Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., October 08, 2006 Tishrei 16, 5767 | | Israel Time: 22:13 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A post-Zionist agenda
By Akiva Eldar

Indeed, "managing a country," as Ehud Olmert defined the prime minister's role in his Rosh Hashanah interview with Haaretz, is a worthy aim for a society. In most of the developed countries, a leader's statement that it is sufficient that he see to the proper running of the nation would not have drawn special attention.

However, an Israeli leader who throws away the challenge of peace - and this is what Olmert was referring to - is divesting the State of Israel of the main value in the name of which it was established.

The Declaration of Independence states: "We extend our hand to all neighboring states and their peoples in an offer of peace and good neighborliness."

Advertisement

That same constitutive Zionist document also declares that the State of Israel "will be based on freedom, justice and peace as envisaged by the prophets of Israel." Either Olmert believes that the aforementioned goals have been achieved, or the prime minister has become a post-Zionist.

Presumably, Olmert had neither of these possibilities in mind. A Haaretz investigation of the conduct of government policy during Lebanon War II, which will be published in the Yom Kippur Eve edition, suggests another explanation for the prime minister's style.

The investigation reveals that for a long time, Olmert ignored the international and regional arena. During those critical days, he distanced himself from Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni and her ministry colleagues, who wanted to suggest a strategy for exiting the war correctly. As always happens, this time, too, the vacuum Israel left afforded an advantage to other elements.

There was no clear Israeli policy with respect to the desired diplomatic outcome of the military conflict. As a result, it was very difficult for the United States to deal with a French-Lebanese position that was based on principles drawn up previously by the G-8 countries. The lack of a diplomatic initiative on Israel's part in all channels after the war is inviting regional and international initiatives. In the nature of things, the extent of Israel's influence on them will be extremely limited.

In her book "The March of Folly," Barbara Tuchman wrote: "Wooden-headedness, the source of self-deception, is a factor that plays a remarkably large role in government. It consists in assessing a situation in terms of preconceived fixed notions while ignoring or rejecting any contrary signs." the acute historian defined a leader's wooden-headedness as "acting according to wish while not allowing oneself to be deflected by the facts." She mentions Phillip II of Spain, "the surpassing wooden-head of all sovereigns," about whom it was said that "no experience of the failure of his policy could shake his belief in its essential excellence."

Olmert's failure, or at least, "lack of success," in achieving the goals he himself set for Israel at the beginning of the war has not succeeded in shaking his belief that ultimately, there was nothing wrong with his policy.

Olmert's retreat from his unilateral convergence plan leads to a suspicion that his determined support of the disengagement from Gaza did not indicate a change in his belief in a diplomatic policy of do-nothing. Olmert spent most of his years in politics in a camp that believes that time, American support, the Jewish settlements in the territories and harassment of the Palestinians would do the job.

His willingness to relinquish so easily the policy of separating from the occupation reinforces the hypothesis that the entire purpose of the unilateral withdrawal from the Gaza Strip was to preserve Jewish rule in the West Bank and East Jerusalem.

Fortunately for Olmert, his coalition partners are also managing pretty well without a diplomatic "agenda." The Labor Party is busy as always with suicide attempts. Shas was and remains a sectarian party, for which peace is not a top priority. The Pensioners' Party is showing no interest in the future of its grandchildren, who will be sent to fight the next wars.

Unfortunately for him, and immeasurably more so for Israel, the right, under the leadership of Likud MK Benjamin Netanyahu and the extreme right, under the leadership of Yisrael Beiteinu MK Avigdor Lieberman are presenting an alternative. They have an agenda, and it is appealing to more and more Jews for whom shalom - peace - is an old-fashioned alternative to "Yallah, 'bye."

It seems that the choice is between a leader who has effectively relinquished the peace agenda and maintenance of the Jewish majority in accordance with the Zionist platform, and leaders who do not believe in this whole business of peace.

If this is so, leaders like Netanyahu and Lieberman are preferable. They, at least, frighten the neighbors. They will make it possible for the international community to know whom it is dealing with.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Family affair
A close look at Noam and Avivit Benek-Koenigsbergers and their 2-year-old son Sapir.
Versace on the Volga
Russia's fashion industry is taking its place in the local - and international - spotlight.
  1.   Anyone will be better than Olmert and Friends 12:44  |  Zev 29/09/06
  2.   "acting according to wish" 12:49  |  Beni 29/09/06
  3.   "the spanish statesman miguel moratinos" 12:50  |  zadok the priest 29/09/06
  4.   i dont know about natanyahu 12:55  |  zadok the priest 29/09/06
  5.   The left has led Israel to DISASTER!!!! 13:12  |  Ben Uziel 29/09/06
  6.   a. eldar 13:31  |  vladimir 29/09/06
  7.   Pray is the Agenda. 14:06  |  Akram Zekaria 29/09/06
  8.   Post-Zionism -- Yallah, `bye 14:15  |  ML Bentovim 29/09/06
  9.   More Israeli war mongers to start trouble in the world 14:22  |  Clickfool 29/09/06
  10.   Netanyahu and Lieberman? 14:35  |  Niall 29/09/06
  11.   Ben Uziel 14:51  |  sh 29/09/06
  12.   CLICKFOOL ALIAS THEFOOL 14:55  |  Nicole 29/09/06
  13.   ML Bentovim 14:57  |  sh 29/09/06
  14.   ARE OLMERT & HIS KADIMA KLOTCH STILL HERE? WHY? 15:09  |  bat yam 29/09/06
  15.   To Bat Yam #14: A simple answer 15:18  |  Jonathan S 29/09/06
  16.   Anyone will be better than Olmert and Friends 15:40  |  el 29/09/06
  17.   Eldar on Frightening the Neighbours 15:40  |  Yaakov Sullivan 29/09/06
  18.   More Israeli war mongers to start trouble in the world 15:48  |  el 29/09/06
  19.   Who is "wooden head"? 15:49  |  Gene 29/09/06
  20.   Heartless one- sided criticism 15:52  |  Shalom Freedman 29/09/06
  21.   to Ben Uziel 15:52  |  wolf 29/09/06
  22.   let the readers think about clickfool`s persona 15:52  |  harzion 29/09/06
  23.   We dont need an Agenda 16:07  |  Ronnie Wolman 29/09/06
  24.   harzion on clickfool #22 16:12  |  Yaakov Sullivan 29/09/06
  25.   Olmert 16:15  |  Klas 29/09/06
  26.   Response to sh #13 16:16  |  Leibel 29/09/06
  27.   the policy of political Verelendung 16:25  |  Ernst 29/09/06
  28.   Olmert`s strategy 16:39  |  abbba 29/09/06
  29.   Zadok the Priest lieberman is anti jewish very dangerous 16:49  |  Jabadini 29/09/06
  30.   #22:Harizon, makes no difference because... 16:54  |  bat yam 29/09/06
  31.   @22 Harzion on Clickfool 16:55  |  Jeroen 29/09/06
  32.   Let the Right rule now 18:18  |  Ben Gurion 29/09/06
  33.   Eldar - The Champion of Appeasement 18:25  |  Tod Zuckerman 29/09/06
  34.   Such Apathy! 21:09  |  Knave Dave 29/09/06
  35.   Ben Gurion: The adding up on the Abacus 21:11  |  Ronnie Wolman 29/09/06
  36.   1. Anyone will be better than Olmert and Friends 21:12  |  Knave Dave 29/09/06
  37.   #12 Nicole: What an idiotic thing to say. 21:16  |  Knave Dave 29/09/06
  38.   disaster 21:47  |  albert l sturmer 29/09/06
  39.   A PEACE AGENDA , for a change 22:05  |  YOSSI 29/09/06
