Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., September 23, 2006 , | | Israel Time: 18:31 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 16:57 18/09/2006
Top Sydney priest backs Pope; Syrians protest Islam comments
By News Agencies

More than 200 Muslims staged a sit-in Monday at the Sayyida Zeinab Shrine in Damascus to protest Pope Benedict XVI's remarks that sparked Muslim anger around the world.

The protest was called for by the Damascus office of Iran's spiritual leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, despite the pope's statement on Sunday that he was sorry his remarks about Islam and holy war had been misinterpreted and had caused offence.

Some Muslims considered this as inadequate, and demanded an outright apology by the pontiff.

Advertisement

A statement issued by the representative office of Khamenei, who has a big following among Shias worldwide, urged the Pope to "openly and plainly apologize for his remarks."

Sheikh Mustafah Zakariya, a mosque preacher, said the pope's remarks "have political reasons and are aimed at pressuring the Arab and Muslim world." He reiterated calls on the pontiff to apologize.

During a speech last week in Germany, the pope, quoting from an obscure Medieval text, cited the words of a Byzantine emperor who had characterized some of the teachings of Islam's Prophet Muhammad as "evil and inhuman."

Benedict on Sunday said that he was "deeply sorry" about the angry reaction and said the remarks came from a text that didn't reflect his own opinion.

Anger and violence over the pope's speech - including attacks on at least seven churches in Palestinian areas over the weekend - reflected one of the biggest international crises involving the Vatican in decades.

Sydney archbishop: Reaction to Pope's speech justifies his fears
The Catholic Archbishop of Sydney said Monday that acts of violence in response to Pope Benedict XVI's speech about Muslims show that some in the Muslim world think linking religion and violence is justified.

"The violent reactions in many parts of the Islamic world justified one of Pope Benedict's main fears," Cardinal Pell said in a statement.

"They showed the link for many Islamists between religion and violence, their refusal to respond to criticism with rational arguments, but only with demonstrations, threats and actual violence," he said.

The Vatican has issued two separate statements expressing regret for any offense the remarks may have caused.

Pell backed the pope's speech, telling Australian Broadcasting Corp. radio the pontiff should be allowed to speak without fearing that he would face the threat of violence.

He said some Australian Muslim leaders who had criticized the pope's remarks were being unhelpful because they avoided the issue of violence committed by some Muslims.

"Our major priority must be to maintain peace and harmony within the Australian community, but no lasting achievements can be grounded in fantasies and evasions."

Pell recognized contributions made by moderate Muslims, but added "evil acts done falsely in the name of Islam around the world need to be addressed, not swept under the carpet."

The Vatican has instructed its envoys in Muslim countries to explain Pope Benedict's words on Islam, which caused widespread fury and led to a personal apology by the pontiff.

Benedict's new Secretary of State, who took office only last Friday as Muslims around the world were protesting, said the Holy See's nuncios (ambassadors) in Muslim countries would be visiting government and religious leaders.

China: Pope's comments 'insulting' and 'hurtful'
A Chinese religious official said Monday that the Pope's comments were insulting to Islam and hurtful to Chinese Muslims, the Xinhua News Agency reported.

"In his speech, Benedict had insulted both Islam and the Prophet Mohammed," Chen Guangyuan, president of Islamic Association of China, was quoted as saying in an interview with Xinhua.

"This has gravely hurt the feelings of the Muslims across the world, including those from China," he told Xinhua.

The Pope's comments could undermine efforts at reconciliation by Beijing and the Holy See. The pope has repeatedly expressed the hope that the Vatican could achieve an opening with China, but the two sides remain sharply divided over who has the power to appoint bishops.

Beijing's ties with the Vatican were broken in 1951 after the communists took power in China. Worship is only allowed in government-controlled churches, but millions belong to unofficial congregations loyal to Rome.

Outrage in Muslim countries
About 500 Iraqi supporters of the radical Shiite Grand Ayatollah Mahmoud al-Hassani marched in the Iraqi city of Basra on Monday, carrying black flags in protest of the pope's comments.

The protesters chanted slogans and burned an effigy of the pope with a large black cross painted on its chest. They also burned Vatican and American flags.

Sheikh Ahmed al-Badrani, al-Hassani's spokesman in Basra said the pope should be tried by a Muslim court.

"I demand that the pope and all the members who took part, heard about and
accept these attacks on the prophet, to be presented to the court," he said.

The Mujahideen Shura Council, an umbrella group led by Iraq's branch of Al-Qaida, vowed a war against the "worshippers of the cross" in response to the pope's speech on Islam.

"We tell the worshipper of the cross that you and the West will be defeated, as is the case in Iraq, Afghanistan, Chechnya," said the group's statement, posted Sunday on an Internet site often used by Al-Qaida and other militant groups.

Another militant group in Iraq, Ansar al-Sunnah, also vowed to fight Christians over the comments.

"You will only see our swords until you go back to God's true faith Islam," it said in a separate statement on the Internet.

Iranian government spokesman Gholamhossein Elham said Monday that the pope's speech saying he regretted the uproar over his remarks on Islam was a "good gesture" but not enough.

Elham demanded a clearer apology, saying that the pope must express "more clearly and frankly that his remarks had been conveyed wrongly and correct them as soon as possible."

On Sunday, numerous religious seminaries in predominantly Shi'ite Muslim Iran were closed and about 500 Iranian theological school students rallied in the holy city of Qom to protest at the lecture.

Bishops meet in Istanbul
Catholic bishops met in Istanbul on Monday morning to discuss the pope's upcoming visit to Turkey amid an uproar in the Islamic world over his comments about Islam and holy war.

A chorus of voices in Turkey has been calling for Pope Benedict XVI to cancel his November visit - his first visit to a Muslim country as pope - if he does not apologize for his remarks.

The bishops' meeting in Istanbul had been scheduled long before the pope made his statement and was closed to the press, Vatican officials said. They said there would be no official announcement after the meeting.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Family affair
In the 12th grade Netali met Oriel, 12 years her senior, and moved in with him.
Still the same love
Singer Arik Einstein talks about his newly released 'biography in dialogue.'
  1.   China sees a chink 12:18  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 18/09/06
  2.   The Cinese said "hurtfull& insulting"Did they say UNTRUE 12:32  |  PETER SM 18/09/06
  3.   to Peter SM 13:08  |  Efraim 18/09/06
  4.   peter 13:31  |  nasser 18/09/06
  5.   to 2&3 13:36  |  Anubhav 18/09/06
  6.   Cud someone remind me? 13:40  |  Nasser 18/09/06
  7.   Pope spoke the truth 13:54  |  Dimitris 18/09/06
  8.   Nasser ur wrong 13:57  |  Dimitris 18/09/06
  9.   pope 14:09  |  charles wildstein 18/09/06
  10.   to Nasser 14:21  |  Efraim 18/09/06
  11.   nasser # 6 14:22  |  fatima 18/09/06
  12.   Geo political move by China 14:28  |  Jeroen 18/09/06
  13.   Fatima 14:39  |  Dimitris 18/09/06
  14.   Dimitris 14:40  |  Efraim 18/09/06
  15.   Lesson for Pope 14:43  |  Martin 18/09/06
  16.   Pope`s Remarks 14:48  |  Jim Brian 18/09/06
  17.   Nasser Islam was spread by violence that is a fact!!!!!! 14:53  |  arthur 18/09/06
  18.   to Jeroen 14:55  |  Efraim 18/09/06
  19.   To Efraim - pls publish 14:55  |  Dimitris 18/09/06
  20.   #10 Efraim 15:06  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 18/09/06
  21.   Efraim.Why didn`t the Chinese(out to score points) say Untrue 15:07  |  PETER SM 18/09/06
  22.   Fatima fatima 15:09  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 18/09/06
  23.   Angry about anger 15:15  |  Mike 18/09/06
  24.   How many times do they declare the same war ? 15:20  |  Jul 18/09/06
  25.   Oh GOD 15:23  |  James 18/09/06
  26.   free speech 15:27  |  Ian 18/09/06
  27.   Mixing between business and religion to 13 15:37  |  Simon Mohammed 18/09/06
  28.   CHINA ENRAGED BY ITALIAN LOVE OF PASTA 15:39  |  paul harris 2 18/09/06
  29.   Efraim. 15:40  |  PETER SM 18/09/06
  30.   #11: yes, you took it out of context 15:44  |  Felix 18/09/06
  31.   to Dimitris (2nd try) 15:44  |  Efraim 18/09/06
  32.   The West is Running Scared 15:51  |  SayItAintSo 18/09/06
  33.   to Peter SM 16:11  |  Efraim 18/09/06
  34.   FATIMA "Out of context"care to repeat your libel about Kol Nidre 16:19  |  PETER SM 18/09/06
  35.   pope in deep macaca 16:26  |  mike 18/09/06
  36.   NASSER, AND ARTHUR YOU ARE BOTH RIGHT.. 16:29  |  Gabriel 18/09/06
  37.   6: Nassar, that`s easy 16:32  |  David Teich 18/09/06
  38.   Simon Mohammed r u kidding 16:39  |  Dimitris 18/09/06
  39.   #6 -Islam reached all these areas via Bashkek 16:40  |  Sal 18/09/06
  40.   @25 SayItAintSo 16:47  |  Jeroen 18/09/06
  41.   no one seems to care what the pope actually said 16:56  |  Mike 18/09/06
  42.   to Jeroen 16:56  |  Efraim 18/09/06
  43.   to Peter SM 16:57  |  Efraim 18/09/06
  44.   When anger rises, think of the consequences. 16:58  |  Confucius 18/09/06
  45.   To SayItAintSo 2 17:05  |  Jeroen 18/09/06
  46.   Oriana Fallacci 17:09  |  Tina 18/09/06
  47.   to Efraim 17:18  |  Ziad 18/09/06
  48.   To Arthur, Please read the Quran... 17:26  |  A Dude 18/09/06
  49.   Dimitris, Pope, and Emperor Manuel Paleologos are all right 17:27  |  Jake 18/09/06
  50.   To Arthur, Please read the Quran... 17:27  |  A Dude 18/09/06
  51.   to Dimitris #19 17:27  |  Ziad 18/09/06
  52.   True faith in God is an expression of reason not violenc 17:28  |  bruce 18/09/06
  53.   Efraim, So well put. 17:32  |  Ziad 18/09/06
  54.   to all those who call muslims IGNORANTS 17:36  |  fk 18/09/06
  55.   To Gabriel #33 17:48  |  A Dude 18/09/06
  56.   Dimitris re appology by Moslems 17:50  |  Ziad 18/09/06
  57.   #50:fk... 18:03  |  a.p. 18/09/06
  58.   To Dimitri # 37, unposted views 18:14  |  Simon Mohammed 18/09/06
  59.   BBC Profile of Joseph Ratsinger 18:22  |  PalPal 18/09/06
  60.   Ironic reaction to prove Islam as peaceful 18:24  |  William 18/09/06
  61.   Islamic reaction. 18:26  |  David Nigel Braham 18/09/06
  62.   fk 18:43  |  Jasmine Murphy 18/09/06
  63.   Old Black Ages are no good reference 18:58  |  John 18/09/06
  64.   "we shall break the cross.." the irony of it all 19:00  |  Wolfman 18/09/06
  65.   efraim #42 19:07  |  seeing eye 18/09/06
  66.   So Ironical 19:07  |  Mike 18/09/06
  67.   Read the Koran 19:18  |  Sol 18/09/06
  68.   Sydney archbishop 19:31  |  Ali 18/09/06
  69.   its a good one on muslims 19:42  |  arthur 18/09/06
  70.   Dimitris #19 19:45  |  Abu Umar 18/09/06
  71.   The Pope was on target 19:58  |  Steve 18/09/06
  72.   But the Catholics have done that, Ali #63 20:08  |  Yaakov Sullivan 18/09/06
  73.   Pope protests 20:11  |  Chris 18/09/06
  74.   to seeing eye 20:12  |  Efraim 18/09/06
  75.   Sol 20:12  |  Paul 18/09/06
  76.   to Ziad 20:12  |  Efraim 18/09/06
  77.   It is an Educational lecture - more for Catholics than Muslims 20:14  |  BP 18/09/06
  78.   Be Careful, Sol #63 20:16  |  Yaakov Sullivan 18/09/06
  79.   #60 20:20  |  oh dear 18/09/06
  80.   from bbc we site 20:26  |  what 18/09/06
  81.   single mindedness 20:29  |  john 18/09/06
  82.   PalPal, RE Galileo 20:44  |  Jake 18/09/06
  83.   Popes Comments 20:47  |  drew 18/09/06
  84.   Ah, the Chinese as well! 20:52  |  Karl 18/09/06
  85.