Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., November 02, 2006 Cheshvan 11, 5767 | | Israel Time: 18:21 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Naftali Tamir, Israel's ambassador to Australia, denies having said Israel and Australia are white sisters amid 'the yellow race' of Asia. (Daniel Tchetchik)
Last update - 16:13 31/10/2006
Israel curtails term of Australia envoy after 'yellow race' remark
By Charlotte Halle, Haaretz Correspondent

Foreign Ministry sources said Tuesday that Israel's ambassador to Australia will have his term cut short in the wake of an interview to Haaretz, in which he called Australia and Israel white sisters amid "the yellow race."

Naftali Tamir was on his way back to Canberra on Tuesday following a two-week review process in Jerusalem where he denied having made the comments attributed to him, Foreign Ministry spokesman Mark Regev said.

But ministry sources say that an internal tender for his post - which includes non-resident accreditation to New Zealand and Papua New Guinea - will be issued shortly. They add that several senior diplomats have already shown an interest the post.

Advertisement

"Israel and Australia are like sisters in Asia," Tamir told Haaretz during a visit to Israel three weeks ago. "We are in Asia without the characteristics of Asians. We don't have yellow skin and slanted eyes. Asia is basically the yellow race. Australia and Israel are not - we are basically the white race. We are on the western side of Asia and they are on the southeastern side."

Following the publication of the interview on October 13, Tamir was immediately recalled to Israel to explain his comments. The ministry swiftly condemned the reported remarks as "grave and unacceptable," adding that it would not return to business as usual if its internal review confirmed the ambassador had indeed made the statements.

Earlier Tuesday, Regev refrained from commenting on whether Tamir's version of events had been accepted by his superiors at the ministry, stating only: "The ambassador denied the remarks attributed to him immediately following their publication, and he did so through all stages of the internal Foreign Ministry review. He is on his way back and will arrive in Australia tomorrow."

Under normal circumstances, Tamir, who arrived in Canberra in January 2005, would have been expected to remain in post for four years, but his return date is now likely to be sometime in 2007.

Tamir's early departure from his post is aimed at minimizing the damage caused by the affair, say sources close to the ministry. The plan to shorten Tamir's term will be made clear to his host governments, a ministry insider added.

In Australia, the comments were labeled as "completely unacceptable" by senior opposition politician Kevin Rudd, while New Zealand's Prime Minister Helen Clark was quoted as saying: "If the remarks are as reported, of course they are completely unacceptable. If they were made by anyone in our public service, there would be quite severe consequences."

The affair, given its widespread coverage in the media in Australia, placed the Jewish community there in an embarrassing position, as they struggled to balance their customary support Israel's highest representative in the region and with efforts to distance themselves from the comments.

It is still unclear what kind of reception Tamir will face upon his return to Canberra. While the Jewish community is likely to rally round the ambassador, the Australian government and the Australian media may be less understanding.

Members of Australia's Jewish community fear that Tamir's return will cause further damage, providing ammunition to those who charge that Israel is a racist state and that the Australian government should moderate its overtly pro-Israel stance.

Some who have followed the affair closely have speculated that firing or recalling Tamir without conclusive proof that he actually made the comments would leave the ministry open to legal action. "The ministry didn't have much room for maneuver," said one insider.

The ministry's response to the incident has been followed closely by those keen to see how its relatively new leadership of Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni and director-general Aharon Abramovich handles a crisis.

While the ministry's initial strong and swift response won widespread praise, those following the affair will take note as to whether senior officials will follow through quickly with seeking a suitable replacement for Tamir.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Illegal gambling sites
Companies are charging for advertising for gambling web sites - illegally.
From hem to hem
Designers Ehud Ziv-Av and Maya Baranes want to ensure their clothes are 100% Israeli.
  1.   never 14:51  |  john 31/10/06
  2.   One has to be an idiot to talk to Jurnos! 14:56  |  Moshe 31/10/06
  3.   Tamir 14:57  |  StevieT 31/10/06
  4.   beaucracacy and chutzpah 15:10  |  Paul 31/10/06
  5.   if he said he should have been fired immediately 15:21  |  steve 31/10/06
  6.   # 2 Moshe 15:23  |  Gil J. Yashar 31/10/06
  7.   White? Israel is muliti coloured. 15:46  |  S Judah 31/10/06
  8.   For external consumption 15:55  |  Dani Reiss 31/10/06
  9.   stupid remark 15:58  |  dimsum 31/10/06
  10.   BUNCH OF IDIOTS, JEWS ARE ALL COLORS OF THE RAINBOW 16:11  |  Like it is 31/10/06
  11.   Didnt Queen Elizabeth`s husband cause a diplo-rift for just this 16:13  |  AV 31/10/06
  12.   Why all the waffling? Livni unfit. 16:45  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 31/10/06
  13.   Stop playing games 16:49  |  Avrum 31/10/06
  14.   As time passes 17:02  |  Michael 31/10/06
  15.   John, politically correct B.S. 17:18  |  Jake 31/10/06
  16.   To Gil Yashar 17:25  |  Jake 31/10/06
  17.   Arrogant and infantile 17:39  |  L A 31/10/06
  18.   If he said it, 17:40  |  sh 31/10/06
  19.   well..Naboliun warned the West about the Yellow race 17:45  |  Gaza Boy 31/10/06
  20.   Jake # 15 17:56  |  Gil J. Yashar 31/10/06
  21.   Jews are Canaanites 18:17  |  AV 31/10/06
  22.   To Gil Yashar 18:24  |  Jake 31/10/06
  23.   Gun Jumpers 18:28  |  D 31/10/06
  24.   to Dani Reiss 18:36  |  Israeli 31/10/06
  25.   JUST ANOTHER ONE HOLDING ON TO HIS CHAIR 19:08  |  Robert 31/10/06
  26.   AV, only Pals jew, Pal moslim, Pal Christians and Pals Druz 19:09  |  Gaza Boy 31/10/06
  27.   AV, slight exaggeration 19:11  |  Jake 31/10/06
  28.   Palestinian Muslims are absolute NOT Canaanites 19:35  |  AV 31/10/06
  29.   J2 is the ancient Indoeuropeans 19:56  |  AV 31/10/06
  30.   ...and Lieberman enters the government... 19:59  |  ben 31/10/06
  31.   To Moshe 20:01  |  Journo 31/10/06
  32.   AV, J2 is PRE-Indo-European 20:47  |  Jake 31/10/06
  33.   a halooween monster snuck out of the closet 21:03  |  dan 31/10/06
  34.   Yes, J2 is PRE-Indo-European 21:22  |  AV 31/10/06
  35.   to Jake 21:42  |  ben 31/10/06
  36.   "without conclusive proof that he actually made the comments " 08:18  |  zayyin ba ayin 01/11/06
  37.   What a waste of time 23:23  |  logipundit 01/11/06
 Today Online
Is IDF using Gaza raid as way of silencing critics after the war?
Responses: 38
Report: Hamas steps up demands on Shalit deal
Responses: 78
Senior officials: Israel ignoring U.S. plans to leave Iraq
Responses: 64
Moroccan wins Iran Holocaust cartoon contest
Responses: 209
Ultra-Orthodox trying to stop gays marching in their own city
Responses: 42
Rosner's Domain
* Domain Guest: Diaspora Jews are marginal to Jewish history
* Ohio Notes: Lamont, Kerry, DeWine
* Wave of change may wash away pro-Israel politicians
* Poll: Is it important to have Jewish legislators in Washington?


More Headlines
18:08 Borovsky to be probed over attempted bribery allegations
16:19 Minister Ben-Eliezer calls on IDF Chief of Staff Halutz to resign
18:16 Court to state: Explain why Gaza students denied entry to Israel
17:11 Yuval Rabin: If alive, my father would save Israel from troubles
17:11 Abbas aide: Hamas given two weeks to decide on unity gov't
16:41 Palestinians: Four people killed in ongoing IDF raid in north Gaza
14:41 IDF paper: Lebanon overflights aim to pressure int'l community
14:45 Iran test fires nuclear-capable missile that could reach Israel
16:30 Canada gives asylum to 54 Palestinians who fled Iraq to Jordan
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Discover LOVE
See why JLove.com is the fastest growing Jewish relationship site committed to preserving Jewish values
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved