Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., October 08, 2006 Tishrei 16, 5767 | | Israel Time: 21:07 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports   Travel Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business   Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Despite, not because
By Gideon Samet

Things look very bad among the Palestinians. Even devout leftists must admit that the street battles, their continuing failure to make peace at home, the incendiary talk and the murder in their eyes are frustrating to the most moderate of Israeli observers. What can be done with this terrible turmoil?

Even Yisrael Beiteinu leader MK Avigdor Lieberman has never said what Hamas and the Fatah are yelling about each other. Armed gangs have settled accounts in street battles. Fatah has demanded that the Hamas interior and foreign affairs ministers be put on trial. In the meantime, its people have shot at the deputy prime minister and kidnapped the finance minister. There are frightening energies there, of hatred and despair and a lust for revenge. This week's "Black Sunday" joins the worst of the bloody incidents between us and them. On that day, amid the inflamed passions, one of the heads of Hamas shouted to the masses at Jabalya that his movement would not recognize Israel even if all its members were killed.

What can be done? The Israeli instinct has always been to spill all the old cliches over such scenes, from "there is no one to talk with" to jets of racist scorn for "the Arabs." We are having a hard time with them? They are also having a hard time with us. When at the beginning of the week, 12 Palestinians were killed in Fatah-Hamas battles, this of course made front page headlines in Israel. But the hundreds whom Israel has killed just in the darkened and hungry Gaza Strip over the past few months have already become stale non-news. The riots in the territories are a big asset for all haters of any agreement with those rioting gangs.

Advertisement

As though in periods of relative quiet, some spark of readiness to talk with a new government - heir to the leadership generation that Israel loved to hate - had ignited. Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, like his predecessor, has been procrastinating over a meeting with Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas for months on end, as though he were a leper. No commission will investigate this failure in our backyard. Defense Minister Amir Peretz seemed to rub his hands together when he said that the defense establishment would continue to follow the clashes "with special attention." He did not do a thing, either before the war or when he found time afterward, to turn his special attention to the increasing pressure, the erupting anger, the terrible poverty and the signs of disintegration in an administration in whose stability Israel should seemingly have a special interest. Throughout, the defense minister has continued to bombard the tough neighborhood across the way.

Now, enters United States Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice. She came for a purposeless visit at perhaps the lowest point in the waning days of the Bush administration. Even if this intelligent woman has something to offer, she does not have the authority and the clout. She is walking in lockstep with a president who is not prepared to recognize Hamas and push Israel to talk with the most dynamic movement in the territories.

This is not how the Israeli majority thinks. It is marching ahead of its limping leadership. A survey by Hebrew University's Truman Center, together with the Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research in Ramallah, found that at the end of last month, 67 percent of Israelis (and 59 percent of Palestinians) supported negotiations with a Palestinian unity government. The government will be surprised to learn that 56 percent are even prepared to speak with just a Hamas government.

At a dinner with Olmert on Wednesday, Rice talked about ways of dealing with jet lag. Her entire waning administration is deep in the throes of jet lag. It is ridiculous to expect it to produce any initiative on the Palestinian issue. What concerns the administration is an attempt to create an Arab coalition against Iran. Our situation, which at one time brought Washington to formulate road maps for an agreement (but not to do anything about implementing them), has now been reduced to opening the Karni crossing "soon."

Olmert has no problem dragging his feet. In the aquarium - an apt nickname for his bureau - it is easy nowadays to formulate the "because": the justifications for why it is impossible to talk with them, to help them. However, Israel's interests demand the "despite" justifications: why it has long been incumbent upon us, and especially in this current crisis period, to make things as easy as possible for the Palestinian population and to talk with its leaders. This is also the right time because the old excuse, that Israeli moderation will play into the hands of Palestinian aggression, is absent. They are flat on their faces, stuck in crippling poverty the likes of which can be found only among the most failed of nations.

He knows what needs to be done, but does not want to do it. More than anything else, Olmert is afraid of what will happen to him in the shaky political arena. He is refusing even though the territories are the most dangerous and nearby stockpile of explosives threatening our national security.

What should be done instead of the declamatory "because?" Aid should be transferred to Gaza, the routes for agricultural exports should be opened, help must be given in restoring the electricity supply, the number of Palestinian workers in Israel ought to be increased, Palestinian prisoners should be released (in the same numbers that will in any case ultimately be released) and Gilad Shalit brought back, talks should be held with the PA chairman and prime minister, a unity government should be encouraged rather than sabotaged, there should be serious discussion of the Saudi initiative, and special attention - not Peretz's sort - has to be directed to the fact that the initiative, which has already been adopted twice, recently, by the Arab League summit, includes pan-Arab recognition of Israel as its culmination.

Quite a selection for anyone who prefers the "because" due to fear of the "despite."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Family affair
A close look at Noam and Avivit Benek-Koenigsbergers and their 2-year-old son Sapir.
Versace on the Volga
Russia's fashion industry is taking its place in the local - and international - spotlight.
  1.   "Despite, not because" 11:13  |  sandra chitayat 06/10/06
  2.   response to Gideon, con`t. 11:26  |  sandra chitayat 06/10/06
  3.   Ma Nishtana... 11:30  |  Ronnie Wolman 06/10/06
  4.   Must Israel negotiate with David Irwing? 12:02  |  Jonathan S 06/10/06
  5.   What a sick joke Ronnie 12:40  |  Marilyn 06/10/06
  6.   Samet would love to become an eunuch in the harem of S.Arabia`s 12:50  |  Absolute Sweden 06/10/06
  7.   Jonathan S 13:18  |  Peter Dale 06/10/06
  8.   To Peter Dale about Irving and Abbas 13:35  |  Jonathan S 06/10/06
  9.   Ronnie Wolman 13:55  |  Gabe1 06/10/06
  10.   Quoting Haaretz`s slanted "67%" doesn`t make it so! 14:00  |  Yaakov K. 06/10/06
  11.   Marilyn #5 14:06  |  Gabe1 06/10/06
  12.   Marilyn #5 14:06  |  Gabe1 06/10/06
  13.   Should Israel re-arrest Hamas leaders for their own safety? 14:06  |  bruce 06/10/06
  14.   Turn out the lights 14:08  |  Michael 06/10/06
  15.   Olmert knows what needs to be done. 14:35  |  Clickfool 06/10/06
  16.   Marilyn and Choices 14:42  |  Ronnie Wolman 06/10/06
  17.   Ronnie, truths exaggerations and convenient ommissions 14:43  |  Ibrahim 06/10/06
  18.   Suffer the idiots, for they... 14:54  |  Peace Train 06/10/06
  19.   arabs 14:54  |  dan 06/10/06
  20.   Swings and roundabouts 15:03  |  bruce 06/10/06
  21.   Swings and roundabouts 11 15:12  |  bruce 06/10/06
  22.   Haaretz agenda vs Israel 15:18  |  B 06/10/06
  23.   Swings and roundabouts 111 15:19  |  bruce 06/10/06
  24.   ClickFOOL knows exactly what has to be done 15:21  |  Jonathan S 06/10/06
  25.   Ibrahim: Tigers,Guerillas and Grandads 15:37  |  Ronnie Wolman 06/10/06
  26.   Ronnie, on change. 16:20  |  Ibrahim 06/10/06
  27.   Gideon Samet`s self destruct agenda 16:40  |  Sal 06/10/06
  28.   #24 AND WHY JUST IRELAND JONATHAN 16:42  |  PAUL HARRIS 06/10/06
  29.   #24 Jon: You can`t be serious. 16:58  |  Clickfool 06/10/06
  30.   Ibrahim#17 17:09  |  Danite 06/10/06
  31.   Steps to be taken for peace 17:10  |  Ben Gurion 06/10/06
  32.   WAKE UP ISRAEL 17:14  |  DAVE 06/10/06
  33.   #5 MARYLIN WHERE DO YOU GET YOUR FIGURES ???? 17:21  |  P. HARRIS 06/10/06
  34.   Reply to Jonathan S#8 17:35  |  Peter Dale 06/10/06
  35.   Clickfool 17:38  |  Jasmine Murphy 06/10/06
  36.   GIDEON SAMET`S ARTICLE UNENVIABLE TRUTH 18:12  |  Smadar 06/10/06
  37.   Olmert knows what is to be done but not G. Samet 18:36  |  Altalena 06/10/06
  38.   #14 Mr Bulb 15 watt not very bright 19:12  |  alan 06/10/06
  39.   Short history 19:24  |  John 06/10/06
  40.   To 5 . Marilyn & friends. Contradiction 19:36  |  Altalena 06/10/06
  41.   #14 Mr bulb #2 19:41  |  alan 06/10/06
  42.   Smadar-Who Are you? 20:03  |  Gabe1 06/10/06
  43.   Jasmine Murphy #29 20:06  |  Guess who 06/10/06
  44.   To Peter Dale comparing vinegar with wine 20:41  |  Jonathan S 06/10/06
  45.   Steps to be taken for peace 21:23  |  Ben Gurion 06/10/06
  46.   to jonathan s from rome 21:36  |  citizen zero 06/10/06
  47.   Israeli Poll: 64% Oppose Giving Away 22:49  |  Bruriah Sarah 06/10/06
  48.   Palestinians 22:57  |  Chaim Gorenstein 06/10/06
  49.   To: Chaim Gorenstein 00:01  |  Keith from UK 07/10/06
  50.   PEACE NOW - SECULAR HUMANISTIC MADNESS ?? 00:50  |  Bill. 07/10/06
  51.   Gideon Samet, Your suggestions are right on target! 01:12  |  Dutch 07/10/06
  52.   Steps to be taken for peace 01:58  |  Ben Gurion 07/10/06
  53.   #38 Gabe1, Palestinians are our brethren based on current DNA 04:43  |  Smadar 07/10/06
  54.   OPINION POLLS 05:27  |  ron 07/10/06
  55.   False hopes 05:58  |  David 07/10/06
  56.   HAMAS /HIZBOLLAH IRAN / HAMAS/HIZBOLLAH/IRAN 09:06  |  PAUL HARRIS 07/10/06
  57.   Clickfool & Olmert knows 09:18  |  EC 07/10/06
  58.   #57 09:44  |  wadha 07/10/06
  59.   arab state 10:05  |  ec 07/10/06
  60.   Ibrahim,I agree,good sentiments... 10:51  |  Ronnie Wolman 07/10/06
  61.   Hamas leader says that will not recognize Israel 11:29  |  Robert 07/10/06
  62.   On ClickFOOL and the Irish wanting a tampon for king 13:09  |  Jonathan S 07/10/06
  63.   Redhill 13:58  |  Chaim Gorenstein 07/10/06
  64.   Clickfool #29 14:04  |  Guess who 07/10/06
  65.   #44 Jonathan S 14:26  |  Peter Dale 07/10/06
  66.   Smadar #53 15:13  |  Gabe1 07/10/06
  67.   #60 WHO ARE THE ISRAELIS TO COUNT ANYONE OUT? 16:26  |  Dutch 07/10/06
  68.   Benny Hill Gurion aka David ibn Avigdor 17:19  |  Gabe1 07/10/06
  69.   Smadar 17:33  |  GabeS1 07/10/06
  70.   America must make Restitution 18:22  |  Paula 07/10/06
  71.   Nonsense! 18:59  |  Nathaniel 07/10/06
  72.   its none of our buisness-let them kill themselves 20:12  |  yahn goodey 07/10/06
  73.   What about the meter? (Ga Ga Gabe1 #66) 20:58  |  Ben Gurion 07/10/06
  74.   Arrogant idiocy In fact no one knows what to do 23:19  |  Shalom Freedman 07/10/06
  75.   ibn Avigdor #73 23:58  |  Gabe1 07/10/06
  76.   FOOL #15 09:39  |  Joe Moer 08/10/06
  77.   When Israelis Embrace Logic 20:57  |  Omar 08/10/06
 Today Online
Gideon Levy: U.S. sycophancy toward Israel
Responses: 104
Sharif Hafez: Israel must see the partner in its enemy
Responses: 47
Row over call by U.K. minister for Muslim women to remove veil
Responses: 30
Assad: Syrian military preparing for war with Israel
Responses: 202
Belgian far-rightist urges Jews to join battle against Muslims
Responses: 125


More Headlines
20:59 Peres: Yisrael Beiteinu not likely to join cabinet
20:12 Witnesses: IDF troops beat two handcuffed Palestinians at Nablus checkpoint
20:32 Hamas PM: Political infighting won't lead to Palestinian civil war
17:25 IDF denies killing Palestinian man near Nablus-area checkpoint
17:43 Galilee Arab towns to receive special budget allotment for first time
20:53 San Antonio Spurs beat Maccabi Tel Aviv in Paris exhibition game
18:06 Qatar proposes Abbas, Haniyeh, Meshal meet at Doha summit
20:08 Lebanese schools stay closed as gov't scrambles to repair war damage
15:45 Driver in crash that killed family remanded for eight days
17:13 Bones of giant camel dating back 100,000 years discovered in Syrian desert
Previous Editions