Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., May 25, 2007 Sivan 8, 5767 | | Israel Time: 21:27 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Minister Jacob Edery. (Archives)
Last update - 06:42 22/10/2006
Israel admits using phosphorus bombs during war in Lebanon
By Meron Rappaport, Haaretz Correspondent

Israel has acknowledged for the first time that it attacked Hezbollah targets during the second Lebanon war with phosphorus shells. White phosphorus causes very painful and often lethal chemical burns to those hit by it, and until recently Israel maintained that it only uses such bombs to mark targets or territory.

The announcement that the Israel Defense Forces had used phosphorus bombs in the war in Lebanon was made by Minister Jacob Edery, in charge of government-Knesset relations. He had been queried on the matter by MK Zahava Gal-On (Meretz-Yahad).

"The IDF holds phosphorus munitions in different forms," Edery said. "The IDF made use of phosphorous shells during the war against Hezbollah in attacks against military targets in open ground."

Advertisement

Edery also pointed out that international law does not forbid the use of phosphorus and that "the IDF used this type of munitions according to the rules of international law."

Edery did not specify where and against what types of targets phosphorus munitions were used. During the war several foreign media outlets reported that Lebanese civilians carried injuries characteristic of attacks with phosphorus, a substance that burns when it comes to contact with air. In one CNN report, a casualty with serious burns was seen lying in a South Lebanon hospital.

In another case, Dr. Hussein Hamud al-Shel, who works at Dar al-Amal hospital in Ba'albek, said that he had received three corpses "entirely shriveled with black-green skin," a phenomenon characteristic of phosphorus injuries.

Lebanon's President Emile Lahoud also claimed that the IDF made use of phosphorus munitions against civilians in Lebanon.

Phosphorus has been used by armies since World War I. During World War II and Vietnam the U.S. and British armies made extensive use of phosphorus. During recent decades the tendency has been to ban the use of phosphorus munitions against any target, civilian or military, because of the severity of the injuries that the substance causes.

Some experts believe that phosphorus munitions should be termed Chemical Weapons (CW) because of the way the weapons burn and attack the respiratory system. As a CW, phosphorus would become a clearly illegal weapon.

The International Red Cross is of the opinion that there should be a complete ban on phosphorus being used against human beings and the third protocol of the Geneva Convention on Conventional Weapons restricts the use of "incendiary weapons," with phosphorus considered to be one such weapon.

Israel and the United States are not signatories to the Third Protocol.

In November 2004 the U.S. Army used phosphorus munitions during an offensive in Faluja, Iraq. Burned bodies of civilians hit by the phosphorus munitions were shown by the press, and an international outcry against the practice followed.

Initially the U.S. denied that it had used phosphorus bombs against humans, but then acknowledged that during the assault targets that were neither civilian nor population concentrations were hit with such munitions. Israel also says that the use of "incendiary munitions are not in themselves illegal."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Time for a new lexicon
Concepts of the 1970s continue to define a reality that has changed completely.
An historic blunder
By 2020, more than 1 in 5 men will be exempt from IDF service due to yeshiva studies.
  1.   Israel must pay for this war crime 01:56  |  Franklin 22/10/06
  2.   you will reap what you sew 02:08  |  Lebanese 22/10/06
  3.   Is it surprise? 02:15  |  Kevin Klauss 22/10/06
  4.   Legal or not? 02:39  |  Walid 22/10/06
  5.   Lebanon got what it deserved 02:56  |  Y 22/10/06
  6.   Cancer to our planet... 03:07  |  Guess who 22/10/06
  7.   Response to Comments 1-4 03:08  |  Steve 22/10/06
  8.   Who is the agressor? 03:12  |  Alex 22/10/06
  9.   Katiushas are legal arms? 03:18  |  Cristina 22/10/06
  10.   #5 To Y 03:19  |  Franklin 22/10/06
  11.   # 1. have you heard the saying sow the wind reap the whirlwind. 03:24  |  ralph 22/10/06
  12.   hez used ball bearing in their rockets!!!! 03:27  |  vik 22/10/06
  13.   Hezbollah hid behind civilians 03:34  |  Ron 22/10/06
  14.   To franklin 03:35  |  Cristina 22/10/06
  15.   To #11 03:44  |  Franklin 22/10/06
  16.   response to Franklin # 1 03:55  |  Eli 22/10/06
  17.   # 13 04:15  |  Moe 22/10/06
  18.   Curiouser and curiouser . . . 04:17  |  Veritas 22/10/06
  19.   Rocket launchers were hidden in groves 04:19  |  jason 22/10/06
  20.   Third protocol ,who cares. 04:27  |  maoriboy 22/10/06
  21.   the purity of arms and the most moral nation in the middle east 04:34  |  raj 22/10/06
  22.   Cristina#9. You`re equating Hezbollah to IDF 04:36  |  Paul 22/10/06
  23.   Curious veritas, maoriboy and spin #18 & 19 04:55  |  Andrew 22/10/06
  24.   Hezbollah spanked nobody, # 13 05:34  |  Ron 22/10/06
  25.   What would have happened if...to Steve#7 05:42  |  Otto Rand 22/10/06
  26.   #23 Andrew 05:49  |  maoriboy 22/10/06
  27.   The Lebanese allowed Hezbollah to build 05:50  |  Gina 22/10/06
  28.   To Eli in Sydney 06:03  |  Otto Rand 22/10/06
  29.   Who cares -there is nothing wrong with insineration devices 06:11  |  Sal 22/10/06
  30.   Equating Hezbollah to IDF (Paul 22) 06:29  |  sk 22/10/06
  31.   use of phosphorus bombs 06:54  |  steve 22/10/06
  32.   This whole discussion is idiotic! 07:03  |  Alex 22/10/06
  33.   Leadership must be punished 07:26  |  Ben Plonie 22/10/06
  34.   Phosphor bombs 07:48  |  Oddvark 22/10/06
  35.   An outright lie or mere verbal subterfuge? 07:48  |  Richard Silverstein 22/10/06
  36.   To#30 SK, and #22 Paul, Both R wrong 08:09  |  Linda 22/10/06
  37.   Eli 08:14  |  Walid 22/10/06
  38.   Fosforbombs 08:26  |  Joost 22/10/06
  39.   Monstrous supporters of these terrible things 08:45  |  Marilyn 22/10/06
  40.   Israel`s over-reaction 08:46  |  Lebanese admirer 22/10/06
  41.   Dear Alex # 32. Follow the goods and not the bads 08:47  |  Defender of freedom 22/10/06
  42.   Andrew 08:50  |  Walid 22/10/06
  43.   InCineration is inhuman No 29 08:54  |  L:ebanese admirer 22/10/06
  44.   Israelis killed Jesus, what else 08:59  |  American 22/10/06
  45.   "Israel has acknowledged for the first time" 09:12  |  john 22/10/06
  46.   Alex 09:12  |  Walid 22/10/06
  47.   Christians in Israel are treated badly by Israelis 09:20  |  Christian 22/10/06
  48.   Oddvark 09:25  |  Walid 22/10/06
  49.   phosphorus 09:34  |  yo 22/10/06
  50.   from an Israeli neighbor in the south 09:41  |  to walid 22/10/06
  51.   Time for peace. 09:43  |  lebanese pacifist 22/10/06
  52.   "only used such bombs to mark out target or territory." 09:43  |  Maureen Ann 22/10/06
  53.   they deserved it 09:45  |  Mark 22/10/06
  54.   Israel - a Godless nation 09:48  |  justajew 22/10/06
  55.   Lebanese writers, pls write 09:50  |  Walid 22/10/06
  56.   THe Army of Allah Used cluster rockets against Israeli Civillians 09:55  |  PETER SM 22/10/06
  57.   Becoming the monster........ 09:56  |  Jim 22/10/06
  58.   # 50: Israeli from the north 10:00  |  Wa7eed 22/10/06
  59.   V ERITAS.Who said Hisbala ONLY fought from behind civillians 10:01  |  PETER. S.M 22/10/06
  60.   Execution means ( to #44) 10:02  |  Dr D 22/10/06
  61.   "international law does not prohibit it" 10:05  |  flavius josephus 22/10/06
  62.   For Justajew # 54 10:06  |  Clickfool 22/10/06
  63.   I do understand that my day consists of 24 hours. 10:06  |  27 million Lebanese 22/10/06
  64.   On the killing of Jesus # 44 10:13  |  Clickfool 22/10/06
  65.   IDF 10:17  |  Khalil 22/10/06
  66.   OTTO RAND Re rational solution.None of your options satisfy 10:22  |  PETER. S.M 22/10/06
  67.   How is Israel supposed to act? 10:31  |  Ronnie Wolman 22/10/06
  68.   For Ronnie Wolman, who asks what the choices were 10:45  |  Clickfool 22/10/06
  69.   My Israeli Neighbor to the South 10:49  |  Walid 22/10/06
  70.   clickfool"theft and murder of innnocents" 11:00  |  harzion 22/10/06
  71.   clickfool "corrupr gangsters" 11:02  |  harzion 22/10/06
  72.   MAORIBOY Inviting Pres.Assad to adress the Knesset is "not 11:03  |  PETER SM 22/10/06
  73.   clickfool what on earth is britain doing in afghanistan? 11:05  |  harzion 22/10/06
  74.   clickfool and "moneychangers tables" 11:08  |  harzion 22/10/06
  75.   clickfool the sas in northern ireland 11:14  |  harzion 22/10/06
  76.   THE FOOL and lies of omission.Hisbula declared WAR 11:18  |  PETER SM 22/10/06
  77.   clcikfool not to forget mr blunkett 11:20  |  harzion 22/10/06
  78.   Dictatorships 11:24  |  Lebanese admirer 22/10/06
  79.   What is Appropriate? 11:36  |  Ben 22/10/06
  80.   Clickfool (62) divine intervention 11:37  |  Gabriel 22/10/06
  81.   Answer to Walid. 11:39  |  David Nigel Braham 22/10/06
  82.   A question to all of you 11:52  |  Jonathan S 22/10/06
  83.   To Alex 12:10  |  gershon 22/10/06
  84.   To American # 44 Jesus 12:19  |  Altalena 22/10/06
  85.   to Cristina (#9) 12:21  |  imad