Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., October 19, 2006 Tishrei 27, 5767 | | Israel Time: 05:34 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 01:10 16/10/2006
FM calls envoy back after controversial remarks on Asians
By Charlotte Halle, Haaretz Correspondent

Synagogues in Australia were abuzz on Sunday over controversial comments made by Israel's ambassador to Canberra in an interview with Haaretz last week.

"I can't tell you how sensitive these things are here," said a senior member of Sydney's Jewish community, referring to Ambassador Naftali Tamir's description of Asians as having "yellow skin" and "slanted eyes." The source added that the comments were the hot topic at both the synagogues he attended over the Simhat Torah holiday, which falls a day later in locales outside of Israel.

Tamir, who was on his way back to Australia from Israel when the report broke, was intercepted at a stop-off in Asia and recalled to Israel to "clarify" the matter with his superiors at the Foreign Ministry.

Advertisement

"If the article is accurate, this is a grave and unacceptable remark," said the ministry in a statement on Friday, adding that it will not return to business as usual if an internal examination confirms that the ambassador did indeed make the comments attributed to him.

The key concern of the Jewish community, the source in Sydney explained, was that the broad coverage of the comments in the Australian press would fuel those who charge that Israel is a racist state and that the Australian government is erring in its overtly pro-Israel position. He added that while the comments were considered offensive and embarrassing, the community would "rally around [the ambassador]," while distancing itself from the sentiments.

Grahame Leonard, president of the Executive Council of Australian Jewry, the community's umbrella organization, told Haaretz on Sunday that the community holds Tamir "in the highest regard," and praised his "outstanding" representation of Israel during the recent Lebanon war. Leonard added: "As far as the reported remarks are concerned, we understand the Foreign Ministry is checking into those and we'd prefer to make no comment until we hear the official report."

The Australian government refused to comment following an inquiry from Haaretz, but Sunday's Sydney Morning Herald quoted opposition foreign affairs spokesman, Kevin Rudd, as saying: "If accurate, these comments are completely unacceptable."

In the interview with Tamir, which appeared in Haaretz on Friday, he said Israel should utilize its strong links with Australia to enhance its position with Asian countries. He described Israel and Australia as "sisters" in Asia and added: "We are in Asia without the characteristics of Asians. We don't have yellow skin and slanted eyes. Asia is basically the yellow race. Australia and Israel are not  we are basically the white race."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
All fun and games
The domestic online gaming industry is growing, but still lags behind the U.S.
Out to lunch
Hot school lunches are back on the menu after MKs approve a compromise bill.
  1.   FM calls envoy back after controversial remarks on Asians 01:21  |  tenalleyraman 16/10/06
  2.   If accurate, he should be sacked 01:49  |  Yitzhak 16/10/06
  3.   read AP reference in INDIAN COUNTRY TODAY, Sept 20, 2005 02:03  |  zayyin ba ayin 16/10/06
  4.   Derogatory? 02:04  |  Logical Discourse 16/10/06
  5.   NO SURPRISE 02:13  |  Brant 16/10/06
  6.   Even Israel Has No Shortage of Idiots 02:17  |  GenerX 16/10/06
  7.   What do you xpecy 02:23  |  Chunfla Burlbe 16/10/06
  8.   Incredibly stupid statements, he doesn`t represent any Jew 02:28  |  amir 16/10/06
  9.   not surprising, but will wait to see if it`s true 02:42  |  molchi 16/10/06
  10.   regarding slanted eyes comments 02:49  |  molchi 16/10/06
  11.   Chunfla Burlbe 03:24  |  ChanahS 16/10/06
  12.   # 11, ChanahS - in English? 03:54  |  Ani 16/10/06
  13.   the reported recall of Amb. Naftali Tamir 04:26  |  zayyin ba ayin 16/10/06
  14.   What do you expect from Zionists? 04:51  |  Dovy 16/10/06
  15.   very disappointed in this guy 05:08  |  yonatan 16/10/06
  16.   ignorant 05:30  |  Victoria 16/10/06
  17.   Politically incorrect statement from Zionist 05:40  |  omolll 16/10/06
  18.   #4 Derogatory? Yes, my friend, very derogatory. 06:08  |  Johnboy 16/10/06
  19.   Tamir`s racial spew 06:11  |  sleven 16/10/06
  20.   To Victoria 06:16  |  sleven 16/10/06
  21.   Israelis need education about race 06:30  |  Harvey Goldberg 16/10/06
  22.   TO Logical Discourse 06:39  |  Bill 16/10/06
  23.   Doesn`t Israel Have More Competent Diplomats? 06:46  |  Yosemite Sam 16/10/06
  24.   Racist 07:11  |  Knowledge 16/10/06
  25.   So this shows Israel is a racist state 07:18  |  slanted and yellowed 16/10/06
  26.   No Offense! 07:24  |  Chiang TK 16/10/06
  27.   whatever happened to innocent until found guilty? 07:31  |  ephraim 16/10/06
  28.   Remarks by the envoy 07:58  |  Frank 16/10/06
  29.   Typical hypocrisy from Dovy, Omoll, et all 08:00  |  David Teich 16/10/06
  30.   Derogatory? 08:22  |  Australian in China 16/10/06
  31.   The concept of racism should be revised 08:49  |  Liberterian 16/10/06
  32.   How clever in helping Israel`s cause 09:18  |  David 16/10/06
  33.   Most Jews and Arabs are Same Race 09:31  |  Israeli 16/10/06
  34.   Uneducated Israeli Diplomats ? 09:39  |  Joe 16/10/06
  35.   Envoy and Asian Comment 09:42  |  Judy Abeles Elisasov 16/10/06
  36.   PC 09:54  |  Linichka 16/10/06
  37.   Innocent until proven guilty? 10:14  |  JW 16/10/06
  38.   Tamir`s unacceptable comments 10:23  |  R.Mann 16/10/06
  39.   Worst than the words, the idea 10:43  |  Marianne 16/10/06
  40.   Let`s all agree... 11:24  |  Hanoman 16/10/06
  41.   generX: "even" in Israel there are idiots in office? 11:31  |  Albert Fischer 16/10/06
  42.   what an idiot 11:41  |  rich 16/10/06
  43.   # 18 Johnboy 11:46  |  Daniel 16/10/06
  44.   Anto-Semitism again 12:51  |  ScotGuy 16/10/06
  45.   ephraim #27 Yeah whatever happened to innocent til proven guilty? 13:07  |  T A Sheppard 16/10/06
  46.   Recall Him Now or suffer the consequences 13:27  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/10/06
  47.   #43 Daniel 13:29  |  Johnboy 16/10/06
  48.   FM Controversy 13:29  |  Jizzi Rahl 16/10/06
  49.   HE IS AN HONEST ZIONIST 13:31  |  AHMAD 16/10/06
  50.   not a small or insignificant matter 13:38  |  Paul 16/10/06
  51.   Dimplomat ? rather Sir Les. 13:44  |  Kym 16/10/06
  52.   Daniel on the Australian iniquities #43 13:59  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/10/06
  53.   And we Jews have big noses... 14:08  |  Avrum 16/10/06
  54.   Johnboy in Aus 14:14  |  rich 16/10/06
  55.   Tamir 14:48  |  david 16/10/06
  56.   45: Sheppard`s lies 14:51  |  David Teich 16/10/06
  57.   That does set you off rich doesnt it? Another diversionary tactic 15:00  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/10/06
  58.   White race 15:30  |  Lebanese in Canada 16/10/06
  59.   Just like a home grown Australian 15:46  |  Maurice 16/10/06
  60.   Public Relations Goldmine for Israel 15:52  |  dan 16/10/06
  61.   #56 David Tiech 15:53  |  John of Jordan 16/10/06
  62.   #25 slanted and yellowed 15:59  |  John of Jordan 16/10/06
  63.   #26 Chaing TK 16:01  |  John of Jordan 16/10/06
  64.   Fire Him. 16:23  |  Bimmer 16/10/06
  65.   to Haaretz: please provide for Talkback on the Anglo File .. 20:50  |  zayyin ba ayin 16/10/06
  66.   Yakoub strikes again #57 00:36  |  Ari ben Yisrael 17/10/06
  67.   remark 13:26  |  Hilda 17/10/06
  68.   I don`t hate Jews...David Teich 16:31  |  T A Sheppard 17/10/06
  69.   Sure it is offensive, but not about the yellow bit 05:19  |  Beansprout 19/10/06
 Today Online
Amira Hass: Israelis forget Israel is a weapons superpower
Responses: 144
Shmuel Rosner: Is the U.S. Jewish left ready for commitment?
Responses: 64
Aluf Benn: Maybe the Golan really is better than peace
Responses: 172
Gideon Samet: Fearing for the fate of the country
Responses: 40
U.S. court defines Jewish group as terror organization
Responses: 90
Rosner's Domain
* Guest: Myth and misunderstanding regarding "the lobby"
* The Jewish left rears its head
* 'First Muslim in Congress' goes to Israel
* Poll: Is it time for American-Jewish lobby for peace?


More Headlines
03:19 PM: Iran should fear consequences of its actions
03:56 PM to have 'quality face time' with Bush in U.S. next month
04:54 MAG orders investigation into suspected leaks during Lebanon war
04:25 Family of abducted soldier seeks help from Russian mufti
01:30 Hamas gunman killed in Nablus, Fatah suspected of involvement
05:11 Mixed Jewish-Arab towns have highest rate of incarceration
00:33 Peretz weighs legalizing some West Bank outposts
23:43 IDF moves 4 km into southern Gaza; Peretz: We won't reoccupy
21:51 Panel drafts ethical code for MKs, recommends harsh penalties
02:26 Ministers demand entry into Israel for Palestinian students
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
One year MBA in Israel
Taught entirely in English
SINGLES ECARDS
Say hello to Jewish singles with E-cards. Send FREE at JDate
Discover LOVE
See why JLove.com is the fastest growing Jewish relationship site committed to preserving Jewish values
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations