Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., October 30, 2006 Cheshvan 8, 5767 | | Israel Time: 12:00 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
In praise of the Lebanon war
By Yossi Sarid

Granted, only two and a half months have gone by since the end of the second Lebanon war, but we need no further perspective to grasp the full scale of its achievements. Already now, it is clear that it was a successful war - not only one of the most justified of Israel's wars, as was noted when it began, but also one of the most successful, as must be admitted at its conclusion. Only incorrigible defeatists and incurable doomsayers will fail to sing its praises. No wonder, then, that the calls for a state commission of inquiry now sound like the faint echo of a distant howling at the moon. Down with the critics!

Here is the story: The Lebanon war removed the realignment in the West Bank, in the name of which Kadima asked for the public's confidence and received 29 Knesset seats, from the national agenda. Let us be serious people, for a change, and accept the postwar reality with satisfaction: The realignment has been expelled from our lives for all time, just as the Egyptian mother and her little boy were expelled to wander in the desert. Good riddance to that can of worms. It would have created a terrible headache, and the ache might have been stronger than the head.

A smart war does not leave a vacuum. Even as it erases one agenda, it is already filling the empty space and drafting a new agenda that is far more desirable for Israel. Instead of uprooting what has been planted in Judea and Samaria, we are planting the uprooted - people and trees; instead of destroying communities, we are rehabilitating destroyed communities with great momentum; instead of investing in the territories for the sake of evacuation, we are investing in the Galilee for the sake of construction. The Holy One did right by us in granting us this war, which is enabling the government to reorganize its order of priorities. This is not the time for internal disputes; this is the time for unity in the ranks. For if not now, when?

Advertisement

The Lebanon war is granting us the opportunity to reap its profits on other fronts as well - another proven achievement. On our northern border, the Arabs' true intentions, of annihilating us, have again been revealed. Israel, of course, will not be able to agree to the creation of a similar threat in the Gaza Strip. Remember what Hezbollah did to us and do not forget what it is incumbent upon us to do to the Palestinian every day, including holidays. Strike at them and strike at them, for we have become fed up with their being there, and here. The lessons of Lebanon bolster our right and duty to kill Palestinians and not to rest, and it is only a matter of not very much time before we return to the Philadelphi Road, and the road will wag the Strip, which will soon be reoccupied completely. Not only is Ehud Olmert's next realignment a thing of the past; Ariel Sharon's previous realignment will be annulled.

We would not have been able to restore the crown of Gaza's former glory had our eyes not been opened by Lebanon's gory present. Nor could we have expanded the line of settlements in the West Bank or even left illegal outposts intact without interference, or received Ephraim Sneh in the Defense Ministry, at long last.

The Lebanon war, it must be remembered - and we need to be reminded - erupted so that we could redeem our soldiers from captivity. The protracted story of the three abducted soldiers is a sad tale. Nevertheless, we must not deny its positive aspects: As long as Gilad Shalit is in the hands of his abductors, no negotiations with the Palestinians will begin: "That is unconscionable." True, negotiations have not been held for eons, and the promised but nonexistent meeting with Mahmoud Abbas is not even visible on the farthest horizon, but at least now, there is a reason.

And our achievements vis-a-vis our enemies pale in the face of our achievements vis-a-vis ourselves. Would it have been possible to expand the government and house within it self-perceived opposites without the paralyzing and silencing fear that was visited upon us? Would it have been possible to sanitize Avigdor Lieberman and initiate him into the community of decision makers? Would it have been possible, with a single stroke, to liquidate Amir Peretz both as defense minister and as chairman of the Labor Party? Would it have been possible to isolate Benjamin Netanyahu and leave him solitary outside the fence, with his tongue wagging? None of this would have happened without the war.

And that is not all. The war left the state comptroller with his hands full of work, so much so that he apparently has no time to complete investigations that were launched with great fanfare. Are they now fading away, on a dying note? The police, too, are tarrying with their investigations, as though feeling harassed. So how will we know in good time whether the first among equals and the equals themselves are equal or unequal? How will we know whether any of those who are at the starting line in the race for the presidency used incentive money illegally? Maybe they will be given blood tests, and then we will know for sure to whom they are related and why.

When outside threats intensify, domestic threats tend to be ignored. True, there are some oddballs among us who view corruption as a strategic threat, but even they would hesitate to entrust the treatment to the person who was placed in charge of the big threats this week. In the name of the government, we give thanks for this war, which came just at the right moment, and at the eleventh hour has restored sanity to its place and made it possible "to see things in proportion."

Similarly, the self-appointed examination committees, which were vilified for no good reason, are gradually being revealed as the right decision. By the nature of their creation and the pace of their work, they promise the politicians and the generals long years in their posts, and that is also for the good. Governmental stability is no small thing, and it is important to maintain it. And in contrast to the rotten custom that prevailed here for many years, even the lowly guard will not get the boot this time.

Let us sum up: The Lebanon war left 156 dead - 117 soldiers and 39 civilians - and about 4,200 wounded. But in light of this overall positive balance, who would dare any longer to cast doubt on its justification and success? Who would dare to be so cruel as to say that the victims died in vain? The dead commanded life to Olmert and his government, a long and good life.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Carpenters of Nazareth
At an Upper Nazareth mall, retirees are offered the chance to work for a pay check.
In their defense
The Defense Ministry wants to pay off its property tax debt directly to the state.
  1.   Praise !? 11:12  |  Bernard Haftel 27/10/06
  2.   Haunted by denial 11:17  |  sh 27/10/06
  3.   Sarid about Lebanon war 11:19  |  S 27/10/06
  4.   Olmert invited Siniora for negotiations but... 11:26  |  Gaza Boy 27/10/06
  5.   In "praise" of Sarid 12:00  |  BenAbuzaglo 27/10/06
  6.   It`s about time 12:02  |  Alan 27/10/06
  7.   Sarid`s sarcasm hides his despair: LandforPeace idea is finished! 12:05  |  Ronny 27/10/06
  8.   Sarid`s sarcasm hides his despair: LandforPeace idea is finished! 12:05  |  Ronny 27/10/06
  9.   No. 1 and 3-Can`t You Recognize Sarcasm When You See It? 12:15  |  Ben Israel 27/10/06
  10.   Yossi Sarid.. 12:41  |  Guess who 27/10/06
  11.   Sarid can`t push his agenda after Lebanon`s war,so he ridicules 12:48  |  Absolute Sweden 27/10/06
  12.   World wide poll states Israel...... 13:01  |  Maureen Ann 27/10/06
  13.   Hebollah down,not yet defeated 13:10  |  Zuriel Sapir 27/10/06
  14.   Maureen Ann 13:21  |  skylark 27/10/06
  15.   Lebanon War Successful? 13:25  |  Pinchas 27/10/06
  16.   Yossi has been sniffing glue? 13:30  |  Natallie Durson 27/10/06
  17.   Judea and Samaria are not part of Israel 13:34  |  John 27/10/06
  18.   I dont believe it 13:34  |  Ronnie Wolman 27/10/06
  19.   To Maureen Ann: Why are you so shy? 13:35  |  Jonathan S 27/10/06
  20.   #9 13:37  |  S 27/10/06
  21.   Great Jokesters of Talkback # 5, Yossi Sarid 14:07  |  Clickfool 27/10/06
  22.   yep, it is called 14:21  |  cool 27/10/06
  23.   #18 14:37  |  Rami Lebanese 27/10/06
  24.   clickfool and howling at the moon 14:44  |  harzion 27/10/06
  25.   SARID IS A RACIST 14:50  |  GEORGE 27/10/06
  26.   Compliments to Yossi Sarid 14:53  |  Danny 27/10/06
  27.   Oh I get it, Yossi`s trying to be sarcastic 15:20  |  Jacob Blues 27/10/06
  28.   to S #3 15:27  |  zeev 27/10/06
  29.   Alan it`s your Trojan horse that has just been revealed 15:35  |  sh 27/10/06
  30.   17 - Judea-Samaria part of Israel 16:19  |  Bruriah Sarah 27/10/06
  31.   Rami Lebanese: Its Size that Matters 16:31  |  Ronnie Wolman 27/10/06
  32.   Sarid - A Moron Who Thinks He Is Superior 16:36  |  Tod Zuckerman 27/10/06
  33.   What a Bunch of Bunk! 16:52  |  Jeff Northridge 27/10/06
  34.   Yossi Sarid, It seems few here got your sarcasm and humour.. 17:14  |  BouSameer 27/10/06
  35.   not even worth a response 17:19  |  tony aron 27/10/06
  36.   One more "achievement", stalling on Syria 17:28  |  Tosefta 27/10/06
  37.   #! 12 Sarcasm? 17:40  |  Tony Anthony 27/10/06
  38.   to #12 Maureen Ann from Australia, re your "Oketz" 18:19  |  zayyin ba ayin 27/10/06
  39.   Sarid`s sarcasm taken literally is the truest thing he ever wrote 18:21  |  True Zionist 27/10/06
  40.   Hilarious, Clickfool, hilarious 19:06  |  Reality Check 27/10/06
  41.   Bernard Haftel 19:09  |  rich 27/10/06
  42.   #37 They should keep their females veiled 19:10  |  Jasmine Murphy 27/10/06
  43.   True Zionist #39 19:44  |  Guess who 27/10/06
  44.   Be careful, Yossi! 19:44  |  Frank 27/10/06
  45.   Sarid, your sarcasm is too subtle 19:58  |  Amos 27/10/06
  46.   Bernard Haftel 20:01  |  David 27/10/06
  47.   To David 20:41  |  Bernard Haftel 27/10/06
  48.   To Rich 20:48  |  Bernard Haftel 27/10/06
  49.   #4 Gaza Boy. Olmert and other Israeli politician will 21:20  |  Haham me Batyam 27/10/06
  50.   Ronnie Wolman #31 21:25  |  Rami Lebanese 27/10/06
  51.   Mr Sarid`s Article 22:34  |  Giles K. 27/10/06
  52.   Australian government "enlightened?" 22:46  |  Lebanese admirer 27/10/06
  53.   I AM IN SHOCK 23:02  |  Elliott 27/10/06
  54.   What next Yossi? 23:42  |  BwanaVic 27/10/06
  55.   #42 Jasmine Murphy-not state, no country? 23:51  |  Maureen Ann 27/10/06
  56.   #4 Gaza B : Siniora and Abbas : a difference 00:04  |  Nicolas 28/10/06
  57.   Bernard Haftel # 47 Casualty Ratios 00:19  |  Jeff Northridge 28/10/06
  58.   Sarid strikes out 00:39  |  Stanley 28/10/06
  59.   Lebanese Admirer leave Beir Jala and go back to Lebanon 00:56  |  Gaza Boy 28/10/06
  60.   Absolutely Nothing Gained for Anyone 01:04  |  Jane 28/10/06
  61.   Does Sarid live in a different plant? 01:20  |  Sal 28/10/06
  62.   Simulate the success of the Lebanon War 01:44  |  Mark Lincoln 28/10/06
  63.   It Surprised Iran! That`s All! 01:51  |  Yosemite Sam 28/10/06
  64.   I am in shock - #50 02:12  |  Domingo 28/10/06
  65.   Pseudo Gazan in London? N0 54 02:17  |  Lebanese admirer 28/10/06
  66.   What a shocker! 02:49  |  Domingo 28/10/06
  67.   Mark Lincoln # 57 "Victory" Declarations 03:49  |  Jeff Northridge 28/10/06
  68.   shoo ya abu shabaab Nicolas 03:57  |  Gaza Boy 28/10/06
  69.   #1 Bernard- Relax 04:31  |  Harry D 28/10/06
  70.   Sarid Is A Prophet- You Must Condemn HIm 04:47  |  Harry D 28/10/06
  71.   Clickfool And The Rest of You Clowns 04:54  |  Harry D 28/10/06
  72.   Clickie-A Modest Proposal 04:56  |  Harry D 28/10/06
  73.   Gaza Boy #61 05:08  |  Harry D 28/10/06
  74.   Mark Lincoln- 05:19  |  Harry D 28/10/06
  75.   #67 Jeff, those are lovely rose-colored glasses 07:51  |  Johnboy 28/10/06
  76.   poor use of irony. a sophmoric piece. 08:23  |  paul 28/10/06
  77.   Lebanese Admirer 09:54  |  Jasmine Murphy 28/10/06
  78.   Sarid is in a state of denial 10:55  |  Fairplay 28/10/06
  79.   on Bruriah Sarah #30 - and the West Bank 11:07  |  zeev 28/10/06
  80.   Zeev # 79 regarding the "west bank" 12:31  |  Yaniv 28/10/06
  81.   zeev and" feeble minded" 13:41  |  zadok the priest 28/10/06
  82.   zeev what would be your response to rockets 13:44  |  zadok the priest 28/10/06
  83.   Yaniv & Zadok 14:28  |  watcher 28/10/06
  84.   John#17 16:25  |  Mickey 28/10/06
  85.   John #17 16:32  |  Mickey 28/10/06
  86.   Johnboy # 75 Neither Side Won 17:11  |  Jeff Northridge 28/10/06
  87.   on Bruriah Sarah #30 and the MFA 17:28  |  zeev 28/10/06
  88.   Jasmine Murphy 18:24  |  Lebanese admirer 28/10/06
  89.   Zeev-87-This is truly irritating to hear you calling the positive 18:27  |  Shlomzion 28/10/06
  90.   to Yaniv #80 18:51  |  zeev 28/10/06
  91.   In Praise of the Lebonon War 18:54  |  Edward 28/10/06
  92.   so zeev is a believer in conspircay theories 18:58  |  zadok the priest 28/10/06
  93.   so according to zeev israel left gaza with the 19:11  |  zadok the priest 28/10/06
  94.   Johnboy 75 is right, Jeff N 67, 86 is wrong; Hezbollah WON 19:15  |  Judge Judy 28/10/06
  95.   Bruriah Sarah 30 and Yaniv 80 are wrong, Zeev 79 is right 19:43  |  Judge Judy 28/10/06
  96.   Court hours 19:45  |  Judge Judy 28/10/06
  97.   Response to Amos, #45 20:07  |  sandra chitayat 28/10/06
  98.   to zadok the priest #82 20:42  |  zeev 28/10/06
  99.   Johnboy 75 is right, Jeff N 67, 86 is wrong; Hezbollah WON 20:57  |  Judge Judy 28/10/06
  100.   nutty story. Real lesson is Israel will not gain land from war 21:06  |  Pablo B 28/10/06
  101.   Tiresome `judge` person 21:15  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 28/10/06
  102.   Maureen Ann, I`m sure, you`d be welcome as a volunteer in Israel. 22:11  |  zayyin ba ayin 28/10/06
  103.   Johnboy 75 is right, Jeff N 67, 86 is wrong; Hezbollah WON 22:22  |  Judge Judy 28/10/06
  104.   Yossi Sarid lives in Moshav Margaliyot, hard on Lebanon`s border. 22:33  |  zayyin ba ayin 28/10/06
  105.   Message for Yossi (3rd try ha`aretz!) 22:38  |  sh 28/10/06
  106.   This is sarcastic 22:41  |  paul 28/10/06
  107.   Tiresome `judge` person 23:17  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 28/10/06
  108.   #Zayyin ba ayin Calabasas/a beautiful part... 23:45  |  Mauren Ann 28/10/06
  109.   Confusion easily understood 00:29  |  Victor 29/10/06
  110.   # 16 Natallie Durson. SNIFFING GLUE? I DON`T THINK SO... 00:32  |  Kathy 29/10/06
  111.   Satire 00:46  |  Jack 29/10/06
  112.   # 33 Jeff Northridge. re: Mr. Sarid, AND HIS ARTICLE... 01:00  |  Kathy 29/10/06
  113.   Yossi Sarid lives in Moshav Margaliyot, in the Upper Galilee, 01:10  |  zayyin ba ayin 29/10/06
  114.   # 67 Jeff Northridge.re:Mark Lincoln--re:Victory.. 01:16  |  Kathy 29/10/06
  115.   zeev, my favorite unruly child 02:32  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 29/10/06
  116.   Judge Judy # 91 Wrong! 02:34  |  Jeff Northridge 29/10/06
  117.   Excellent Satirical Article; thanks Haaretz 02:38  |  Tony Price 29/10/06
  118.   #Judge Judy and Jeff Northridge/Missing evidence? 03:44  |  Maureen Ann 29/10/06
  119.   Maureen Ann from Australia: you take control 03:48  |  zayyin ba ayin 29/10/06
  120.   #92, Sandra Chitayat 03:58  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 29/10/06
  121.   Forests of the beautiful Galilee 05:38  |  zayyin ba ayin 29/10/06
  122.   Sarid-- Amateur Satirist 06:47  |  NYC Jew 29/10/06
  123.   Sarid dislikes russian Jews 07:05  |  James 29/10/06
  124.   On sarcasm 08:35  |  Not fooled 29/10/06
  125.   James 08:42  |  sh 29/10/06
  126.   #123 Sarid himself has colonial syndrome. 08:43  |  Oleg 29/10/06
  127.   Margie in Tel Aviv - Yesha and pesha 08:48  |  sh 29/10/06
  128.   What may Satire do? All.. 09:14  |  Tucholski 29/10/06
  129.   to #122 NYC Jew 09:58  |  Ari ben Yisrael 29/10/06
  130.   sorry #127 (sh) you are wrong 10:03  |  Joe Moer 29/10/06
  131.   Sorry Sarid, the position of Court Jester is filled. 10:25  |  Uncle John`s Band 29/10/06
  132.   # 130 Joe Moer. A QUESTION FOR YOU .... 21:19  |  Kathy 29/10/06
  133.   # 127 sh.re: Apartheid...................... 21:32  |  Kathy 29/10/06
  134.   This is for you Mr.Sarid. STOP THE EXAGGERATIONS... 21:46  |  Kathy 29/10/06
  135.   to Shlomzion #89 - 2nd try 00:21  |  zeev 30/10/06
  136.   to zadok the priest #92 - 3rd try 00:28  |  zeev 30/10/06
  137.   to Cipora J.Kohn #115 - 2nd try 00:43  |  zeev 30/10/06
  138.   #137, zeev 05:32  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 30/10/06
  139.   to C. J. Kohn #138 11:37  |  zeev 30/10/06
 Today Online
Akiva Eldar: Avigdor Lieberman is worse than Joerg Haider
Responses: 22
Danny Rubinstein: To fight terror, transfer money to the PA
Responses: 15
Editorial: Why did Livni choose to boycott Qatar?
Responses: 15
Rabbi Michael Cohen: Let Palestinians study in Israel
Responses: 7
Lawyer: Katsav won't quit until indictment decision
Responses: 12
Police to begin probe of PM's role in Bank Leumi affair
Responses: 10


More Headlines
07:39 Lawyer: Katsav won't quit until indictment decision
11:50 Study: Rate of gov't spending on social services continues to fall
09:50 Police to begin preliminary probe of PM's role in Bank Leumi affair
10:30 Report: UN team probing whether IDF used uranium weapons in Lebanon
11:25 Histadrut: Unpaid wages in local authorities may lead to strike
07:15 Knesset to vote on Lieberman's ministerial appointment
07:10 Finance Minister to submit 2007 budget proposals Monday
06:20 Likud member: Police sought deal for blocking Sharon probe
10:38 Knesset committee concludes officers' testimony on Lebanon war
11:46 Seven-year-old killed on board school bus in Negev
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Discover LOVE
See why JLove.com is the fastest growing Jewish relationship site committed to preserving Jewish values
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved