Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., March 26, 2007 Nisan 7, 5767 | | Israel Time: 03:10 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 11:25 22/10/2006
Targeting Muslims - the new Inquisition
By Bradley Burston

Were I a Muslim living in the West, I'd be mad as hell. Not to mention terrified.

Were I a Muslim living in the West, I'd begin to believe that a new Inquisition had begun. An inquisition aimed at no one but Muslims.

Were I a Muslim living in the West, my wife, or my sister, or my daughter might well decide to wear a headscarf or a veil when she went out in public.

Perhaps it would be because she was tired of men and boys ogling her, objectifying her. Perhaps it would be because she felt she was entitled to her dignity. Perhaps she simply might prefer modesty and privacy to fashion slavery.

Perhaps she just thought it was a free country.

And perhaps, on that last point, she would have been mistaken.

For years, and especially since 9/11, law-abiding Muslims have been verbally and physically attacked across North America and Europe. They are scorned for their faith, shunned for their piety, falsely condemned for dual-loyalty, blamed for the crimes of terrorists they abhor.

Of late, however, there has been a disturbing new trend, particularly in Europe, where cabinet ministers and influential lawmakers have increasingly made it their mission to combat, of all things, the head scarf and veil worn by growing numbers of Muslim women and girls.

  • In Germany, the states of Baden-Wurttenberg and Bavaria recently introduced legislation to outlaw the wearing of head scarves in schools.

    Bavarian Education Monika Hohlmeier said the head scarf was increasingly being used as a political symbol. To the understandable ire of Muslims, Hohlmeier went on to say that it was acceptable to wear Christian crosses or Jewish symbols.

  • In Spain, home to the original Inquisition, Minister for Social Affairs Juan Carlos Aparicio was quoted as having said that the Muslim veil was "not a religious sign but a form of discrimination against women," and having compared it to genital mutilation.

  • In Britain, the government minister for race and faith relations, Phil Woolas, was quoted this week as demanding that Muslim teaching assistant Aisha Azmi, 24, who refused to remove her veil at work, be fired for that reason.

    "She should be sacked," Woolas was quoted as telling the Sunday Mirror. "She has put herself in a position where she can't do her job."

    Azmi worked at the Headfield Church of England junior school in Dewsbury, which took pains to state that her suspension had nothing to do with religion.

    The scarf issue had already taken center stage when former British Foreign Secretary Jack Straw, now an MP and Leader of the House of Commons, voiced public objections to the wearing of the niqab, a full-face veil, at face-to-face meetings with his constituents.

    The national debate has since widened, with David Davis, a top Conservative Party official, taking the anti-veil stance to a new level.

    ''What Jack touched on was the fundamental issue of whether in Britain we are developing a divided society,'' Davis said. ''Whether we are inadvertently encouraging a kind of voluntary apartheid.''

    The anti-veil arguments dovetail with a parallel campaign, which takes as its premise the concept that Islam itself renders its adherents incapable of integrating into Western societies.

    "If you are going to have Islamic schools, the question is whether they are going to embrace Western values," Patrick Sookhdeo, a Pakistan-born Anglican priest in England who converted from Islam, told the New York Times this month.

    "I would argue that Islamic values are not compatible with Western values," he said.

    And what Western values might these be? Are they the time-honored Western values of intolerance for people of color, suspicion and marginalization of non-Christians, fear and loathing of non-Whites? Exploitation of and contempt for the residents of former imperial possessions and colonies?

    At this point, there will be a pause for the springloaded Islamophobes among us to suggest that it is any society's right and duty to protect itself against elements that may foment terrorism. There will be those who will argue that the veil may both mask and encourage extremism.

    Perhaps it is time for us in the Western world to declare that Islam has a right to exist.

    Perhaps it is time for us to recognize that non-violent, non-Judeo-Christian religious observance is a right, not an act of war.

    Scarves don't explode. Veils do not kill. The niqab does not incite.

    It takes courage to wear the veil in the West. Certainly, no one should be forced to wear it against her will. But those who do so voluntarily, have chosen to brave ridicule, and perhaps to risk their own livelihood. They have made a choice for self-respect, in the face of all that is vacuous in contemporary Western civilization, where the worship of the superficial has taken on the potency and universality of a state religion.

    We in the West have allowed the veil to become the symbol of all that we do not know and do not trust about Islam.

    In the Age of Paris Hilton, however, the West desperately needs women who devote themselves to serious pursuits, to the betterment of society, women who believe that self-esteem and dignity are worthy values. If they choose to wear a veil, and we take offense, that is wholly our problem. We have no business making it theirs.

    __________________


    Talkback Guidelines

    The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and an openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

    Censorship will be unapologetic.

    Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

    The following will be grounds for deletion:

    1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
    2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, ethnic cleansing, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
    3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
    4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.
    5.Use of the phrase: "There are no Palestinians" or derivatives thereof.

    _________________


    Previous blogs:
    Israel's spokesman, Israel's enemy
    Peace Never
    The great blood libel of Sept. 11
    Be afraid, America. Be very afraid

  • Bookmark to del.icio.us
    The last word
    Israel won't make it to Euro '08 but to judge Kashtan by his current results would be unfair.
    Soft on corruption
    A police force that is weak in white-collar probes is good for politicians but not the public.
      1.   the new inquisition 10:47  |  clear thinking 20/10/06
      2.   headscarf 10:59  |  Serge 20/10/06
      3.   Bradley, thoughts on the niqab I 11:00  |  sh 20/10/06
      4.   Bradley, thoughts on the niqab II 11:01  |  sh 20/10/06
      5.   Bradley Burston the heroic defender of Islam 11:02  |  Jonathan S 20/10/06
      6.   Bravo Brad 11:11  |  Richard Silverstein 20/10/06
      7.   You`re a guy - no one is forcing you to wear a veil! 11:33  |  A Free Woman 20/10/06
      8.   I too say: BRAVO, Bradley! 12:00  |  Mario Fiorito 20/10/06
      9.   The New Crusaders 12:01  |  volov 20/10/06
      10.   Richard Silverstein, Know Nothing of Seattle 12:04  |  Akiva Patysh 20/10/06
      11.   To dear and stupid Bradley Burton 12:08  |  Jeroen 20/10/06
      12.   Bingo 12:08  |  Michael 20/10/06
      13.   targeting muslims 12:11  |  G Gargour 20/10/06
      14.   tolerance is a two-way street 12:15  |  Mike 20/10/06
      15.   THE NEW CRUSADERS II 12:16  |  volov 20/10/06
      16.   veils 12:17  |  janez 20/10/06
      17.   The ttuth is .. 12:18  |  Gee 20/10/06
      18.   Targeting Muslims 12:33  |  crystaldragon402 20/10/06
      19.   Scarfs 12:44  |  Wael 20/10/06
      20.   What`s wrong with you? Would Muslims react like you do? 12:50  |  Dan 20/10/06
      21.   To Jonanathan S 12:55  |  o 20/10/06
      22.   The scarf the veil 12:58  |  FOX 20/10/06
      23.   Holier than thou 13:02  |  Yael 20/10/06
      24.   Bradley,what we havent heard... 13:02  |  Ronnie Wolman 20/10/06
      25.   Half of the story The Muslim non- integration in Europe 13:10  |  Shalom Freedman 20/10/06
      26.   A question for Bradley 13:10  |  Hastaroth 20/10/06
      27.   the veil 13:11  |  michel wandel 20/10/06
      28.   Islamophobia 13:21  |  Bader Abu-Ghosh 20/10/06
      29.   Muslims Fear Other Muslims 13:22  |  Klaudia 20/10/06
      30.   To Jonathan S (# 5) 13:35  |  Bader Abu-Ghosh 20/10/06
      31.   Brad holier than thou 13:41  |  Shelly 20/10/06
      32.   No orthodox wear 13:45  |  Marilyn 20/10/06
      33.   Muslims 13:51  |  Choni 20/10/06
      34.   Spot on Bradley 13:53  |  Stephen Duke 20/10/06
      35.   Who is the real victim here? 13:55  |  Paul Henzen 20/10/06
      36.   Partially true, but . . 14:06  |  Peter Dale 20/10/06
      37.   Spare a thought 14:09  |  Australit 20/10/06
      38.   Muslims 14:17  |  j10 20/10/06
      39.   Burston`s double standard 14:17  |  Carmel 20/10/06
      40.   #5 14:19  |  Peter Dale 20/10/06
      41.   #5 Hear, hear 14:28  |  Paul Henzen 20/10/06
      42.   WHO IS FORCING MUSLIMS TO CONVERT? 14:28  |  B 20/10/06
      43.   you are absolutely right 14:33  |  cool 20/10/06
      44.   To Bader Abu-Ghosh 14:36  |  Klaudia 20/10/06
      45.   To #17 and #26: Middle Ages in Europe again 14:39  |  Jonathan S 20/10/06
      46.   o # 17 14:45  |  ChanahS 20/10/06
      47.   Klaudia #25, well put 14:53  |  FOX 20/10/06
      48.   Try this!! 14:54  |  Willy 20/10/06
      49.   Modesty or Enslavement? 14:56  |  Jane 20/10/06
      50.   EUROPEAN HIPOCRISY 14:56  |  MICHELE 20/10/06
      51.   the New Inquisition 14:58  |  Shpend 20/10/06
      52.   Kudos to Bradley 14:58  |  Michael Perez 20/10/06
      53.   That`s almost the story if the Jews all over again... 15:00  |  Bousameer 20/10/06
      54.   What if they were forced to wear the hijab? 15:04  |  FOX 20/10/06
      55.   Bader #26. Reaction to veil not islamohobia.. 15:11  |  BouSameer 20/10/06
      56.   Bradley Typical Leftist Garbage 15:15  |  Gabe1 20/10/06
      57.   Bradley Typical Leftist Garbage 15:15  |  Gabe1 20/10/06
      58.   ##Fox 21 15:28  |  Peter Dale 20/10/06
      59.   you are mad, you are dangerous 15:32  |  carlos 20/10/06
      60.   Very well said, Bradley! 15:48  |  Tom Kaufmann 20/10/06
      61.   My Home Is My Castle! 15:49  |  Alicia 20/10/06
      62.   Bradley why the censorship ref journalists 15:52  |  rich 20/10/06
      63.   Earth to Burston 15:55  |  Seth Halpern 20/10/06
      64.   Western Women Forced to Cover 15:56  |  David 20/10/06
      65.   Dear Bradley, not enough place here.... 16:04  |  Karl 20/10/06
      66.   Daniel Pearl also believed Muslims were being discriminated 16:05  |  Jake 20/10/06
      67.   Bravo Bradley!I agree "Islam has a right to exist" 16:06  |  Le Maudit Anglais 20/10/06
      68.   Intolerance 16:07  |  Jeff Siddiqui 20/10/06
      69.   # Jonathan S. Your usual plea for tolerance. 16:13  |  Le Maudit Anglais 20/10/06
      70.   Correction 16:14  |  seth halpern 20/10/06
      71.   The new inquisition 16:39  |  Moustafa Nour 20/10/06
      72.   regarding the niqab 16:41  |  JW 20/10/06
      73.   Wael 16:43  |  sh 20/10/06
      74.   Dale bending till he breaks 16:44  |  FOX 20/10/06
      75.   Bader Abu-Ghosh 16:47  |  sh 20/10/06
      76.   To Dan 16:50  |  Tim 20/10/06
      77.   I am ashamed by all the intolerance shown here! 16:55  |  Le Maudit Anglais 20/10/06
      78.   Is there inquisition in Turkey and Tunisia? 17:01  |  McQueen 20/10/06
      79.   Ironically in Europe not US 17:02  |  McQueen 20/10/06
      80.   Spouse Abuse is Common in All Societies 17:03  |  Jack 20/10/06
      81.   Freedom of Religion in the West 17:04  |  Simon 20/10/06
      82.   So the only two choices are Paris H or a veil? 17:05  |  McQueen 20/10/06
      83.   Thinly veiled antagonism,(Haaretz, 3rd X post) 17:06  |  Akiva Patysh