Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., October 16, 2006 Tishrei 24, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:49 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Hamas' fall is nearer
By Danny Rubinstein

The headline of Palestinian Authority Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh's speech before masses of his supporters in Gaza last weekend was: "Despair not! Hamas will lead the next government." But when the content of his speech is examined, in fact, the first hints of despair and distress emerge. An oriental fable explains why when iron strikes iron it makes a loud sound, but when iron strikes wood no sound is heard. The reason is that when iron strikes iron, the iron cries out in pain because its brother, the flesh of its flesh, is hitting it. Not so with wood, which is a stranger to iron.

In this context, portions of Haniyeh's speech were interesting. He complained about powerful forces in the world, headed by the United States, that have been wrestling his government since it was first established. Clearly hinting at PA Chairman Mahmoud Abbas (Abu Mazen) and his Fatah movement, Haniyeh added that to his great regret, there are those in the Palestinian camp who are abetting this. Haniyeh had a clearer cavil about his brothers, the Arab governments. Since his party's election victory, no Arab government has invited him to visit aside from the emirate of Qatar.

It appears that betrayal by Arab brethren is causing the most pain. A journalist from Gaza says he also heard Haniyeh complain that in the past few months, Abu Mazen has traveled to every corner of the world, but not once did he bother to take along anyone from the Hamas government. Although I have not found a report in the Palestinian newspapers about any such complaint, it doesn't matter. The picture that emerges from Haniyeh's complaints is that for the first time in the seven months since the government's formation, it appears he is a bit fearful.

Advertisement

In one Palestinian publication last week, Haniyeh was quoted as having said that the outlook is black. In the best case scenario, he said, Gaza and the PA will sink into anarchy, and in the worst case, a civil war will break out.

Haniyeh has reasons for a bad mood and bleak predictions. It appears that the siege imposed by Israel and countries throughout the world, as well as by Arab nations and Fatah - Hamas' Palestinian rivals - has been unable to change the party's ideological positions, which are based on an infrastructure of radical Islam. Public opinion surveys in the West Bank and Gaza have recently shown a weakening of Hamas, and the Palestinian public seems to be sending the organization a message: We elected you in order to lead reforms in the government and demonstrate pride and determination vis-a-vis Israel, but not to transform Palestine into a branch of Iran.

In this context, the tone of Abu Mazen's remarks, or threats, regarding Hamas now sounds clearer. The whole world supports Abu Mazen, and is suggesting to him that he disband the Hamas government, delegate the formation of the government to a neutral figure, and declare elections next year. Everyone is declaring that it is necessary to strengthen him.

It is doubtful that this will help. Hamas will not surrender easily. One way the leadership can react to the government's disbanding by Abu Mazen is to stop observing the truce, and embark on a campaign of terror attacks against Israel: it has the means and ability to do so. It is also possible that it is behind the video cassette distributed two days ago in the Gulf emirates on behalf of Al Qaida cells in Palestine, on which there are threats to execute any Palestinian commander who acts like an enemy of the people. In the cassette, the leadership takes responsibility for the murder of Palestinian officer Jad al Taya and four aides three weeks ago in Gaza as well as the assassination attempt four months ago on the head of intelligence in Gaza, General Tarq Abu Rajab.