  40.   realistic arab agenda 23:38  |  peter 29/09/06
  41.   Re #23 THERE MUST BE AN AGENDA 23:58  |  MEIR WEINSTEIN 29/09/06
  42.   Hello Akiva, I have to agree with Ernst # 27 00:00  |  Dutch 30/09/06
  43.   Re#32 Ben Gurion 00:03  |  Meir Weinstein 30/09/06
  44.   To clickFOOL 00:05  |  Jordan 30/09/06
  45.   To clickfool and others 00:10  |  Yossi 30/09/06
  46.   To clickfool and others 00:10  |  Yossi 30/09/06
  47.   #20 Shalom Freeman , you are from the heartless side 00:31  |  Dutch 30/09/06
  48.   #@22Harizon on clickfool/Jerome 00:43  |  maureen Ann 30/09/06
  49.   Netanyahu/Lieberman as alternative 00:44  |  Esther Thomas 30/09/06
  50.   moshiach maniacs 02:53  |  satan 30/09/06
  51.   The lesser of two evils 04:31  |  Baz Mann 30/09/06
  52.   #42 DORIS GOES FROM THE SUBLIME TO THE RIDICULOUS 06:14  |  paul harris 3 30/09/06
  53.   #39 YOSSI AND THE IMPOSSIBLE DREAM 06:19  |  paul harris 4 30/09/06
  54.   Peace? 06:26  |  Johnson 30/09/06
  55.   Peace 2 06:33  |  Johnson 30/09/06
  56.   Barbara Tuchman Quotations 06:33  |  david 30/09/06
  57.   NETANYAHU THE CRIMINAL 06:40  |  indrajaya 30/09/06
  58.   Re #54 brainwashed 06:48  |  Baz Mann 30/09/06
  59.   Re #54 The land of milk and honey 06:57  |  Baz Mann 30/09/06
  60.   #58 and #59, Prescience 07:19  |  Johnson 30/09/06
  61.   #57 IN DRAJAYA AND THE BLIND SPOT 08:37  |  paul harris 30/09/06
  62.   Apologies to Jeroen for spelling.... 08:38  |  Maureen Ann 30/09/06
  63.   #58/59 BAZ MANN AND THE STORY OF JOB 08:42  |  paul harris 1 30/09/06
  64.   Netanyahu and Lieberman 09:19  |  Khalid Husian 30/09/06
  65.   Johnson`s hate 09:41  |  Esther Thomas 30/09/06
  66.   Prescience 12:00  |  Baruch Nili 30/09/06
  67.   # 61, PAUL HARRIS 12:54  |  indrajaya 30/09/06
  68.   Johnsons vision 13:41  |  Klas 30/09/06
  69.   Remember Rabin 13:54  |  Bernard Haftel 30/09/06
  70.   Netanyahu and Lieberman are not preferable at all! 14:20  |  Louis T. Sigel 30/09/06
  71.   Would Israelis be so stupid to follow Bibi ever again? 14:29  |  Louis T. Sigel 30/09/06
  72.   indrajaya/God knows their sins 15:48  |  maureen A 30/09/06
  73.   # 53 PAUL HARRIS and the dream of peace 16:56  |  YOSSI 30/09/06
  74.   #70 MAUREEN AND THE LIES PROPAGATE 17:25  |  paul harris 30/09/06
  75.   #57 The Man From the Banana Republic 18:08  |  Dutch 30/09/06
  76.   peace for Peter Harris 18:28  |  Maureen Ann 30/09/06
  77.   Netanyahyu and Leiberman 18:33  |  khalid husain 30/09/06
  78.   netanyahu the criminal 18:57  |  Khalid husain 30/09/06
  79.   Ben Uziel 19:07  |  ilana 30/09/06
  80.   Re #60. Solid research 19:09  |  Baz Mann 30/09/06
  81.   Did not he apologize 19:13  |  Baz Mann 30/09/06
  82.   12 -Nicole 19:35  |  Michael 30/09/06
  83.   Dutch has no Bananas 19:39  |  Michael 30/09/06
  84.   Leibel 19:43  |  sh 30/09/06
  85.   Eldar and new friends 19:50  |  Allan Leibler 30/09/06
  86.   Absolutely correct 20:38  |  BradL 30/09/06
  87.   my heart 21:33  |  christoph 30/09/06
  88.