Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., October 31, 2006 Cheshvan 9, 5767 | | Israel Time: 10:37 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Why boycott Qatar?
By Haaretz Editorial

Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni made an odd decision. She canceled her participation in the UN-sponsored sixth International Conference on New or Restored Democracies, which is being held next month in Qatar.

The reason for the cancelation: the participation in the event by Palestinian government lawmakers from Hamas.

It is difficult to comprehend what motivated Livni's decision, especially in light of the fact that she will permit senior Foreign Ministry officials to take part in the conference.

Advertisement

Does this mean that the presence of a representative from the Israeli Foreign Ministry in the same place as parliamentarians from Hamas does not indicate recognition of Hamas, while a minister's participation in the event would translate into recognition of the movement?

Perhaps Israel should declare a boycott of Qatar, the only Arab state that is willing to maintain friendly relations with it and to permit an Israeli representation to operate in Doha, despite the absence of formal diplomatic ties? Or perhaps the conference should be boycotted because it includes representatives from, among others, Iran, Syria and Lebanon?

A significant lack of insight characterizes Livni's decision. She was not being asked to speak with the Hamas members or to shake their hands. Furthermore, Qatar was the target of great pressure and criticism for having invited her.

The Lebanese foreign minister, among others, decided not to attend the conference, but Qatari Foreign Minister Sheikh Hamad bin Jassem al-Thani, was not deterred - just as he has not been deterred from meeting Israeli officials in New York and other locations, and just as he did not refrain from an attempt to mediate the conflict with the Palestinians despite the low chance of success. By inviting Israel - with the agreement of Qatar's leader - the foreign minister sought to reach an additional stage in Israel's legitimization that would have tested the other Arab and Islamic states that are participating in the event.

Livni apparently decided that Israel was not obligated to respect the boldness shown by Qatar's leaders.

In her eyes, the opportunity just to make an appearance in surroundings that are ordinarily out-of-bounds to Israel was less important than enforcing the boycott against Hamas.

The result is not only a diplomatic loss to Israel, but also a total win to Hamas. Its representatives who, like Israel's, are suffering from a dearth of invitations to Arab states, now realize that they have veto power over any Arab gesture toward Israel. It is sufficient for a Hamas representative to attend a conference for Israel to be left out. The leaders of Hamas could not have predicted such a diplomatic achievement.

Livni's self-righteous declaration that Israel will not go where terror organizations have been invited cannot be accepted in this instance.

Representatives of states that are friendly with Israel went to Qatar, and the conference is sponsored by the UN, in which Israel is active and which is itself bound by certain definitions of terror organizations. Most of the states attending continue to boycott Hamas, for exactly the same reasons as Israel does.

Livni should have taken more time for consideration before making her decision.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Carpenters of Nazareth
At an Upper Nazareth mall, retirees are offered the chance to work for a pay check.
In their defense
The Defense Ministry wants to pay off its property tax debt directly to the state.
  1.   Israel and PR 09:54  |  Maral 30/10/06
  2.   HOW about asking Livni instead of attributing motives? 09:54  |  PETER SM 30/10/06
  3.   Because she is so weak and lazy 10:09  |  Gaza Boy 30/10/06
  4.   Livni Should Go To Anyplace Except Iran And Syria! 10:20  |  Yosemite Sam 30/10/06
  5.   Hamas: an imposing reality in today`s world 10:23  |  Jew 30/10/06
  6.   Linvi is either stupid like other ministers or Olmert vetoed it. 10:25  |  Haham me Bat Yam 30/10/06
  7.   no. 1 hi Maral counterproductive 10:28  |  cool 30/10/06
  8.   Well Done Livni . Now Order IDF to Blow Hamas Down 10:35  |  Joseph E . 30/10/06
  9.   there is an Israeli delegation in Qatar 11:20  |  jean marie 30/10/06
  10.   ok joe 11:26  |  jean marie 30/10/06
  11.   joseph E 11:28  |  A.M. 30/10/06
  12.   Reading minds 11:31  |  Michael II 30/10/06
  13.   EMOTION COMES FIRST 11:38  |  indrajaya 30/10/06
  14.   .. BECAUSE ISRAEL IS NOT A DEMOCRACY 11:47  |  Messaoud 30/10/06
  15.   Isolation 11:51  |  Fritz 30/10/06
  16.   Maral. Livni is actually one of the most level-headed people in 12:06  |  Shlomzion 30/10/06
  17.   Cool. You, writing to us from Germany, relying stricltly on a 12:20  |  Shlomzion 30/10/06
  18.   To meet somebody 12:26  |  Anne 30/10/06
  19.   don`t give peace a chance 12:37  |  freddy 30/10/06
  20.   What is it about capital letters?? 12:39  |  Honi 30/10/06
  21.   Gift from heaven 12:40  |  Peter 30/10/06
  22.   Maral 12:42  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 30/10/06
  23.   Hello, Margie :) 13:02  |  Maral 30/10/06
  24.   Livni could have gone and stated Israel`s case against Hamas 13:08  |  Ronnie Wolman 30/10/06
  25.   Hi Shlomzion 13:09  |  Maral 30/10/06
  26.   Making headlines 13:09  |  JJ 30/10/06
  27.   #13 Jakartan Ape 13:36  |  Itsik 30/10/06
  28.   Who Cares? 13:44  |  Nizo the Palestinian 30/10/06
  29.   Not seeking openings - dont want peace 13:45  |  lennybruce 30/10/06
  30.   Margie in Tel Aviv 13:47  |  Walid 30/10/06
  31.   we all love what she done 13:51  |  kessemah 30/10/06
  32.   "Haaretz" won`t rest until a new hostage , Livni, is taken 13:53  |  Absolute Sweden 30/10/06
  33.   Incompetence 13:59  |  Jo Jo 30/10/06
  34.   Margie 14:03  |  Judith 30/10/06
  35.   # 11 A.M. 14:37  |  Joseph E . 30/10/06
  36.   Maral. Actually, I was not offended by your terminology, so no 14:45  |  Shlomzion 30/10/06
  37.   Walid forget about the US 14:53  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 30/10/06
  38.   Judith 14:57  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 30/10/06
  39.   Haaretz is very sweet with Tzipi 14:59  |  Jonathan S 30/10/06
  40.   Walid. Your first paragraph was good, but once you start to 15:03  |  Shlomzion 30/10/06
  41.   Kessemah 15:08  |  Walid 30/10/06
  42.   Ronnie Wolman 15:17  |  CHGODMK 30/10/06
  43.   Linvi/Hamas/Lieberman 15:17  |  Political 30/10/06
  44.   Re: Fritz. What for is he righting ti JEWISH newspaper. Several.. 15:24  |  Vittorio 30/10/06
  45.   Maral #1 15:31  |  Guido 30/10/06
  46.   17, may God - in whom you do not believe - forgive your lies 16:07  |  John and the Truth 30/10/06
  47.   An ISRAELI MINISTER seen wih ARABS! 16:11  |  Lubnani Yehudi 30/10/06
  48.   Why boycot Qatar 16:17  |  Shmuelshachor 30/10/06
  49.   MORE PATHETIC INCOMPETENCE OF THE INCOMPETENTS... 16:21  |  bat yam 30/10/06
  50.   Livni should go to Beirut 16:21  |  Lubnani Yehudi 30/10/06
  51.   To Maral re: Livni and Hamas 16:39  |  David James Vickery 30/10/06
  52.   to Shlomzion - is this Israel`s best? 16:48  |  Peter 30/10/06
  53.   To Margie about diplomacy 16:56  |  John 30/10/06
  54.   Olmert/Livni: Driven by Polls not Ideas 17:07  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 30/10/06
  55.   44 - Truth? 17:08  |  Bruriah Sarah 30/10/06
  56.   Lubnani Yehudi 17:08  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 30/10/06
  57.   Livni 17:38  |  PLRT 30/10/06
  58.   A mistake on Livni`s part 17:48  |  Jacob Blues 30/10/06
  59.   Livni needs to reconsider 17:48  |  peter 30/10/06
  60.   Apt observation Maral 17:52  |  Jacob Blues 30/10/06
  61.   Joseph E. you`re wrong on this one 17:55  |  peter 30/10/06
  62.   I disagree Walid 17:56  |  Jacob Blues 30/10/06
  63.   To Margie: Shalom/Salaam registration form 17:58  |  David James Vickery 30/10/06
  64.   Chutzpah! Boycotting Qatar 18:20  |  Fed Up 30/10/06
  65.   Foreign boycott of Qatar 18:24  |  Peter Halban 30/10/06
  66.   Walid on Israeli bashing Israeli 18:40  |  Ronnie Wolman 30/10/06
  67.   clothes 18:43  |  gershon 30/10/06
  68.   She should have gone. Olmert said No 19:03  |  Semsem 30/10/06
  69.   Peter: "Is this Israel`s best?" 19:11  |  Shlomzion 30/10/06
  70.   # 39 Jonathan S., You missed my other posts 19:34  |  Haham me Bat Yam 30/10/06
  71.   The invitation wasn`t in a formal way 19:45  |  Gaza Boy 30/10/06
  72.   for once I agree with a Haaretz editorial 19:57  |  Noam 30/10/06
  73.   Jacob Blues on Livni and Diplomacy #57 19:58  |  Yaakov Sullivan 30/10/06
  74.   LIVNI IS A HYPOCRITE 20:12  |  Dutch 30/10/06
  75.   Israel confused about Palestinian elections 20:25  |  Tosefta 30/10/06
  76.   CHGODMK: There is Nothing To Lose 20:41  |  Ronnie Wolman 30/10/06
  77.   #17 Fritz, Thank you 20:47  |  Dutch 30/10/06
  78.   To Haham me Bat Yam #63 20:49  |  Jonathan S 30/10/06
  79.   To jonathan s and joseph e 21:05  |  A.M. 30/10/06
  80.   Why indeed? 21:19  |  Asher Levelheaded 30/10/06
  81.   Israel missed an oppportunity. 21:22  |  Blinky the Fish 30/10/06
  82.   Ronnie Wolman, I agree with you on the PR issue 21:37  |  Mark B. 30/10/06
  83.   Quatar Meeting 22:13  |  Gregdn 30/10/06
  84.   MACBETH 22:14  |  Arik Silverman 30/10/06
  85.   to Peter Halban 22:18  |  gershon82 30/10/06
  86.   Israel confused about Palestinian elections 22:24  |  Tosefta 30/10/06
  87.   Fed Up #59 Speaking of Chutzpah! 22:39  |  Gee 30/10/06
  88.   # 56 Peter @ Montreal / Canada 22:48  |  Joseph E . 30/10/06
  89.   Certainly it was