Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., November 04, 2006 Cheshvan 13, 5767 | | Israel Time: 08:56 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Yisrael Beiteinu MK Esterina Tartman. (Archive)
Last update - 19:19 31/10/2006
Yisrael Beiteinu MK retracts bill on expelling 'anti-Israel' MKs
By Gideon Alon, Haaretz Correspondent

Yisrael Beiteinu MK Esterina Tartman on Monday backed down from her intention to submit a bill that would grant the Knesset power to revoke the membership of a legislator deemed to be anti-Israeli.

Under the bill, a majority of 80 lawmakers could expel MKs who oppose the existence of the State of Israel as a democracy, are found responsible for racist incitement, or support armed resistance against Israel.

Tartman withdrew her proposal at the request of Knesset Speaker Dalia Itzik (Kadima), after left-wing lawmakers were outraged by the law, which was presented at a Knesset House Committee meeting.

Advertisement

Upon submission, the Yisrael Beiteinu MK also requested that her bill be brought for a preliminary reading in the Knesset this week, bypassing the standard 45-day waiting period for new bills.

During the stormy debate, MK Dov Khenin (Hadash) said "a similar bill was passed in the 1930s by the Reichstag in Nazi Germany, where 95 Communist parliamentarians were expelled."

Coalition chairman MK Avigdor Yitzhaki (Kadima) who backs the bill replied, "I have done a hundred times more for the Arabs than you; stop saying the nonsense that this is a racist bill."

MK Mohammed Barakeh (Hadash) fired back: "All the people sitting here think they are running a military regime."

Likud faction chairman, MK Gideon Sa'ar, also expressed his dismay at the bill, saying it goes too far. MK Zehava Galon (Meretz) said "this is a racist bill, which seeks to turn the Knesset into a judiciary tribunal; it contridicts constitutional principles and would not survive the scrutiny of the High Court."

MK Barakeh slammed Yitzhaki for his support of the bill. "Your support of such a racist bill is part of the way in which Kadima prostitutes itself in order to let Yisrael Beitenu into the coalition," he said.

Tartman respondend to the allegations, saying her bill is not directed against Arab MKs, but against anyone who goes against the state. She said she would consider when would be the appropriate timing for submitting her bill before the Knesset.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Super spears
The story of a stormy winter's night and a dream about asparagus.
Sins of the husbands
Haredi women who complain about abusive spouses risk being made outcasts.
  1.   WHAT !! Is wrong with our Left! 14:10  |  JM 30/10/06
  2.   Can someone tell me, what would have been wrong with such law? 14:18  |  Raphael 30/10/06
  3.   Hey! That was one of the few things YB had right... 14:20  |  David Teich 30/10/06
  4.   but it was okay to expel Kach and Kahane? 14:35  |  uzi silber 30/10/06
  5.   long live the resistence 14:42  |  Leon Rosgarten 30/10/06
  6.   Unbelievable. 14:55  |  The Raccoon 30/10/06
  7.   MK`s faulty rules 15:12  |  Peter 30/10/06
  8.   From Moldova, Tashkent and Kiev, come words of the "in" tribe 15:24  |  Yaakov Sullivan 30/10/06
  9.   JM totally agree 15:31  |  bev 30/10/06
  10.   What is wrong with Saar? 15:33  |  Piranha 30/10/06
  11.   Even in the U.S. 15:43  |  Sidney 30/10/06
  12.   Yisrael Beitenu MK retracts bill on expelling `anti-Israel` MKs 15:44  |  paul 30/10/06
  13.   No JM it is called freedom of speech! 15:50  |  Itsik 30/10/06
  14.   A BUNCH OF FASCISTS IN THE KNESSET 15:53  |  Messaoud 30/10/06
  15.   Yisrael Beitenu--A Logical Conclusion 15:55  |  Ibn Filastin 30/10/06
  16.   Expell anti-Israel MK`s from Gov`t. 16:00  |  Terry Brodsky 30/10/06
  17.   racist bill 16:06  |  sandra chitayat 30/10/06
  18.   Left wing outraged by the existance of Israel-send them to Mecca 16:08  |  Sal 30/10/06
  19.   The Left 16:15  |  CAtherine 30/10/06
  20.   bev and her trumped up charges #8 16:21  |  Yaakov Sullivan 30/10/06
  21.   "Yaakov" Sullivan and tribes - #7 16:26  |  Kate 30/10/06
  22.   Seems like a totally reasonable bill to me .. 16:41  |  redmike 30/10/06
  23.   #6 - did you vote for IB ? I did and I don`t feel betrayed ! 16:43  |  redmike 30/10/06
  24.   Brodsky and his call for the Slansky Trials of Israel 16:46  |  Yaakov Sullivan 30/10/06
  25.   The spirit and the letter, son of palestine 16:55  |  Jasmine Murphy 30/10/06
  26.   Tartman 17:08  |  Bob 30/10/06
  27.   Sullivan #7, and the like-minded 17:16  |  Antonio Arab-hater 30/10/06
  28.   Obviously, Kate you did choose to stay #15 17:17  |  Yaakov Sullivan 30/10/06
  29.   A government must protect its citizens 17:22  |  Bruriah sarah 30/10/06
  30.   Israel digs her own grave 17:27  |  Bimmer 30/10/06
  31.   #7 That`s right Paddy, They`re Jews 17:36  |  Alexander 30/10/06
  32.   Polish up the bill 17:40  |  Efox 30/10/06
  33.   Insane left 17:44  |  Gene 30/10/06
  34.   Israel- a thoroughly amazing country 17:59  |  Avrum 30/10/06
  35.   Son of Palestine. 1)No MK in Israel can be charged of that which 17:59  |  Nadav 30/10/06
  36.   Katz, I second your statement with regard to Mr. Sullivan!!! 18:26  |  Yaniv 30/10/06
  37.   yaakov 18:32  |  bev 30/10/06
  38.   Apparently, Kate, You`ve decided to stay in London #15 19:12  |  Yaakov Sullivan 30/10/06
  39.   Yes, Alexander, quite right #20 19:15  |  Yaakov Sullivan 30/10/06
  40.   What is fascism 19:40  |  Yakov 30/10/06
  41.   Yaniv, I think you meant "Kate" 19:45  |  Yaakov Sullivan 30/10/06
  42.   bev-look at home 20:01  |  peter 30/10/06
  43.   Can someone tell me, what would have been wrong with such law?? 20:04  |  Raphael 30/10/06
  44.   What about the Jew MPs in other countries? 20:07  |  Petteri 30/10/06
  45.   This seems like a something to defend all minorities, not racist 20:12  |  David 30/10/06
  46.   tartman and the tart yaakov sullivan 20:54  |  zadok the priest 30/10/06
  47.   london kate a good and sensible post 21:03  |  disraeli 30/10/06
  48.   Yaakov: Up the dosage, the lithium`s not working 21:05  |  David Teich 30/10/06
  49.   Antonio the Arab Hater on Ethnicity #19 21:20  |  Yaakov Sullivan 30/10/06
  50.   bev, I asked you to define their "treason" #29 21:51  |  Yaakov Sullivan 30/10/06
  51.   What`s the difference between Kahane and Tibi? 21:52  |  Polybios 30/10/06
  52.   Traitors of Democracy 21:55  |  Simon 30/10/06
  53.   Haaretz, how do you put `anti-Israel` in quotes?!? 22:00  |  Joshua Berman 30/10/06
  54.   Hats off, halfway 22:31  |  Yoseph 30/10/06
  55.   sullivan that you should label others" haters" 00:23  |  zadok the priest 31/10/06
  56.   To Simon # 53 00:32  |  Yoseph 31/10/06
  57.   yaakov treasonhow about Wasal Taha???? 00:35  |  bev 31/10/06
  58.   Petteri perhaps... 00:39  |  bev 31/10/06
  59.   to those who have opposed this law 01:53  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 31/10/06
  60.   Double standards - Its okay to discriminate against Jews 01:54  |  Dr David Gross 31/10/06
  61.   Yaakov Sullivan 03:20  |  Truth detector 31/10/06
  62.   When Islamofasists in Knesset call for Israel`s destruction 03:27  |  PETER SM 31/10/06
  63.   Reasonable minds prevailed. So don`t worry. Be happy. 05:01  |  Timothy 31/10/06
  64.   Sandra Chitayat and looks on the face 05:24  |  James 31/10/06
  65.   Sullivan 05:24  |  TM 31/10/06
  66.   #13 Itsik 06:28  |  Willy 31/10/06
  67.   Contortions 08:03  |  Tom 31/10/06
  68.   You`re absolutely right. 08:18  |  Micha 31/10/06
  69.   Oh by the way... 08:21  |  Micha 31/10/06
  70.   I haven`t seen obvious tie-in with Hezb mentioned & 63 agreed 08:29  |  sheri 31/10/06
  71.   As far as it being a Jewish state... 08:32  |  sheri 31/10/06
  72.   #67, Tom 08:50  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 31/10/06
  73.   # 5 Leon Rosgarten 10:06  |  Josef 31/10/06
  74.   Cipora Julianna Kohn 10:07  |  sh 31/10/06
  75.   to Raphael #2 10:08  |  zeev 31/10/06
  76.   # 44 Petteri 10:08  |  Jouni 31/10/06
  77.   to C. J.Kohn #72 11:02  |  zeev 31/10/06
  78.   #73, Josef 11:11  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 31/10/06
  79.   #74, sh 11:16  |  Cipora Jolianna Kohn 31/10/06
  80.   #77, zeev 12:01  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 31/10/06
  81.   to C. J.Kohn #80 16:47  |  zeev 31/10/06
  82.   to Leon Rosgarten #5 18:46  |  zeev 31/10/06
  83.   Zeev - yes its an act, but in the US it`s congress who judges 18:57  |  sheri 31/10/06
  84.   #81, zeev 23:54  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 31/10/06
  85.   to C. J.Kohn #84 02:03  |  zeev 01/11/06
  86.   83: Sheri, There is grey, but not everything is grey 08:02  |  David Teich 01/11/06
  87.   #86 I agreed on the treason... 18:03  |  sheri 01/11/06
  88.