Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., October 01, 2006 Tishrei 9, 5767 | | Israel Time: 22:39 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan (center) and the UNIFIL commander on August 29 viewing a portrait of a UN soldier killed in Lebanon. (Reuters)
Last update - 16:09 30/09/2006
UN blames IDF for lack of information on deadly Lebanon air strike
By Shlomo Shamir and Yoav Stern, Haaretz Correspondents and Agencies

A United Nations team blamed the Israel Defense Forces on Friday for its inconclusive report on an Israel Air Force air strike that hit a UN outpost in southern Lebanon, killing four UN soldiers.

The report determined that a 500-kilogram, precision-guided missile hit the UN post on July 26 near the southern Lebanon village of Al-Hayam.

Israel said the bombing of the post along the Israeli-Lebanese border was a mistake that occurred at the "operational level." But the panel investigating the attack was not allowed to interview commanders at that level to determine what happened, UN spokesman Stephane Dujarric said in a statement.

Advertisement

Because of Israel's refusal, the inquiry was "unable to determine why the
attacks on the UN position were not halted despite repeated demarches to the Israeli authorities from UN personnel, both in the field and at headquarters," Dujarric said.

Around two weeks ago, Israel issued a report to the UN, saying that the accidental attack on the UN post could have been the result of incorrectly marked IDF maps.

After investigating the soldiers' deaths in the air strike, the Israeli government presented the report to diplomats and military attaches from the officers' countries of origin - Finland, Austria, China and Canada. The report was presented to the UN at the beginning of the week.

After the attack, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert spoke with UN Secretary-General Koffi Annan to express his condolences and vowed to investigate the event and report back to Annan on the results of the probe.

The Israeli report two weeks ago gave a lengthy description of Hezbollah's operations in southern Lebanon, and said the air strike was meant to hit a Hezbollah stronghold 180 meters from the UN outpost at Al-Hayam.

In the days before he was killed, the Canadian officer who was killed wrote that IDF tank shells had fallen only two meters away from the UN troops, but that the shelling was justified due to Israel's tactical needs in the area.

In the aftermath of the event, some had interpreted the Canadian officer's testimony as verification of Israeli claims that Hezbollah guerrillas had been firing Katyusha rockets from the area. The UN said it had complained about the shelling, but that the IDF had not called off its fire.

After the four officers were killed, Annan accused Israel of attacking the UN post on purpose, saying that he was shocked and disturbed by the strike. Israel was furious at the accusation, and the UN chief later retracted his statement.

The UN chief had also said after the attack that the outpost had been set up a long time before and was well marked.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
It's a wonderful life
Sayed Kashua takes a close look at his life and makes some New Year resolutions.
Post-fast repast
Two delicious and appropriate recipes to savor while breaking that Yom Kippur 25-hour fast.
  1.   UN Idiots! 21:09  |  stude ham 29/09/06
  2.   What a surprise... 21:12  |  Clickfool 29/09/06
  3.   Wrong, Clickfool 21:22  |  Gabe 29/09/06
  4.   UN always blames Israel 22:04  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 29/09/06
  5.   To #1 22:08  |  John 29/09/06
  6.   not likely 22:29  |  Colin Wright 29/09/06
  7.   The only conclusion 22:36  |  Chris Linthwaite 29/09/06
  8.   Would the have targeted 23:00  |  Absentminded Sweden 29/09/06
  9.   Why all the fuss 23:10  |  Michael 29/09/06
  10.   Another conspiracy? 23:11  |  ariel 29/09/06
  11.   To 7. Attack on UN position 23:13  |  Altalena 29/09/06
  12.   Maps & UN 23:22  |  Max Molenaar 29/09/06
  13.   shame on U N 23:26  |  talkback observer 29/09/06
  14.   #4 And Israel always claim it was a "mistake" ! 23:28  |  MS 29/09/06
  15.   Attacks was carried out because UN allowed Hezbollah to operate 23:32  |  Haham me Bat Yam 29/09/06
  16.   # 14 No IDF is not full of retard.We spoon feeding the UN retards 23:38  |  Haham me Bat Yam 29/09/06
  17.   what benefit? 23:43  |  Pssd Off American 29/09/06
  18.   # 7 Which army or armed group permits a hostile foreign ... 23:46  |  Haham me Bat Yam 29/09/06
  19.   #11 Altalena 23:51  |  Chris Linthwaite 29/09/06
  20.   The United Nations can go to hell. 23:56  |  whomever 29/09/06
  21.   UN was spying 00:05  |  Twogunz 30/09/06
  22.   #15 00:21  |  MS 30/09/06
  23.   UN - what a waste 00:25  |  Jon 30/09/06
  24.   usless Un 01:10  |  bigbadakita 30/09/06
  25.   Let`s get real 01:11  |  Mark Lincoln 30/09/06
  26.   # 15 MS or whatever it means.Just get off your high of hate 01:18  |  Haham me Bat Yam 30/09/06
  27.   # 17 Pssd off American. Please read Gen.Lewis McKenzies articles 01:47  |  Haham me Bat Yam 30/09/06
  28.   #20 bass ackwards 01:48  |  watcher X 30/09/06
  29.   Why don`t you attack the real enemy? 01:53  |  negevboy 30/09/06
  30.   What the UN is for anyway? 02:07  |  David 30/09/06
  31.   it IS the IDF`s fault, not the soldier`s 02:15  |  Chill People 30/09/06
  32.   UN has to change 02:23  |  t 30/09/06
  33.   Haham me Bat Yam 03:20  |  Anna 30/09/06
  34.   THIS WAS NOT A MISTAKE 03:27  |  wally 30/09/06
  35.   Another disservice to the Israeli people 05:32  |  A Lebanese 30/09/06
  36.   UN-SHMUEN-KISHMAHEN-TUHASARAN 05:33  |  UHEBR 30/09/06
  37.   Annan disregarded UN 1559 causing UN 1701 06:02  |  Joseph E . 30/09/06
  38.   deliberate action 07:28  |  Rose 30/09/06
  39.   Post and Hezb 08:21  |  Lola 30/09/06
  40.   THE REASON 09:24  |  Boss Hog 30/09/06
  41.   that`s why UN now armed to the teeth 09:26  |  clever guy 30/09/06
  42.   # 38 rose , Unifil collaboration with hezbollah is recorded 09:49  |  Joseph E . 30/09/06
  43.   Normal, completally normal 10:00  |  Eduardo Zani 30/09/06
  44.   For Whomever # 20 10:24  |  Clickfool 30/09/06
  45.   This was just another bloody Israeli atrocity in a long list 10:28  |  Clickfool 30/09/06
  46.   Anna 10:28  |  Uday 30/09/06
  47.   Israeli Prisoners 11:06  |  Serge 30/09/06
  48.   Show some respect for U.N. 11:22  |  U.N. 30/09/06
  49.   Not Likely Colin? No.6 Colin Wrong AGAIN 11:33  |  Joe Moer 30/09/06
  50.   UN blames IDF for lack of information on deadly air strike 11:42  |  Sens 30/09/06
  51.   #34 GR8 Big Wally infers that.................... 11:45  |  Joe Moer 30/09/06
  52.   #26 Joseph 12:27  |  John of Jordan 30/09/06
  53.   Getting away with murder (as usual) 12:31  |  Natallie Durson 30/09/06
  54.   Hmm, The IAF 12:37  |  John of Jordan 30/09/06
  55.   if only everyone could endorse its share of resposiblity... 12:50  |  Fred 30/09/06
  56.   Whose safety is paramount? 13:08  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 30/09/06
  57.   Families should sue the UN 13:11  |  geoff 30/09/06
  58.   We`re forgetting something 13:12  |  watcher 30/09/06
  59.   #42 Operational errors abound in all wars.Why lalaland obsession 13:36  |  Haham me Bat Yam 30/09/06
  60.   I feel sick 13:37  |  Hanoman 30/09/06
  61.   Cowardice 14:01  |  JJ 30/09/06
  62.   S-t happens! 14:31  |  Alicia 30/09/06
  63.   Since November 29, 1947, when did the UN had something positive 14:36  |  Shlomzion 30/09/06
  64.   # 46 Haham me Bat Yam , Houuuuah , a hot batyami you`re 15:26  |  Joseph E . 30/09/06
  65.   We could give them info --UN post was 15:30  |  Sal 30/09/06
  66.   Kofi, you should inform 16:28  |  KUTW 30/09/06
  67.   To Lebnese# 35 - RIGHT ON!!!!! 16:38  |  JUDGE 30/09/06
  68.   Uday 17:51  |  Anna 30/09/06
  69.   # 35 A Lebanese , and his sens of legitimacy 17:52  |  Joseph E . 30/09/06
  70.   To #14 18:07  |  bill morgan 30/09/06
  71.   #9 Michael 18:26  |  Boycott 30/09/06
  72.   u.n post ,idf favorite target 19:24  |  bint jbeil 30/09/06
  73.   #34 there was a mistake !! 19:26  |  Gatorbait 30/09/06
  74.   UN needs to be blame itself 22:23  |  bf 30/09/06
  75.   JJ Good parallel 23:27  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 30/09/06
  76.   un should use ketusha to defend themself 01:38  |  fouad 01/10/06
  77.   Israel kills UN peace keepers 21:17  |  Nathan 01/10/06
 Today Online
Yossi Sarid: Perhaps Herzl's vision is too big for us
Responses: 38
How to prevent the next war: talk to Hamas and Hezbollah
Responses: 68
Gideon Levy: Israel doesn't want peace with Syria - period
Responses: 124
Uzi Benziman: Is Israel a partner for peace?
Responses: 31
During war, Olmert ignored Livni's plan for early exit
Responses: 40
Rosner's Domain
* New guest: Former consul general and Israel Factor panelist Alon Pinkas
* New poll: Should US/Israel "bolster" President Abbas?
* When Coach Allen came to Tel Aviv
* Lieberman watch: Is he ahead by 2 or by 10 points?


More Headlines
22:22 Abbas: Renew unity gov't talks, civil war is 'red line'
22:23 Lebanese gov't and Hezbollah say IDF pullout is incomplete
21:25 Palestinians: IDF tanks, troops move into northern Gaza
12:37 PM delayed FM's start of war plan to exit Lebanon