Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., November 06, 2006 Cheshvan 15, 5767 | | Israel Time: 11:54 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A lethal combination
By Ze'ev Sternhell

Democracy is capable of overcoming all hardships: wars, economic crises, unemployment and distress. But there is one obstacle that it will not overcome for long: the loss of its citizens' confidence. The source of the crisis in which Israeli society now finds itself is not really the failure in the Lebanon war, but government leaders' refusal to admit that the defeat was their own handiwork. It is not the regime that is to blame, but the petty people into whose hands the reins of government have fallen.

Since the establishment of the state, the parliamentary regime has withstood every test and challenge it faced, including difficult wars. Parliamentary democracy is very far from perfect, but, unlike demagoguery of the Olmert-Lieberman school, it is not responsible for the erosion of confidence in the government.

The real reason for the erosion of confidence is not the system of government, but the bankruptcy of the political elite. In order to remove the stain of failure from themselves, many members of this government, and Ehud Olmert first and foremost, are willing to disrupt the necessary checks and balances among the different branches of government, and thus to undermine the foundations of Israeli democracy and call individual freedoms and rights into question to a degree that is intolerable in a free society. And let us not forget: Israel is not America.

Advertisement

Because it betrayed all its promises, from the convergence plan to repairing society, and thus finds itself in serious distress, the governmental elite is now calling for help from the most dangerous politician we have ever had in Israel. Rehavam Ze'evi was also a racist whose "legacy" is a disgrace to Israeli society, but he did not have the benefit of a power base such as the one that Avigdor Lieberman has consolidated. This base does not consist only of the Russian-speaking community; Lieberman also has the ability, through the power of xenophobia and by slinging mud at the Knesset and the Supreme Court, to mobilize the frustrations of the lower middle class. In the past, this role was reserved for the Likud, but Benjamin Netanyahu's movement today represents the interests of the bourgeoisie, rather than those of the weaker sectors. Lieberman caught this wave even before the war, but now he is exploiting his success in order to fill the vacuum that has been created by the center's moral collapse.

And indeed, by turning to Lieberman, Olmert is declaring that he does not have the strength to lead the country on his own, while Defense Minister Amir Peretz, for his part, is admitting that he does not have the political and emotional strength to fight back. This is a process that typically occurs among a defeated elite: In order to save itself, it tends to call in the bully for assistance. Olmert and Peretz know they have lost the public's confidence; they know that the recent Lebanon war, which was begun and conducted irresponsibly, was a major strategic failure. But government leaders refuse to recognize their responsibility and are breaking all the records for that familiar public cynicism and corruption.

European history has taught us that cooperation between a defeated conservative politician and a right-wing extremist politician with no restraints and a dictatorial temperament can be lethal. In this way, the fastest gun in the East is establishing himself in the heart of the Israeli consensus and lending legitimacy to viewpoints that in the Western world, very few members of the extreme right would dare to voice. He also knows that the loss of confidence in the political elite constitutes a golden opportunity for undermining the regime itself: Lieberman is entering the government not as a collaborator, but as a reformer and legislator who is changing long-standing practices.

We always knew that Olmert was a cynic, but few people expected him to behave so irresponsibly, particularly when Israel is entering one of the most dangerous periods it has ever known. The United States has frequently abandoned its friends without batting an eyelash, and its anticipated flight from Iraq will create a new situation in the regional and international arenas. More than ever before, we will have need for imagination, vision, judgment, responsibility and mature leadership. In light of that, and given the present circumstances, the move initiated by the disintegrating political elite headed by Olmert is no less than a moral and political crime.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Money to burn
No MK will propose ways to save money on the budget, so here are some suggestions.
'Chained women'
Rabbi Shlomo Amar canceled the conference on women who can't get divorces.
  1.   Sternhell`s hypocrisy 10:52  |  Matthias Roth 27/10/06
  2.   "not only the russian community" 11:00  |  zadok the priest 27/10/06
  3.   the abuse of lieberman has become a touchstone 11:02  |  zadok the priest 27/10/06
  4.   what exactly has lieberman done to deserve 11:09  |  zadok the priest 27/10/06
  5.   "viewpoints that very few right wingers in the western 11:16  |  zadok the priest 27/10/06
  6.   lethal combination indeed 11:18  |  joe 27/10/06
  7.   "european history has taught us that cooperation between 11:19  |  zadok the priest 27/10/06
  8.   To Number 1.... 11:27  |  Jack 27/10/06
  9.   "lieberman urges discretion on iran" 11:30  |  zadok the priest 27/10/06
  10.   The betrayed who watch and wait 11:31  |  sh 27/10/06
  11.   A small-BIG MISTAKE: If the U.S. "ABANDONES" US WE`LL BE SAVED 11:32  |  EYES2C 27/10/06
  12.   Moral and political crime 11:42  |  Paul Usiskin 27/10/06
  13.   No it isn`t a crime 11:48  |  Liz Biggin 27/10/06
  14.   I Don`t Like This Ze`ev report , Full of BS 11:58  |  Joseph E . 27/10/06
  15.   The author is a very confused, leftist waffler 12:00  |  Ronny 27/10/06
  16.   A small-BIG MISTAKE: If the U.S. "ABANDONES" US WE`LL BE SAVED 12:00  |  EYES2C 27/10/06
  17.   US abandonning Israel 12:25  |  Ernst 27/10/06
  18.   Pathetic Lefties of "Haaretz": Hamas&Assad OK,but not Lieberman?! 12:36  |  Absolute Sweden 27/10/06
  19.   Lieberman is just another Goy-hater 12:37  |  Al 27/10/06
  20.   To Joeph E.: you like this? 12:45  |  Mark B. 27/10/06
  21.   About Lieberman and the YAKUZA 12:52  |  NPR+NRG*****NPR+NRG* 27/10/06
  22.   FOX is now among the chickens 12:53  |  Ha ha ha 27/10/06
  23.   Olmert as PM, Peretz as DM is the real crime 12:55  |  Rachel 27/10/06
  24.   Swings and roundabouts 13:03  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 27/10/06
  25.   Sternhall has made a career of dumping on Israel 13:03  |  Shalom Freedman 27/10/06
  26.   no, today Israel is far better off! 13:06  |  Ernst 27/10/06
  27.   Lieberman is best friend of Palestinians 13:09  |  Jonathan S 27/10/06
  28.   Oolmert`s Crime 13:18  |  David 27/10/06
  29.   Good articles 13:20  |  cfs 27/10/06
  30.   Don`t Worry, Sternhell 13:20  |  Ben Israel 27/10/06
  31.   Moral and Political Crime Indeed 13:21  |  Yaakov Sullivan 27/10/06
  32.   no, today Israel is far better off! -2 13:25  |  Ernst 27/10/06
  33.   Zadok (#2) is right! 13:37  |  Ernst 27/10/06
  34.   #19 So What? 13:40  |  Liz Biggin 27/10/06
  35.   goes back fifty years in search of israeli crimes 13:47  |  zadok the priest 27/10/06
  36.   ernst "al majdal lod and ramle" 13:50  |  zadok the priest 27/10/06
  37.   ernst and jabotinski 13:52  |  zadok the priest 27/10/06
  38.   What can this say about Peretz and Lieberman? 14:00  |  Ronnie Wolman 27/10/06
  39.   Philological failure 14:03  |  Vladimir 27/10/06
  40.   the righteous priest dedicates his life to something else #36 14:07  |  Yaakov Sullivan 27/10/06
  41.   ernst and "at least" 14:10  |  zadok the priest 27/10/06
  42.   ernst your hatred of the jews is drowning you 14:19  |  zadok the priest 27/10/06
  43.   Erosion of confidence 14:22  |  Altalena 27/10/06
  44.   yaakov sullivan there is sordid and sordid 14:39  |  zadok the priest 27/10/06
  45.   Lieberman. A srtong man for strong state. 14:42  |  Vittorio 27/10/06
  46.   # 4 Zadok the priest..your answer Nr.1 15:00  |  Krin 27/10/06
  47.   Yes Ronnie Israel deserves better 15:03  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 27/10/06
  48.   To # 1 15:06  |  Choni 27/10/06
  49.   Zadok has no answer 15:12  |  Ernst 27/10/06
  50.   Stern Hell 15:12  |  Gabe1 27/10/06
  51.   habemus papam 15:16  |  zadok the priest 27/10/06
  52.   Sternhell is wrong 15:16  |  Sidney 27/10/06
  53.   #37 on jabbotinsky and other "great men" 15:17  |  Yaakov Sullivan 27/10/06
  54.   One more thing, my good buddy Zadokski 15:18  |  Ernst 27/10/06
  55.   krin and "the jewish controlled media" 15:30  |  zadok the priest 27/10/06
  56.   To Roth # 1 15:34  |  Choni 27/10/06
  57.   To Liz Biggin: When will we stop funding Israel? 15:35  |  Al 27/10/06
  58.   Liz: big and strong? 16:03  |  A.M. 27/10/06
  59.   To Ernst. Mea Culpa 16:06  |  Altalena 27/10/06
  60.   To "Sullivan" Great and small men 16:13  |  Altalena 27/10/06
  61.   To Ernst as a Dutchman to a Dutchman 16:25  |  Mark B. 27/10/06
  62.   Nice one Ernst 16:29  |  skylark 27/10/06
  63.   The sad irony of this article... 16:31  |  SHIMON 27/10/06
  64.   Hamas is ok, but A legally elected right wing politician isnt? 16:31  |  SHIMON 27/10/06
  65.   To admit the failure of the regime 16:32  |  Pssd Off American 27/10/06
  66.   bravo vova, @34 16:33  |  vladimir 27/10/06
  67.   Margie 2nd try 16:37  |  Ronnie Wolman 27/10/06
  68.   To 37 Jabotinski 16:38  |  Altalena 27/10/06
  69.   Ernst. What do you know about Zeev (Vladimir) Jabotiski that you 16:53  |  Shlomzion 27/10/06
  70.   Who belongs in the government 16:55  |  DovBer 27/10/06
  71.   Sternhell supported Oslo - that`s how clever he is! 16:57  |  Me 27/10/06
  72.   Not yet loss of confidence by the people 17:05  |  Tosefta 27/10/06
  73.   #57 Al 17:06  |  Liz Biggin 27/10/06
  74.   Look who you are comparing to Altalena #60 17:12  |  Yaakov Sullivan 27/10/06
  75.   I`m still surprised at you Yaacov. 17:14  |  Jacob Blues 27/10/06
  76.   #58 A.M 17:17  |  Liz Biggin 27/10/06
  77.   Yaacov Sullivan goes on and on about `Great Men` 17:19  |  Jacob Blues 27/10/06
  78.   The Left`s room with a view 17:28  |  peter 27/10/06
  79.   Shimon makes an interesting Point, Yaacov 17:29  |  Jacob Blues 27/10/06
  80.   Heaven and Hell 17:37  |  jewlover 27/10/06
  81.   To Ronnie Wolman on the Spurs 17:40  |  Mark B. 27/10/06
  82.   Mark B: Isnt AJAX Haimishe????????? 17:51  |  Ronnie Wolman 27/10/06
  83.   Bolsheviks in fear 17:58  |  Gene 27/10/06
  84.   Jacob, yaakov avoids questions that are too much for him 17:59  |  SHIMON 27/10/06
  85.   Zadok the Priest 18:00  |  Stephen Connor 27/10/06
  86.   Does "IDF" distinguish between YAKUZA and JACUZZI 18:06  |  source: NRG & NPR 27/10/06
  87.   Jack 18:06  |  Stephen Connor 27/10/06