Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., November 02, 2006 Cheshvan 11, 5767 | | Israel Time: 09:21 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Pride and prejudice
By Yoav Sivan

After the cease-fire agreement was reached in August, it took only a few days for the Jerusalem Open House to reschedule a gay pride parade in town, after the WorldPride march was put off indefinitely because of the war. It took an even shorter amount of time for the usual opponents of the Israeli lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) community to launch their missiles. Indeed, ultra-Orthodox Shas was quick to comment, saying the party regards "with severity those who do not allow the country to recover after the war."

This brought about the usual responses; this time, sharp protests from MKs and activists in Meretz, the gay-friendly party. But these conflicting opinions are old news in Israel. What is new is the common ground shared by the Jerusalem Open House and Shas. Apparently both parties seem to think the war should set aside ongoing issues, including confrontations about gay legitimacy.

Of course, this ad hoc agreement should come as no surprise. War is grave enough an affair to make all other matters redundant. Nevertheless, this is not the first time WorldPride was pushed aside by a large-scale event. During the pullout from Gaza, the Open House chose not to hold WorldPride on its original date while residents were being evacuated from their homes. Now the cannons are silent again: Has the time arrived to embark anew on the gay rights campaign? Or perhaps, as the Shas spokesman implicitly suggested, the fight should only resume when the aftermath of the war comes to an end.

Advertisement

From the very beginning, the Open House faced a tough call. In the last couple of months, police said it would be difficult to secure the parade, due to threats by Jewish extremists. WorldPride even brought about the impossible coalition of Christian, Jewish and Muslim religious leaders through a unified call for intolerance at the supposed abomination of the Holy City. When the war broke out, the police shifted its attention to the North, and it became evident that not only would it be unfeasible for the police to secure the event, but such a demand would lose the public's support. The goal from the onset was to isolate the conservative anti-gay Jewish Orthodox community and to encourage the general public to side with the LGBT community. The Open House, in the end, compromised on switching to a low-profile protest instead of the march.

Recently, after an appeal to the Supreme Court, the parade was rescheduled to November 10. This event will hardly be the planned flagship march. It aims modestly to entrench the rather new Jerusalem Pride tradition and help ultra-Orthodox Mayor Lupolianski accommodate it. Unlike the parades in Tel Aviv, the parades in Jerusalem are hardly a carnival, but are rather an old-fashioned political demonstration.

But even in its modest form, the planned event - the fifth Pride parade in Jerusalem thus far - has come under growing attack. Interestingly, the opposition has spread from the religious circles to the secular mainstream. Most notably, Vice Premier Shimon Peres signed a petition opposing the parade, proving that being a champion of peace does not necessarily correlate to being an advocate of human rights. Nobel Peace laureate Peres is not alone. National Infrastructures Minister Benjamin Ben-Eliezer has joined the petition too. Education Minister Professor Yuli Tamir undermined the LGBT claim for legitimacy when she said the parade should not take place in the city center.

This whole affair can shed some light on the current situation and the political goals of the LGBT community in Israel. Ten years ago, gay activists were fighting for recognition among the liberal-secular sectors of society. Now the struggle is focused on our place in the mainstream.

In a demonstration last week, thousands of ultra-Othodox Jews blamed gay people for arousing God's wrath, causing Israel's downfall in the recent war. Gay people have never before been credited with having such an influence. Yet, at the same time, the fact that a religious extremist stabbed three people during the parade in Jerusalem last year did not factor in with the rabbis' sense of public responsibility.

Advocates of gay rights will gradually shift to demanding LGBT's inclusion in the local lexicon of political correctness. This call is addressed at the mainstream politicians, rather than the rabbis: If Mr. Peres is indeed serious about being elected as the next president, he should prove he can lead everyone, including myself. Similarly, it is about time we expect Prime Minister Olmert, whose daughter is openly gay, to also be publicly supportive of LGBT rights.

Yoav Sivan, LGBT Coordinator of Young Meretz, is a member the Presidium of the International Union of Socialist Youth.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Illegal gambling sites
Companies are charging for advertising for gambling web sites - illegally.
From hem to hem
Designers Ehud Ziv-Av and Maya Baranes want to ensure their clothes are 100% Israeli.
  1.   Pride and prejudice 09:53  |  Gerald Zang 29/10/06
  2.   Gerald, about "flag waving" 10:30  |  Maral 29/10/06
  3.   If only 10:48  |  Frantz 29/10/06
  4.   in reply to # 1 Gerald 10:57  |  SJ 29/10/06
  5.   To No 4. SJ the "Tzadik" 11:26  |  Ben Israel 29/10/06
  6.   to # 5 12:06  |  Paul Vanwynsberghe 29/10/06
  7.   Ben Israel 12:15  |  Maral 29/10/06
  8.   In your face? no. 12:53  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 29/10/06
  9.   reply to ben #5 13:00  |  SJ 29/10/06
  10.   #3rd try: Haaretz editors censoring religious right viewpoint 14:45  |  Moshe 29/10/06
  11.   Mrgie. I find myself agreeing with you again, although it is not 14:47  |  Shlomzion 29/10/06
  12.   Gay parades 15:20  |  Sam 29/10/06
  13.   Hot Air - A National Resource 15:41  |  Dani Reiss 29/10/06
  14.   Shlomzion, haveri 15:43  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 29/10/06
  15.   Moshe 15:44  |  Jasmine Murphy 29/10/06
  16.   #15 Jasmine: Then you are suspicious of G-d`s word 16:13  |  Moshe 29/10/06
  17.   Margie. Thank you for the information. Also it is interesting you 16:38  |  Shlomzion 29/10/06
  18.   Gay Parade 16:43  |  Terry 29/10/06
  19.   What is needed is balance 17:20  |  Ronnie Wolman 29/10/06
  20.   reply to #16 17:59  |  SJ 29/10/06
  21.   Moshe 18:09  |  Jasmine Murphy 29/10/06
  22.   HOW UNFAIR--GAYS MARCH BUT KAHANISTS ARE ILLEGAL 18:30  |  DAN ROSENTHAL 29/10/06
  23.   Yoav Sivan is NOT correct in his thesis. 19:58  |  sk 29/10/06
  24.   Haaretz censorship strikes again 21:15  |  sk 29/10/06
  25.   Re: Jerusalam parade is balanced 22:41  |  John 29/10/06
  26.   The Numbers Don`t Add Up 23:50  |  Dave 29/10/06
  27.   IN RESPONSE TO EVERYONE 00:56  |  WAHEAB 30/10/06
  28.   Assumptions, assumptions 01:22  |  Steph 30/10/06
  29.   when was the last time you heard of a straight sex parade? 01:27  |  Saul Tobin 30/10/06
  30.   Dan Rosenthal -- have you considered... 01:42  |  bbl 30/10/06
  31.   Dave -- the standard figure is 10% 01:51  |  bbl 30/10/06
  32.   Oh and Dave... 01:52  |  bbl 30/10/06
  33.   The survival of Israel is absolutely necessary for gays 02:21  |  AV 30/10/06
  34.   Such a delightful picture 02:25  |  Thinker 30/10/06
  35.   we like yossy beilin, give us gay pride parade. 02:26  |  vladimir 30/10/06
  36.   When was the last time you heard of a straight sex parade? ... 02:34  |  AV 30/10/06
  37.   @22, let`s have gay - kach parade!!!!!! 02:37  |  vladimir 30/10/06
  38.   Prom queen and prom king - ALL HETEROSEX PARADES 02:38  |  AV 30/10/06
  39.   @23, sk you are not right, we have y. beilin, 02:39  |  vladimir 30/10/06
  40.   @24, yes, we like kahanist gays. bravo y. beilin 02:41  |  vladimir 30/10/06
  41.   In the Tora, it is permitted for men to have sex with eachother. 02:52  |  AV 30/10/06
  42.   @26, dave, give us parade with y. beilin and kh. mashal 02:55  |  vladimir 30/10/06
  43.   @27, waheab, gay rights to pals too with y. beilin and kh. mashal 02:57  |  vladimir 30/10/06
  44.   @31, bbl, in left circles standard figure is 45%, not 10. 03:05  |  vladimir 30/10/06
  45.   Furthering Stereotypes 03:23  |  Joseph 30/10/06
  46.   Advice: Lehiot Haham lo Tzodek 03:23  |  Judy Abeles Eliasov 30/10/06
  47.   #39 AV and the "Canaanite sex ritual" 03:31  |  Steph 30/10/06
  48.   gay parade 06:15  |  Jorge Noe 30/10/06
  49.   gays to be respected but.... 06:27  |  Noah 30/10/06
  50.   Gay pride parade 08:50  |  Eli 30/10/06
  51.   41 - AV 09:27  |  Thinker 30/10/06
  52.   Fighting For Survival ... is it A joke 10:00  |  Samir 30/10/06
  53.   STRAIGHT PEOPLE 11:23  |  The Golem 30/10/06
  54.   Homosexuality in the Torah 13:03  |  Terry 30/10/06
  55.   To Thinker (51) 20:16  |  sk 30/10/06
  56.   why the parade shouldnt happen 03:30  |  - 02/11/06
  57.   to sk 08:13  |  Thinker 02/11/06
 Today Online
IDF soldier, eight Palestinians killed in north Gaza raid
Responses: 318
U.S. fears Iran and Syria aiding Hezbollah bid to oust Siniora
Responses: 115
Nasrallah: 'Serious' negotiations underway on fate of IDF soldiers
Responses: 166
Yossi Sarid: Yitzhak Rabin's assassin will inevitably be pardoned
Responses: 85
Lieberman's rise is due to the intifada and the Lebanon fiasco
Responses: 108
U.K. minister: Iranians 'hell-bent' on getting nuclear weapons
Responses: 155


More Headlines
09:05 Palestinians: Man killed in ongoing Gaza fighting
03:25 Hamas official: Initial agreement reached on unity gov't
09:14 Jerusalem officials say Israel ignoring U.S. plans to leave Iraq
06:50 Poll shows sharp drop in public's confidence in the state
08:22 Workers' strike causes delays at Ben Gurion International Airport
00:05 Moroccan wins first place in Iran Holocaust cartoon contest
09:06 Arab students say Hebrew Univ. med school discriminates against them
02:26 Blair likely to visit Middle East in next two months
08:26 IDF troops encounter gunfire in Jenin area, no casualties
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Discover LOVE
See why JLove.com is the fastest growing Jewish relationship site committed to preserving Jewish values
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved