Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., October 01, 2006 Tishrei 9, 5767 | | Israel Time: 14:07 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Recognize the PA government
By Danny Rubinstein

Despite the rising tension this past weekend between Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas and the Hamas movement, it is safe to assume that soon a government of national unity will be formed in the PA. Actually, the Palestinians have no other option but to establish such a government, in order to try and lift the political-economic siege imposed on the Hamas government, and in effect on the entire PA, by most of the world's governments.

It has been seven months since most of the PA's workers - some 160,000 people providing a living to support nearly a million souls - have last been paid, even partially. The Palestinian economy has long since become one of beggars. The public services, primarily health and education, which have more or less been functioning, are progressively deteriorating. Strikes have prevented the start of the school year.

The political agenda of the Palestinians' national unity government does not meet the three familiar demands of the Quartet and the international community. That is the truth of the matter.

Advertisement

The first demand is to recognize the State of Israel, but instead the draft of the new Palestinian government's guidelines states that it "recognizes the political reality of the region." Even chairman Abbas said that this recognition was not clear; over the weekend he defined it as a "recognition by inference" of Israel. According to these guidelines (the majority of which are based on the so-called prisoners' document), the Palestinian government also does meet the second demand: the adoption of past international accords and agreements. Instead it is written that the government accepts the accords and agreements which serve the Palestinian interest. In this way, it will always be possible for someone to argue that the past agreements are harmful to Palestinian interests. Even regarding the third demand, a total cessation of violence, the new Palestinian government announces that resistance will continue in the occupied territories - the West Bank and East Jerusalem.

Yet, nevertheless, the Israeli government should recognize this government, negotiate and try to enter into a political process with it. Why? The makeup of the unity government, with Hamas at its center, is clear evidence of an obvious process that the Palestinian political system is undergoing.

The Hamas movement, whose genesis is rooted in the declaration of an unconditional and total war on the State of Israel, has gradually changed. The first changes were evident in its participation in the municipal elections and the Palestinian parliamentary elections, after denouncing it for years because it said the PA was established on the basis of the Oslo Accords. Later, the Hamas government decided to interact with Israel on daily issues, and to allow the PLO and Abbas to continue the political negotiations with Israel. This government has also brought about the renewal of the cease-fire - as long as Israel does not operate in Gaza. Now they are willing to let other Palestinian factions into their government, to forfeit cabinet majority and to recognize Israel and past agreements "by inference."

The direction is therefore clear. The European countries have started to acknowledge it, and there is a fair chance that they will begin to offer aid to the new government. The Israeli government should also fall into line with this trend. Israel does not have the option of getting rid of Hamas. It is an authentic Palestinian movement, which rose to power democratically, and in fact with our approval. Abbas indeed has the authority to dissolve the Hamas government and assemble a government of professional experts. He did not do this, nor will he, since that would spell his end. He would lose the remainder of his public support, and condemn himself to be branded as the United States and Israel's stooge.

The alternative to Israeli recognition of the Palestinian unity government is to keep pressuring Hamas and chairman Abbas by a siege and a boycott. The deterioration in the West Bank, and especially in Gaza, will continue, and the violence will increase. Nothing good can come out of it.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
It's a wonderful life
Sayed Kashua takes a close look at his life and makes some New Year resolutions.
Post-fast repast
Two delicious and appropriate recipes to savor while breaking that Yom Kippur 25-hour fast.
  1.   Time, energy , life and money wasting 09:43  |  zeev 18/09/06
  2.   So much for America/Israel`s desire to emasculate Hamas 09:50  |  Clickfool 18/09/06
  3.   The World Is Waiting. 10:05  |  Peace Train 18/09/06
  4.   They changed because of pressure! 10:12  |  Curious 18/09/06
  5.   A small land 10:34  |  JW 18/09/06
  6.   Clickfool, You Fool 10:36  |  Haifa 18/09/06
  7.   Zeev of Geneva 10:53  |  GSW 18/09/06
  8.   Mr. Rubinstein...You Are Putting the Devil Out of His Job 11:02  |  Klaudia 18/09/06
  9.   6) You should also recognise the refugees` right 11:05  |  zeev 18/09/06
  10.   Danny Rubinstein 11:09  |  Julian Marc 18/09/06
  11.   7) Yes I read about events... Zionists destroyed 380 villages 11:23  |  zeev 18/09/06
  12.   For Haifa 11:25  |  Clickfool 18/09/06
  13.   #11, you are so right 11:57  |  PEACE ON EARTH ? 18/09/06
  14.   To Haifa #6 12:01  |  Amoz 18/09/06
  15.   #4 Such a typical attitude.... 12:30  |  Johnboy 18/09/06
  16.   #6 Haifa 12:36  |  Johnboy 18/09/06
  17.   ISRAEL demanded the quartet conditions from Hamas.It is working 12:39  |  PETER SM 18/09/06
  18.   Why must Israel be the Village Idiot? 13:21  |  Bennie 18/09/06
  19.   Its time for peace,time for truth 13:22  |  Ronnie Wolman 18/09/06
  20.   JOHNBOY RE.Typical attitude. Ignore anything Hamas says or does 13:59  |  PETER SM 18/09/06
  21.   If Israel recognizes the governent 14:17  |  Mark Lincoln 18/09/06
  22.   #20 PETER SM and his spin 14:19  |  Johnboy 18/09/06
  23.   Palestinian Poll 14:38  |  cindyanna 18/09/06
  24.   Hamas and Haider 14:41  |  Seth Greenberg 18/09/06
  25.   Mark Lincoln`s brilliant comments 14:45  |  Curious 18/09/06
  26.   Johnboy 14:47  |  Proud Zionist 18/09/06
  27.   To Zeev 14:50  |  Curious 18/09/06
  28.   Recognize Israel 14:52  |  David Kass 18/09/06
  29.   BELIEVING IN A LIE WILL CAUSE THE SHEDDING OF MORE INNOCENT BLOOD 14:56  |  Bill. 18/09/06
  30.   Dancing with the devil never ends well!!! 15:00  |  Timothy 18/09/06
  31.   #27 15:07  |  Cindyanna 18/09/06
  32.   The same left-wing, Haaretz Oslo Psychotic thinking 15:10  |  Yakov 18/09/06
  33.   For David Kass #27 15:11  |  Clickfool 18/09/06
  34.   #25 Proud Zionist wants his lapdogs 15:13  |  Johnboy 18/09/06
  35.   For Proud Zionist, on Gimme Israel 15:14  |  Clickfool 18/09/06
  36.   For Curious 15:17  |  Clickfool 18/09/06
  37.   For Peter SM, who can`t read 15:21  |  Clickfool 18/09/06
  38.   66% of pals feels that Hamas should not recognise Israel 15:26  |  Infidel 18/09/06
  39.   1st reconize the creator of the world 16:11  |  Sam 18/09/06
  40.   Please retire Mr. Rubinstein Forty years of lokhshim are enough 16:26  |  Shalom Freedman 18/09/06
  41.   Curious 16:45  |  Mark Lincoln 18/09/06
  42.   Clickfool - 1947 16:48  |  Mark Lincoln 18/09/06
  43.   Does the term moral hazard mean anything? 17:02  |  bruce 18/09/06
  44.   How about this 17:05  |  danite 18/09/06
  45.   Hey Proud Zionist! 17:06  |  Danite 18/09/06
  46.   For Sam 17:16  |  Clickfool 18/09/06
  47.   Mark Lincoln 17:19  |  Danite 18/09/06
  48.   Clikfool 17:21  |  Danite 18/09/06
  49.   Mark Lincoln - The Clintons 17:21  |  Ernie 18/09/06
  50.   For Mark Lincoln on the 1947 UN Partition Plan 17:25  |  Clickfool 18/09/06
  51.   Which government 17:43  |  Choni 18/09/06
  52.   Mark Lincoln 17:58  |  Danite 18/09/06
  53.   Clikfool-- show your evenhandness 18:09  |  Daniel 18/09/06
  54.   Partition Plan(s) 18:17  |  Ernie 18/09/06
  55.   PA 18:25  |  Mark 18/09/06
  56.   #39 Sam 18:29  |  Ayalin Baal 18/09/06
  57.   Ernie 18:30  |  Danite 18/09/06
  58.   Hey Proud zionist 18:32  |  Danite 18/09/06
  59.   Nothing Good can come of Recognizing Hate and Jihad 19:00  |  B 18/09/06
  60.   Hey Danite 19:03  |  Ernie 18/09/06
  61.   #43 #48 The land was given to the Jews 19:05  |  Sam 18/09/06
  62.   If Hammas does renounce violence, then what? 19:13  |  H50 18/09/06
  63.   israel will only be recognising reality 19:13  |  ravi 18/09/06
  64.   38... infidel 19:20  |  ravi 18/09/06
  65.   There was NO INTIFADA, when Israel had FIRM leaders. 19:47  |  Vittorio 18/09/06
  66.   Pal refugees for jewish refugees 19:59  |  Jabadini 18/09/06
  67.   Hamas will never change its their religous belief 20:03  |  Jabadini 18/09/06
  68.   To Curiots in Boston 20:05  |  Lebanese in Canada 18/09/06
  69.   Someone tell me how many pals have died of starvation???? 20:05  |  Jabadini 18/09/06
  70.   Hamas Charter calls for killing Jews. Would you recognize that? 20:08  |  David 18/09/06
  71.   Clickfool hamas never said they would recognise 20:09  |  Jabadini 18/09/06
  72.   Clickfool even Koran talks about how Israel is the jewish land 20:12  |  Jabadini 18/09/06
  73.   #59, I only recognize Jordan as an Arab Palestine, what about you 20:14  |  David 18/09/06
  74.   Sam, #57 20:15  |  Dave 18/09/06
  75.   Palestinian instituations teach hatred towards west and jews 20:15  |  Jabadini 18/09/06
  76.   #9, Zeev do you recognize 1 million Jewish refugees? 20:20  |  David 18/09/06
  77.   Ernie Hello 20:28  |  Danite 18/09/06
  78.   Poor Johnboy doesn`t get it 20:37  |  Proud Zionist 18/09/06
  79.   ClickFOOL 20:39  |  Proud Zionist 18/09/06