Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., October 21, 2006 Tishrei 29, 5767 | | Israel Time: 04:40 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Say yes to Syria
By Nehemiah Shtrasler

When you are a new and inexperienced candidate for prime minister, the plans that you present to the public soar. Out of excessive enthusiasm you promise to solve the problem of poverty, achieve quiet on the borders and make Israel into a country "where it is fun to live."

But then you attain the office and discover that the "reality imp" is dancing on your desk. He makes it clear to you that despite your victory in the elections, your government is shaky, and it is not certain that you will even arrive safely at the next session of the Knesset. He laughs in your face when he encounters your far-reaching diplomatic plans and your proposals for containing poverty.

One morning the reality imp whispers in your ear: If you want to live, throw aside all your revolutionary plans and concentrate on only one thing: your political survival. And if you ask him, 'Is it for this that I have arrived at this important position?' he will reply: Look what happened to Yitzhak Rabin and Ehud Barak, who wanted to solve fundamental problems. This is exactly what is happening now to Prime Minister Ehud Olmert.

Advertisement

He has abandoned all his big plans and he has no agenda, apart from his political survival. To shore up his shaky government he is looking for an ally in the shape of Yisrael Beiteinu MK Avigdor Lieberman, a step that will give him the dose of oxygen needed for his continued existence. The price is clear: a freeze on diplomatic moves.

The convergence plan - the sole reason for his victory in the in the elections - has been defined by Olmert as irrelevant. The evacuation of the illegal outposts has been postponed indefinitely. And, if this were not enough, he became a staunch peace refuser when he rejected entirely all of Syrian President Bashar Assad's attempts to open negotiations on peace in return for the Golan Heights.

Immediately after the Six-Day War, then prime minister Levi Eshkol said that the territories were only a deposit that we would be prepared to return in exchange for full peace, because peace is the only guarantee of security. But within a few weeks we "sobered up" and fell in love with the territories.

At one time we saw United Nations Security Council Resolution 242 (territories in return for peace) as a major achievement. Today Assad is adopting the resolution, and Olmert is not only rejecting it, but he is also publicly scorning it and saying with typical Olmertian arrogance: "The Golan Heights will remain in our hands for all eternity." What alternative is he leaving Assad?

Every prime minister until now understood that a peace agreement with Syria is a strategic asset. Therefore Rabin, Barak and Benjamin Netanyahu conducted secret and indirect negotiations with the Syrian president - which did not ripen into an agreement. When Barak presented his plan for a withdrawal from the Golan in return for peace to the top echelon of the Israel Defense Forces, Gabi Ashkenazi, who was GOC Northern Command at that time and is now the director general of the Defense Ministry, said that he would help him market the plan to the public.

Israel's most dangerous enemy is Iran, which aspires to achieve nuclear capability. Syria has an alliance with Iran. Cutting it off is a definite Israeli interest. Let us not forget that Syria is ruled by a secular (Alawite) regime that is fighting the Muslim Brotherhood. From our perspective, an Islamic fundamentalist takeover of the Arab world is a possibility that is far worse than the entire Assad dynasty.

Olmert is accusing Syria of supporting Palestinian terror and providing weapons to Hezbollah. The accusations are correct, but it is clear that one of the achievements of negotiations with Syria has to be a total cessation of support for terror.

If we do nothing, the situation will only degenerate. One day Assad could conclude that force is the only thing that Israel understands and the "quiet" Golan is liable to become a new terror arena. Syria has rockets that are targeted on every corner of Israel, including Dimona. The nuclear test that has just been made by North Korea stirs the imagination to even scarier scenarios. Therefore, Olmert is not entitled to listen to the reality imp's advice and concentrate only on his own political survival. He must at least respond to the Syrian challenge. This is crucial for us.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Daring to be subversive
Turkish writers like Orhan Pamuk risk prison or exile to have their political say.
Victims of success
The better Jews fared, the more they fueled the hatred that led to the Holocaust.
  1.   The Obvious for Everybody is Not So for Olmert 09:32  |  Karim 10/10/06
  2.   Is Syria ready for peace? 09:53  |  Daniel Leopold 10/10/06
  3.   A Referendum 09:54  |  An Arab Neighbor 10/10/06
  4.   Peace for Land 09:57  |  FOX 10/10/06
  5.   Peace with Lebanon and Syria 10:00  |  sandra chitayat 10/10/06
  6.   Strasler,whom arte you trying to con?Arabs don`t want land for pe 10:05  |  Absolute Sweden 10/10/06
  7.   Israel`s refusal 10:17  |  Andrew Watson 10/10/06
  8.   A.WATSON "Quiet borders" but war by Syria`s proxies 10:37  |  PETER SM 10/10/06
  9.   Israel the stumbling block to peace 10:52  |  Clickfool 10/10/06
  10.   Leftwing stupidity?! 10:56  |  Matthias Roth 10/10/06
  11.   SYRIA is ready to talk peace.Their peace conditions are not on. 10:59  |  PETER SM 10/10/06
  12.   say no to syria 11:03  |  joe 10/10/06
  13.   golan heights 11:15  |  izaak 10/10/06
  14.   Who cares for Syria whoever attacks us should be nuked!!!! 11:30  |  arthur 10/10/06
  15.   formalize relations, offer an economic union 11:35  |  freddy 10/10/06
  16.   No Peace at the top of the hill is better than P. at the bottom 11:35  |  Te M 10/10/06
  17.   to 14 11:57  |  European 10/10/06
  18.   Watson said ..."Those opposing peace with Syria.. 12:01  |  T M 10/10/06
  19.   To # 8 12:07  |  Andrew Watson 10/10/06
  20.   To # 18 12:22  |  Andrew Watson 10/10/06
  21.   A.WATSON.in 1967 Israel had to fend off Egypt first. 12:43  |  PETER SM 10/10/06
  22.   About ClickFOOL and the real stumbling block for peace 12:55  |  Jonathan S 10/10/06
  23.   About Shtrasler and Alice in Wonderland 13:12  |  Jonathan S 10/10/06
  24.   Golan vs Alexandretta (Hatay) 14:19  |  Avi Yerushalmi 10/10/06
  25.   Before rushing to deal with Syria, let us examine a few historic 14:20  |  Shlomzion 10/10/06
  26.   Syria and Assad 14:37  |  LandForPeace 10/10/06
  27.   Political Survival at Any Price 14:44  |  Yaakov Sullivan 10/10/06
  28.   The Naiive Versus the Hysterical- Part 1 14:52  |  LandForPeace 10/10/06
  29.   The Naiive Versus the Hysterical- Part 2 15:00  |  LandForPeace 10/10/06
  30.   The America-syndrome? 15:15  |  Alicia 10/10/06
  31.   An Arab Neighbor #3 15:29  |  Gee 10/10/06
  32.   Land for peace? 15:30  |  Walter 10/10/06
  33.   to FOX #4 15:38  |  ka 10/10/06
  34.   Karim-# 1-What`s seems so obvious to you is just make believe. 15:40  |  Daniel Leopold 10/10/06
  35.   #27 Yaakov 15:44  |  John of Jordan 10/10/06
  36.   Must Assad get on his knees before Israel will talk? 15:45  |  Le Maudit Anglais 10/10/06
  37.   WHAT FOOLS! 15:50  |  Brant 10/10/06
  38.   Yes To What? 15:56  |  Yosemite Sam 10/10/06
  39.   27 - Settlements Are Legal 16:10  |  Bruriah Sarah 10/10/06
  40.   Syria is not a peace partner 16:16  |  Bruriah Sarah 10/10/06
  41.   The Arabs don`t want peace 16:17  |  peter 10/10/06
  42.   Arthur 16:18  |  northern neighbor 10/10/06
  43.   LandForPeace, practise what you preach 16:26  |  Ibrahim 10/10/06
  44.   Who needs peace? 16:29  |  peter 10/10/06
  45.   an attempted wedge between US and Israel? 16:29  |  nehemia 10/10/06
  46.   Bon Jour, Peter 16:54  |  Ibrahim 10/10/06
  47.   Give back Golan, accept Islam and there will be peace 16:57  |  Jean 10/10/06
  48.   Shtrasler - Either Intellectually Dishonest or Delusional 17:06  |  Tod Zuckerman 10/10/06
  49.   Golan and Alsace -Loraine 17:08  |  Avi Yerushalmi 10/10/06
  50.   Search for peace 17:15  |  david 10/10/06
  51.   le maudit anglais, 36, 17:16  |  Nadav 10/10/06
  52.   #25 Shlomziom.1948-67 17:24  |  Peter Dale 10/10/06
  53.   I wish to ask a naive question. Perhaps someone out there can 17:30  |  Shlomzion 10/10/06
  54.   Olmert vs. Bush 17:35  |  Ben Gurion 10/10/06
  55.   #39 Bruniah.Journo opinions vs.International Law 17:36  |  Peter Dale 10/10/06
  56.   S. Lebanon?s largest town, Sidon, is taken over as Russian-Syria 17:38  |  raul 10/10/06
  57.   North Korea, blow jobs & emails 17:46  |  FOX 10/10/06
  58.   Le maudit or whatever the Arab equivalent is 17:54  |  Gabe1 10/10/06
  59.   Olmert vs. Bush, II 18:01  |  Ben Gurion 10/10/06
  60.   Peter Dale 18:01  |  Shlomzion 10/10/06
  61.   Say yes to Syria 18:03  |  Albert 10/10/06
  62.   #Shlomzion 53 An assist showing you`re wrong 18:04  |  Peter Dale 10/10/06
  63.   #55 - Peter Dale - 4th Geneva Convention 18:21  |  Bruriah Sarah 10/10/06
  64.   Peter Dale on International Law 18:33  |  peter 10/10/06
  65.   TO: #53 Shlomzion 18:43  |  Finnish example 10/10/06
  66.   dont fall into the Arafat wants peace trap 18:50  |  zionist forever 10/10/06
  67.   FOX you`re some kind of cookie 18:51  |  peter 10/10/06
  68.   Pax per Potens 18:54  |  Charles 10/10/06
  69.   Peter Dale 18:55  |  Shlomzion 10/10/06
  70.   #Shlomzion 60 18:56  |  Peter Dale 10/10/06
  71.   About Peter Dale and the mirage of Syrian victories 18:59  |  Jonathan S 10/10/06
  72.   Peter Dale #62 18:59  |  Gee 10/10/06
  73.   Albert of Toronto 19:04  |  Peter Dale 10/10/06
  74.   Bruriah Sarah, UN and affiliated International Organizations 19:13  |  Shlomzion 10/10/06
  75.   #63 Bruniah. You cut and paste endorses what I said 19:24  |  Peter Dale 10/10/06
  76.   Oh, Come on! 19:36  |  Tony Anthony 10/10/06
  77.   Syria is the key 19:44  |  Ben Gurion 10/10/06
  78.   Perpetual Hostility Policy 19:53  |  chet 10/10/06
  79.   #69 19:57  |  Peter Dale 10/10/06
  80.   #71 Jonathan S 20:00  |  Peter Dale 10/10/06
  81.   Benny G. and the cow jumped over the moon 20:26  |  FOX 10/10/06
  82.   Peter Dale 20:28  |  Walter 10/10/06
  83.   Ibrahim 20:48  |  Calhoun 10/10/06
  84.   no agenda... 20:51  |  imp 10/10/06
  85.   Peter Dale still at odds with Syrian victories 21:02  |  Jonathan S 10/10/06
  86.   Calhoun #83 21:06  |  Gee 10/10/06
  87.   #82 Walter 21:10  |  Peter Dale 10/10/06
  88.   #81 FOX from the fairytales 21:12  |  Ben Gurion 10/10/06
  89.   YES, WE WANT LAND FOR PEACE. 21:12  |  JEWS EVERYWHERE 10/10/06
  90.   TERRORISTS CANT GIVE PEACE, THEY DONT HAVE IT 21:14  |  THINKING JEW 10/10/06
  91.   Clickfool 21:21  |  P Plyman 10/10/06
  92.   Assad invited to Jerusalem 21:31  |  Jonathan S 10/10/06
  93.   Ben Gurion #77 21:35  |  zionist forever 10/10/06
  94.   ben gurion 22:07  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 10/10/06
  95.   european 22:13  |  larry k 10/10/06
  96.   #86 Gee 22:15  |  Peter Dale 10/10/06
  97.   ibrahim 22:21  |  bev 10/10/06
  98.   #85 Jonathan 22:28  |  Peter Dale 10/10/06
  99.   Can There Be Peace With State Sponsor of Terrorism? 22:29  |  Jane 10/10/06
  100.   #Shlomzion69 22:35  |  Peter Dale 10/10/06
  101.   Peter Dale #96 22:44  |  Gee 10/10/06
  102.   #99 Jane 22:45  |  Peter Dale 10/10/06
  103.   Calhoun, you need to get caught up. 22:59  |  Ibrahim 10/10/06
  104.   bev from Toronto 23:02  |  Ibrahim 10/10/06
  105.   David From Royal Oak Michigan 23:04  |  Ibrahim 10/10/06
  106.   To Peter Dale about double standards 23:33  |  Jonathan S 10/10/06
  107.   Ibrahim #103 23:38  |  Gee 10/10/06
  108.   Chet...missing something here 00:13  |  T M 11/10/06
  109.   Our "Friends"Pakistan and Saudi Arabia 00:18  |  Jane 11/10/06
  110.   Ibrahim, you`re better and smarter than that 00:27  |  peter 11/10/06
  111.   Make peace with Syria 00:45  |  Altalena 11/10/06
  112.   We don`t need Syria. 00:48  |  Antonio Arab-hater 11/10/06
  113.   to clickfool 00:49  |  citizen zero 11/10/06
  114.   Ben Gurion - Peace - Shalom, Saalam 00:51  |  Mark Lincoln 11/10/06
  115.   to mathias roth 00:52  |  citizen zero 11/10/06
  116.   Another Example Ben Gurion 00:55  |  Mark Lincoln 11/10/06
  117.   Can There Be Peace With State Sponsor of Terrorism? 00:58  |  Mark Lincoln 11/10/06
  118.   Can There Be Peace With State Sponsor of Terrorism? 00:58  |  Mark Lincoln 11/10/06
  119.   Can There Be Peace With State Sponsor of Terrorism? 00:58  |  Mark Lincoln 11/10/06
  120.   Peter Dale - and Mussharaf laughs 01:00  |  Mark Lincoln 11/10/06
  121.   #99 Peace with state sponsor of terrorism? 01:02  |  Johnboy 11/10/06
  122.   #103 and land for peace 01:02  |  JO JO 11/10/06
  123.   Ibrahim-#103-About Jordan and WB 01:40  |  Daniel Leopold 11/10/06
  124.   #93 Zionist "forever" (Fat chance without peace) 01:53  |  Ben Gurion 11/10/06
  125.   Brant 01:59  |  John 11/10/06
  126.   Daniel Leopold 02:13  |  Ibrahim 11/10/06
  127.   Reality and its discontents (Cipora #94) 02:22  |  Ben Gurion 11/10/06
  128.   Comedy and tragedy of the anti-peace people (Mark Lincoln #109) 02:28  |  Ben Gurion 11/10/06
  129.   # 70 Peter Dale 02:32  |  ChanahS 11/10/06
  130.   Peter Dale # 82 02:39  |  ChanahS 11/10/06
  131.   John to Brant 02:49  |  ChanahS 11/10/06
  132.   #120, ben gurion 02:50  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 11/10/06
  133.   There are good people and bad people 02:54  |  Alan 11/10/06
  134.   #123, ben gurion 02:54  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 11/10/06
  135.   Say yes to Syria, say no to Syria 03:01  |  Sam 11/10/06
  136.   #120-John and pre-emptive strikes 03:24  |  peter 11/10/06
  137.   FOR JOHN #120 03:32  |  Brant 11/10/06
  138.   Ibrahim-#121 03:35  |  Daniel Leopold 11/10/06
  139.   DonG and Mark Panza ride again 03:40  |  peter 11/10/06
  140.   The day Syria will sign peace agreement w/Israel in white house.. 03:42  |  A 11/10/06
  141.   Not analogous 03:59  |  John Onewife 11/10/06
  142.   to Shlomzion #25 - part 1 04:10  |  zeev 11/10/06
  143.   Syria may be too honorable to make a deal with Israel 04:25  |  Timothy 11/10/06
  144.   to Shlomzion #25 - part 2 04:34  |  zeev 11/10/06
  145.   Talk To Syria 04:42  |  SLS 11/10/06
  146.   A fantasizer in the real world (Peter #135) 04:55  |  Ben Gurion 11/10/06
  147.   Oh my (Cipora #128) 05:00  |  Ben Gurion 11/10/06
  148.   #141, ben gurion 05:19  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 11/10/06
  149.   DonG tilting at windmills 05:47  |  peter 11/10/06
  150.   Talks with Syria can be positive if...... 06:10  |  ATLAS 11/10/06
  151.   a stone throw away from Damascus, not Tehran 06:21  |  stuck in neutral 11/10/06
  152.   #138, A 07:14  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 11/10/06
  153.   Say yes to Syria 08:58  |  Ibrahim 11/10/06
  154.   deposit,,love,timing greatness 09:39  |  simple 11/10/06
  155.   #138 Daniel 10:05  |  Itsik 11/10/06
  156.   Watson What is your aim ? 10:17  |  Aby 11/10/06
  157.   on zionist forever #93 10:26  |  zeev 11/10/06
  158.   #106 Jonathan S 10:28  |  Peter Dale 11/10/06
  159.   #109 Jane 10:36  |  Peter Dale 11/10/06
  160.   #129 Chanah 10:43  |  Peter Dale 11/10/06
  161.   #130 Chanah 10:47  |  Peter Dale 11/10/06
  162.   A former Israeli ambassador speaks his mind 12:58  |  zeev 11/10/06
  163.   yes to syria 20:34  |  Damascus gate 11/10/06
  164.   To Peter Dale a falsifier of history 21:48  |  Jonathan S 11/10/06
  165.   PEACE AT LAST !!! 18:22  |  D.SHAMI 12/10/06
  166.   Returned of seized land to Arabs 03:43  |  madwee 13/10/06
  167.   Say Yes to Syria 15:09  |  Mr. Shlomo Sokol 13/10/06
  168.   Losing my Muslim faith 01:17  |  Adam(formerly Hafas) 21/10/06
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: Targeting Muslims - the new Inquisition
Responses: 147
Shmuel Rosner on Jimmy Carter's 'apartheid' analogy
Responses: 82
Iranian President says Israel is 'disappearing'
Responses: 123
Peace Now: Most outposts partly built on Palestinian land
Responses: 130
Israel's UN envoy: Iran bribed Hamas to block Shalit's release
Responses: 50


More Headlines
00:34 Fatah: We had no role in attack on Haniyeh convoy
03:50 One person hurt, several treated for shock as Qassam hits Sderot
23:10 France to suspend push for UN sanctions if Iran cooperates
04:05 France calls IAF overflights in Lebanon 'extremely dangerous'
23:32 Hezbollah marks Al-Quds Day in relatively subdued fashion
16:54 Labor and Meretz may merge to form 'center-left' bloc
00:28 New Yorker to serve as Poland's first progressive rabbi since Holocaust
19:10 Kremlin tries to explain away Putin's Katsav rape joke
10:13 Turkish soldiers arrive in Beirut to join UN peacekeeping force
18:42 Peretz objects to conjugal visits for Rabin's assassin Amir
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
One year MBA in Israel
Taught entirely in English
SINGLES ECARDS
Say hello to Jewish singles with E-cards. Send FREE at JDate
Discover LOVE
See why JLove.com is the fastest growing Jewish relationship site committed to preserving Jewish values
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
ISRAEL-SHOPS ONLINE STORE
Gifts from Israel + FREE ISRAELI FLAG ON EVERY PURCHASE OVER $50
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved