Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., October 26, 2006 Cheshvan 4, 5767 | | Israel Time: 21:49 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The voice is the voice of Netanyahu
By Aluf Benn

Over the last few weeks, the Israeli government has changed dramatically, as manifested by Yisrael Beiteinu leader Avigdor Lieberman's entry into the coalition. But the dispute over the personality and outlook of the minister-to-be for strategic threats has concealed a more important and more interesting change: Prime Minister Ehud Olmert has adopted the positions of Likud Chairman Benjamin Netanyahu.

Whoever doesn't believe this to be the case should read the speeches Olmert and Netanyahu gave in the Knesset when the government was sworn in about six months ago. At the time, Olmert spoke about setting the state's border and evacuating settlements in the West Bank as the lifeline of Zionism, and Netanyahu told him to concentrate on the Iranian threat instead of moving settlers from one hilltop to another.

Now Olmert is carrying out the Netanyahu policy, point by point. The prime minister is sending veiled threats to Iran, burying the convergence plan and allowing accelerated construction in settlements. His social-economic policy, too, was copied from Netanyahu. Who needs a social welfare minister? Let the poor get a job and stop making demands.

Advertisement

Something similar happened to Ariel Sharon when he was stuck without an agenda after the 2003 elections and adopted the proposal of his rival, Amram Mitzna, for a unilateral withdrawal from Gaza. But there is a difference. Mitzna left politics after he lost at the polls, while Netanyahu remains and is steering government policy from the opposition benches. The hands are the hands of Ehud, but the voice is the voice of Bibi.

So what happened? One can argue that the war in Lebanon and the events in Gaza opened Olmert's eyes and made him recognize that his understanding of the threats facing Israel was mistaken. Nonetheless, it appears that political constraints and the prime minister's personality structure were a greater influence.

The strategic threat to Olmert's term of office is not Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and his calls to eliminate the "Zionist regime," but rather the potential desertion of 11 MKs from Kadima back to the Likud. Only such a move would translate Netanyahu's advantage in the polls to a change of government. In order to foil him, Olmert executed a double maneuver: He stole his rival's positions - in order to rule out an ideological excuse on the part of the swing MKs in Kadima - and he split the right-wing camp by bringing Lieberman into the government. The emphasis on the Iranian threat had another function as well: to lock up Amir Peretz and prevent his Labor Party from fleeing the coalition. When the state faces existential danger, as Olmert put it, you don't evade responsibility for its fate.

Those who compared Olmert to Netanyahu and Ehud Barak over the last few months do not understand the prime minister. Olmert does not have their intellectual pretension. Perhaps in the depths of his fortified residence he reads books, listens to symphonies and solves mathematical equations. But the Olmert public persona speaks only about soccer, not Winston Churchill or Charles de Gaulle.

Olmert compensates for his inferiority by quoting from encyclopedias with cunning and with emotional intelligence. He is a far better political operator than Barak or Netanyahu, and not only because of his astonishing success in surviving the war and acquiring Lieberman at a good price. Olmert is more disciplined than they are, and even during the abyss of his fall in the polls, he controlled himself and did not get dragged into giving radio interviews on morning programs - a clear sign of political collapse.

Olmert's weak point is his sensitivity to challenges to his masculinity. Netanyahu understood this when he called him "Smolmert" (a combination of the premier's name and the Hebrew word for "left") during the election campaign. Ever since then the prime minister has made an effort to prove his courage and show that he is the distaff of the left. This has led to Olmert's tendency to use force, to get embroiled in a war with Hezbollah chief Hassan Nasrallah and into total chaos on the Palestinian front - and, it appears, to relinquish the positions that he presented to the public when he was elected, and return to being a Likudnik.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Orange crosses red line
Cell phone provider publishes advertisements in schools despite prohibition.
Safe return
Minister seeks draft waiver for children of Israelis living in the United States.
  1.   why would olmert not have right wing views 11:46  |  zadok the priest 25/10/06
  2.   aluf benn is trying too hard to "see into men`s souls" 11:50  |  zadok the priest 25/10/06
  3.   Netanyahu should go home 11:58  |  Gaza Boy 25/10/06
  4.   All That`s "Left": Pathological Hatred of Bibi 12:13  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 25/10/06
  5.   Olmert sounds more like Abbas than Bibi 12:14  |  Ronnie Wolman 25/10/06
  6.   Reading books and listening to symphonies 12:23  |  sh 25/10/06
  7.   Na... Too good to be true. 13:03  |  Natan 25/10/06
  8.   Olmert still a hardcore Likudnick 13:47  |  Israeli 25/10/06
  9.   Benn now understands that Land-for-Peace idea is finished 14:38  |  Ron 25/10/06
  10.   It`s Called Politics 14:48  |  Tony Anthony 25/10/06
  11.   Worry about your own intelligence BENN 15:20  |  B 25/10/06
  12.   maral your mail on kuntar is misleading 16:04  |  zadok the priest 25/10/06
  13.   And the voice of Bibi is the voice of majority Jews 17:42  |  e.m 25/10/06
  14.   Re:Gaza Boy.He is at his home 17:50  |  e.m 25/10/06
  15.   #10, Tony A. Here`s how politics actually works. 17:54  |  Voice of Reason 25/10/06
  16.   peace with Palestinians defuses Iran threat 19:39  |  steve 25/10/06
  17.   Survival. 19:55  |  Nora 25/10/06
  18.   voice vs. brain 21:58  |  Michael N 25/10/06
 Today Online
Study: Israelis and U.S. Jews no longer seen as one nation
Responses: 121
Shmuel Rosner: As Bush enters his fourth term, he's on his own
Responses: 35
Lieberman's not a monster - he's just a political opportunist
Responses: 56
B'Tselem: Families of Palestinian prisoners denied visitation rights
Responses: 104
IDF: No shots were fired in IAF incident with German ship
Responses: 310


More Headlines
20:07 Peretz: IAF to continue Lebanon overflights until troops freed
21:26 High Court approves route of fence around W. Bank enclave
20:51 Israeli hurt in W. Bank shooting; Three Palestinians killed in Gaza
21:47 Pensioners threaten to vote against Lieberman joining gov't
16:55 UNIFIL: Administrative snags delaying IDF pullout from Ghajar
15:40 Israel thwarting Hamas effort to set up West Bank security force
13:44 PA official: Hamas interior minister brought $2 million into Gaza
20:36 Israeli ambassador to the Ukraine appointed head of Nativ
21:20 American evangelical group arrives in Ashdod on solidarity mission
17:10 Danish court rejects suit against newspaper that printed Mohammed cartoons
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
One year MBA in Israel
Taught entirely in English
SINGLES ECARDS
Say hello to Jewish singles with E-cards. Send FREE at JDate
Discover LOVE
See why JLove.com is the fastest growing Jewish relationship site committed to preserving Jewish values
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved