Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., May 04, 2007 Iyyar 16, 5767 | | Israel Time: 23:31 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The ember died long ago
By Yossi Sarid

Tomorrow is the Heshvan 11 in the Hebrew calendar - the day Israel mourns Yitzhak Rabin's assassination. After 11 years, everyone knows: Not only was Rabin assassinated, his legacy was buried with him. Essentially, that legacy was his resolute attempt to find cracks in the wall of hostility surrounding Israel - to find them and force himself through the narrow opening, hoping to detect, beyond the wall, signs of a coming to terms with Israel's existence.

Rabin was determined that the mettle of both Israel and the Israel Defense Forces not be tested unless it was absolutely necessary. A general, and an expert on Israel's security, in uniform and as a civilian, he understood what Ehud Olmert, Amir Peretz and Dan Halutz will never comprehend: You do not go to war - you never fight yet another war - unless you have no other choice, and only after you have investigated and exhausted all other possibilities.

Once, in a moment of candor, he told me, "Yossi, even the best army in the world cannot deliver a punch that is beyond its capacity. Even a strong nation cannot flex its muscles without ever relaxing them, because it will eventually exhaust itself." Rabin knew what a heavy responsibility he shouldered. He had broad shoulders, which had to carry the full weight of responsibility for Israel's future. That sense of responsibility pursued him relentlessly, and he never shirked his duties. Thus, he was prepared to do things he disliked, even loathed, because he felt obligated to do so.

Advertisement

Tomorrow, at the official state ceremony, the nation's eyes will be turned to Mount Herzl. Olmert, Shimon Peres, Avigdor Lieberman and Benjamin Netanyahu will be sitting solemnly in the first row. Sitting beside them will be the guardians of the dying embers of Rabin's party, the Labor Party, may it rest in peace (or war) - everyone, from Peretz to Binyamin (Fuad) Ben-Eliezer and Isaac Herzog.

What an assembly of Laborites, yet the ember died long ago. Between the eulogies, when the silence of the tombstones and cypresses - the silence of death - momentarily descends upon that scene, one might well hear Rabin bewailing his successors.

Yedioth Ahronoth reported on Friday that one in every three Israelis supports a pardon for Rabin's assassin, and that one in every two religious right-wing Israelis favors his early parole. Your eyes burn in their sockets as you read this news, as you refuse to believe what you are reading. Yet, why should we be surprised? The spirit of amnesty is drifting down from the upper echelons of Israeli society, slowly descending to the lower ones. The rabbis who encouraged the assassin, explicitly or implicitly, long ago received their pardons. Those who stood on the balcony at Jerusalem's Zion Square the night that bloodshed was sanctioned inherited Rabin's place, and were later even declared his ideological successors - the last "Mapainiks."

Although the assassin was apprehended and sent to prison, because he was the one who fired the three bullets, those who drew a bull's-eye on Rabin's back and told him that the prime minister was a permissible target have never been forced - perish the thought! - to account for their actions.

True, it is disgusting to crawl between the stained sheets of the assassin and his little Trembovler. Who really wants to approach the bed where they made love? Who really cares whether any child will be born from that union? Nevertheless, many see the granting of permission for their conjugal visit in a finely furnished guest-house as part of the pattern of forgiveness that is leading inevitably to a pardon, which, though the process may take some time, will ultimately be granted.

The writing is on the wall, even if the writing is concealed by moss.

"A Jew, even a sinner, never stops being a Jew." Today we can add, "A Jew, even after assassinating a prime minister, never stops being a Jew." Furthermore, it is important that he perform Judaism's commandments and that his rights be protected.

Our Shin Bet security service is famous for its hypersensitivity to the need for protecting human and civil rights, especially those of terrorists. We must never forget: Rabin's targeted liquidation was a murderous act of terror, not an assassination, and Jewish terrorism, grown on our home turf, is more - much more - dangerous than terrorism perpetrated by external forces.

It was reported that the Shin Bet submitted its professional opinion to the State Prosecutor's Office in which it stated that the victorious assassin "no longer constitutes a security threat."

I was told that his report infuriated the Shin Bet, which claimed the facts had been distorted. To avoid further injustice to our "fine young lads," I phoned the office of Shin Bet chief Yuval Diskin, requesting the text of that professional opinion. Ten days have passed and I have still not received it. A courteous spokeswoman did call me; however, when I asked for a document, she merely gave me an explanation. She promised to call me back the next day; however, I have yet to hear from her.

I must rely on what has been publicized, because much has apparently been going on behind the scenes.

The assassin "no longer constitutes a security threat" - the Shin Bet is absolutely correct here: Yitzhak Rabin has already been assassinated, and you cannot assassinate the same person twice.

Well, maybe you can.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Singing their song
Many of the up-and- coming songwriters in the local music market are artists themselves.
A receding world
Existence and the non-existence do not balance out; they amplify the longing.
  1.   Yossi Sarid has found the Rabin religion 10:08  |  Ilan 01/11/06
  2.   yossi sarid- just retire 10:43  |  joe 01/11/06
  3.   Political parties never die in Israel 10:49  |  Richard 01/11/06
  4.   Sarid`s Righteous Wrath Is Kindled 10:55  |  Ben Israel 01/11/06
  5.   Well written Sarid 11:01  |  Ari ben Yisrael 01/11/06
  6.   Call on the corrupt politicians to step down 11:10  |  Richard 01/11/06
  7.   no other choice.... 11:33  |  freddy 01/11/06
  8.   Why not bring Yigal Amir into the governement ?? 11:40  |  Swiss 01/11/06
  9.   Rabin`s killers are free 11:42  |  Lila 01/11/06
  10.   #6 Dicky. & I say the Kinneret isn`t full either!! 11:42  |  Ari ben Yisrael 01/11/06
  11.   To Ari ben Yisrael 11:52  |  Richard 01/11/06
  12.   SWISS Amir is not crooked enough to be Swiss.He is in jail 12:06  |  PETER SM 01/11/06
  13.   neuclear diplomacy will never get anywhere 12:36  |  zionist forever 01/11/06
  14.   freddy hi 13:01  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 01/11/06
  15.   Rabin and Amir 13:01  |  Miriam 01/11/06
  16.   I am not a follower of the Rabin religion 13:09  |  Menachem 01/11/06
  17.   Death Penalty, Amir & the Left 13:11  |  Simon 01/11/06
  18.   Peter Sm. 13:21  |  Silvia 01/11/06
  19.   Rabin and Amir 13:27  |  Choni 01/11/06
  20.   its treason 13:27  |  Jo Nimmer 01/11/06
  21.   Rabins assassination 13:29  |  dihirod 01/11/06
  22.   Rabin And Kahane 13:34  |  Choni 01/11/06
  23.   Get your dates right 14:09  |  George 01/11/06
  24.   FYI Lila from Jerusalem, he admitted being guilty here 14:21  |  nehemia 01/11/06
  25.   # 12 PETER SM Well, when it comes to buy (bribe) things....... 14:23  |  Swiss 01/11/06
  26.   A "National Prize" for Assassinating P.M. Yitzchak Rabin 14:27  |  Shimon Z. Klein 01/11/06
  27.   Terrorist Amir, imach shmo, should never see the light of day 14:49  |  Haya 01/11/06
  28.   Reply to #16 14:49  |  Shimon Z. Klein 01/11/06
  29.   Gag us with a spoon, Yossi 15:03  |  Shlomo 01/11/06
  30.   Sarid is Rabin Assasin,together with all the Lefty stupids 15:05  |  Sal 01/11/06
  31.   Menachem and Choni 15:29  |  Jack 01/11/06
  32.   Shimon Z. #28 15:29  |  Menachem 01/11/06
  33.   The Tragedy of All This Is The Nodding Heads of Assent 15:30  |  Yaakov Sullivan 01/11/06
  34.   Choni and His Sicarii Partners #22 15:37  |  Yaakov Sullivan 01/11/06
  35.   YOSSI SARID-And why Not......... 15:56  |  Gabe1 01/11/06
  36.   It`s really incredible how right wing fanatics blame lefties 16:17  |  Richard 01/11/06
  37.   Transfer Him Over Here! 16:24  |  Yosemite Sam 01/11/06
  38.   Shimon Z. Klein 16:28  |  Gabe1 01/11/06
  39.   Rabin 16:33  |  Suzy 01/11/06
  40.   #31 Choni Will Justify It and Provide HIS Rabbis to OK It 16:43  |  Yaakov Sullivan 01/11/06
  41.   Amir and Rabin and The Problem of Evil 16:44  |  Tony Anthony 01/11/06
  42.   #31 Choni Will Justify It and Provide HIS Rabbis to OK It 16:44  |  Yaakov Sullivan 01/11/06
  43.   Yosemite Sam (Post No. 37) 17:00  |  Johnny Weintraub 01/11/06
  44.   Yosemite Sam (Post No. 37) 17:01  |  Johnny Weintraub 01/11/06
  45.   The Ember Died 17:08  |  Shaul 01/11/06
  46.   The Ember Died 17:10  |  Shaul 01/11/06
  47.   Haya 17:10  |  Gabe1 01/11/06
  48.   Yaakov Sullivan....On Choni etc.... 17:30  |  Jack 01/11/06
  49.   yaakov sullivan 17:38  |  zadok the priest 01/11/06
  50.   Choni 17:57  |  Asher Levelheaded 01/11/06
  51.   Who killed more Jews? 18:00  |  Yossi 01/11/06
  52.   Sarid , Beilin, and Haaretz are Hijackers of Rabin`s Memory 18:09  |  Tod Zuckerman 01/11/06
  53.   the courts may pardon the assassin 18:14  |  zadok the priest 01/11/06
  54.   Choni don`t tempt me 18:32  |  Ari ben Yisrael 01/11/06
  55.   Insanity without Borders 18:44  |  Kate 01/11/06
  56.   what have you learned?? 18:47  |  Bob 01/11/06
  57.   shocked, appalled, dismayed, and disheartened 19:02  |  leucippe 01/11/06
  58.   shocked, appalled, dismayed, and disheartened 19:02  |  leucippe 01/11/06
  59.   Answer for Yossi #47 19:16  |  Ari ben Yisrael 01/11/06
  60.   The State of israeli politcal culture 19:23  |  Danite 01/11/06
  61.   The State of israeli politcal culture 19:23  |  Danite 01/11/06
  62.   Israel is a small country, you cannot get lost 19:30  |  d.dor 01/11/06
  63.   Send this terrorist to Teheran 19:44  |  Nathaniel 01/11/06
  64.   The ember died long ago 19:44  |  david 01/11/06
  65.   Ha`Aretz What was wrong with my response to Yossi? 19:48  |  Ari ben Yisrael 01/11/06
  66.   Enough with "candle in the wind" 20:09  |  Paul Freedman 01/11/06
  67.   Jewish terrorism not more deadly than Arab 20:12  |  Paul Freedman 01/11/06
  68.   Remember the Altelena!! 20:26  |  Menachem 01/11/06
  69.   6x4 20:36  |  U.R 01/11/06
  70.   right wing sephardi religous murderer 20:53  |  geula amir 01/11/06
  71.   Stop The Leftist Incitement And Get The Real Murderers 20:54  |  ML Bentovim 01/11/06
  72.   Danite #55 20:59  |  gabe1 01/11/06
  73.   Ari Ibn Ishmael #50 21:05  |  Gabe1 01/11/06
  74.   The ember died long ago 21:40  |  Ricardo Kolbe 01/11/06
  75.   eshkeNAZI scum 21:59  |  Menachem 01/11/06
  76.   The State of israeli politcal culture 22:09  |  Mark Lincoln 01/11/06
  77.   Mark Lincoln 22:42  |  Danite 01/11/06
  78.   Menachim 22:46  |  danite 01/11/06
  79.   Geula 22:53  |  Danite 01/11/06
  80.   SWISS I will"open my mouth" as much as I want 23:16  |  PETER SM 01/11/06
  81.   Israeli astonishing responses! 23:38  |  Sharif Hafez 01/11/06
  82.   Torah and Punishement in Israel 23:49  |  Lubnani Yehudi 01/11/06
  83.   A pardon for the murder of the prime minister! 00:05  |  mike goldberg 02/11/06
  84.   No One Takes Responsibility 00:15  |  Ed 02/11/06
  85.   gabe1(3rd try) 00:17  |  Danite 02/11/06
  86.   uala!!! menajem 00:28  |  dr danielito 02/11/06
  87.   Rabin: assassinating the assassin 00:42  |  BigL 02/11/06
  88.   Yigal Amir 01:43  |  Wendy 02/11/06
  89.   RABIN WAS A TERRIBLE LEADER 01:55  |  MEIR WEINSTEIN 02/11/06
  90.   no way. he should rot until his bones turn to dust 02:22  |  ralph 02/11/06
  91.   we`re no longer under the law. 02:59  |  maria 02/11/06
  92.   To Menachem #75 03:07  |  Lubnani Yehudi 02/11/06
  93.   still no reason to pardon. let him rot until he is dust 03:15  |  ralph 02/11/06
  94.   Menachem (Post No. 68) 03:29  |  Johnny Weintraub 02/11/06
  95.   The survey showed only 5% want Amir released now.95% DO NOT 04:04  |  PETER SM 02/11/06
  96.   amir 07:17  |  daave 02/11/06
  97.   And Israel wants peace? 07:32  |  Iymen 02/11/06
  98.   Yigal Amir the Great Zionist Hero will be Honored like Hertzl . 07:43  |  Joseph 02/11/06
  99.   jew does not imprison jew 08:42  |  abbba 02/11/06
  100.   Pardon 09:10  |  Frank 02/11/06
  101.   Are you sure Haaretz? Shin Bet`s...... 09:18  |  Maureen Ann 02/11/06
  102.   Rabin, may he rest in peace 09:49  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 02/11/06
  103.   IF RABIN WERE ALIVE HE ..... 10:06  |  YONI 02/11/06
  104.   LET YIGAL GO 11:54  |  asa 02/11/06
  105.   #101 - Maureen 01:45  |  BEN JABO 03/11/06
  106.   Request 23:24  |  Jennifer C. Ward 04/05/07
  107.   Request 23:27  |  Jennifer C. Ward 04/05/07
 Today Online
U.S. presents Israel, PA with detailed demands
Responses: 327
Sources: Evidence on Bishara sufficient for indictment
Responses: 46
Avi Issacharoff: The world has forgotten about Gaza
Responses: 72
Editorial: Peres must assume temporary leadership of country
Responses: 54
Mairovich: Israel will again correct failures by going to war
Responses: 64


More Headlines
20:27 U.S. official: Demands not being imposed on anyone
20:33 Border Police kill 3 Islamic Jihad militants in gunbattle near Jenin
19:18 Olmert vows to stay on despite mass rally calling on him to quit
22:47 PA officials deny reports Abbas may resign over int'l sanctions
22:48 University heads postpone ultimatum to end student strike
21:10 Two-year-old goes missing during family outing in Upper Galilee
19:40 Israeli, Palestinian activists urge EU role in reviving peace efforts
17:19 Jewish monument in Germany vandalized a second time in days
22:35 Police Chief Cohen appoints new officers to top positions
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved