Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., October 30, 2006 Cheshvan 8, 5767 | | Israel Time: 02:30 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Captive IDF soldier Gilad Shalit. (Archives)
Last update - 02:40 29/10/2006
After Cairo talks, Israel doubtful breakthrough reached on Shalit
By Aluf Benn, Avi Issacharoff, Yoav Stern and Jack Khoury, Haaretz Correspondents and Reuters

Senior Israeli security sources on Saturday expressed doubts that a breakthrough had been achieved among Palestinian factions involved in negotiating the release of Israel Defense Forces soldier Gilad Shalit, and urged caution, citing previous experience in talks for the release of Israelis.

The same sources pointed to the failure of Khaled Meshal, the head of the Hamas political office in Damascus, to arrive for pre-arranged talks in Cairo with Egyptian negotiators. Meshal is considered to be key to any move forward on the issue of Shalit, the likelihood of a Palestinian prisoner release, and the thorny subject of the establishment of a Palestinian national unity government.

The Popular Resistance Committees [PRC], a group involved in the abduction of Shalit, announced Saturday in the Gaza Strip that a resolution of the problem was due in "a number of days."

Advertisement

The spokesman for the PRC, Abu Mujahed [nom de guerre], said that the three Palestinian factions involved in the raid and abduction of Shalit last June have agreed to the deal put together by Egypt. According to the deal, Shalit will be freed in return for the release of Palestinian prisoners held in Israel.

A Hamas leader in the Gaza Strip, Osama al-Mazini, said in response to the PRC announcement that "significant progress has indeed been achieved in the matter of Gilad Shalit, but it is still too early to say if the deal will be carried out soon.

"Israel has agreed on the number of prisoners that will be released but we must also agree on their identity and only then can we say that there is an agreement," he said.

Shalit was kidnapped in June during a cross-border raid by the Gaza militants, including members of the Hamas military wing. Two other IDF soldiers were killed in the attack on their base, close to the Gaza border.

Al-Mazini was responsible for liaising between the Hamas military wing and the Egyptian mediators in the negotiations for Shalit's release, and as such his comments are considered highly reliable.

Other Palestinian sources said that a prisoner exchange would involve 1000 Palestinians held in Israel, and would be carried out in stages.

Earlier Saturday afternoon, Hamas downplayed claims by a separate Palestinian militant group of an imminent solution to the kidnapping, saying that while there had been "real progress," a prisoner swap was not about to take place.

Abu Obeida, a spokesman on behalf of Izz al-Din al-Qassam, Hamas' military wing, said that the negotiations over the Israeli soldier were at a standstill. Abu Obeida claimed that Israel is delaying its response to the demands posed by the kidnappers. He also insisted that his statements did not contradict those of the PRC.

The failure of Meshal to arrive for meetings in Cairo has clearly dented any hopeful prognoses for a quick release. According to Salah al-Bardawil, a senior Hamas figure in the Gaza Strip, there is no point in holding talks in Cairo if there is no agreement on the principles of the exchange and the establishment of a unity government.

Palestinian Chief Negotiator Saeb Erekat of Fatah said it was premature to think the crisis would soon be resolved.

"I don't think we're closer today to solving Shalit's problem than we were yesterday," Erekat told reporters in the West Bank city of Ramallah.

On Friday the Arabic-language newspaper Al Hayat reported a senior Hamas official in Damascus is demanding that Israel release Palestinian prisoners at the same time that Hamas frees Shalit.

According to the report, Hamas was awaiting an Israeli response to the proposal. The paper quoted the senior Hamas source as saying that the group was expecting Israel to be flexible on the timing of Shalit's release and that of the Palestinian prisoners.

Fatah officials had previously said that an Egyptian prisoner swap proposal calls for an initial release of Palestinian prisoners along with Shalit. The Fatah officials said a small group of prisoners would be freed in the first phase and a larger group would be freed two months later, including Palestinian prisoners considered to be political leaders. Altogether, 1,000 Palestinian prisoners would be released in the exchange.

Commenting on this proposal, Israeli sources said that "Israel can live with such a deal."

More than a week ago, Egyptian intelligence chief Omar Suleiman presented Meshal and his aides in Damascus with an initiative that includes the prisoner swap proposal and a deal on the establishment of a national unity government for the Palestinian Authority.

Meanwhile, the Palestinian factions in the Gaza Strip reached another agreement Saturday to put an end to the violent incidents between Fatah
and Hamas.

The Gaza Strip will be at the center of a security cabinet meeting on Wednesday, in which a decision will be made on Israel's response to the
continued launching of Qassam rockets and the smuggling of weapons from Sinai using tunnels.

Meshal slated to hold Cairo meeting on Shalit deal
Khaled Meshal, the head of Hamas's political bureau, skipped a scheduled meeting with senior Egyptian officials in Cairo on Saturday to discuss the proposed prisoner exchange.

Sources involved in the talks had described the meeting as "critical," estimating that if Meshal really did come from Damascus to attend the session, he would probably accept the proposed deal.

Israeli and Hamas sources had said that they were pessimistic about the chances of a deal actually materializing at the end of the Cairo meeting.

Senior Palestinian sources said Thursday that following the Cairo meetings, further consultations are expected to take place in Damascus among representatives of Fatah, Hamas, Syria, Qatar and Spain in order to solve the unity government conundrum.

The sources explained that Spain is willing to send representatives to these talks in an effort to solve the crisis in the Gaza Strip.

However, a senior Hamas official told Haaretz on Thursday that he is not optimistic that the talks in Egypt will result in either Shalit's release or the establishment of a national unity government.

An Israeli government source similarly said that "there is no reason to get excited about Meshal's visit to Cairo."

Government sources explained that they are not aware of any significant progress having been made in talks about a prisoner exchange.

Noam Shalit, Gilad Shalit's father, told Haaretz on Thursday that he was skeptical about the results of the meeting between Meshal and Suleiman.

He added that not a single Israeli official has reported to him on the government's expectations of this meeting.

"I hope that this meeting will take place and be fruitful. However, as long there is no such meeting, we have nothing to say on this matter," Shalit said.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Carpenters of Nazareth
At an Upper Nazareth mall, retirees are offered the chance to work for a pay check.
In their defense
The Defense Ministry wants to pay off its property tax debt directly to the state.
  1.   Exchange is a Form of Kidnapping Incitement 06:23  |  Joseph E . 27/10/06
  2.   It is very interesting that the Palestinian need to abduct people 06:58  |  Yaniv 27/10/06
  3.   A question 07:30  |  Hastaroth 27/10/06
  4.   #4, Khalid 09:51  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 27/10/06
  5.   @ $ Ali Baba`s business ethics 10:19  |  Nora 27/10/06
  6.   Ali Baba`s Consultations for Shalit 10:32  |  Nora 27/10/06
  7.   When will Meshal be eliminated? 10:49  |  Professional Pete 27/10/06
  8.   #1 Joseph E 11:51  |  Itsik 27/10/06
  9.   #2 .How Pals LIVED before the Partition.? 12:23  |  27/10/06
  10.   Eliminate Khalid Meshaal 13:08  |  Stane 27/10/06
  11.   No propaganda victory for Israel whatsoever 13:38  |  Clickfool 27/10/06
  12.   not 1000, not 100, not 10, not 1 - I am sorrry about Gilad Shalit 13:49  |  redmike 27/10/06
  13.   Exchange 14:01  |  Altalena 27/10/06
  14.   For Redmike # 12 14:10  |  Clickfool 27/10/06
  15.   Clickfool 14:11  |  Nik Miller 27/10/06
  16.   Do not legitimize kidnapping: Pal legislators for Shalit 14:22  |  Umm El Kul Naqba 27/10/06
  17.   HAMAS IS ILLEGAL ISLAMIC ENTITY IN THE LAND OF ISRAEL 14:23  |  Liberation 27/10/06
  18.   #10 Stane - We killed him once. We can do it again 14:27  |  Umm El Kul Naqba 27/10/06
  19.   To 11. Propaganda 14:35  |  Altalena 27/10/06
  20.   # 7 14:36  |  hamas 27/10/06
  21.   Arabs have won this round ... 14:43  |  Boris 27/10/06
  22.   #4, Khalid 14:50  |  Boris 27/10/06
  23.   One Jew for Thousands of Arabs?Sounds Right 14:57  |  Jane 27/10/06
  24.   1000 Palestinians for 1 Israeli 15:03  |  Isac 27/10/06
  25.   Is this too hard-headed? 15:08  |  Paul Freedman 27/10/06
  26.   KIDNAP KHALED MESHAAL 15:10  |  jay 27/10/06
  27.   Altalena 15:14  |  sh 27/10/06
  28.   #15 nick miller 15:28  |  Itsik 27/10/06
  29.   We Do Not Give in To Terrorists 15:28  |  Ronnie Wolman 27/10/06
  30.   Different values 15:34  |  ScotGuy 27/10/06
  31.   Now, Isac # 18, they value life, the life of their own people as 15:36  |  Yaniv 27/10/06
  32.   to 18 15:38  |  * TALKBACK OBSERVER* 27/10/06
  33.   to josef.e 15:40  |  * TALKBACK OBSERVER* 27/10/06
  34.   to#2 15:41  |  * TALKBACK OBSERVER* 27/10/06
  35.   @17 Jane 15:57  |  Ben 27/10/06
  36.   counter offer 16:01  |  vik 27/10/06
  37.   To sh. Reputation 16:27  |  Altalena 27/10/06
  38.   Exchange 16:28  |  Avraham 27/10/06
  39.   Kidnap Exchange 16:32  |  * BEN JABO 27/10/06
  40.   Kidnap Exchange 16:32  |  * BEN JABO 27/10/06
  41.   Punish Hamas 16:39  |  Dave 27/10/06
  42.   hamas demanding 17:06  |  ljf-canada 27/10/06
  43.   Yet another Olmert incompetence 17:22  |  Mike Savage 27/10/06
  44.   Now: Gilad - to Israel. Then: HAMAS leaders - to Mohammed Yassin. 17:31  |  Vittorio 27/10/06
  45.   too hard headed 17:31  |  naftaly k 27/10/06
  46.   Arab Terrorist 17:45  |  Rolland 27/10/06
  47.   Israel has imprisoned far too many fathers, brothers, sons 17:46  |  Ibrahim 27/10/06
  48.   Send Meshal packing. He wants create a mirage of victory 17:46  |  Haham me Bat Yam 27/10/06
  49.   reverse the ransom 17:47  |  peter 27/10/06
  50.   Pleased Olmert dont release Any Terrorists 17:49  |  Guy 27/10/06
  51.   # 11 Clickfool you fool. Olmert will not dare to exchange 1000 17:53  |  Haham me Batyam 27/10/06
  52.   lives are not very important for the arab world 17:58  |  dovdevan 27/10/06
  53.   For Altalena # 19 on negotiations 18:29  |  Clickfool 27/10/06
  54.   you stubed hamas 18:32  |  jew 27/10/06
  55.   Here`s a tissue, Dave # 41 18:32  |  Clickfool 27/10/06
  56.   isac you shock me 18:34  |  skylark 27/10/06
  57.   Ben Jabo 18:36  |  skylark 27/10/06
  58.   Yaniv 18:37  |  Omar 27/10/06
  59.   #45--another approach 18:58  |  Paul Freedman 27/10/06
  60.   47 Ibrahim 19:04  |  ScotGuy 27/10/06
  61.   To Clikfool 19. Negociations 19:18  |  Altalena 27/10/06
  62.   "Spain is willing to send representatives" can it get more INSANE 19:23  |  ilana 27/10/06
  63.   hamas demanding simultaneous swap 19:48  |  Shmuelshachor 27/10/06
  64.   ScotGuy from Glasgow 20:03  |  Ibrahim 27/10/06
  65.   ibrahim - why release them? 20:06  |  jay 27/10/06
  66.   scotguy - well said! 20:08  |  jay 27/10/06
  67.   Why not 1,000 for 3 20:15  |  Avi 27/10/06
  68.   Ibrahim not posted yesterday 20:21  |  bev 27/10/06
  69.   hmmm 20:46  |  vik 27/10/06
  70.   Disproportionality 21:14  |  Polybios 27/10/06
  71.   BETTER TO AGREE IF CONDITIONS FOR UNITY GOV`T ACCEPTED 21:20  |  Smadar 27/10/06
  72.   Hamas, the spoiled princess 21:22  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 27/10/06
  73.   Can we also give Hamas Yigal Amir in the exchange? 21:40  |  Umm El Kul Naqba 27/10/06
  74.   Jane #23 22:00  |  roxie 27/10/06
  75.   Funny! 22:12  |  Sam 27/10/06
  76.   Clickfool...answer me this: 22:22  |  Mark 27/10/06
  77.   It is not up to Hamas 22:24  |  b 27/10/06
  78.   Jane #23 22:37  |  TonyL 27/10/06
  79.   To ClickFOOL who wants convicted murderers free 22:46  |  Jonathan S 27/10/06
  80.   1 Jewish life in exchange for 1000 Moslem lives. 23:17  |  Avrum 27/10/06
  81.   1 Jewish life in exchange for 1000 Moslem lives. 23:17  |  Avrum 27/10/06
  82.   We`ll give you Peretz 23:32  |  Efox 27/10/06
  83.   Clickfool...u are what ur name is.... 00:24  |  Stright to the point 28/10/06
  84.   How Many are Murders?