Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., October 25, 2006 Cheshvan 3, 5767 | | Israel Time: 05:13 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Forbidden to settlers, not the state
By Amira Hass

The Israel Defense Forces and the Civil Administration did well to inform the Israeli public about the steps being taken to ensure that the olive harvest is conducted properly; the season began last week. Well-trained Israeli ears are quick to locate the matrices of that well-guarded harvest: any village that might serve as the target of settlers' attacks on Palestinian farmers, their orchards or their crops.

In contrast to the limited military and police protection that Palestinian harvesters received in the previous two years, this year, the protection is expected to be especially serious, and the IDF talks of "harvesting to the very last olive." This implies that attempts by settlers to attack or intimidate the harvesters will be averted. Rabbi Arik Ascherman, director of Rabbis for Human Rights, is under the impression that, at least at the command level, the IDF is determined to protect the welfare of the harvesters and the harvest.

Harassment and attacks by settlers, who tried to terrify the villagers, existed even before 2000, but they grew more prevalent after the second intifada began. The army and the police turned out to be either absent, helpless or apathetic. The military commanders found an easy way out: They closed vast areas of farmland to their owners, the Palestinians, as a means of "protecting them" against the settlers.

Advertisement

Rabbis for Human Rights (RHR) and other left-wing Israeli organizations, such as the Ta'ayush Arab Jewish Partnership, decided as early as 2002 to accompany the Palestinian farmers, despite the danger that the settlers would also attack them. The rich experience of RHR activists supplied the factual basis for a petition against the state and the security forces that was submitted by the Association of Civil Rights in Israel, together with this dissident group of rabbis and five Palestinian villages, to the High Court of Justice in 2004. It took the court two years to hear the petition, including the state's responses, additions and corrections to the petition, examining the state's assurances, correcting the responses and so forth. But in July 2006, the court handed down a ruling that obliged the security forces to protect Palestinians' property rights and their right to cultivate their land. The IDF, the Civil Administration and the police are now bound by the court's ruling. That is why they now sound more resolute than ever before in their warnings to the settlers.

Of all the systematic Israeli assaults on Palestinian farmers, those which are initiated and carried out by settlers have received the most successful negative public relations: A few well-known personalities signed up to assist in one or two well-publicized harvest expeditions, members of the Kibbutz Movement expressed shock and regularly accompany farmers from some of the villages, and there were tough editorials in the press. But what is forbidden to the settlers is permitted to the state, the IDF and the Civil Administration, big time.

MachsomWatch, another group of dissident Israelis, has been accompanying farmers in the northern West Bank on their troubled journeys to their lands, which are locked behind the separation fence and, in effect, have been expropriated from them. The women of MachsomWatch get reports from the various gates in the fence. The state promised the High Court that it would make it possible for the farmers to reach these lands. So it promised. But most of the year, the gates are open only twice a week. People have therefore given up on trying to grow vegetables and wheat, which require daily attention, or on letting their sheep graze in uncultivated pastures. Many times, the gates do not open at the appointed hour. Many times, soldiers do not accept the residents' permits or confiscate them on various pretexts. The activists from MachsomWatch spend long hours on the telephone, trying to reach army command posts to check why a gate was not opened on time, why a permit was confiscated, why a request by two women for permission to work their family lands was turned down.

Now that it is harvest time, the gates are due to open every day, three times a day. Instead of several dozen permits for every village, several hundred are being given out. Yet there are still many who are turned down, in arbitrary fashion. This daily damage to the Palestinians does not find its way into the headlines.

The Israeli occupation establishment constantly imposes various forms of harassment on Palestinians engaged in agriculture, one of the foundations of the Palestinians' existence: the separation fence, which imprisons the lands of 42 villages behind it; the settlers' constantly expanding security fences; the expropriation of lands for the construction of bypass roads and security roads; the destruction of wells; the closure of various areas (including the entire Jordan Valley) for military purposes; the closing of roads to Palestinian vehicles; the checkpoints every few kilometers; the diversion of trucks carrying produce to long and badly paved roads; the waiting in line for hours and days at Israeli crossings; the closing of the Gaza crossing for months, thereby making it impossible for Gazans to market agricultural produce; the discouraging bureaucracy required at Civil Administration bases to obtain a pass to reach one's own lands - or to not obtain it at all.

All these forms of assault by the establishment, which appear to be more and more deliberate, explain why more and more Palestinian agricultural lands appear as if they have been abandoned, with unplowed soil and trees with rotten fruit. They also explain why more Israeli than Palestinian produce can be seen in Palestinian marketplaces, and why so very many farmers need food parcels.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Birthright revival
Some 11,000 Jewish students are to arrive this winter as part of Taglit - Birthright Israel.
Assassin's privileges
The murderer is allowed to enter the conjugal visit room in Ayalon Prison with his beloved.
  1.   Amira you have OCD 10:18  |  Joel Meyers 11/10/06
  2.   Palestinians chose war, not peace. 10:39  |  Bennie 11/10/06
  3.   Harassment Leads to Abandon Then Confiscation 10:51  |  Karim 11/10/06
  4.   LIBERATED TERRITORY not occuqied territory!!! 11:31  |  Richard the lion 11/10/06
  5.   And what about Jewish farmers who are attacked by Palestinians? 11:38  |  Matthias Roth 11/10/06
  6.   #1 | @Joel Meyers 11:40  |  Dan 11/10/06
  7.   Amira and the olives ... 11:41  |  Marlene 11/10/06
  8.   #2 would Palestinians get 12:06  |  cool 11/10/06
  9.   Richard is correct 12:11  |  Antonio 11/10/06
  10.   THE APARTHEID SYSTEM AND THE SETTLERS ... STINK 12:25  |  Messaoud 11/10/06
  11.   PAID RESPONSES STRIVE TO DE-LIGITIMIZE 12:34  |  nu 11/10/06
  12.   oh matthias Roth 12:49  |  Jean-Luc Ngarambe 11/10/06
  13.   its about the occupation, stupid! 12:52  |  freddy 11/10/06
  14.   Liberated land...but both peoples are incarcerated 13:04  |  meir gush etzion 11/10/06
  15.   #10 Messaoud: Palestinian apartheid 13:18  |  Bennie 11/10/06
  16.   Amira, you mean you want it like the Pals, 13:20  |  David Teich 11/10/06
  17.   HAARETZ: Pay a fine to the State of Israel for lies of A.Hass. 13:29  |  Vittorio 11/10/06
  18.   Your own ... 13:50  |  Marco 11/10/06
  19.   Simple solutions 14:02  |  Alicia 11/10/06
  20.   # 15 - one state solution ? 14:20  |  alex 11/10/06
  21.   Same people who harrass Pales. farmers, worries about N Kor 14:52  |  omolll 11/10/06
  22.   WHAT DOES THIS CRUELTY PROVE? 15:06  |  Marilyn 11/10/06
  23.   #14 exactly! good post.... 15:08  |  T A Sheppard 11/10/06
  24.   As a Jew, I am ashamed by such harsh treatment. 15:58  |  Le Maudit Anglais 11/10/06
  25.   PRAISE HAAS AND SUCH JEWS 16:01  |  ISHMAEL ISHMAEL 11/10/06
  26.   Amira, It is as you say..... 16:19  |  Dutch 11/10/06
  27.   Amira, This is disgraceful and it is just as you say.......... 16:25  |  Dutch 11/10/06
  28.   The separation fence 16:37  |  KUTW 11/10/06
  29.   3.Karim: Harassment 16:40  |  KUTW 11/10/06
  30.   Marilyn in Australia 16:40  |  redsmith 11/10/06
  31.   #24. `Dutch`-Doris Cadigan from Mass. USA. Take your medication 16:46  |  Vittorio 11/10/06
  32.   Bennie#15..... THE PALESTINIANS ARE ON THEIR LAND 16:46  |  Messaoud. 11/10/06
  33.   Israeli apartheid? 16:48  |  Anne 11/10/06
  34.   5.What about pal aggressions 16:48  |  KUTW 11/10/06
  35.   Reality 16:49  |  Shimon 11/10/06
  36.   Geneva convention legal basis is not relevant here 17:06  |  Jabadini 11/10/06
  37.   Shimon - keep your `reality` to yourself 17:08  |  Josh Goldman 11/10/06
  38.   Myth: Palestine was always a country 17:15  |  Bruriah Sarah 11/10/06
  39.   Myth: Settlements are an Obstacle to Peace 17:18  |  Bruriah Sarah 11/10/06
  40.   Shimon#35... WHY FORGOT THE REALITY OF THE OCCUPATION!? 17:18  |  Messaoud 11/10/06
  41.   13. freddy: its about jihad, stupid! 17:23  |  KUTW 11/10/06
  42.   #36 - Geneva Conventions do not Apply to Israel 17:24  |  Bruriah Sarah 11/10/06
  43.   IDF protection 17:28  |  KUTW 11/10/06
  44.   Forbidden to settlers, not the state 17:50  |  Nurradin 11/10/06
  45.   22.Marilyn: Have you ever heard...? 17:50  |  KUTW 11/10/06
  46.   Dutch:don?t you mind terrorists murdering Israelis? 17:54  |  Dutch Conscience 11/10/06
  47.   Israeli high court judges are more rational than the State 17:59  |  Bedouin 11/10/06
  48.   Amira and the olives 18:01  |  bobby goodman 11/10/06
  49.   Zionists protecting arab farmers 18:07  |  peter 11/10/06
  50.   amira and the olives 18:11  |  bobby goodman 11/10/06
  51.   # 1 Joel Meyers. AMIRA`S REPETITIONS. I WILL PROPOSE A SOLUTION.. 18:13  |  Kathy 11/10/06
  52.   Arab apartheid for Anne 18:20  |  peter 11/10/06
  53.   Jabadini is wrong again 18:22  |  Marilyn 11/10/06
  54.   # 16 David Teich. AMIRA WANTS JEWS DEAD AND GONE!!! 18:27  |  Kathy 11/10/06
  55.   Amira, thanks once again 18:28  |  JG 11/10/06
  56.   Marilyn is wrong again 18:48  |  peter 11/10/06
  57.   # 24 Le Maudit Anglais. GOSH,WE LEARN SOMETHING EVERY DAY... 18:55  |  Kathy 11/10/06
  58.   54: No Kathy, understand jihad 19:00  |  David Teich 11/10/06
  59.   And What Will the Excuses Be For This? 19:21  |  Yaakov Sullivan 11/10/06
  60.   But Yaakov 20:00  |  Danite 11/10/06
  61.   to David teich : don`t make of Hass another anna Politkovskaîa ! 20:19  |  wahbi 11/10/06
  62.   Kathy,Amira only raises the issue of harasment 20:19  |  Le Maudit Anglais 11/10/06
  63.   Josh Goldman - So we started the intifada then 20:36  |  Jabadini 11/10/06
  64.   Josh Goldman - So we started the intifada then 20:39  |  Jabadini 11/10/06
  65.   Amira, It`s occupation, what u think they`ll do 20:45  |  asking 2 b free 11/10/06
  66.   Blessed are the peacemakers 20:49  |  Pssd Off American 11/10/06
  67.   Danite also remember that the elections...#60 20:50  |  Yaakov Sullivan 11/10/06
  68.   Dont Be Radical 20:52  |  Elliott Kessler 11/10/06
  69.   Marilyn - Some insight for you 21:09  |  Jabadin 11/10/06
  70.   Joel Myers in regards to Amira 21:46  |  Omar 11/10/06
  71.   GODS CHOSEN...??? 21:49  |  mike katz 11/10/06
  72.   lmao Richard the BEAST 21:49  |  Omar 11/10/06
  73.   Danite, you are incoherent. 21:57  |  Ibrahim 11/10/06
  74.   Two out of three 22:32  |  Kevin 11/10/06
  75.   # 62 Le Maudit Anglais. YES INDEED READ AMIRA`S ARTICLE.. 22:43  |  Kathy 11/10/06
  76.   71.mike katz. I know who are demonic driven 22:46  |  KUTW 11/10/06
  77.   Amira Hass is a Human 22:46  |  Man 11/10/06
  78.   73. Ibrahim re Danite 22:52  |  KUTW 11/10/06
  79.   71: What does the Chosen People mean? 22:59  |  Bruriah Sarah 11/10/06
  80.   Under your watchful eye, Amira 23:04  |  TonyL 11/10/06
  81.   And what about Jewish farmers who are attacked by Palestinians? 23:20  |  wibism 11/10/06
  82.   Chosen people? 23:25  |  wibism 11/10/06
  83.   Not Necessarily `Philanthropic Imperialism` 23:38  |  Malleck Amode 11/10/06
  84.   # 80 TonyL WELCOME BACK,AND WELL SAID.. 23:40  |  Kathy 11/10/06
  85.   Our disgrace 00:00  |  sh 12/10/06
  86.   Cheering the killers of Jews 00:00  |  * BEN JABO 12/10/06
  87.   # 64 Jabadini. re:Josh Goldman. HE IS NOT HERE IS HE?? 00:05  |  Kathy 12/10/06
  88.   harassing farmers... 00:19  |  christoph 12/10/06
  89.   Amira,may GOD bless you for your words of truth 00:37  |  Clickright 12/10/06
  90.   Josh 37 Reality vs Fantasy 00:39  |  Shimon 12/10/06
  91.   Kathy #84 00:45  |  TonyL 12/10/06
  92.   Messaoud 40 00:47  |  Shimon 12/10/06
  93.   81, they should go home 01:00  |  Fritz 12/10/06
  94.   `reality` versus opinion 01:08  |  Josh Goldman 12/10/06
  95.   can palestinians and jews be friends? 01:38  |  maria 12/10/06
  96.   Wrong Yaakov 02:00  |  Hamas 12/10/06
  97.   No International Politics Please. 02:16  |  Akram Zekaria 12/10/06
  98.   Josh 94 02:31  |  shimon 12/10/06
  99.   Amira is the Conscience of Israel 02:54  |  Timothy 12/10/06
  100.   Share this article with others. 03:28  |  Timothy 12/10/06
  101.   What a state and it calls herself "democratic" 04:24  |  Petteri 12/10/06
  102.   #46, Dutch Conscience 04:45  |  Dutch 12/10/06
  103.   jews are chosen people---GOD IS ALL-KNOWING. 05:28  |  maria 12/10/06
  104.   you`re chosen too..... 05:35  |  maria 12/10/06
  105.   Amira Hass 05:57  |  Maureen Ann 12/10/06
  106.   Kathy 07:03  |  Walid 12/10/06
  107.   Amira 07:54  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 12/10/06
  108.   Kathy - Right or Wrong 08:02  |  Gordon 12/10/06
  109.   101: Dutch conscience. Now there`s an oxymoron 08:09  |  David Teich 12/10/06
  110.   Timothy very well said # 99 - 100 08:30  |  Clickright 12/10/06
  111.   Amira Hass 08:44  |  A. Bennett 12/10/06
  112.   to Sarah: the choosen people for what ? that is the questi 09:12  |  wahbi 12/10/06
  113.   Security of Israelis 09:50  |  Michael II 12/10/06
  114.   shimon 09:52  |  Josh Goldman 12/10/06
  115.   maria#140..... THE CHOSEN PEOPLE OF GOD CAN COMMIT CRIMES? 11:43  |  Messaoud 12/10/06
  116.   #89 - The Fence 12:12  |  * BEN JABO 12/10/06
  117.   #115 messaoud....these things you mentioned. 14:59  |  maria 12/10/06
  118.   #117.....geez 19:46  |  Rudeboy 12/10/06
  119.   Perspective 23:18  |  Efox 12/10/06
  120.   Josh 114 23:33  |  Shimon 12/10/06
  121.   Forbidden to settlers 00:30  |  Michael Katz 14/10/06
  122.   amira haas? liberal? 04:45  |  george 25/10/06
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: Smile when you hear Death to Israel
Responses: 160
Shmuel Rosner: Iran - What Americans want, what U.S. Jews want
Responses: 55
Rabin killer Yigal Amir holds conjugal visit with wife
Responses: 49
Settlements grow on Arab land, despite vow to U.S.
Responses: 251
Editorial: Lieberman is a strategic threat
Responses: 79
'IAF wiped out 59 Iranian missile launchers in 34 min.'
Responses: 208


More Headlines
03:34 Labor central c'tee to meet on Lieberman Sun.
04:49 Mashal invited to Cairo for talks on new Shalit plan, unity gov't
02:37 UN mediator in negotiations with Hezbollah so far unsuccessful
02:24 Halutz: Hundreds of arms-smuggling tunnels being dug in Gaza
01:01 AG orders probe into allegations of Olmert wrongdoing in Leumi deal
00:37 PA official: Kidnappers free Spanish photographer after several hours
04:06 First playground for the senses to be inaugurated Wednesday
04:09 Holes in Dead Sea shores endanger Route 90
04:13 Absorption Ministry: Without draft, more Israelis abroad would return
22:18 Report: U.S.-backed draft would ban missile and nuclear sales to Iran
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
One year MBA in Israel
Taught entirely in English
SINGLES ECARDS
Say hello to Jewish singles with E-cards. Send FREE at JDate
Discover LOVE
See why JLove.com is the fastest growing Jewish relationship site committed to preserving Jewish values
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
ISRAEL-SHOPS ONLINE STORE
Gifts from Israel + FREE ISRAELI FLAG ON EVERY PURCHASE OVER $50
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved