Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., October 08, 2006 Tishrei 16, 5767 | | Israel Time: 09:22 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A struggle among losers
By Danny Rubinstein

In an open letter to Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas, Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh and the leadership of Hamas and Fatah, Dr. Ali Jarbawi, a lecturer at Bir Zeit University writes: "If you think that in your fighting, there will be a winning side, you are delusional. In such struggles, no one wins; everyone loses!

He is probably right. The strength of the Palestinian groups currently at odds is about equal. The two movements, Fatah and Hamas, with their private militias in the Gaza Strip, are unable to overcome one another. It is clear to almost everyone in the territories that neither side will be able to emerge victorious from this fighting; a deal is necessary.

It is easy, in theory, to strike an agreement between Fatah and Hamas on a joint political platform. Just two-three weeks ago, Abbas and Haniyeh announced they had formulated such a plan. Abbas then claimed that Hamas officials had distanced themselves from the agreement, and all accused Damascus-based Khaled Meshal, the head of Hamas' political office, of being responsible for the failure of the deal.

Advertisement

This may be because Meshal has absolutely no use of a stable government in the Gaza Strip, with most of his associates, just like himself, in exile and not part of such a government.

It could also be because his Syrian hosts are pressing him to adopt more extreme positions because of their own considerations.

Either way, according to one Palestinian report, during his visit to Qatar last week, Abbas managed to hold talks with Meshal, and the two may even have reached an agreement. The main points are: A national unity government will be established with a neutral figure at its head, neither from Hamas nor from Fatah. This government, which will comprise members of both movements, will recognize past accords with Israel and accept the principle of two states for two peoples.

The Palestine Liberation Organization will undergo reforms and Hamas will join it. The agreement also includes a prisoner exchange deal under which abducted Israel Defense Forces soldier Gilad Shalit will be freed.

In addition to this report, recent days have seen a plethora of Palestinian proposals for solving the crisis. It appears that Abbas' associates are deliberating the idea of early elections (according to the head of the Fatah faction in the Palestinian Legislative Council, Azam al-Ahmed), or the disbandment of the Hamas government and its replacement with a temporary cabinet of technocrats.

The latter was an option raised by former minister Nabil Amar, who is close to Abbas. There are those who are also saying that the chairman is fed up and occasionally repeats his threat to resign.

It is possible that nothing will alter the situation and the chaos will only get worse. In recent years the inclination in the Gaza Strip has been for a return to a tribal society, in which family-based militias impose order.

When authority and public services collapse, the sole security of the individual - physical, economic, social and spiritual - is family based. A teacher from Khan Yunis, who works at an UNRWA school, said on a radio show from the Gulf that in the past, his meager wages provided for two households - his and that of his widowed sister. Now, he says, he also provides for the families of his two unemployed brothers.

But the problem in the Gaza Strip is not a deal between Fatah and Hamas. The problem is that tens of thousands of its residents no longer work in Israel, and all the local economic initiatives have collapsed. Goods from subcontracting work for Israeli firms (mostly in textiles) and agricultural produce are blocked at the Karni crossing, which is closed most of the time.

The Erez industrial zone is destroyed; infrastructure projects, such as the construction of the port, have been halted; and there is no way to find employment and develop a career. In an effort to show that they are of some value, the youth join the gangs, carrying guns in displays of manliness.

If this situation continues, the Gaza Strip will explode - in Israel's face too. A courageous and creative Israeli government could announce the flow of extensive aid to the Gaza Strip.

This would include the transfer of funds and investments, an increase in subcontracting work, the construction of the port, the development of natural gas and water resources, and the passage of workers into Israel. This is unlikely to happen. The bleak forecasts are the realistic ones.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Family affair
A close look at Noam and Avivit Benek-Koenigsbergers and their 2-year-old son Sapir.
Versace on the Volga
Russia's fashion industry is taking its place in the local - and international - spotlight.
  1.   Build lots of bridges - in each area of activity 10:51  |  Bruno 05/10/06
  2.   and many idiots blame the Pals for not developing their country! 10:57  |  Gaza Boy 05/10/06
  3.   God bless this decent man, and this decent, caring society 10:59  |  Clickfool 05/10/06
  4.   Johnny one- note plays the `threaten Israel` card again 11:56  |  Shalom Freedman 05/10/06
  5.   Hey, You Forgot to Mention Al-Aqsa in Your Editorial 12:43  |  Klaudia 05/10/06
  6.   Help the enemies who want to destroy us? How utterly self-hating. 12:44  |  Bennie 05/10/06
  7.   God is watching-with many, many eyes 12:50  |  Virginia 05/10/06
  8.   A Marshall Plan for Palestine, then a MEU 13:03  |  Freddy 05/10/06
  9.   re: A Marshall Plan for Palestine, then a MEU 13:37  |  whizbang 05/10/06
  10.   Bennie the imbecile 14:04  |  Marilyn 05/10/06
  11.   A precedent for Clickfool 14:05  |  Robert 05/10/06
  12.   Struggle? 14:05  |  David Nigel Braham 05/10/06
  13.   Bennie`s convenient error 14:18  |  Nahman Umani 05/10/06
  14.   Marilyn #10 14:19  |  Gabe1 05/10/06
  15.   Marilyn -Part Deux 14:25  |  Gabe1 05/10/06
  16.   Umani #13 14:31  |  Gabe1 05/10/06
  17.   The only loser in her is Rubinshtein 14:38  |  Sal 05/10/06
  18.   Response to #10 14:43  |  Dave 05/10/06
  19.   To #18 Robert on CLICKFOOL 14:46  |  Sam 05/10/06
  20.   Why not aid the West Bank instead? 14:48  |  bruce 05/10/06
  21.   Marilyn -Part Une 15:01  |  Gabe1 05/10/06
  22.   Communism is the only answer 15:02  |  Yakov 05/10/06
  23.   Clckfool 15:05  |  Chaim Gorenstein 05/10/06
  24.   And what about Israeli Arabs? 15:20  |  bruce 05/10/06
  25.   Abbas asking for too much 15:22  |  Ben Gurion 05/10/06
  26.   #10 Bennie 15:25  |  key 05/10/06
  27.   Robert: re the fool 15:43  |  Jasmine Murphy 05/10/06
  28.   I don`t buy this 15:49  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 05/10/06
  29.   Help Hate Unify to Kill Israel? 15:53  |  B 05/10/06
  30.   Including Hamas would de-legitimise the PLO 16:16  |  bruce 05/10/06
  31.   Marilyn 16:21  |  Nik Miller 05/10/06
  32.   #25 Shlomo 16:31  |  Mich 05/10/06
  33.   Answer to Gaza boy. 16:37  |  David Nigel Braham 05/10/06
  34.   Good Advice 16:37  |  Danite 05/10/06
  35.   #25 Shlomo 16:41  |  Michael II 05/10/06
  36.   Abbas and Hamas 16:43  |  Danite 05/10/06
  37.   #3 is a fake Clickfool. I didn`t write it. 17:06  |  Clickfool 05/10/06
  38.   Dan Rubinstein 17:08  |  Federico Glez. 05/10/06
  39.   Losers Agree on Losing Platform 17:11  |  Jack Shattuck 05/10/06
  40.   Do we Jews fear argument? 17:30  |  Richard Zatban 05/10/06
  41.   David Nigel, very anwser is very simple 18:05  |  Gaza Boy 05/10/06
  42.   September 12, 2005: a palestinian kristalnaacht 18:08  |  Bimmer 05/10/06
  43.   HELP TO PALESTINIANS???? please... 18:10  |  yuda 05/10/06
  44.   Gaza is Egypt 18:18  |  Herbert Kaine 05/10/06
  45.   there is natural gas ready to be tapped oof shore Gaza 18:21  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/10/06
  46.   Self determination 18:29  |  Daniel 05/10/06
  47.   Herbert Kaine are you ready to pack your bags 18:46  |  Gaza Boy 05/10/06
  48.   Danite-Wannabee Humanist 18:48  |  Gabe1 05/10/06
  49.   what is occupation? 18:51  |  Pssd Off American 05/10/06
  50.   Response to 49 - Myth; Occupation 19:04  |  Bruriah Sarah 05/10/06
  51.   34 I Am Reminded Danite 19:18  |  Mark of Lewiston 05/10/06
  52.   Who is Bruriah Sarah? 19:31  |  Pssd Off American 05/10/06
  53.   Post script to #50 Bruriah Sarah 19:36  |  Bimmer 05/10/06
  54.   Hamas Irresponsibility 19:36  |  Mark of Lewiston 05/10/06
  55.   Economic co-operation is key 19:40  |  Howard 05/10/06
  56.   39 Jack Shattuck - The Saudi Proposal 19:43  |  Mark of Lewiston 05/10/06
  57.   44 Herb Caine - Not According to Your Government 19:48  |  Mark of Lewiston 05/10/06
  58.   Is`t a "Talkback` or a "`Talkchatter" ? 19:58  |  Akram Zekaria 05/10/06
  59.   Darwin, Haniya, and Meshal (Mark of Lewiston #54) 20:01  |  Ben Gurion 05/10/06
  60.   Bimmer # 53 20:14  |  christa 05/10/06
  61.   # 50 B.Sarah.So Israel really belongs to Syria? 20:25  |  Le Maudit Anglais 05/10/06
  62.   59 Ben Gurion - Hard to Disagree with Reality 20:29  |  Mark of Lewiston 05/10/06
  63.   I say it again:More guns than brains in Gaza! 20:31  |  Le Maudit Anglais 05/10/06
  64.   #49. Well put, Bruriah 20:48  |  polybios 05/10/06
  65.   Darwin, Einstein, and Mark of Lewiston #62 21:03  |  Ben Gurion 05/10/06
  66.   No Gaza boy, I am not packing my bags 21:06  |  Herbert Kaine 05/10/06
  67.   to Christa #60 Totally incorrect 21:11  |  Bimmer 05/10/06
  68.   #22 I agree with Yaakov, Communism is the only way 21:12  |  Dave 05/10/06
  69.   to Christa #60 Incorrect history and language 21:13  |  Bimmer 05/10/06
  70.   # 63 looks like Fake Le Maudit Anglais 21:17  |  Clickfool 05/10/06
  71.   65 BG - Getting Philosophical 22:03  |  Mark of Lewiston 05/10/06
  72.   Chaim Gorenstein 22:27  |  I Understand 05/10/06
  73.   Well meaning, but a bit naive... 22:29  |  Nathaniel 05/10/06
  74.   # 70 Clickfool. Surprise! It is the real LMA 22:37  |  Le Maudit Anglais 05/10/06
  75.   Offensive comparison 22:37  |  Nathaniel 05/10/06
  76.   Mark of Lewiston "Let me remind you" 22:45  |  Danite 05/10/06
  77.   Ben Gurion or David ben Avigdor 22:45  |  Gabe1 05/10/06
  78.   Christa 22:48  |  Gabe1 05/10/06
  79.   Mark Of Lewiston2 22:51  |  danite 05/10/06
  80.   Mark Of Lewiston re "BG"#65 22:58  |  Danite 05/10/06
  81.   Marshall Plan for Palestine 23:07  |  juan 05/10/06
  82.   Gabe1 Wake up and join the world will you? 23:24  |  Danite 05/10/06
  83.   Explosion 23:34  |  Ron 05/10/06
  84.   #6 BENNIE - HELP ENEMIES - MESHUGA 23:35  |  * BEN JABO 05/10/06
  85.   Howard #55 00:08  |  Guess who 06/10/06
  86.   # 4 Shalom Freedman.HELLS,BELLS !!! 00:09  |  Kathy 06/10/06
  87.   To Mr. Rubinstein 00:11  |  TonyL 06/10/06
  88.   # 5 Klaudia. YUP! VERY CONVENIENT.THANKS FOR REMINDING HIM !! 00:11  |  Kathy 06/10/06
  89.   # 6 Bennie. YOU`VE SAID CHUM! ABSOLUTE BUNKUM 00:14  |  Kathy 06/10/06
  90.   # 14 Gabe 1. I HAVE JUST THIS TO SAY.THE SOONER THE BETTER GABE1 00:17  |  Kathy 06/10/06
  91.   Response to 61 00:25  |  Bruriah Sarah 06/10/06
  92.   Response to 49 00:30  |  Bruriah Sarah 06/10/06
  93.   Danite #82 The deliberate Falsifier 00:34  |  Gabe1 06/10/06
  94.   Isn`t this what you wanted? 00:34  |  Colin Wright 06/10/06
  95.   52: Who is Bruriah??? 00:37  |  Bruriah Sarah 06/10/06
  96.   Danite - The deliberate Falsifier 00:56  |  Gabe1 and only 06/10/06
  97.   75 Nathaniel - The Republican Leadership is Offensive 01:37  |  Mark of Lewiston 06/10/06
  98.   75 Nathaniel - The Republican Leadership is Offensive 01:37  |  Mark of Lewiston 06/10/06
  99.   Danite - Hamas and the way of the Dodo 01:47  |  Mark of Lewiston 06/10/06
  100.   Gabe1 #77 01:53  |  Ben Gurion 06/10/06
  101.   Clickfool 01:58  |  John 06/10/06
  102.   Michael11 02:14  |  John 06/10/06
  103.   Ibn Gurion #100-Challenged 02:14  |  GabeS1 06/10/06
  104.   Jack Shattuck...Never lived there??? 02:20  |  John 06/10/06
  105.   Mark of Lewiston 02:21  |  GabeS1 06/10/06
  106.   Gabe1 02:27  |  Danite 06/10/06
  107.   Gabe1 and Anarchism 02:29  |  Danite 06/10/06
  108.   Bebby Hill Gurion aka David ibn Avigdor 02:35  |  Gabe1 and only 06/10/06
  109.   I still do not Understand 03:06  |  An Honest American 06/10/06
  110.   Gabe1 #16 03:07  |  Janice 06/10/06
  111.   "Gazans are angry because they are starving" 03:43  |  Panama Red 06/10/06
  112.   Mark of Lewiston #97 03:52  |  TonyL 06/10/06
  113.   #2 Gaza Boy 04:10  |  MR 06/10/06
  114.   Gaza 04:13  |  Johnson 06/10/06
  115.   # 100- Ben Gurion re: poem- Don`t Quit Your Day Job ! 04:49  |  Klaudia 06/10/06
  116.   To #85 Guess who 07:14  |  Howard 06/10/06
  117.   104 TonyL 07:18  |  Mark of Lewiston 06/10/06
  118.   to le Maudit Anglais regarding B . Sarah 07:51  |  clickright 06/10/06
  119.   Clickfool 08:02  |  Willy 06/10/06
  120.   RETALIATION WILL FIND A WAY 08:20  |  indrajaya 06/10/06
  121.   RETALIATION WILL FIND A WAY 08:20  |  indrajaya 06/10/06
  122.   Where are the millions promised from the arabs neighbours 08:31  |  Infidel 06/10/06
  123.   For Le Maudit Anglais # 74 09:23  |  Clickfool 06/10/06
  124.   It`s so obvious 09:23  |  sara 06/10/06
  125.   For Willy in New York City # 114 (and for the Censor) 10:15  |  Clickfool 06/10/06
  126.   #119, Willy to Clickfool. Fake one writing to real one? 11:52  |  zmogus 06/10/06
  127.   hamas will never reconize israel 18:17  |  dovdevan 06/10/06
  128.   The IDF murders children 11:27  |  Marilyn 07/10/06
  129.   whizbang- thank you mam 19:00  |  larry 07/10/06
  130.   marrilyn the moron 19:06  |  larry 07/10/06
  131.   Gun control in Gaza? 19:52  |  Charlton Heston 07/10/06
  132.   the death of Israel 08:39  |  ricki bobbi 08/10/06
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: Be afraid, America. Be very afraid
Responses: 335
Can a Palestinian Muslim and a Zionist Jew be friends?
Responses: 321
Palestinians have to realize that Israel will never convert to Islam
Responses: 159
Assad must do more for peace than repeat rigid formulas
Responses: 60
Olmert knows what needs to be done but doesn't want to do it
Responses: 75


More Headlines
05:42 PM's circle: Lieberman is desirable partner
07:40 Olmert to convene panel of top officials to discuss Iran
07:39 Report: IDF kills Al Aqsa Martyrs' Brigades militant in Nablus
07:40 ANALYSIS: Iran and the UN - no sanctions on the horizon
09:10 Belgian far-rightist calls on Jews to join battle against Muslims
08:00 Defacement in Jerusalem monastery threatens diplomatic crisis
08:47 Four killed, six seriously hurt in weekend traffic accidents
08:21 Happy holidays - time to get a flu vaccination
08:07 Aviation reforms to lower prices and raise traffic
07:44 Taibeh man, 24, shot dead in apparent blood-feud between rival clans
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Nahal Haredi
Defending Israel's homeland. Help support our troops
EZER MIZION
Help those that need it most!
JOIN FREE AT JDate.com
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
ISRAEL-SHOPS ONLINE STORE
Gifts from Israel + FREE ISRAELI FLAG ON EVERY PURCHASE OVER $50
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
One year MBA in Israel
Taught entirely in English
FREE REGISTRATION at JLove.com
Join The Fastest Growing Jewish Singles Community Now! Click Here!
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved