Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., September 23, 2006 , | | Israel Time: 13:35 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 18:15 19/09/2006
UN calls Israel's use of cluster bombs in Lebanon 'outrageous'
By News Agencies

Israel scattered at least 350,000 unexploded cluster bombs on south Lebanon in its war with Hezbollah, mostly when the conflict was nearing its end, leaving a deadly legacy for civilians, United Nations officials said on Tuesday.

David Shearer, the UN humanitarian coordinator in Lebanon, said at a news conference in Beirut that "The outrageous fact is that nearly all of these munitions were fired in the last three to four days of the war."

He said it was "Outrageous because by that stage the conflict had been largely resolved in the form of (UN Security Council) Resolution 1701."

Advertisement

The resolution came into effect three days after it was signed on August 11, bringin 34 days of fighting to an end. The truce reached has largely held since then.

During the war, Israel used the bombs to attack Hezbollah fighters, who often use village streets and civilian neighborhoods in southern Lebanon to launch rockets at Israel.

Israel has stressed that all the weapons it uses are legal under international Law, and has denied illegal use cluster bombs.

No international treaties or laws specifically forbid the use of cluster bombs, but the Geneva Conventions outline rules to protect civilians during conflict.

A UN fact sheet said the figure of 350,000 unexploded bombs was based on reports by Israeli soldiers, and excluded cluster bomb firings by conventional artillery or aircraft.

Chris Clark, manager of the UN Mine Action Coordination Center of South Lebanon, said the cluster bomb threat in the south was "extensive and, in my opinion, unprecedented."

While Israel has provided general information about where it believes unexploded ordnance might be, Clark said tactical maps given to the UN by Israeli forces withdrawing from the south were "absolutely useless" in clearance efforts.

"What we'd like is the number of shells that were fired in, and the actual coordinates, so we can go in and short-circuit what we're doing now and go and find those munitions straight away," Shearer said. "But that has not happened yet," he added.

Israeli government spokeswoman Miri Eisin said she was unaware of any official UN complaint or further request over cluster bomb mapping.

The UN has so far identified 516 cluster bomb strike locations and says 30 to 40 percent of the bombs scattered over the south failed to explode on contact.

Only about 17,000 bombs have been defused so far and the UN says clearance work could take up to 30 months.

Dalya Farran, spokeswoman for the UN Mine Action Coordination Center in the southern city of Tyre, said the task force has about 100 deminers currently at work, both from specialized aid groups and from contracted companies.

They coordinate with the Lebanese army and the UN peacekeeping force in south Lebanon, which both also have some demining teams.

The task force worries that rains in the coming months will sweep the bombs downhill to contaminate new areas, or cover them with a thin layer of dirt that will make them invisible.

Shearer said cluster bombs had killed or wounded an average of three people a day since the war ended, with 15 killed, including a child, and 83 wounded, of whom 23 are children.

Clearance efforts have so far focused on villages, schools and playing areas, but will soon shift towards farmland, which provides 70 percent of household incomes in the south, he said.

"The cluster munitions are stopping farmers from getting out to their fields and resuming their farming activities," he said.

Cluster bombs have been found on the ground and hanging on barbed-wire fences and trees, including in citrus, banana and olive groves, Clark said. They have also turned up in the rubble of destroyed buildings, complicating reconstruction efforts.

Because cluster bombs often maim civilians after fighting ends, their use by Israel against targets in Lebanese cities and towns has been criticized by human rights groups.

Human rights groups have criticized both Israel and Hezbollah for indiscriminate attacks on civilians in the fighting that began after the Hezbollah captured two Israeli soldiers on July 12.

