Lewiston 05/11/06
  94.   #90, Mark of Lewiston 23:05  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/11/06
  95.   oh, the poor little IDF 23:15  |  flimflam 05/11/06
  96.   clickfool how about the murderous butchery of 23:35  |  harzion 05/11/06
  97.   clickfool calls others bigmouths 23:37  |  harzion 05/11/06
  98.   #45 Adrian de Klerk 23:41  |  Rad 05/11/06
  99.   Beit Hanoun - a Settlement? 23:48  |  Lebanese admirer 05/11/06
  100.   FRITZ.Using women under a false flag is the problem. 00:18  |  PETER SM 06/11/06
  101.   #83 Tosefta from Tveria 00:22  |  Smadar 06/11/06
  102.   Doesn`t taking part in a military operation... 00:26  |  natan 06/11/06
  103.   messaoud #58 00:32  |  natan 06/11/06
  104.   CFOOL.RE Your question to T Zuckerman.You are full of advice 00:53  |  PETER SM 06/11/06
  105.   #58 - Messauod - Hit it on the head. 02:10  |  * BEN JABO 06/11/06
  106.   No matter what 02:29  |  Stealth RO 06/11/06
  107.   #51 - Clickfool`s legends 02:29  |  * BEN JABO 06/11/06
  108.   as always it`s all Israel`s fault 04:40  |  tunnel digger 06/11/06
  109.   Even Palestinian terrorists have tried non-violence 05:27  |  Lee 06/11/06
  110.   #107 Nah, BEN JABO 06:35  |  Johnboy 06/11/06
  111.   109, not quite 06:51  |  Oddvark 06/11/06
  112.   #110 - Johnboy`s head is in the Kangaroo`s pouch 07:04  |  8 BEN JABO 06/11/06
  113.   #97 - Clickfools posts - Renumeration for each post??? 07:14  |  * BEN JABO 06/11/06
  114.   #111 Oddvark knows things I do not. 07:36  |  Johnboy 06/11/06
  115.   Praise to the Heroic Palestinian Women! 08:02  |  Mark Kienan 06/11/06
  116.   #112 BEN JABO you have taken leave of your senses 09:03  |  Johnboy 06/11/06
  117.   1984 09:26  |  Shlomissimo 06/11/06
  118.   #116 - What`s your name today?? 15:47  |  * BEN JABO 06/11/06
 Today Online
IDF girds for possibility of war with Syria next year
Responses: 120
Red Cross: IDF hit clearly marked ambulance workers
Responses: 72
Reuven Pedatzur: A dangerous nuclear race in the Mideast
Responses: 23
IAF missile kills Gaza youth, 16, wounds several
Responses: 47
Yair Sheleg: Opposing the gay pride parade
Responses: 30
Rosner's Domain
* New guest: David Saperstein on the Jewish community and American politics
* Poll: What should be the number 1 topic for the Bush-Olmert meeting next week?
* Kentucky notes: GOP, Israel, Dirt
* A political tsunami in Ohio


More Headlines
16:12 IDF soldier lightly hurt in north Gaza suicide attack
15:27 Comptroller: Peres should consider returning donations
14:45 Lebanese discuss demands for national unity government
15:30 Blair: We'll talk to Hamas-led gov't if meets Quartet demands
13:37 Police Chief: 12,000 police to secure J'lem gay pride march
09:51 IDF girds for possibility of war with Syria, Hezbollah in 2007
11:18 Iran says ready to share weapons systems with allies
14:31 Jordan weighs sending PLA unit to bolster Palestinian security
10:26 Treasury opposes bill to aid needy Holocaust survivors
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved