Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., October 22, 2006 Tishrei 30, 5767 | | Israel Time: 10:59 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Olmert's true colors
By Tom Segev

He embroiled Israel in a superfluous and failed war, and this week threatened to join up with the most Kahanist politician active in Israel since the death of Rehavam Ze'evi. What is happening to us, to our Ehud Olmert? Nothing. Olmert is coming back to himself.

A year and a half ago, it seemed that he stood behind Ariel Sharon's decision to dismantle the settlements in the Gaza Strip. Olmert grew up, they said then; he realized that the territories that Israel captured in the Six-Day War have caused it nothing but damage, and that the continued occupation endangers Israel's future as a Jewish and democratic state. It was not unreasonable; after all, people really do grow up. A lot of good people embraced and welcomed him.

Olmert seemed at the time like a man who could be prime minister. Precisely because he's a professional politician in a business suit, not one of the giants of the founding generation, it appeared that he would be able to manage the conflict with the Palestinians. He promised to dismantle most of the settlements in the West Bank. Many people believed that it was the most daring and promising peace plan since the Six-Day War.

Advertisement

Less than six months after he became prime minister, it has become clear that Olmert was not new, but just a political mirage. Ultimately, Olmert is Olmert is Olmert. Someone will have to explain some time how it was that so many Israelis got caught up in the belief that Olmert offers a new hope. The interim answer is that many Israelis apparently needed the man he pretended to be, and primarily the promise he made: if not an agreement, then at least a unilateral withdrawal to the fence. So much naivete and hypocrisy and self-deception went into this belief, so little readiness and ability to recognize the truth: There is no unilateral agreement.

What has happened since then places the "new Olmert" somewhere alongside the forgotten image of the late Yigael Yadin, perhaps the father of all political disappointments. Yadin taught the public an important lesson, but he, too, has been forgotten for now. "Why didn't you take an interest in knowing who the real Yadin is before you elected me?" he once asked in an interview with Haaretz.

The real Olmert disappeared from sight for only a limited time, but is now returning and being revealed as the person he was since going into politics some 40 years ago. He prefers land to peace, because he doesn't believe in peace with either the Palestinians or the Syrians. He is completely closed off to the terrible humanitarian disaster underway in Gaza, and the horrors of the occupation in the West Bank are continuing as before. There is no basis for expecting Olmert to dismantle the settlements in the West Bank; the more he returns to himself, the more dubious it is that he ever planned to dismantle them. All the signs indicate that he has no intention of dismantling even those settlements classified as illegal outposts.

Olmert is not the first prime minister to miss a chance to make peace with Syria, in exchange for the Golan Heights, but Bashar Assad appears to be the first Syrian president since 1949 to be practically begging for peace. Olmert could have gone down in history as a Menachem Begin, who gave Sinai back to Egypt. Instead, he is reacting to Syria's offers of peace with contempt, loathing and threats: As long as he is prime minister, Israel will not give up the Golan Heights, he declared, and for a moment, it was possible to think that the results of the war in Lebanon assured a glorious victory over Syria. This is the familiar Olmert, the real one.

And the real Olmert is also the man now making nice to Avigdor Lieberman. Lieberman is talking about changing the government, about an inquiry committee, about civil unions; these are respectable issues. But Lieberman is also suggesting that several communities populated by Arabs be left out of the borders of the state, to leave the Jews a "solid majority." He suggests giving up Wadi Ara as part of an agreement to swap land with the Palestinians. Such a deal would revoke the Israeli citizenship of hundreds of thousands of Arabs and force them to become citizens of Palestine. It's taken for granted that their agreement won't be sought. This platform places Lieberman alongside the worst of the extremist right-wing parties active in Europe today.

It is said that talk of Lieberman's joining the government is meant only to frighten the Labor Party and Shas. But what this move shows about the ethical aspect of Olmert's worldview should frighten every decent person. Yes, Lieberman has already served as transportation minister and Rehavam Ze'evi was also part of the government, and in general, who's looking for ethics in politics anyway? But even in politics, there are moments that require society to take a break from its cynicism and recall the basic principles of democracy and human rights. A decent person should not even think about bringing into the government a man who wants to remove from the state one out of every five citizens, just because they are not Jewish. The real Olmert sees in this man a desirable partner.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Home brew
Any beer-lover can transform from a passive consumer into an active brewer.
The meltdown
'How sad,' I hear my wife whispering next to the cage. 'He's depressed, that lion.'
  1.   Segev,Segev,analyse your own past analyses and stop fooling every 09:56  |  Absolute Sweden 10/10/06
  2.   To Mr. Tom Segev 10:01  |  Choni 10/10/06
  3.   Is making threats the same as diplomacy? 10:38  |  Natallie Durson 10/10/06
  4.   Assad begging for peace? 10:40  |  Shalom Freedman 10/10/06
  5.   Tom Segev: How ridiculous! 10:43  |  Neil 10/10/06
  6.   i dont agree with everything, but segev has some good points... 10:49  |  yonatan 10/10/06
  7.   Another humane, deeply knowledgeable, and truthful, Segev article 11:38  |  Jon Friedman 10/10/06
  8.   who can stop the slide to the far-right? 11:40  |  freddy 10/10/06
  9.   Israelis are loosing hope 13:32  |  Ernst 10/10/06
  10.   The right is wrong for me 13:59  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 10/10/06
  11.   And So Do Most Israelis 14:56  |  Yaakov Sullivan 10/10/06
  12.   Tom Segev is a fool 15:01  |  Gene 10/10/06
  13.   damn right Segev 15:04  |  Michael N 10/10/06
  14.   Mirage, mirage, mirage...wake up Tom. 15:13  |  bat yam 10/10/06
  15.   A Chameleon will stay … a Chameleon 15:23  |  Jonathan S 10/10/06
  16.   to Mr. Choni Davidowitz in Sunny Durban S.Africa 15:28  |  Ari ben Yisrael 10/10/06
  17.   About Assad 15:46  |  uncle moishy 10/10/06
  18.   tom segev is a clown 15:53  |  daniel deronda 10/10/06
  19.   Ahmadinejad is also begging for peace 15:54  |  Elvis Scudbubble 10/10/06
  20.   numerous lefties writing for haaretz 15:56  |  lord acton 10/10/06
  21.   jobs for the boys 16:00  |  isaac singer 10/10/06
  22.   Segev can`t have it both ways 16:19  |  Dani 10/10/06
  23.   Segev Wants an Appeaser PM - A Weakling is Not Sufficient 16:55  |  Tod Zuckerman 10/10/06
  24.   because of 5 million presidents 16:57  |  JPL 10/10/06
  25.   No Sullivan 17:00  |  Jasmine Murphy 10/10/06
  26.   Politics "at its best" a la Olmert. 17:19  |  H.H.M 10/10/06
  27.   Ms Murphy on the merits of meretz #25 17:20  |  Yaakov Sullivan 10/10/06
  28.   To Ari # 16 17:21  |  Choni 10/10/06
  29.   Lieberman is a leftist, NOT a Kahanist 17:24  |  Antonio, Arab hater 10/10/06
  30.   Olmert, Labor, and Lieberman 17:58  |  Ben Gurion 10/10/06
  31.   #29 Antonio, please return to Germany 18:01  |  Yaakov Sullivan 10/10/06
  32.   So much hate from the US Jews 18:23  |  Marilyn 10/10/06
  33.   More about peace 18:31  |  Marilyn 10/10/06
  34.   To Choni #28 19:26  |  Ari ben Yisrael 10/10/06
  35.   Marilyn #33 19:27  |  Antonio, Arab-hater 10/10/06
  36.   To Antonio, "Arab hater" in Haifa 19:37  |  David James Vickery 10/10/06
  37.   to Yaakov Sullivan #27 amongst others 19:39  |  Ari ben Yisrael 10/10/06
  38.   Antonio re: Marilyn 19:50  |  David James Vickery 10/10/06
  39.   Another thing Yaakov #27 19:57  |  Ari ben Yisrael 10/10/06
  40.   Is this animal antonio REALLY from Haifa 20:02  |  Ari ben Yisrael 10/10/06
  41.   Vikery #38 20:09  |  Antonio, Arab-hater 10/10/06
  42.   ari ben israel 20:13  |  michael 10/10/06
  43.   David James Vickery 20:15  |  Ari ben Yisrael 10/10/06
  44.   Ari ben Yisrael #39 on Respect and Popularity 20:29  |  Yaakov Sullivan 10/10/06
  45.   Olmert 20:38  |  Sivan 10/10/06
  46.   To Michael in Canda #42 20:42  |  Ari ben Yisrael 10/10/06
  47.   Sullivan#44 20:43  |  Antonio, Arab-hater 10/10/06
  48.   Sullivan #44 20:48  |  Ari ben Yisrael 10/10/06
  49.   Antonio, as I said, you would be more comfortable #47 21:01  |  Yaakov Sullivan 10/10/06
  50.   Mr. ben Yisrael and Tom Segev #48 21:08  |  Yaakov Sullivan 10/10/06
  51.   Ari ben Yisrael`s pay-off day 21:19  |  Stanley 10/10/06
  52.   ARI BEN iSRAEL #34 21:53  |  Gabe1 10/10/06
  53.   ari ben israel 21:58  |  michael 10/10/06
  54.   And it`s about time 22:00  |  David Teich 10/10/06
  55.   Redrawing the borders of Israel to insure Jewish Majority 22:31  |  Zeev 10/10/06
  56.   TOM SEGEV IS CORRECT: DIFFICULT TO GAUGE OLMERT NOW 22:32  |  Smadar 10/10/06
  57.   Olmert`s True colors 03:48  |  Dana 11/10/06
  58.   # 6 Yonatan, 06:49  |  Dutch 11/10/06
  59.   Mr. Sullivan 10:14  |  Jasmine Murphy 11/10/06
  60.   What a breath of fresh air 20:14  |  Case 11/10/06
  61.   Olmert`s true colors 01:44  |  Samuel Ramirez 12/10/06
  62.   IS THIS Segev For REAL? 01:48  |  Marcus 12/10/06
  63.   Time for suicidal pacifistst to wake up and to grow up 02:08  |  Dave Loev 12/10/06
  64.   Marilyn and Antonio 04:08  |  Allen 12/10/06
  65.   on #1 and Absolute Sweden`s true colors 20:15  |  zeev 12/10/06
  66.   after Zeev`s #55 - an imaginary dialog 21:38  |  zeev 12/10/06
  67.   Sivan 21:45  |  kimi 12/10/06
  68.   to Dave Loev #63 06:07  |  zeev 13/10/06
  69.   on S. Freedman #4 - some true feelings 11:59  |  zeev 13/10/06
  70.   people Wake UP! 21:29  |  Blaine 13/10/06
  71.   Jiber jabber 23:14  |  adam 13/10/06
  72.   on S. Freedman #4 - some true feelings. 05:05  |  zeev 14/10/06
  73.   to Dave Loev #63 05:07  |  zeev 14/10/06
  74.   on #1 and Absolute Sweden`s true colors 10:17  |  zeev 14/10/06
  75.   on Absolute Sweden #1 - a story of PMs 12:00  |  zeev 14/10/06
  76.   Please leave Gaza and West Bank as per UN resolution 02:22  |  Scott Wistaff 16/10/06
  77.   Syrian Assad Begging for Peace 19:53  |  Magen 16/10/06
  78.   About Assad 20:00  |  Hymee 16/10/06
  79.   Maureen and Australia 20:43  |  Larry 16/10/06
  80.   segev 23:24  |  david s. 16/10/06
  81.   To zeev #73: wake up and grow up 20:22  |  Dave Loev 18/10/06
  82.   to Dave Loev #81 12:32  |  zeev 19/10/06
  83.   To zeev #82 23:20  |  Dave Loev 19/10/06
  84.   to Dave Loev #83 - part 1 (2nd try) 10:25  |  zeev 22/10/06
  85.   to Dave Loev #83 - part 2 (2nd try) 10:36  |  zeev 22/10/06
 Today Online
Gideon Levy: The last days of Defense Minister Peretz
Responses: 17
Avirama Golan: Fear of Islam motivates EU politicians
Responses: 11