Shearer said it "defied belief" that so many cluster bombs were fired in the last hours of the war.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Family affair
In the 12th grade Netali met Oriel, 12 years her senior, and moved in with him.
Still the same love
Singer Arik Einstein talks about his newly released 'biography in dialogue.'
  1.   cluster bombs 16:46  |  lebanese maronite 19/09/06
  2.   cluster bombs 17:02  |  Andrew Michaels 19/09/06
  3.   That`s funny, I didn`t hear them calling Hizbulla`s attack outrag 17:08  |  David 19/09/06
  4.   What do Israelis think about cluster bombs? 17:14  |  Redsmith 19/09/06
  5.   Hezbollah-lebanese lives saved from 17:15  |  Joseph E . 19/09/06
  6.   A 17% failure rate 17:15  |  Mark Lincoln 19/09/06
  7.   What`s the answer to 4000 Rockets??? 17:23  |  Brant 19/09/06
  8.   More filthy Israeli war crimes exposed by UK press 17:23  |  Clickfool 19/09/06
  9.   Shame on Israel 17:32  |  Justine 19/09/06
  10.   Clickfool Lies 17:39  |  Brant 19/09/06
  11.   In reference to the British Independent newspaper 17:42  |  Shlomzion 19/09/06
  12.   UN Calls Israel`s Use of Cluster Bombs In Lebanon "Outrageous" 17:46  |  Miranda Rose Smith 19/09/06
  13.   Redsmith 17:53  |  Maral 19/09/06
  14.   to lebanese maronite 17:56  |  mazen 19/09/06
  15.   For Shlomzion, a suggestion 18:02  |  Clickfool 19/09/06
  16.   #2 18:02  |  lebanese maronite 19/09/06
  17.   British news papers 18:05  |  Clever Guy 19/09/06
  18.   Clickfool lies or numbers lie? 18:08  |  peter 19/09/06
  19.   To No. 4, Redsmith: What do Israelis think 18:09  |  Shlomzion 19/09/06
  20.   To No. 4, Redsmith: What do Israelis think 18:09  |  Shlomzion 19/09/06
  21.   Black and white for Redsmith 18:21  |  Brant 19/09/06
  22.   Answer to #4 18:22  |  Sergio 19/09/06
  23.   Cluster bombs = weapons of evil terrorists 18:27  |  Stephen Murray 19/09/06
  24.   More Israeli Crimes 18:46  |  Sam 19/09/06
  25.   To Shlomzion 18:53  |  Sam 19/09/06
  26.   Well, no matter where you stand on this.. 18:55  |  Canadian 19/09/06
  27.   Whatdo israelis think... No, not funny at all 18:55  |  Maxim 19/09/06
  28.   Picky Picky! 19:00  |  Sam The Sham 19/09/06
  29.   Respected international media 19:04  |  Shlomzion 19/09/06
  30.   "ball bearings Inside" 19:04  |  Lebanese Canadian 19/09/06
  31.   we IS israel we can do what we want 19:05  |  CHEEWAWA 19/09/06
  32.   To Shlomzion 19:06  |  Sam 19/09/06
  33.   To mazen: Why the hostility towards maronite christian? 19:08  |  Ari 19/09/06
  34.   answer to #21 19:09  |  Sergio 19/09/06
  35.   Cluster Bomb 19:09  |  Elie P. Z. 19/09/06
  36.   Rockets/vs Cluster Bombs 19:10  |  Honestly Now 19/09/06
  37.   To No. 17: British News Media 19:20  |  Shlomo Eilon 19/09/06
  38.   Dear Joseph E from Givatayim... 19:23  |  marios polycarpou 19/09/06
  39.   Why hasn`t Israel been clearing these out of the areas they hold? 19:27  |  Palbo B 19/09/06
  40.   Remember - Israel Intentionally Fired Upon Civilians First 19:27  |  Fred Farkelsteinman 19/09/06
  41.   Answer to #35 19:36  |  Sergio 19/09/06
