Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., September 24, 2006 , | | Israel Time: 22:11 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The legal status of fighters
By Meron Benvenisti

The Israeli legal system, stretched to the limit by cases of private and public corruption, still finds the time and the resources to provide massive support for spreading and deepening Israel's image as a country suffering from terrorism and fighting for its existence. It is an image of a country threatened by traitors from within (Arab Israelis, hoping for a victory of the Axis of Evil whose center is in Damascus), by Hamas operatives (who aspire to destroy it) and by murderous Lebanese (Hezbollah).

On Tuesday, the trial of three Hezbollah fighters started. They are charged with murder, weapons possession, undergoing military training and membership in a terrorist organization. On the same day, a military court extended the remands of 21 Hamas ministers and legislators, who have been charged with membership in a terrorist organization. And also on that day, police began questioning a Balad member who visited Damascus - the "capital of terrorism" - and praised Hezbollah's victory.

The ideological basis for these legal steps is the definition of the suspects as terrorists. In other words, criminals. Their supporters are defined as traitors. Israel has taken it upon itself to define what legitimate violence is, and it is claiming a monopoly on the use of force, demanding that others accept its unilateral definitions. If they do not, they will be accused of being hostile, or worse. All practical resistance to Israel, whether violent or political, is an act whose purpose is illegitimate. Therefore, the definition of a "terrorist act" is not limited to the murder of innocents; it includes any use of "illegitimate" force. This definition encompasses "incitement" and "abetting the enemy." One could say, on the basis of this mainstream outlook, that a person can be either a Zionist or a terrorist.

Advertisement

The need to entrench this view, and thus to justify violent, deterrent, consciousness-searing action - and to reject all other definitions that are critical and unflattering - is highlighted by the absurdity of filing criminal charges. It is clear that the elected officials from Hamas were arrested and jailed only to serve as hostages for the release of Gilad Shalit, the abducted Israel Defense Forces soldier, and that the charge of belonging to a terrorist organization is just a pretext, as has already been determined by one court proceeding, which ordered the Hamas officials released.

Is the continuation of the trial supposed to serve as a means of pressure? Against whom? Is it meant to make it more difficult for the government to release Palestinian prisoners, or perhaps to undermine the diplomatic process that may emerge upon the creation of a Palestinian national unity government? When the exchange of prisoners does take place, and the Hamas officials are released, the sanctimonious cry will be heard: How could we undermine the rule of law in such a way? But the rule of law did not object when its dignity was exploited for cynical ends.

The trial of the Hezbollah fighters only heightens the absurdity and stains the legal system, which is ready to subserviently serve a military establishment that aims to humiliate an imprisoned enemy. According to the state's representative, "these are not prisoners [of war], because Hezbollah does not abide by the rules of war." Does Israel strictly adhere to the rules of war? Whoever denies his enemies the status of prisoners of war exposes his own imprisoned soldiers to the same treatment.

The United States invented the status of "unlawful enemy combatants" for such prisoners, and thus denied them the benefit of the Geneva Convention. However, the U.S. Supreme Court rejected this argument and applied the convention's content to them as well. Israel, however, was not moved by this. Nor is it moved by the implied humiliation of the IDF, which fought a difficult war against Hezbollah. After all, if the enemy fighters are criminals, murderers and terrorists, but they still managed to successfully withstand the onslaught of Israel's might, what does that say about the IDF's abilities as a fighting force? The attempt to describe the second Lebanon War as a police action, in which a number of criminals were caught and are now being tried for murder and attempted murder, is so pathetic that it should be abandoned immediately. In any case, its wretchedness will be revealed once the negotiations for an exchange of prisoners are completed.

The prosecution, in its eagerness to serve an inflamed public opinion at the expense of the Arab MKs - who dared to praise Hezbollah's successes - appears about to be caught up once again in the heat of the moment and investigate the Arab MKs over their statements in Damascus.