It is hard to see a political Palestinian element that will face down Hamas and replace it in the government. The Fatah leadership is dismembered, and there is not an inkling of the start of reforms in the movement that were promised some time ago. The quarrels between the young guard and old timers have not ceased for a moment. The situation that will emerge from Hamas' fall could be even worse.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Delayed restitution
The WJC calls on Austria to reopen the reimbursement agreement on Jewish property.
Grass is always greener
As Ben-Gurion turns 120, he looks far better than any of our current leaders.
  1.   He is right 09:41  |  Khalid 09/10/06
  2.   The Palestinian mayhem 10:13  |  Andrew Watson 09/10/06
  3.   KHALID Nice to see your faith & loyalty to "no peace" 10:14  |  PETER SM 09/10/06
  4.   RE: He is right 10:20  |  Dan 09/10/06
  5.   Wake us up when something changes 10:24  |  sh 09/10/06
  6.   Why would any Jew, moreso Israeli Jew, lament? 10:32  |  Yaakov K. 09/10/06
  7.   HAMAS weaker?-it is not important. HAMAS-terrorist group. 10:39  |  Vittorio 09/10/06
  8.   What could be worse than `Hamas`? 10:43  |  Shalom Freedman 09/10/06
  9.   To # 3, # 4, and # 6 10:45  |  Andrew Watson 09/10/06
  10.   Changes are opportunities 10:47  |  Altalena 09/10/06
  11.   If Hamas` Fall is Near 10:47  |  surreal 09/10/06
  12.   Thank you for saying it again. 10:52  |  Akram Zekaria 09/10/06
  13.   Dan: I am for the 67 borders, too. 11:08  |  Khalid 09/10/06
  14.   THERE IS FAR FAR WORSE THAN HAMAS...!! 11:11  |  Messaoud 09/10/06
  15.   The question that I would ask Danny Rubinstein is: And what will 11:43  |  Shlomzion 09/10/06
  16.   Khalid, Israel did go to the 1967 boundaries in the Gaza Strip, 11:53  |  Shlomzion 09/10/06
  17.   13: Khalid and jihad 11:57  |  David Teich 09/10/06
  18.   Abbas NOW HAS THE MANDATE That He Needs/Needed! 12:06  |  Proud Pal Defender 09/10/06
  19.   Khalid, Hamas has elected honerly & will never fall down 12:19  |  Romario 09/10/06
  20.   David Teich: you talk like a Talmudic settler 12:38  |  Khalid 09/10/06
  21.   Palistinians should visit Calcutta to see bad..stop moaning 13:09  |  British academic 09/10/06
  22.   David Teich, Kill then negotiate, Is this Israel policy 13:17  |  Romario 09/10/06
  23.   #16 arrogant response 13:18  |  jamo 09/10/06
  24.   Khalid to David Teich 13:18  |  Shlomzion 09/10/06
  25.   Khaled # 20 13:36  |  ChanahS 09/10/06
  26.   # 20 And what 13:39  |  ChanahS 09/10/06
  27.   The PA governments see themselves as a war machine 13:50  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 09/10/06
  28.   David Teich is right 13:54  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 09/10/06
  29.   Khalid - If Israel offered 67 borders Hamas wins 13:57  |  Jabadini 09/10/06
  30.   Messaoud - Hamas 67 borders only first step 14:00  |  Jabadini 09/10/06
  31.   Jamo, Arrogant response 14:01  |  Shlomzion 09/10/06
  32.   Romario how can you even hint that Islam is the only religion in 14:09  |  Jabadini 09/10/06
  33.   Andrew Watson, Do you have any mental sanity 14:13  |  Aby 09/10/06
  34.   Margie in Tel Aviv the PA is very ambious 14:18  |  Gaza Boy 09/10/06
  35.   What a farce 14:20  |  Gee 09/10/06
  36.   Bad causes, bad actions, bad effects 14:32  |  B 09/10/06
  37.   British Zionist academic: where is the rectitude? 14:39  |  Khalid 09/10/06
  38.   Gaza Boy, I suggest that you refer to my post no. 31 to Jamo in 14:50  |  Shlomzion 09/10/06
  39.   B: you returned as thieves and murderers and liars 14:56  |  Khalid 09/10/06
  40.   To Khalid. 14:58  |  David Nigel Braham 09/10/06
  41.   To Margie in Tel Aviv 14:58  |  Mark B. 09/10/06
  42.   hamas`fall 15:01  |  michel wandel 09/10/06
  43.   # 37 Khaled 15:03  |  ChanahS 09/10/06
  44.   # 37 Khaled cont`d 15:06  |  ChanahS 09/10/06
  45.   No Peace, EVER 15:11  |  Jimbo 09/10/06
  46.   Khalid, "British Zionist academic......" (37) 15:13  |  Shlomzion 09/10/06
  47.   # 8 Pssst, You Are Not Getting It 15:20  |  Tony Anthony 09/10/06
  48.   What we Want 15:29  |  Ronnie Wolman 09/10/06
  49.   Khalid, by now I am nearly convinced that you are an Immam. 15:31  |  Shlomzion 09/10/06
  50.   David Nigle Barham: What a stupid question? 15:38  |  Khalid 09/10/06
  51.   Chana: your represent optimal terror 15:49  |  Khalid 09/10/06
  52.   Khalidi 15:51  |  B 09/10/06
  53.   Khalid, When your leaders set out to destroy the Hashemite 15:53  |  Shlomzion 09/10/06
  54.   BARAK WALKED OUT ON CAMP DAVID 15:56  |  Marilyn 09/10/06
  55.   # 50 Khaled 15:58  |  ChanahS 09/10/06
  56.   Chana: every serious historian knows your history is marginal 15:59  |  Khalid 09/10/06
  57.   # 39 Khaled Wrong again 16:04  |  ChanahS 09/10/06
  58.   The situation in Gaza... 16:04  |  sandra chitayat 09/10/06
  59.   Shlomzion: I know the Talmud very well 16:05  |  Khalid 09/10/06
  60.   ShlomoZion: where are you living? 16:12  |  Khalid 09/10/06
  61.   # 51 Khaled Thank You 16:18  |  ChanahS 09/10/06
  62.   Ronnie...maybe you speak on your own behalf 16:18  |  Khalid 09/10/06
  63.   If Hamas falls the things cannot get any worse 16:22  |  Sal 09/10/06
  64.   Khalid, this is probably going to be my last response to you, 16:24  |  Shlomzion 09/10/06
  65.   We want our corrupt puppets back 16:33  |  rr 09/10/06
  66.   Chanah....you are living an evil mythology 16:38  |  Khalid 09/10/06
  67.   20:Khalid, of course it`s difficult 16:39  |  David Teich 09/10/06
  68.   Khaled 16:43  |  Watcher. 09/10/06
  69.   53: Khalid & Shlomzion, don`t forget Black September 16:44  |  David Teich 09/10/06
  70.   Khalid 16:49  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 09/10/06
  71.   David: I probably know about Israel more than you do 16:51  |  Khalid 09/10/06
  72.   To Khalid 16:59  |  Bob 09/10/06
  73.   #62 Khalid Conspiracy number One Hundred and Forty Two 17:01  |  Ronnie Wolman 09/10/06
  74.   Khaled # 62 Who are you trying to fool? 17:10  |  ChanahS 09/10/06
  75.   Khaled # 66 17:17  |  ChanahS 09/10/06
  76.   Khaled # 66 17:17  |  ChanahS 09/10/06
  77.   Yes Danny,History Always Proves You Right 17:18  |  Tod Zuckerman 09/10/06
  78.   Khalid #71 17:18  |  Gee 09/10/06
  79.   decmocray ? 17:39  |  jihad 09/10/06
  80.   Hamas is a terrorist organization 17:44  |  Bruriah Sarah 09/10/06
  81.   response to VITTORIO 17:44  |  jihad 09/10/06
  82.   khalid 17:45  |  bev 09/10/06
  83.   Re:#62 Khalid Conspiracy number One Hundred and Forty Two 17:50  |  jihad 09/10/06
  84.   to Margie #27 17:51  |  zeev 09/10/06
  85.   Museum of tolerance is a good example 17:53  |  peter 09/10/06
  86.   Fall of Hamas is nothing to cheer about 18:09  |  peter 09/10/06
  87.   It is so depressing! Everyone a zealot! 18:19  |  Le Maudit Anglais 09/10/06
  88.   Hamas will fall, and...