  42.   War is not fun...don`t start one 19:39  |  Brian Mcarty 19/09/06
  43.   NOT ILLEGAL? 19:40  |  Marilyn 19/09/06
  44.   cluster bombs 19:44  |  colin elkon 19/09/06
  45.   to 36: honesty now..WAKE UP pls 19:47  |  paul 19/09/06
  46.   To Ari: Re mazen 19:53  |  "Lebanese Lebanese" 19/09/06
  47.   To No. 32, Sam from Beirut 19:56  |  Shlomo Eilon 19/09/06
  48.   Taking Bets on Irans next wave of imports. 19:57  |  Haley 19/09/06
  49.   what lies , leb maronite 20:09  |  jacob 19/09/06
  50.   No Fred, Hizbullah attacked civilians first 20:16  |  real historian 19/09/06
  51.   How can 350,000 be launched in 3 days? 20:18  |  mathematician 19/09/06
  52.   #47 : Shlomo Eilon - Crawl Before Walking 20:20  |  Haley 19/09/06
  53.   What`s outrageous? 20:37  |  Jeff 19/09/06
  54.   52: Haley makes Texas Republicans look smart 20:38  |  David Teich 19/09/06
  55.   HEZBOLLAH DID NOT START THIS 20:40  |  Marilyn 19/09/06
  56.   Shlomo Eilon gets out his tedious old Jewish violin 20:45  |  Clickfool 19/09/06
  57.   Shlomzion as a jew that lived in England 20:49  |  Jabadini 19/09/06
  58.   War losers 20:49  |  Alef 19/09/06
  59.   Independent article on Gaza with typical lies 20:58  |  David 19/09/06
  60.   #54: Thorw a rock through my window and I`ll Blow up your house? 21:00  |  Haley 19/09/06
  61.   To No. 52: Haley 21:00  |  Shlomo Eilon 19/09/06
  62.   Elie P.Z. you are great at distorting facts 21:01  |  Jabadini 19/09/06
  63.   Pablo the UNIFIL is not Israels friend and nevr has been 21:03  |  Jabadini 19/09/06
  64.   Most if not all cluster bombs in Hizballah strongholds 21:05  |  Jabadini 19/09/06
  65.   UN calls Israel`s use of cluster bombs in Lebanon `outrageous` 21:09  |  paul 19/09/06
  66.   #56, Clickf.... can not bring myself to pronouce or spell 21:16  |  Shlomo Eilon 19/09/06
  67.   Haley hizballah have much control in lebanon 21:17  |  Jabadini 19/09/06
  68.   #55, Marilyn..Hezbollah committed act of War 21:31  |  David 19/09/06
  69.   #40, Fred, intentionally? says whom? 21:34  |  David 19/09/06
  70.   #61: Shlomo 21:38  |  Haley 19/09/06
  71.   Haley not making a fair comparison 21:38  |  David 19/09/06
  72.   #63 Jabadini 21:42  |  reader 19/09/06
  73.   #61: Shlomo cont.... 21:43  |  Haley 19/09/06
  74.   Cluster bombs only used against Military targets. 21:47  |  David 19/09/06
  75.   david 3 21:48  |  potaboc 19/09/06
  76.   Philosopher: Palestinians have the moral right to use "terror" 21:50  |  Clickfool 19/09/06
  77.   real historian 50 21:52  |  potaboc 19/09/06
  78.   UN bias 22:01  |  L. Gomberoff 19/09/06
  79.   #10/11: The Independent 22:02  |  USA 19/09/06
  80.   61: Haley continues to excuse jihad, p2 22:06  |  David Teich 19/09/06
  81.   #43 marylyn 22:08  |  val 19/09/06
  82.   What a bunch of morons 22:35  |  KUTW 19/09/06
  83.   Kidnapping and murdering Israelis must be legal 22:37  |  KUTW 19/09/06
  84.   UN Resolutions 22:45  |  Louis 19/09/06
  85.   NOT SURPRISED 22:45  |  Bert 19/09/06
  86.   #51, it is - as usual - a misleading headline 22:47  |  Danny - Israeli one