Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., April 24, 2007 Iyyar 6, 5767 | | Israel Time: 09:29 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Liberal leadership candidate Michael Ignatieff speaking to students while campaigning at the Universite de Montreal on September 8.
Last update - 16:10 14/10/2006
Top Liberal candidate in Canada accuses Israel of war crimes
By Reuters

The leading candidate to head Canada's opposition Liberal Party was defiant on Friday after opening a political can of worms with the charge that Israel committed war crimes during its Lebanon campaign this summer.

Michael Ignatieff, a human rights expert and a former Harvard don, said at the weekend that Israel committed a war crime when it bombarded the Lebanese village of Qana in July.

That prompted angry complaints from Conservative Prime Minister Stephen Harper that the Liberals, who have more often than not run Canada, had taken an anti-Israel stance.

Advertisement

"I think we all remember last summer when the Liberals were making all these anti-Israeli comments," Harper told reporters, noting that only two candidates to head the party had distanced themselves from such remarks at the time.

Ignatieff has a hold on the largest single number of delegates to the Liberal leadership convention in December, although there could be several rounds of voting and he is by no means guaranteed victory in the race to head the party.

He said on Friday that it would be up to international bodies to determine whether Israel had committed war crimes at Qana, although he also said he thought both sides in the conflict were guilty of crimes against civilians.

"I do believe that in this explosive conflict, war crimes were visited on Israeli citizens and were visited on Lebanese civilians," he said.

Ignatieff, who stressed his friendship for Israel and said he would travel there soon, said it was disgraceful for Harper to suggest the Liberals were anti-Israeli.

"There is no basis whatever for Mr. Harper to suggest that the Liberal Party is biased against Israel."

Harper said that only two of the eight Liberal leadership candidates, Joe Volpe and Scott Brison, had criticized anti-Israel rhetoric over the summer, and he accused other candidates of being hypocritical when they spoke out against Ignatieff's remarks on Israel this week. Volpe and Brison are near the bottom of the pack in Liberal support.

"I think for them (the others) to be attacking Michael Ignatieff now - and I totally disagree with Ignatieff - but I think it's a bit hypocritical for them to show their faces now," he told reporters. "They should have done it before."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
In praise of smoking
The quick, simple way to smoke meat or fish for immediate consumption.
Concrete Eden
After we've paved paradise, what we are left with is our constructed landscape.
  1.   Canadian Liberal candidate 23:22  |  Sam 13/10/06
  2.   Before the usual hysteria brigade steps in 23:30  |  Peter Dale 13/10/06
  3.   expert on human rights? 00:05  |  jean marie 14/10/06
  4.   Canada - EH !! 01:03  |  Avrum 14/10/06
  5.   yes Peter but in Canada 01:12  |  John 14/10/06
  6.   Liberal party and criticism of Israel 01:29  |  jake fisher 14/10/06
  7.   end war crimes AND the occupation 01:48  |  Mary 14/10/06
  8.   Ignatieff is a (reformed?) neocon 01:50  |  redsmith 14/10/06
  9.   Whoa...someone speaking the truth..get him! 02:04  |  Mark Kienan 14/10/06
  10.   Don`t worry 02:49  |  Tim 14/10/06
  11.   oy vey, 03:02  |  alan 14/10/06
  12.   Mary from Canada 03:17  |  Bruce 14/10/06
  13.   to #10 (maradona) 03:31  |  * TALKBACK OBSERVER* 14/10/06
  14.   He also said before he wasn`t losing any sleep over it 03:38  |  Joe Frazier 14/10/06
  15.   Peter Dale is the "hysteria brigade" 03:54  |  FOX 14/10/06
  16.   Mark #9 hypocrite 04:01  |  FOX 14/10/06
  17.   Canada - yup 04:34  |  Gordon 14/10/06
  18.   To redsmith 04:42  |  Gabriel 14/10/06
  19.   who 05:41  |  George 14/10/06
  20.   election 05:49  |  bev 14/10/06
  21.   What does it say about a person who is interested in human 06:02  |  Yair 14/10/06
  22.   To 3 06:14  |  Chris 14/10/06
  23.   Iggy; A Typical Liberal 06:20  |  Michael T 14/10/06
  24.   Redsmith 06:25  |  Brad 14/10/06
  25.   canadian conservatives will soon be history 06:26  |  anti-racist 14/10/06
  26.   canadian conservatives will soon be history 06:26  |  anti-racist 14/10/06
  27.   Israel accused of war crimes,tell me something new 06:43  |  maoriboy 14/10/06
  28.   So Bev...about the Palestinians in Canada 06:43  |  David James Vickery 14/10/06
  29.   Leading candidate of Canada`s Liberals accuses Israel of war crim 07:08  |  Stief shousheh - 14/10/06
  30.   numbers 07:13  |  Stief shousheh - 14/10/06
  31.   numbers 07:17  |  Stief shousheh - 14/10/06
  32.   dare you to post 07:36  |  Stief shousheh - 14/10/06
  33.   Muslim vote 07:51  |  Dale 14/10/06
  34.   I told you, didn`t I...... 08:43  |  Maureen Ann 14/10/06
  35.   Dale ##33 09:24  |  Dr Joi Cherian 14/10/06
  36.   To Israel, the children`s souls are still screaming 09:39  |  Lebanese 14/10/06
  37.   Dale, may be you should talk about the Jewish vote In US 09:43  |  Lebanese 14/10/06
  38.   Politicians. one day they say something the next they say the oth 09:47  |  Joe 14/10/06
  39.   Is there a Canadian Jewish Lobby...... 09:48  |  Clickfool 14/10/06
  40.   # 28- David James Vickery...Dear Fellow Canadian... 09:51  |  Klaudia 14/10/06
  41.   Southpark was Right 09:56  |  Michael 14/10/06
  42.   trip to Canada 10:06  |  Doubchak Alexander 14/10/06
  43.   Ignatieff clearly an antisemite 10:30  |  Semsem 14/10/06
  44.   Both sides committed war crimes? Does anybody deny it? 10:36  |  Michael 14/10/06
  45.   Mary worry about Canada 10:39  |  skylark 14/10/06
  46.   Mark Kienan 10:41  |  skylark 14/10/06
  47.   Maureen Ann 10:48  |  skylark 14/10/06
  48.   Lebanese 10:49  |  skylark 14/10/06
  49.   Same old story... 11:15  |  Hanoman 14/10/06
  50.   Michael the problem is definition 11:19  |  skylark 14/10/06
  51.   Peter Dale and the hysteria brigade 11:26  |  Selma Hayim 14/10/06
  52.   # 49 12:13  |  Farooq 14/10/06
  53.   Canada Only a Two Bit Colony 12:14  |  An Observer 14/10/06
  54.   Change ways now before it`s too late... 12:42  |  fletch 14/10/06
  55.   Hanoman 12:45  |  Fletch 14/10/06
  56.   SemSem 12:54  |  Fletch 14/10/06
  57.   Sorry Skylark, I don`t agree 12:54  |  Michael 14/10/06
  58.   Mark Kienan#9 13:08  |  Yariv 14/10/06
  59.   re: Fletch 13:20  |  Efox 14/10/06
  60.   re: Farooq 13:25  |  Efox 14/10/06
  61.   re: Michael 13:34  |  Efox 14/10/06
  62.   re. Doubchak Alexander 13:36  |  Efox 14/10/06
  63.   re: Mark Kienan 13:40  |  Efox 14/10/06
  64.   #7 have I got news for you. 13:47  |  Don Saliman 14/10/06
  65.   Say what, we critisized the UNTOUCHABLES 13:52  |  John DOWN THE WALL 14/10/06
  66.   To #36 13:53  |  Don Saliman 14/10/06
  67.   # 12 Bruce 14:00  |  John DOWN THE WALL 14/10/06
  68.   # 33 Dale 14:10  |  John DOWN THE WALL 14/10/06
  69.   Michael#57 14:14  |  Yariv 14/10/06
  70.   Canadians, A little Humility, Please 14:24  |  Tony Anthony 14/10/06
  71.   What is happening in Darfur is a Sudaniese issue 14:28  |  KarimZidan 14/10/06
  72.   Michael 15:17  |  skylark 14/10/06
  73.   KarimZidan 15:20  |  skylark 14/10/06
  74.   Peter Dale #2: some of your assertions, Peter 15:29  |  Ivo 14/10/06
  75.   Canada violates human rights 15:39  |  Gene 14/10/06
  76.   Efox & Yariv. Only Israeli media tells truth? 15:45  |  Michael 14/10/06
  77.   MOSLEM VOTE 15:47  |  Tzvi 14/10/06
  78.   To Klaudia 16:01  |  David James Vickery 14/10/06
  79.   foot and mouth disease 16:02  |  garry 14/10/06
  80.   Ignatieff was wrong to judge one country over another 16:07  |  donna 14/10/06
  81.   Muslims threaten to overcome us by demographics, not reason 16:17  |  donna 14/10/06
  82.   Canadadian Paradise 16:36  |  Palestinian American 14/10/06
  83.   Is this guy look like the Spanish (commie) Prime Minister mimicki 16:41  |  ng Hugo Chavez? 14/10/06
  84.   i think he wrote isaiah berlin`s biography 16:54  |  zadok the priest 14/10/06
  85.   Michael#73 17:52  |  Yariv 14/10/06
  86.   david james vickory 18:28  |  Alon