Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., October 11, 2006 Tishrei 19, 5767 | | Israel Time: 16:39 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 14:58 08/10/2006
Row over British Muslim veil remarks rumbles on
By Reuters

A row over a British government minister's remarks that it would be better for social integration if Muslim women did not veil their faces refused to die down on Sunday.

The comments last week by Leader of the House of Commons Jack Straw provoked Muslim ire, political tremors and public commentaries that he had voiced a feeling silently held by many people.

The row erupted after Straw, whose northern English constituency has a large Muslim population, revealed that he asked visitors to his office to remove their veils, saying they acted as "a visible statement of separation and difference".

But he defended Muslims' right to wear headscarves, hijabs, unlike the French government which banned them from state schools, provoking protests across the Islamic world.

One leading Muslim said his comments were responsible for an attack on a Muslim woman in the northern city of Liverpool in which her veil was ripped off and racial abuse was shouted.

Phil Woolas, minister for race and equality, came out in support of Straw.

"Muslim women who wear a veil have every right to do so," he wrote in the Sunday Mirror newspaper. "But they must realise that other people who don't understand the culture can find it frightening and intimidating."

Deputy Prime Minister John Prescott said he understood why Straw had aired his concerns but that he risked his argument being hijacked by bigots and ending up doing more harm than good.

"I think this debate does open it up, thank goodness Jack has done that," he told BBC television. "But I fear sometimes people might use it in a more prejudiced way and I am concerned it might damage relations rather than improve them."

Opponents accused Straw, demoted from foreign minister earlier this year, of opening a thinly-disguised bid to become deputy prime minister when Prescott stands down sometime within the next year.

Muslim News accused him in an editorial of demonising Islam and said he had made sure that Muslim women would "refuse to participate in the democratic process."

"The blatant absurdity of that reaction is unfortunately typical of a section of the Muslim community which does its best to suppress any form of debate," the Sunday Telegraph newspaper responded in an editorial.

"Indeed we should all be grateful that Mr Straw had the courage to raise the issue of the impact the face covering veil can have on community cohesion. Courage of that kind has been in short supply," it added.

In many British towns, communities are divided with little or no contact between ethnic groups. Commentators fear this is fuelling tension and extremism.

Two weeks ago Home Secretary (Interior Minister) John Reid, a possible successor to Prime Minister Tony Blair who is to quit the job within a year, vowed to prevent Muslim extremists setting up "no-go" ghettos in British cities.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
A rocky road
Bedouin trackers say they are Israeli enough for the IDF, but not for an ID card.
Wet and wild
Tel Aviv University boasts an important center for wildlife preservation.
  1.   human rights 14:34  |  * TALKBACK OBSERVER* 08/10/06
  2.   According to most polls 14:35  |  British academic 08/10/06
  3.   Please, Not the BEHEAD THEM Signs Again! 15:08  |  Tony Anthony 08/10/06
  4.   Where is the line drawn? 15:13  |  Ronnie Wolman 08/10/06
  5.   veil uncovered 15:21  |  Anna 08/10/06
  6.   # 1 It`s Called " Life" 15:33  |  Tony Anthony 08/10/06
  7.   Frightening? 15:45  |  john of Jordan 08/10/06
  8.   British Racism 15:46  |  JO JO 08/10/06
  9.   Dear British "academic" 15:48  |  David James Vickery 08/10/06
  10.   human rights to talkback observer 15:50  |  British academic 08/10/06
  11.   Infidels 16:09  |  Niall 08/10/06
  12.   Straw made a mistake......... 16:15  |  richard 08/10/06
  13.   Answer to David James Vickery. 16:17  |  David Nigel Braham 08/10/06
  14.   freedoms 16:23  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 08/10/06
  15.   Personal choices 16:30  |  Niv 08/10/06
  16.   Muslim Ire (Third attempt) 16:43  |  Nik Miller 08/10/06
  17.   So far there have been few muslim veil suicide bombers 16:53  |  Ronnie Wolman 08/10/06
  18.   #17 Ronnie Wolman 17:22  |  Boycott 08/10/06
  19.   Fashion not religion 17:26  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 08/10/06
  20.   Muslims have to learn... 17:49  |  Marie 08/10/06
  21.   Fashon statement 17:53  |  maoriboy 08/10/06
  22.   Thats not the issue MR Straw 17:56  |  Danite 08/10/06
  23.   average brit hates muslims 17:59  |  rich 08/10/06
  24.   Marie; the Law in the UK legislates Civil Rights 18:22  |  Ronnie Wolman 08/10/06
  25.   Insidious Infiltation of Radical Islam in Britian 18:23  |  Jane 08/10/06
  26.   British Academic "here here"! 18:28  |  Danite 08/10/06
  27.   JACK STRAW IS RIGHT 18:55  |  Nicole 08/10/06
  28.   Can a women live in Iran or Saudi Arabia and... 19:04  |  What do you think? 08/10/06
  29.   # 14 Cipora Julianna Kohn. re: freedoms. 19:39  |  Kathy 08/10/06
  30.   Some Muslim Women Should Keep The Veil! 19:55  |  Sam The Sham 08/10/06
  31.   When the Brits ruled the world, did they wear native clothes? 19:56  |  Le Maudit Anglais 08/10/06
  32.   Jack Straw has left Labour 20:15  |  H50 08/10/06
  33.   # 14 Ipora Julianna Kohn. freedom. (Second Try) 20:15  |  Kathy 08/10/06
  34.   Haaretz is selective in publishing comments 20:30  |  Ben 08/10/06
  35.   ban the burka 20:40  |  Jessica 08/10/06
  36.   absurdity 21:54  |  peter 08/10/06
  37.   to jessica 21:56  |  * TALKBACK OBSERVER* 08/10/06
  38.   to6 21:58  |  * TALKBACK OBSERVER* 08/10/06
  39.   To Anna, 5, 21:59  |  Jozef 08/10/06
  40.   Ben: Freedom and You 22:16  |  Ronnie Wolman 08/10/06
  41.   Jack Straw is right -- but so are his critics. 22:22  |  Colin Wright 08/10/06
  42.   to the academic (calm down) 22:25  |  * TALKBACK OBSERVER* 08/10/06
  43.   How they will react 22:29  |  krystal 08/10/06
  44.   to 34 22:31  |  * TALKBACK OBSERVER* 08/10/06
  45.   #29, Kathy 22:32  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 08/10/06
  46.   The premise behind the vail is ridiculous, sexist 22:36  |  Comforti 08/10/06
  47.   British "academic" 22:48  |  Lebanese admirer 08/10/06
  48.   Margie in Tel Aviv 22:49  |  Walid 08/10/06
  49.   No 28: are those my only options 22:49  |  multiple choice 08/10/06
  50.   Margie in Tel Aviv 22:55  |  Walid 08/10/06
  51.   Behave violently because of words, be labelled as violent 23:01  |  British academic 08/10/06
  52.   #31- you are missing the point! 23:03  |  Posek 08/10/06
  53.   Le Maudit Anglais if.. 23:05  |  British academic 08/10/06
  54.   To multiple choice #49 23:08  |  What do you think? 08/10/06
  55.   To Le Maudit Anglais: Straw is Right 23:27  |  Psalm 08/10/06
  56.   maoriboy 23:30  |  rich 08/10/06
  57.   H50 23:32  |  rich 08/10/06
  58.   # 51 Psalm. re: Covering The Faces!!!!............ 23:58  |  Kathy 08/10/06
  59.   on looking threatening 23:58  |  peter 08/10/06
  60.   When in Rome 01:23  |  Australit 09/10/06
  61.   2500 Gendarmes injured so far this year in Paris "Intifada" 01:23  |  PETER SM 09/10/06
  62.   H50 Jack Straw has joined the BNP when ??Any more lies?? 01:27  |  PETER SM 09/10/06
  63.   Laity in the west! 01:40  |  Mario Fiorito 09/10/06
  64.   they came to britain for a better life 02:18  |  troy 09/10/06
  65.   Troy 02:56  |  Connie 09/10/06
  66.   A legal point to consider. 03:06  |  Tony Price 09/10/06
  67.   # 53 British academic. Short memory, eh? 03:16  |  Le Maudit Anglais 09/10/06
  68.   #56 to rich 04:50  |  maoriboy 09/10/06
  69.   Trouble in Londonistan ? 04:56  |  Klaudia 09/10/06
  70.   To Margie in Tel-Aviv No. 19 - Veil is Not Burka 06:58  |  Karim 09/10/06
  71.   Boycott Britain 07:07  |  Semsem 09/10/06
  72.   Danite 07:13  |  Walid 09/10/06
  73.   #34 Amen, Ben! 07:15  |  hala 09/10/06
  74.   WE PROMISE RETALIATION 07:25  |  indrajaya 09/10/06
  75.   What freedom? 07:30  |  BTFWS 09/10/06
  76.   Le Maudit...cant compare like with like can you 07:40  |  British Academic 09/10/06
  77.   Le Maudit loves Hezb because of their nazi ideology 07:45  |  British academic 09/10/06
  78.   Indrajaya you need a cup of hot chocolate 07:56  |  Dimitris 09/10/06
  79.   Indrajaya, thank you 08:10  |  British academic 09/10/06
  80.   To Indrajaya 374 08:11  |  Niall 09/10/06
  81.   #74 Indra 08:13  |  Willy 09/10/06
  82.   whaa??? this makes no sense 08:17  |  kula 09/10/06
  83.   INDIRAJAYA.Ya Jihad.How exactly are you going to retaliate? 08:39  |  PETER SM 09/10/06
  84.   THE NEXT LADY DIANA WILL COME 08:45  |  indrajaya 09/10/06
  85.   Indrajaya Forgetting To Take His Meds Again! 08:46  |  Sam The Sham 09/10/06
  86.   # 83, PETRE SM 09:27  |  indrajaya 09/10/06
  87.   # 80, NIALL 09:36  |  indrajaya 09/10/06
  88.   Karim you confuse me again 09:37  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 09/10/06