Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., November 06, 2006 Cheshvan 15, 5767 | | Israel Time: 06:33 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 09:15 03/11/2006
Key data withheld from army officers during Lebanon war
By Amos Harel and Avi Issacharoff, Haaretz Correspondents

Senior Northern Command and Division 91 officers were not privy to essential intelligence information regarding Hezbollah's deployment prior to the second Lebanon War.

The intelligence, which was available to the Israel Defense Forces, included accurate information about the locations of Hezbollah bunkers and positions, as well as the internal structure of such positions.

The officers were aware that such information existed, but were prevented by the Intelligence Directorate's Committee on Source Security, claiming that the information was secret. Military Intelligence decided that the information would only be made available in the event of a war.

Advertisement

Officers' demands to gain access to information on routine security preparations that could counter Hezbollah raids inside the border fence were also rejected, and led to repeated and heated arguments among various units.

The information on Hezbollah positions was also withheld from the units during the war itself. Although there was a plan to transfer the data, which was stored in sealed boxes, to relevant units during a war, it was not carried out in time.

The initial boxes of intelligence reached the division command only a week after the initial encounter between an elite IDF unit and Hezbollah guerrillas inside a bunker (on July 19). But even then, it was difficult to adapt the intelligence to the immediate needs of the unit fighting there.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Money to burn
No MK will propose ways to save money on the budget, so here are some suggestions.
'Chained women'
Rabbi Shlomo Amar canceled the conference on women who can't get divorces.
  1.   Haaretz Blah blah BSing 06:52  |  Joseph E . 03/11/06
  2.   Who are these IDIOTS?????? 07:36  |  Gadi 03/11/06
  3.   IT HAS TO BE A LIE 09:33  |  Jay A Friedman 03/11/06
  4.   HERE WE GO AGAIN story telling time again 09:48  |  rocket launches 03/11/06
  5.   Again Israeli `rosh katan` causes Jews to die.Thank u bureaucrats 09:51  |  arthur 03/11/06
  6.   Again Israeli `rosh katan` causes Jews to die.Thank u bureaucrats 09:51  |  arthur 03/11/06
  7.   Again Israeli `rosh katan` causes Jews to die.Thank u bureaucrats 09:51  |  arthur 03/11/06
  8.   Intelligence 10:02  |  sh 03/11/06
  9.   military intelligence behave like infants 10:39  |  zadok the priest 03/11/06
  10.   LOUSY JOURNALISM 10:41  |  Larry Klein 03/11/06
  11.   To joseph and rocket launches 10:44  |  A.M. 03/11/06
  12.   Its true they want us to look weak 10:48  |  joe the eskimo 03/11/06
  13.   WHY ISRAEL LOOKS LIKE IT DOES 11:01  |  Larry Klein 03/11/06
  14.   #6 11:10  |  Brian 03/11/06
  15.   # 7 A. M @ Tel-Aviv Accuser on Stigma Same as Leftists 11:24  |  Joseph E . 03/11/06
  16.   larry klein 11:55  |  dubious 03/11/06
  17.   The IDF does not work well 11:56  |  Altalena 03/11/06
  18.   Leftie officers withold the vital data on purpose 12:36  |  Absolute Sweden 03/11/06
  19.   # 5- arthur ... Please explain rosh katan.... 12:48  |  Klaudia 03/11/06
  20.   a scandal - there should be an enquiry 12:50  |  reuben jacobs 03/11/06
  21.   altalena 13:13  |  A.M. 03/11/06
  22.   Key date withheld 13:56  |  Bob 03/11/06
  23.   Olmert is P.M.of which country? 14:35  |  Sam 03/11/06
  24.   Are We Serious?! 14:54  |  BenAbuzaglo 03/11/06
  25.   #14 15:13  |  Brian 03/11/06
  26.   key data withheld 15:16  |  John Snow 03/11/06
  27.   the real reason 15:17  |  dave 03/11/06
  28.   Intelligence withheld 15:40  |  Jerry 03/11/06
  29.   withholding of inteligence from own forces 15:57  |  ivo jelinek 03/11/06
  30.   Gen. Amos YADLIN, MI , Halutz nominee, ISAF-must resign w/ Halutz 16:46  |  Clean Ass Holes? 03/11/06
  31.   To AM in Tel Aviv. Denial from the army 16:54  |  Altalena 03/11/06
  32.   Sounds exaggerated 17:16  |  Tosefta 03/11/06
  33.   intelligence data witheld from field commanders 17:30  |  amir 03/11/06
  34.   Altalena 17:38  |  A.M. 03/11/06
  35.   Dont share info... hang em!!! 17:52  |  Twogunz 03/11/06
  36.   not unheard of, but should not have happened no excuse for it 17:53  |  ralph 03/11/06
  37.   He must go... 18:14  |  Walter 03/11/06
  38.   15 Altalena & 25 Jerry - interesting inputs 18:47  |  sheri 03/11/06
  39.   #27. Insanity and inanity 19:23  |  Polybios 03/11/06
  40.   Can this be true? 20:47  |  Ken 03/11/06
  41.   #24 Dave 21:04  |  sheri 03/11/06
  42.   data with held???? 21:05  |  ljf-canada 03/11/06
  43.   Astrology wasnt advantageous! 23:33  |  Benyameen ReshMany 03/11/06
  44.   twogunz 02:02  |  dubious 04/11/06
  45.   Well, of course... 15:12  |  Oliver 04/11/06
  46.   Who really cares??..! 13:20  |  H.H.M 05/11/06
  47.   h h m 05:21  |  dubious 06/11/06
 Today Online
Lieberman: 'Exchange' Arabs for 'homogenous' state
Responses: 407
David Grossman at Rabin memorial: We have no king in Israel
Responses: 188
The IDF and Beit Hanun, the next Palestinian legend
Responses: 109
Let the gay community march proudly in its Tel Aviv shtetl
Responses: 54
Zvi Bar'el: What keeps U.S., Israel, choking on their own power?
Responses: 71
Rosner's Domain
* New guest: David Saperstein on the Jewish community and American politics
* Poll: What should be the number 1 topic for the Bush-Olmert meeting next week?
* Kentucky notes: GOP, Israel, Dirt
* A political tsunami in Ohio


More Headlines
03:19 IDF may face a war with Syria, Hezbollah in 2007
03:12 IDF troops kill three Palestinians in northern Gaza Strip operation
03:56 AG instructs police to approve 'modest' gay pride march in J'lem
03:43 Justice Min.'s PID indicts 3 policemen for abusing Palestinian
05:56 Lieberman's remarks on 'minorities' spark anger and denunciations
05:24 Peretz unlikely to choose Ehud Barak as Pines-Paz replacement
01:22 Ramon attorneys: police's illegal wiretaps 'obstructed justice'
21:41 Shalit's father says he hopes Gaza raid will come to swift end
06:11 Red Cross: IDF hit clearly marked ambulance workers
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved