Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., November 11, 2006 Cheshvan 20, 5767 | | Israel Time: 00:43 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
What are 20 tons of explosives?
By Amira Hass

Hamas has smuggled 20 tons of explosives into the Gaza Strip, and that is aside from the anti-aircraft and antitank missiles. That is what the Israel Defense Forces has calculated, and it made sure to pump this frightening information into the Israeli media over the course of several days, raising the specter of Hezbollah-type attacks.

Despite half-hearted denials from Hamas, these statistics are believable. The Israeli information about weapons smuggling is supported by the simplistic thinking of Palestinian groups and their desire to engage in emulation: Hezbollah defeated Israel, so let us arm ourselves like Hezbollah. Armed resistance proved itself in Lebanon, they think, and it will prove itself for us, too. Minor issues like the very different geographic expanse, the population density, and the Strip's isolation from the rest of the world do not affect the mimics' considerations.

Neither do more complex analyses that show that Hezbollah erred in its political-military calculations and did not expect such a destructive Israeli response. The mimics are particularly unconcerned by questions such as: How many striking teachers could be paid salaries with the money that is being paid to weapons procurers and tunnel diggers? And has it not been proven over the last six years that harming Israeli citizens within the state's borders only strengthens public support for their government's policy of occupation? The Palestinian weapons mimics are finding themselves on the same side of the barricade as the Israeli security establishment, both of which are inflating the significance of Palestinian arms.

Advertisement

Whenever Israeli military officials report on the dangers awaiting us from the Palestinian side, they are aided by three phenomena. First, in Israel, information from military sources about Palestinians (unlike information about the recent war in Lebanon or other generals' wars) is considered neutral, driven not by any personal or group interests but by purely patriotic motives and concern for the good of the nation. Second, a significant percentage of Israelis simply forget their rich military experience. Everyone - including current and former combat soldiers and their families - turns into a naive civilian convinced by the television images of masked gunmen running around besieged Palestinian cities that "the other side is a warmonger" (and we are peace seekers).

Finally, in contrast to Palestinian weaponry, which is quantifiable, it is impossible to quantify the amount of "explosives" in Israel's hands - all the different types of shells and bombs, all the weapons that Israeli soldiers use or will use. The IDF Spokesman's Office does not volunteer that information, but in any case, the quantities are enormous, and they are constantly being restocked, whether through imports or through the flourishing Israeli arms industry. Before the recent war in Lebanon, did anyone calculate how many millions of cluster bombs Israel had in its warehouses (of which 1.2 million were fired during the war, as Meron Rapoport reported in this newspaper on September 12)?

And therefore, what exists in Israelis' consciousness is not the millions of cluster bombs - that is, the flying mines - or the tens of millions of bombs and shells and lethal bullets stored in our arms warehouses and our gun barrels and the bellies of our helicopters and planes. Although the amount of such explosives is measured in the millions of tons, it is the 20 tons of explosives and the few thousand rifles that permeate the Israeli consciousness.

Israelis are convinced that we are facing an existential danger. But what has been erased from the Israeli consciousness is that Israel is a weapons superpower, and that the weapons this state has, as is the nature of all weapons, are lethal and frightening.

The Israeli media, of course, cooperates with this distortion of reality. It devoutly reports every shot fired by the Palestinians and every rocket they launch - even when they cause no harm. But Israeli bullets and shells, which are fired routinely, do not exist in the media unless there are fatalities, and even those are quickly forgotten.

The purpose of instilling such fear in Israelis is to win ongoing support for the IDF's policy of constant escalation. The security establishment is not neutral. Its members, no less than bureaucrats in any other system, want to perpetuate the rationale for their existence and their salaries. They need public silence about the free use the IDF makes of the weapons and ammunition that it puts into its soldiers' hands. This serial intimidation is meant to give the IDF a free hand while it expands its operational infrastructure, perhaps to the point of using thousands of cluster bombs on Gaza, too.

The military establishment in Israel is joined at the hip with the political decision-making establishment, and hyping the security threat facing Israelis, while completely disengaging from the reality of the Israeli occupation, assures continued Israeli support for the myth that there is a military "solution" but not a political one. This in turn provides support for the ongoing regime of occupation and dispossession, and for the privileges that this bestows on Israelis.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Paint over the mosaic
Elana Gomel has no idea what life is like for the Israelis who support Lieberman.
On U.S. and them
The vitriolic hatred that the U.S. inspires in so many is striking chords everywhere.
  1.   Funny 10:51  |  Maral 18/10/06
  2.   Unsophisticated weapons are for terror against Israeli civillians 11:01  |  PETER SM 18/10/06
  3.   Amira, You are sick... 11:06  |  free the moon 18/10/06
  4.   meaning of 20 tons 11:06  |  Chris 18/10/06
  5.   To end the Arab?s occupation on the Land of Israel is a moral dut 11:07  |  Ayelet 18/10/06
  6.   But, Peter, the IDF also 11:11  |  Maral 18/10/06
  7.   Superpower ? 11:28  |  Altalena 18/10/06
  8.   May I suggest something ?... 11:35  |  Yankelowitz 18/10/06
  9.   Truck Bomb (less than 20 tons) Almost Took Down WTC in 1st Attack 11:36  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 18/10/06
  10.   To # 5 Haven`t you made a slight mistake ? lol 11:38  |  Yankelowitz 18/10/06
  11.   Indeed, Israel is a superpower... 11:42  |  Yankelowitz 18/10/06
  12.   Arab Moslems created the Israeli weapons superpower 11:42  |  Bennie 18/10/06
  13.   Sometimes it is not superior weapons which matters 11:46  |  Marco 18/10/06
  14.   Why, do you think, Amira, is Israel a weapons superpower? 11:46  |  Matthias Roth 18/10/06
  15.   Thanks Ayelet:We have to stope the Arab`s occupation 11:47  |  Talia 18/10/06
  16.   20 tons of explosives = alot of dead Jews 11:50  |  Moshe 18/10/06
  17.   PeterSM, FTM Ayelet, Altalena et al 11:53  |  Tony Price 18/10/06
  18.   Maral Sophisticated weapons not needed to kill a pregnant mother 11:54  |  PETER SM 18/10/06
  19.   There is at least one difficulty with Amira Hass`s commentary and 12:08  |  Shlomzion 18/10/06
  20.   Sure, Peter, cause the checkpoints wrok just fine 12:10  |  Maral 18/10/06
  21.   T PRICE Bored? why do you stain your clealy superior intellect- 12:25  |  PETER SM 18/10/06
  22.   What are 20 tons of explosives? 12:27  |  SIMON 18/10/06
  23.   to Altalena #7 12:32  |  Raf 18/10/06
  24.   Ayelet and Talia are Goy-haters 12:37  |  Al 18/10/06
  25.   Israeli the only State in the ME with a nuclear weapons 12:41  |  Nuradin 18/10/06
  26.   It is good that Hamas is arming itself 12:42  |  Stephen Murray 18/10/06
  27.   israel is not anymore 12:45  |  mehmet 18/10/06
  28.   Superpower, but whimps 12:52  |  Andreas 18/10/06
  29.   Amira Hass is a Joke on 2 Legs - She is her own selfparody 13:10  |  Zebedee 18/10/06
  30.   Hass should live in Jenin, convert to Islam & speak only Arabic 13:11  |  Dudu 18/10/06
  31.   Peter SM 13:20  |  Tony Price 18/10/06
  32.   #14 Matthias makes a BOLD statement 13:25  |  Johnboy 18/10/06
  33.   # 27 Al (and to Ayelet &Talia) 13:34  |  Shelly 18/10/06
  34.   To # 28 LOL 13:34  |  Yankelowitz 18/10/06
  35.   What are four airplanes? 13:49  |  Herbert Kaine 18/10/06
  36.   A Hass forgot that she id an Israel Citizen. Shame on her. 13:55  |  Vittorio 18/10/06
  37.   Ms. Hass, you`re a fool! One doesn`t compare the arsenal of 13:55  |  Yaakov K. 18/10/06
  38.   Dudu 14:03  |  Muhammed the great 18/10/06
  39.   #32 Johnboy part I 14:33  |  howiej 18/10/06
  40.   Shelly 14:48  |  Muhammed the Great 18/10/06
  41.   #32 Johnboy part II 14:49  |  howiej 18/10/06
  42.   Israeli Occupation?? Where? 14:50  |  Yaakov Sullivan 18/10/06
  43.   20 tons of explosives! 14:56  |  Sam 18/10/06
  44.   Ayelet/Talia/Shelly 14:57  |  Tzedaka 18/10/06
  45.   Conveniantly sidestepping some issues 15:00  |  Allon 18/10/06
  46.   To 26 Steven Murray 15:11  |  Allon 18/10/06
  47.   T.PRICE Re "Grow up and stop whinning`For a moment I thought it- 15:14  |  PETER SM 18/10/06
  48.   Maral 15:20  |  Nik Miller 18/10/06
  49.   Ms. Hass Question 15:29  |  Gee 18/10/06
  50.   #40 So, tell me howiej... 15:30  |  Johnboy 18/10/06
  51.   Israel is SURROUNDED By Enemies 15:32  |  Ben Israel 18/10/06
  52.   Ben Israel #51 15:53  |  Gabe1 18/10/06
  53.   Stephen Murray #26 15:55  |  Muhammed the Great 18/10/06
  54.   Fear is a Weapon 15:57  |  dan 18/10/06
  55.   andreas 16:00  |  alan 18/10/06
  56.   Johnboy from Australia 16:06  |  Stranger 18/10/06
  57.   AMIRA, WHAT EVIL! 16:12  |  Dutch 18/10/06
  58.   So what is your point Amira? 16:28  |  Bruriah 18/10/06
  59.   The warmongers 16:31  |  KUTW 18/10/06
  60.   42 - Weapons 16:32  |  Bruriah Sarah 18/10/06
  61.   Come on people!!! 16:34  |  Gabriel 18/10/06
  62.   Calling for Israel to disarm? 16:35  |  KUTW 18/10/06
  63.   43 - what is the significance? 16:38  |  Bruriah Sarah 18/10/06
  64.   Weapons of defense or agression 16:39  |  Hedwig Kossow 18/10/06
  65.   What?s so strange? 16:40  |  KUTW 18/10/06
  66.   To #35 You just made Mr Hass` point, thank you 16:40  |  lennybruce 18/10/06
  67.   The existential danger 16:50  |  KUTW 18/10/06
  68.   Hedwig Kossow #64 16:53  |  Gee 18/10/06
  69.   Why shouldn?t the Israeli media inform? 16:54  |  KUTW 18/10/06
  70.   Amira, dear, 1 17:05  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 18/10/06
  71.   In utter agreement 17:13  |  hollingsworth 18/10/06
  72.   ?The purpose of instilling such fear? 17:18  |  KUTW 18/10/06
  73.   The cluster bombs 17:21  |  KUTW 18/10/06
  74.   Amira Hass neutrality 17:24  |  KUTW 18/10/06
  75.   ..and Sadaam had weapons of mass destruction 17:28  |  Le Maudit Anglais 18/10/06
  76.   71hollingsworth, in utter agreement 17:31  |  KUTW 18/10/06
  77.   Johnboy in Aus forgets the aboriginals 17:33  |  rich 18/10/06
  78.   to maral 17:44  |  * TALKBACK OBSERVER* 18/10/06
  79.   #26 Stephen Murray, Please consider this 18:05  |  Dutch 18/10/06
  80.   DUTCH 18:29  |  Omar 18/10/06
  81.   To 79. Dutch. Victory & defeat 18:50  |  Altalena 18/10/06
  82.   Numbers indeed, Dutch provides some figures for Amira 18:56  |  Jacob Blues 18/10/06
  83.   Nonsense, those enemies dont value their lives 19:03  |  israel 18/10/06
  84.   Israelis concerned about what will cause casualties to Israelis 19:05  |  Shalom Freedman 18/10/06
  85.   #81 Altalena 19:09  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 18/10/06
  86.   To 85. Cipora 19:31  |  Altalena 18/10/06
  87.   Amira, forget about Israelis and Israel. 19:33  |  Uziel 18/10/06
  88.   An explosve editorial 19:34  |  Michael 18/10/06
  89.   It`s not fair... 19:42  |  Yitzhak 18/10/06
  90.   Amira, The war mongers on the forum 19:45  |  Dutch 18/10/06
  91.   To 81. Cipora 19:51  |  Altalena 18/10/06
  92.   94: Kassams Just firecrackers???? 20:06  |  Bruriah Sarah 18/10/06
  93.   Myth of Military Solution 20:47  |  peter 18/10/06
  94.   This is a proff Israel has free speach 20:48  |  Inyaki Bilbao 18/10/06
  95.   To 90. Dutch , again mistaken 20:56  |  Altalena 18/10/06
  96.   Arabs Pals admit they have a corrupted PA 21:16  |  Joseph E . 18/10/06
  97.   Al - over half of Israeli Jews are arabs 21:23  |  Jabadini 18/10/06
  98.   # 91 Altalena. re: Cipora. AND MY ADDENDUM... 21:26  |  Kathy 18/10/06
  99.   Jacob Blues 21:27  |  Walid 18/10/06
  100.   Post # 49 hit it right on the head about Amira 21:27  |  Dan Kelso 18/10/06
  101.   Nik Miller 21:35  |  Walid 18/10/06
  102.   Amira is saying there is no difference 21:35  |  Chill People 18/10/06
  103.   Bruriah Sarah 21:37  |  Walid 18/10/06
  104.   Mi$$ing the point 21:47  |  Pssd Off American 18/10/06
  105.   Altalena # 81 Wrong! 21:49  |  Jeff Northridge 18/10/06
  106.   Dutch: You know the ?prey? consists of terrorists 21:52  |  Dutch Conscience 18/10/06
  107.   Altalena 22:01  |  Walid 18/10/06
  108.   This is what is called fear marketing.. 22:17  |  BouSameer 18/10/06
  109.   Walid, you are correct. The Jews are the problem. 22:28  |  bobby 18/10/06
  110.   94.Inyaki:This is a proff Israel has free speach 22:43  |  Jabitxu 18/10/06
  111.   103: Which Occupation? 22:51  |  Bruriah Sarah 18/10/06
  112.   #107 Walid 22:53  |  Peter Dale 18/10/06
  113.   Israeli benevolence 22:54  |  Tzvi 18/10/06
  114.   Take off the kid gloves 22:57  |  SchtarkerYid 18/10/06
  115.   20 tons of explosives with intent to cause maximum casualties 23:02  |  lenny 18/10/06
  116.   Bobby 23:14  |  Walid 18/10/06
  117.   75.Le Maudit ...And the sheep harass the wolves 23:17  |  KUTW 18/10/06
  118.   #113 Tzvi 23:17  |  Tony Price 18/10/06
  119.   Hey Walid, 23:23  |  Jacob Blues 18/10/06
  120.   Post #32 by Johnboy 23:28  |  Tim 18/10/06
  121.   NYC reaction to violence 23:31  |  Jacob Blues 18/10/06
  122.   Bruriah Sarah 23:33  |  Walid 18/10/06
  123.   Where one stands on an issue, Walid 23:36  |  Jacob Blues 18/10/06
  124.   Going one step further Walid 23:43  |  Jacob Blues 18/10/06
  125.   #105 Jeff, is that why? 00:02  |  Dutch 19/10/06
  126.   What are 20 tons of explosives? 00:38  |  Charles 19/10/06
  127.   Hezbollah invented the latest fatal weapon ! 00:40  |  Yankelowitz 19/10/06
  128.   SUPPORT THIS FRIEND OF ISRAEL 00:42  |  KUTW 19/10/06
  129.   Walid 00:47  |  Gabe1 19/10/06
  130.   #98, Kathy 01:04  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 19/10/06
  131.   #32 Johnboy 01:07  |  Joseph 19/10/06
  132.   Hass the Korach 01:15  |  Debra 19/10/06
  133.   Thank you Hamira Hass 02:05  |  Yankelowitz 19/10/06
  134.   KUTW 02:35  |  Gabe1 19/10/06
  135.   #121 Joseph makes some statements 02:46  |  Johnboy 19/10/06
  136.   Defence against terrorism 02:49  |  Carl 19/10/06
  137.   #105 Jeff, who knows so much military history 03:27  |  Johnboy 19/10/06
  138.   the editorial 03:36  |  lerner 19/10/06
  139.   #138 lerner asks "what occupation"? 04:42  |  Johnboy 19/10/06
  140.   Friends like Hass who needs enemies 04:50  |  cuban 19/10/06
  141.   Amira its right it`s just a ruse 04:56  |  raul 19/10/06
  142.   Jabadini #97, I`ll give you credit for being truthful 05:07  |  Palestinian Prince 19/10/06
  143.   Walid #99 however..... 05:11  |  Palestinian Prince 19/10/06
  144.   Jacob Blues #124 going one step further 05:19  |  Palestinian Prince 19/10/06
  145.   # 27 Mehmet, You stopped your thinking at the current technology 06:03  |  Haham me Bat Yam 19/10/06
  146.   Johnboy/Joseph 06:53  |  Walid 19/10/06
  147.   Carl 07:02  |  Walid 19/10/06
  148.   AMIRA...SEE THE VOLUME OF NEGATIVE COMMENTS HERE 07:14  |  DWAYNE 19/10/06
  149.   Palestinian Prince 07:17  |  Walid 19/10/06
  150.   To Johnnyboy Re #135 07:23  |  Tim 19/10/06
  151.   All the education in the world, Prince 07:33  |  Jacob Blues 19/10/06