Thus the circle is complete: The whole world is against us. Our neighbors, citizens of the state, are a fifth column; the Palestinians in the territories want to wipe us out; Hezbollah is a forward division of Syria and Iran; our very existence is threatened; but our fearless legal system will protect us against all our enemies and bring justice to light. And afterward, we will be able to continue our "deterrence" work with a clear conscience.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Words that linger
New books for youngsters will remain in the memory long after they have been shelved.
Treasury of treasures
A guide to nearly a hundred unusual, fascinating places to visit in Israel.
  1.   Thanks for something rational 10:41  |  Marilyn 21/09/06
  2.   Stupid and infantile 10:42  |  Maral 21/09/06
  3.   Rule of Law is Isreal 10:47  |  Sami 21/09/06
  4.   To All Zionist 11:00  |  Muhyddine 21/09/06
  5.   an article that is rational and sound 11:26  |  Khalid 21/09/06
  6.   Hezbollah fighters 11:43  |  Israel Israeli 21/09/06
  7.   Poor Muhyddine and Khalid 11:45  |  Proud Zionist 21/09/06
  8.   proud Zionist`s hypocrisy 11:58  |  Khalid 21/09/06
  9.   Defend Your Home & You Are a Terrorist ! 12:04  |  Karim 21/09/06
  10.   meron benvenisti to the palestinians 12:10  |  thucydides 21/09/06
  11.   prosecute Israeli soldiers 12:17  |  Kiki Bardot 21/09/06
  12.   Well said mr. Benvenisti 12:21  |  Rose 21/09/06
  13.   karim you attacked us 12:32  |  thucydides 21/09/06
  14.   maral`s "moderation "did not last long 12:34  |  yaheskel 21/09/06
  15.   Wake up Karim 12:37  |  Richard 21/09/06
  16.   Khalid you are wrong, as usual 13:04  |  Proud Zionist 21/09/06
  17.   Karim`s lies 13:06  |  Curious 21/09/06
  18.   yaheskel 13:11  |  Maral 21/09/06
  19.   marilyn " i will defend to the death the right 13:16  |  thucydides 21/09/06
  20.   squeal like a pig! 13:18  |  FOX 21/09/06
  21.   marilyn 13:25  |  thucydides 21/09/06
  22.   To Thucydides No. 13 - Are You So Sure ? 13:30  |  Karim 21/09/06
  23.   To Richard No. 15 - Would You ? 13:34  |  Karim 21/09/06
  24.   To Curious No. 17 - Israel Already Did ! 13:38  |  Karim 21/09/06
  25.   It is not complicated 13:39  |  Natallie Durson 21/09/06
  26.   maral 13:39  |  yeheskel 21/09/06
  27.   Why is Haaretz employing this defeatist, self-ahting loser?? 13:41  |  Dudu 21/09/06
  28.   maral 13:42  |  yeheskel 21/09/06
  29.   karim 13:46  |  thucydides 21/09/06
  30.   Good one Karim! 13:49  |  Maral 21/09/06
  31.   to the proud Zionist, 9/11 www.barrychmish.com 13:52  |  Muhyddine 21/09/06
  32.   To Richard "Very Simple" 13:54  |  Muhyddine 21/09/06
  33.   Wake Up Karim, please deal in reality 14:09  |  Richard 21/09/06
  34.   Meron`s Fishing Trip 14:10  |  Tony Anthony 21/09/06
  35.   To Muhyddine 14:11  |  Richard 21/09/06
  36.   maral 14:14  |  yahezkel 21/09/06
  37.   yaheskel 14:16  |  Maral 21/09/06
  38.   The best Benvenistic can do is defend Terrorists and Traitors 14:16  |  Shalom Freedman 21/09/06
  39.   Richard in Tel Aviv 14:27  |  Marilyn 21/09/06
  40.   Yaheskel, since you asked... 14:30  |  Maral 21/09/06
  41.   Yaheskel/yehezkel 14:40  |  Maral 21/09/06
  42.   To Richard No. 33 - The Gap 14:44  |  Karim 21/09/06
  43.   Proud Zionist: you have an army so what? 14:52  |  Khalid 21/09/06
  44.   It`s over for Israel, the moral abyss has been reached. 14:54  |  Joe 21/09/06
  45.   marilyn is "sick to death" 14:55  |  thucydides 21/09/06
  46.   marilyn after you get over your sickness 15:02  |  thucydides 21/09/06
  47.   maral still so aggressive 15:07  |  yehezkel 21/09/06
  48.   To Thucycides No. 29 - Only Two in 2006 15:21  |  Karim 21/09/06
  49.   Karim, does not give you the exuce to 15:24  |  Aby 21/09/06
  50.   Shalom Freedman: in terms of terror, who under the sun can 15:26  |  Khalid 21/09/06
  51.   joe "sliding into moral oblivion" 15:35  |  thucydides 21/09/06
  52.   To Marilyn 15:38  |  Richard 21/09/06
  53.   joe and isreal`s sins. 15:42  |  thucydides 21/09/06
  54.   To Richard No. 35 - About the UN 15:44  |  Karim 21/09/06
  55.   To Curious 15:49  |  Lebanese in Canada 21/09/06
  56.   Karim 15:51  |  Richard 21/09/06
  57.   Never, ever attempt to break the logjam!! 15:53  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/09/06
  58.   Maybe Hezbollah should occupy Kiryat Shemona 15:59  |  Lebanese in Canada 21/09/06
  59.   Dudu and prozac #27 16:06  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/09/06
  60.   Hezbollah Fighters 16:22  |  Nina 21/09/06
  61.   thucydides 16:34  |  Free thinker 21/09/06
  62.   To Karim - continued 16:41  |  Richard 21/09/06
  63.   Khalid-Nobody owes you anything 16:42  |  Sam 21/09/06
  64.   yehezkel 16:51  |  Maral 21/09/06
  65.   To Nina - Hoorah for the glorious Hizbulla Victory 16:52  |  Richard 21/09/06
  66.   To Israel ISraeli #6 - Make up your mind 16:53  |  A Lebanese 21/09/06
  67.   Thought you should know... 16:59  |  Maral 21/09/06
  68.   karim from your post i can understand 17:15  |  thucydides 21/09/06
  69.   maral we have no hate 17:21  |  yehezkel 21/09/06
  70.   Meron, Please Join Amira in Ramallah 17:59  |  Tod Zuckerman 21/09/06
  71.   Khalid and Sheik Yassin 18:15  |  Proud Zionist 21/09/06
  72.   Muhyddine (31) 18:17  |  Proud Zionist 21/09/06
  73.   Sullivan and Rosh HaShana 18:20  |  Curious 21/09/06
  74.   "exposes his own imprisoned soldiers to the same treatment"???? 18:33  |  Danny - Israeli one 21/09/06
  75.   Curious and his love of his own and the other #73 18:36  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/09/06
  76.   Zionist or terrorist? But they are the same thing 18:42  |  Stephen Murray 21/09/06
  77.   A Law Unto Itself 18:58  |  chet 21/09/06
  78.   maral 19:06  |  Danite 21/09/06
  79.   "Yaakov" 19:09  |  Danite 21/09/06
  80.   #76 Looking for attention 19:11  |  Sam 21/09/06
  81.   TELL ME KHALID 19:26  |  TOBIA 21/09/06
  82.   Legal fiction and its use 19:29  |  Ben Gurion 21/09/06
  83.   Danite, you are in fantasy land... 19:33  |  Ibrahim 21/09/06
  84.   Richard again 19:35  |  Marilyn 21/09/06
  85.   Proud Zionist, spare me your definitions of "terrorist" 19:36  |  Ibrahim 21/09/06
  86.   #76 19:38  |  TOBIA 21/09/06
  87.   Curious in Boston 19:39  |  Marilyn 21/09/06
  88.   Baloney 19:46  |  Rick 21/09/06
  89.   Friend and Brother, Danite? #79 19:49  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/09/06
  90.   Ben Gurion #82 19:54  |  Wiseplato 21/09/06
  91.   TO: Danite # 78 19:56  |  AF11 21/09/06
  92.   To Richard - We are Not Stuck, You Are 20:12  |  Karim 21/09/06
  93.   Insanity and other comforts 20:20  |  Vav 21/09/06
  94.   to Muhyddine re#4 20:21  |  jeff atkinson 21/09/06
  95.   to Khalid re#8 20:26  |  jeff atkinson 21/09/06
  96.   arrogance+ignorance=dudu=right incarnate 20:33  |  experienced 21/09/06
  97.   20 FOX - Missing the Point 20:39  |  Mark of Lewiston 21/09/06
  98.   To Karin Post # 9 Defending.... 20:41  |  Deena 21/09/06
  99.   Curious #73 & the self claimed Jew Jake 20:44  |  Ari ben Yisrael 21/09/06
  100.   Stephen Murray, regarding Zionists and Terrorists... 20:44  |  Ibrahim 21/09/06
  101.   self-criticism 20:45  |  Felix 21/09/06
  102.   Or Islamists` lackey 20:47  |  Gaby 21/09/06
  103.   44 Joe in Ramallah - Treaty Violations 20:48  |  Mark of Lewiston 21/09/06
  104.   Ari Ben Yisrael and his snipped cat #99 21:01  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/09/06
  105.   Marilyn is Delusional 21:08  |  Richard 21/09/06
  106.   Karim, the Lebanone people are being held hostage 21:10  |  Richard 21/09/06
  107.   Ibrahim, you get today`s award #100 21:13  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/09/06
  108.   Mark Lewiston, we are working on the treaty violations 21:16  |  Ibrahim 21/09/06
  109.   Prisoners of war (Wiseplato #90) 21:17  |  Ben Gurion 21/09/06
  110.   Ben Gurion, a hole in your legal fiction 21:18  |  Ibrahim 21/09/06
  111.   Perhaps these "fighters" should disappear 21:20  |  peter 21/09/06
  112.   Ibrahim "I want to be an Arab" 21:21  |  Danite 21/09/06
  113.   I am one 21:23  |  christa 21/09/06
  114.   Geneva Convention 21:24  |  Cetshwayo 21/09/06
  115.   Yaakov Wrong 21:27  |  Danite 21/09/06
  116.   To # 72 21:29  |  christa 21/09/06
  117.   AF11 21:30  |  Danite 21/09/06
  118.   To My Detractors 21:35  |  Danite 21/09/06
  119.   To Marilyn 21:37  |  christa 21/09/06
  120.   Danite, what about the Polish Christians? 21:40  |  Ibrahim 21/09/06
  121.   108 Ibrahim - And US Government Intentions 21:41  |  Mark of Lewiston 21/09/06
  122.   Prisoners of war 21:44  |  christa 21/09/06
  123.   Listen to yourself Danite? Your hyperbole #115 21:52  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/09/06
  124.   Yaakov re Ibrahim 21:54  |  danite 21/09/06
  125.   108 Christa - A Matter of Debate 21:58  |  Mark of Lewiston 21/09/06
  126.   118 Danite - I Make a Point 22:03  |  Mark of Lewiston 21/09/06
  127.   Ha`Aretz be fair @ least on marilyn 22:05  |  Ari ben Yisrael 21/09/06
  128.   absolutelly brilliant 22:05  |  yulia 21/09/06
  129.   Mark Lewiston regarding US Gov Intentions 22:08  |  Ibrahim 21/09/06
  130.   Danite on Ibrahim and Sullivan 22:11  |  peter 21/09/06
  131.   What a, excuse me, stupid article 22:27  |  Bimmer 21/09/06
  132.   The hole and the wall 22:27  |  Ben Gurion 21/09/06
  133.   Ibrahim 22:29  |  Danite 21/09/06
  134.   #2 "Rinocerous" play by Ionescu 22:31  |  Haham me Bat Yam 21/09/06
  135.   Yaakov 22:35  |  Danite 21/09/06
  136.   IAF destroyed churches in Lebanon 22:41  |  Banyameen ReeshMany 21/09/06
  137.   Mark of Lewiston Hello 22:41  |  danite 21/09/06
  138.   peter 22:43  |  Danite 21/09/06
  139.   It is absurd to request that everybody be free except Israelis 22:44  |  Altalena 21/09/06
  140.   Peter on the Jew and the Arab #130 22:47  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/09/06
  141.   Dear Danite, I fear for your mental health #135 22:50  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/09/06
  142.   Danite re. Yaakov & Ibrahim 22:51  |  Howard 21/09/06
  143.   to all zionists....response to muhyddine 22:59  |  maria 21/09/06
  144.   Danite-so Arab Christians are a year away from a holocaust? 22:59  |  Ibrahim 21/09/06
  145.   Ben Gurion, having your cake and eating it too. 23:02  |  Ibrahim 21/09/06
  146.   136 Danite - Happy New Year 23:07  |  Mark of Lewiston 21/09/06
  147.   Wrong Yaakov 23:12  |  Danite 21/09/06
  148.   Ibrahim Oy Vey Already!! 23:20  |  Danite 21/09/06
  149.   Mark of Lewiston 23:35  |  Danite 21/09/06
  150.   You`re either a zionist, or an anti-racist 23:41  |  John 21/09/06
  151.   Charge the prosecutors 23:43  |  John 21/09/06
  152.   pure pure and pure 23:47  |  Omar 21/09/06
  153.   Brave Zionists and Jews 23:47  |  Fadi 21/09/06
  154.   Danite 23:51  |  Omar 21/09/06
  155.   sullivan don`t flatter yourself 23:56  |  peter 21/09/06
  156.   Yaakov Sullivan 00:22  |  marios polycarpou 22/09/06
  157.   Dear Danite... 00:25  |  marios polycarpou 22/09/06
  158.   Shake and cake (Ibrahim #145) 00:37  |  Ben Gurion 22/09/06
  159.   Omar 01:06  |  Danite 22/09/06
  160.   #149 Danite with a loooooong "i"As I recall 01:07  |  Ari ben Yisrael 22/09/06
  161.   This is the most nonsensical haaretz article yet 02:03  |  McQueen 22/09/06
  162.   #90, Wiseplato 02:24  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 22/09/06
  163.   HAPPY HEALTHY NEW YEAR 02:54  |  TOBIA 22/09/06
  164.   MAN, just when I thought I was 02:55  |  Aussie RA 22/09/06
  165.   Muhyddine...denials, denials 03:24  |  Jake 22/09/06
  166.   HAPPY HEALTHY NEW YEAR TO ALL 03:34  |  TOBIA 22/09/06
  167.   Ibrahim, 3 Christians executed in Indonesia today 03:35  |  Jake 22/09/06
  168.   To my Muslim friends on this site 03:35  |  Hannah 22/09/06
  169.   YAAKOV SULLIVAN @140 03:45  |  TOBIA 22/09/06
  170.   Shake and cake (Ibrahim #145) 03:53  |  Ben Gurion 22/09/06
  171.   How not to make friends on this forum... 04:13  |  Chris S 22/09/06
  172.   CHRISTANS IN BETHLEHAM LEAVING 04:26  |  TOBIA 22/09/06
  173.   Who started the Lebanese war? 04:27  |  Johnboy 22/09/06
  174.   Mr. Benvenisti is trying to be fair 04:58  |  Mauro V. Mendlowicz 22/09/06
  175.   Definition of terrorism 05:19  |  Tom 22/09/06
  176.   Israel is legitimate because Jews live there 05:57  |  Saul Tobin 22/09/06
  177.   who started the war? Johnboy of Sydney.... 06:16  |  NYCNeil 22/09/06
  178.   #165 Mario - so Benvenisti has written TWO articles? 06:30  |  Johnboy 22/09/06
  179.   Either U R with us or U R against us. 08:22  |  Robert 22/09/06
  180.   Thank you Hanna 09:07  |  Khalid 22/09/06
  181.   To Deena No. 98 - I agree 09:52  |  Karim 22/09/06
  182.   To Richard No. 106 - Who Is A Hostage ? 09:57  |  Karim 22/09/06
  183.   Shana Tova from a secular zionist Israeli to all Jews 13:03  |  Haham me Bat Yam 22/09/06
  184.   Dear Yaakov Sullivan... 18:28  |  marios polycarpou 22/09/06
  185.   Logical Calm Posts? 21:42  |  BP 22/09/06
  186.   ben gurion 07:41  |  potaboc 24/09/06
 Today Online
Fatah: For unity gov't, Hamas must recognize Israel
Responses: 120
Lebanese Christian leader: War was a disaster
Responses: 45
Saudis, on news reports: No evidence Bin Laden is dead
Responses: 37
Egypt slams West for shielding Israel over nuclear arms
Responses: 158
Gunmen open fire on Florida mosque
Responses: 63


More Headlines
18:44 Assad: I want peace with Israel, but failure may lead to war
18:36 Haniyeh: Hamas serious about success of unity gov't efforts
22:11 Irish lecturers call on EU to boycott Israeli universities
17:53 Egyptian minister: Cairo to start building nuclear powerplants
21:08 Egypt bans French, German papers for comments on Islam
13:20 West, Saudis unable to confirm reports Bin Laden is dead
21:53 Northerners welcome vacationers, but say there are still not enough
18:19 Lebanese Christian leader: War was disaster, Hezbollah must disarm
13:52 Pope to visit statue of 'great Pontiff' Benedict during Turkey visit
20:21 Two people drown off Israeli beaches over New Year weekend
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Nahal Haredi
Defending Israel's homeland. Help support our troops
EZER MIZION
Help those that need it most!
JOIN FREE AT JDate.com
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
ISRAEL-SHOPS ONLINE STORE
Gifts from Israel + FREE ISRAELI FLAG ON EVERY PURCHASE OVER $50
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
One year MBA in Israel
Taught entirely in English
FREE REGISTRATION at JLove.com
Join The Fastest Growing Jewish Singles Community Now! Click Here!
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved