Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., October 17, 2006 Tishrei 25, 5767 | | Israel Time: 15:02 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Lessons of the Palestinian fighting
By Ze'ev Schiff

The bloody clashes between Hamas and Fatah in the Palestinian Authority, in which innocent bystanders make up the majority of the casualties, offers some important lessons. Lesson number 1 is that the international financial and economic siege of the Hamas government, which is being led by the United States, is succeeding. It is no wonder that some officials, including Israelis, are proposing that the pressure on Hamas be ended just because it has been so successful.

Lesson 2: Despite the suffering caused by the economic hardship and the inability to pay the salaries of PA employees; despite the fragility of the PA and despite the bloodshed - Hamas has an objective that supersedes all of this: Not to recognize Israel, not to accept the agreements that have been signed with Israel and not to forgo terror attacks (which they call "resistance").

Lesson 3: The war in Lebanon affected events among the Palestinians. According to public opinion surveys, many Palestinians support "resistance," i.e., a continuation of terror attacks. In their view, only resistance brings results and victories, and Hezbollah has proved this.

Advertisement

Lesson 4: Despite Hamas' rigid ideological stance against Israel, cracks have begun to show in the organization. The large movement is not as cohesive as it was in the past. There is a debate within Hamas between the ideological level and the pragmatic one, between external Hamas in Damascus and some of the leaders of internal Hamas. The more pragmatic types argue that in order to really capitalize on its election victory, Hamas needs a period of quiet. Only thus will it be able to genuinely take control of the Palestinian Authority. The pragmatists would be willing to remove their opposition to the wording of the so-called "Prisoners' Document," which they at first opposed on the grounds that it implied indirect recognition of Israel.

The ideological level, led by external Hamas and headed by Khaled Meshal - which is supported by the military arm in the Gaza Strip and by Mahmoud al-Zahar, the foreign minister in the Hamas government, contends that no disaster will befall the Palestinians if the diplomatic process falls apart. The continuation of the "resistance" is more important. In their view, Israel is the one that must be pragmatic and accept the reality and Hamas' demands.

Lesson 5: Hamas is not prepared to recognize the agreements that have been signed with Israel, yet it still proposes that Israel accept a new agreement (or understanding) - a 10-year hudna (cease-fire). During this time, Hamas will grow stronger, the financial siege on it will be canceled and it will complete its takeover of the Palestinian political system.

The hudna proposal isn't new. But Hamas' approach is a bit peculiar: They say that they are not ready to uphold agreements with Israel, but at the same time they propose a hudna agreement with Israel, which they are sure to violate when an opportunity presents itself. The naive in Israel, who believe that despite all this such an agreement should be accepted, ought to be reminded of the conditions attached to the proposed hudna: A withdrawal to the 1967 borders, agreement that Hamas will operate in Jerusalem and that Israel will agree to act immediately to resolve the refugee issue.

Lesson 6: Since September 8, Hamas has not taken responsibility for the Qassam rockets that have been fired at Israel. Meaning: They are not doing the firing, but they may well be supplying rockets to others. Hamas claims that it cannot ensure that Islamic Jihad will also agree to the cease-fire. Meanwhile, the organization's military arm says that it will agree to stop firing the Qassams, but not to halt the terror attacks. In the Gaza Strip, nihilistic groups like the Army of Islam and the Resistance Committees who are adopting Al Qaeda's principles have been gaining strength.

Lesson 7: The fate of kidnapped soldier Gilad Shalit is being decided not only in Gaza, and the Egyptians are not alone in playing a role in the matter. Syrians and Iranians have also been meeting with Meshal. This just goes to show that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is expanding to the point of multilateral involvement by numerous parties.

Final lesson: The current bloody conflicts among the Palestinians indicate once again that Hamas is far from ready to forsake its religious principles, which say there shall be no relinquishing of the Islamic holy lands upon which Israel sits. This is a problem that the Palestinians will have to resolve among themselves - because there is no chance that Israel will agree to convert to Islam.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Know thy body
'Learning to move in a healthy, flowing, harmonious, precise and aesthetic way.'
Foul Gesture
The movie 'Tnua meguna' won first place in the feature film category at the festival in Haifa.
  1.   On a point of grammar 11:22  |  Peter Dale 06/10/06
  2.   7 alternative lessons for ze`ev 11:41  |  freddy 06/10/06
  3.   The ONLY Lesson 11:44  |  Yishai Kohen 06/10/06
  4.   freddy @ # 2 12:33  |  Akiva Patysh 06/10/06
  5.   Comments on your "final lesson" 13:00  |  Natallie Durson 06/10/06
  6.   So let’s convert! 13:18  |  Jonathan S 06/10/06
  7.   Natallie Durson 13:33  |  JTC 06/10/06
  8.   I Have An Idea! 14:04  |  Sam The Sham 06/10/06
  9.   akiva #4 14:20  |  freddy 06/10/06
  10.   Natallie - why go back only 60 years? 14:20  |  Bob 06/10/06
  11.   The only lesson here 14:27  |  sh 06/10/06
  12.   P.S. 14:32  |  sh 06/10/06
  13.   Twisting the issue 14:46  |  fk 06/10/06
  14.   Jews chasing their own tails 14:47  |  Bernard Ross 06/10/06
  15.   The Only Conversion 15:00  |  Ronnie Wolman 06/10/06
  16.   Sam try the Lichtenstein model 15:02  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 06/10/06
  17.   Resolution 15:46  |  Johnson 06/10/06
  18.   Mr. Schiff, "supercede." 15:51  |  Johnson 06/10/06
  19.   Misguided practice 15:58  |  Johnson 06/10/06
  20.   ronnie, seriously? 16:09  |  freddy 06/10/06
  21.   Radical Islam Must Not Be Underestimated 16:10  |  Jane 06/10/06
  22.   A matter of Faith 16:15  |  maoriboy 06/10/06
  23.   #7 Natallie Durson 16:16  |  Rick 06/10/06
  24.   Another Idea to slove the problem 16:23  |  KS 06/10/06
  25.   I totally agree with the writer, as a muslim, as an American 16:29  |  omolll 06/10/06
  26.   At Last.. 16:39  |  Danite 06/10/06
  27.   And 16:39  |  gerald 06/10/06
  28.   A guide for the perplexed 16:51  |  Ben Gurion 06/10/06
  29.   #1 Peter Dale 17:22  |  Yonatan 06/10/06
  30.   #5 Natalie Durson 17:25  |  Yonatan 06/10/06
  31.   #8 I have a better idea 17:29  |  Yonatan 06/10/06
  32.   #13 fk 17:32  |  Yonatan 06/10/06
  33.   Israel will not coonvert to Islam 18:01  |  fairminded 06/10/06
  34.   To # 3 YOUR LAND ?! 18:47  |  Yankelowitz 06/10/06
  35.   To # 7 You better learn history, not tales ! 18:59  |  Yankelowitz 06/10/06
  36.   To # 10 Completely irrelevant ! 19:03  |  Yankelowitz 06/10/06
  37.   To Yankelowitz - you`re numbers are very selective 19:29  |  Richard 06/10/06
  38.   analysis 19:31  |  H 06/10/06
  39.   re: fk Twisting the issue 19:43  |  Sam 06/10/06
  40.   Islam is right everyone else is infidel scum 19:45  |  British academic 06/10/06
  41.   To 1 , 7 & 25. No 19:57  |  Altelena 06/10/06
  42.   Response to 25 20:05  |  Bruriah Sarah 06/10/06
  43.   the schiff paradox 20:06  |  tadchase 06/10/06
  44.   to yankeowitz: Jordan Palestine is ONLY Arab Palestine 20:10  |  David 06/10/06
  45.   Radical Islamic Fundamentalists Won`t Take No for An Answer 20:11  |  Jane 06/10/06
  46.   convert to Islam? 20:32  |  JewBoy#1 06/10/06
  47.   # 25 Froggy What about Jews in Box Cars? 20:55  |  Kissel 06/10/06
  48.   ZE`EV KEEP COUNTING UNTIL HAMAS COMES 21:03  |  arab 06/10/06
  49.   A guide for the perplexed 21:20  |  Ben Gurion 06/10/06
  50.   Yankelowitz #26 -- You are quite wrong 21:38  |  bbl 06/10/06
  51.   Entire Arab-Israel conflict explained is less than 20 lines 21:53  |  MG 06/10/06
  52.   To the author-errors and correction 21:58  |  Lebanese in Canada 06/10/06
  53.   #32 22:07  |  Peter Dale 06/10/06
  54.   #24, fairminded, hardly 22:08  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 06/10/06
  55.   If Palestinians Continue to Follow Hamas They`re Hopeless 22:27  |  Jane 06/10/06
  56.   #25 To # 3 YOUR LAND ?! 22:32  |  Rick 06/10/06
  57.   #30 re: fk Twisting the issue 22:36  |  Rick 06/10/06
  58.   Eight for so long existing lessons, and than some 22:37  |  TonyL 06/10/06
  59.   5 % 22:39  |  eva 06/10/06
  60.   to # 30 Sam 22:56  |  Wes 06/10/06
  61.   At Last.. 22:57  |  Danite 06/10/06
  62.   Wes, #39 not quite... 23:18  |  bbl 06/10/06
  63.   Serves them right 23:38  |  John 06/10/06
  64.   To 39. Accept facts 23:41  |  Altalena 06/10/06
  65.   #21 Yonatan, Natalie Durson 23:56  |  Boycott 06/10/06
  66.   G-D AND HIS WORD COMMAND STRANGERS TO DWELL AT PEACE WITH ISRAEL 00:15  |  Bill. 07/10/06
  67.   JEWISH PEOPLE WILL NEVER SUBMIT TO THE SWORD OF ISLAM ?? 00:26  |  Bill. 07/10/06
  68.   on a point of grammar 00:31  |  gershon 07/10/06
  69.   Natallie Durson 00:34  |  gershon 07/10/06
  70.   #39 Wes 00:56  |  Hastaroth 07/10/06
  71.   A guide for the perplexed 01:55  |  Ben Gurion 07/10/06
  72.   #43 #21 Yonatan, Natalie Durson 02:35  |  Rick 07/10/06
  73.   to Cipora J.Kohn #33 03:17  |  zeev 07/10/06
  74.   Ben Gurion #56 03:36  |  TonyL 07/10/06
  75.   Convert--never work!! 03:38  |  Pastor Phil 07/10/06
  76.   #64, zeev 04:40  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 07/10/06
  77.   Sure, let`s convert 04:41  |  Daniel 07/10/06
  78.   pastor phil, you`re right... 05:05  |  maria 07/10/06
  79.   Ben Gurion 05:09  |  Unassuming 07/10/06
  80.   the roman procurator declared the land of israel 05:20  |  maria 07/10/06
  81.   to fk, no compulsion 05:23  |  jn 07/10/06
  82.   Pals are so confused they do not know their priority 05:33  |  Infidel 07/10/06
  83.   To the perplexed "Ben Gurion" 06:13  |  Danite 07/10/06
  84.   #78, Maria.... 07:16  |  Pastor Phil 07/10/06
  85.   #83, Danite 08:15  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 07/10/06
  86.   13. fk, Twisting the issue 08:33  |  KUTW 07/10/06
  87.   Stolen land 08:39  |  EC 07/10/06
  88.   AMEN NATALLIE!! #10 08:49  |  Frank