  152.   Lerner 07:37  |  Walid 19/10/06
  153.   Johnboy/Jeff Northridge 08:01  |  Walid 19/10/06
  154.   NOT FAIR 08:11  |  George 19/10/06
  155.   #2 Peter SM 08:21  |  maoriboy 19/10/06
  156.   Peter Dale 09:08  |  Walid 19/10/06
  157.   Jacob Blues 09:09  |  Walid 19/10/06
  158.   20 tons of explosives 09:10  |  RW 19/10/06
  159.   Peaceful resistance will work best for palestinians... 09:36  |  BouSameer 19/10/06
  160.   To 105, 107, 156. Walid. Water ressources 10:20  |  Altalena 19/10/06
  161.   To 81. Jeff. Who wins a war ? 10:32  |  Altalena 19/10/06
  162.   The Land of Israel ??? 10:35  |  Frenchie 19/10/06
  163.   To 98. Kathy 10:51  |  Altalena 19/10/06
  164.   Amira and Maral forgetting the facts... 11:18  |  victor 19/10/06
  165.   andreas 11:36  |  misha 19/10/06
  166.   # 130 Cipora J.K re: Altalena # 91. My understanding was correct 13:42  |  Kathy 19/10/06
  167.   # 163 Altalena. 14:02  |  Kathy 19/10/06
  168.   Actually Walid, I can 15:32  |  Jacob Blues 19/10/06
  169.   wow. a clarity of discourse I haven`t heard in Israeli media 17:52  |  JD 19/10/06
  170.   110 Jabitxo, we almost agree on everything but... 18:38  |  Inyaki 19/10/06
  171.   #148 Amira, Don`t Count on the masses 21:23  |  Dutch 19/10/06
  172.   A superficial analyse 21:45  |  Nicolas 19/10/06
  173.   162 frenchie 21:54  |  maria 19/10/06
  174.   Does Hamas intend to use it all against Fatah? 00:17  |  Murray of Montreal 20/10/06
  175.   I agree Peter 00:40  |  Kage 20/10/06
  176.   Israeli preSS for the destruction of ISrael 02:02  |  David 20/10/06
  177.   #148 Amira, Getting to the truth 02:51  |  Dutch 20/10/06
  178.   Proxy War 07:27  |  Jerry Lawrence 20/10/06
  179.   right walid 16:27  |  dusi 20/10/06
  180.   A difference of purpose 20:44  |  Bob Stewart 20/10/06
  181.   Simon: What are 20 tons? 01:35  |  Temporario 22/10/06
  182.   not aimed at pals 03:29  |  david 22/10/06
  183.   the situation 21:10  |  Robert 22/10/06
  184.   Walid 21:58  |  Dan 22/10/06
  185.   Terror Terror on the wall who is the greatest terrorist of all. 10:12  |  Athair Siochain 23/10/06
  186.   20 tons of explosives 10:15  |  athair siochain 23/10/06
  187.   400 illegal nuclear missiles-a lot of dead Arabs 10:20  |  athair siochain 23/10/06
  188.   Iran & N.Korea...2 of a kind...!!! 17:42  |  Jay 23/10/06
  189.   Answer to #187 17:58  |  Jay Wheeler 23/10/06
  190.   20 tons 18:21  |  don olson 23/10/06
  191.   twenty tons 10:01  |  frank mcenroe 07/11/06
  192.   IDF trying to Scare Israel 00:24  |  David King 12/11/06
 Today Online
Why didn't we use Air Force against Qassams from Gaza?
Responses: 170
Minister: Israel must stop Iran's nuclear program at all costs
Responses: 388
Yossi Beilin: Clash of Israeli and American civilizations
Responses: 137
Abraham Foxman: Fanatical Islam is like its totalitarian forbears
Responses: 115
Editorial: It's time Bush led a convincing peace effort
Responses: 93


More Headlines
21:13 Olmert: Convergence plan still exists, must be reevaluated
21:28 U.S. vetoes UN Security Council resolution condemning Beit Hanun shelling
21:34 Hezbollah, Amal announce resignation from Lebanese government
16:38 Putin holds talks with top Iranian nuclear negotiator
18:37 U.S. engineer indicted for passing secrets to Israel
20:31 Livni: Haniyeh resignation would present hope for moderates
19:06 German far-right NPD party meets in Berlin amid protests
17:26 Iran complains to UN Security Council over Sneh comments
00:30 Thousands of Palestinians commemorate two-year anniversary of Arafat's death
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved