Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., September 18, 2006 Elul 25, 5766 | | Israel Time: 09:33 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 13:40 14/09/2006
IAEA: U.S. report on Iran's nuclear plan 'outrageous and dishonest'
By Yossi Melman, Haaretz Correspondent and Reuters

VIENNA - UN inspectors have protested to the U.S. government and a Congressional committee about a report on Iran's nuclear work, calling parts of it "outrageous and dishonest," according to a letter obtained by Reuters.

The letter said the errors suggested Iran's nuclear fuel program was much more advanced than a series of IAEA reports and Washington's own intelligence assessments have determined.

IAEA spokeswoman Melissa Fleming said: "We felt obliged to put the record straight with regard to the facts on what we have reported on Iran. It's a matter of the integrity of the IAEA."

Advertisement

The letter said the report falsely described Iran to have enriched uranium at its pilot centrifuge plant to weapons-grade level in April, whereas IAEA inspectors had made clear Iran had enriched only to a low level usable for nuclear power reactor fuel.

The U.S. has also said that mass quantities of uranium gas await enrichment, which would ultimately be used for the construction of some 40 nuclear bombs.

"Furthermore, the IAEA Secretariat takes strong exception to the incorrect and misleading assertion" that the IAEA opted to remove a senior safeguards inspector for supposedly concluding the purpose of Iran's programme was to build weapons, it said.

The letter said the congressional report contained "an outrageous and dishonest suggestion" that the inspector was dumped for having not adhered to an alleged IAEA policy barring its "officials from telling the whole truth" about Iran.

The letter recalled clashes between the IAEA and the Bush administration before the 2003 Iraq war over findings cited by Washington about Iraqi weapons of mass destruction that proved false, and underlined continued tensions over Iran's dossier.

"This (committee report) is deja vu of the pre-Iraq war period where the facts are being maligned and attempts are being made to ruin the integrity of IAEA inspectors," said a Western diplomat familiar with the agency and IAEA-U.S. relations.

Sent to the head of the House of Representatives' Select Committee on Intelligence by a senior aide to International Atomic Energy Agency chief Mohamed ElBaradei, the letter said an Aug. 23 committee report contained serious distortions of IAEA findings on Iran's activity.

Diplomats say the inspector remains IAEA Iran section head.

The IAEA has been inspecting Iran's nuclear program since 2003. Although it has found no hard evidence that Iran is working on atomic weapons, it has uncovered many previously concealed activities linked to uranium enrichment, a process of purifying fuel for nuclear power plants or weapons.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Soccer ban lifted
UEFA lifts ban on home matches in Israel a month after the end of the Lebanon war.
MDA Mafia
Magen David Adom attempts to replace its workers' committee by intimidating employees.
  1.   Oh dear, UN nuclear inspectors distance themselves from US lies 13:28  |  Clickfool 14/09/06
  2.   After Iraq, US is now spoon-feeding lies about Iran 13:38  |  Isaac Hassen 14/09/06
  3.   clickfool? just a fool... 13:43  |  mark 14/09/06
  4.   Impermeable Clickfool (an answer for Mark) 14:00  |  Brant 14/09/06
  5.   The world has become fed up with US 14:05  |  Adel 14/09/06
  6.   Mark the Capacity 14:12  |  Hanoman 14/09/06
  7.   Brant, what`s wrong with what Clickfool said? 14:12  |  Michael 14/09/06
  8.   #3 14:13  |  Nuclear plan 14/09/06
  9.   Lies lies and damned lies 14:15  |  Chris Linthwaite 14/09/06
  10.   IAEA underestimating Iran 14:16  |  zionist forever 14/09/06
  11.   great satan indeed 14:20  |  Amir 14/09/06
  12.   For Mark in London 14:23  |  Clickfool 14/09/06
  13.   For my pal Brant, in Hilton Head 14:26  |  Clickfool 14/09/06
  14.   Sussex ? 14:28  |  Kym 14/09/06
  15.   #2 --- Not too far off 14:30  |  PR 14/09/06
  16.   Cheney Redux 14:34  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/09/06
  17.   Are the Americans that stupid or fear-struck? 14:37  |  Mark B. 14/09/06
  18.   Brant #4 Attaack of character is hardly dialogue 14:40  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/09/06
  19.   Here We Go Again Fabricating a Case 14:42  |  Karim 14/09/06
  20.   Clickfool from Sussex 14:50  |  Adel 14/09/06
  21.   If Israel joins the American fascists on Iran, then it 14:52  |  Mark B. 14/09/06
  22.   For Kym 14:57  |  Clickfool 14/09/06
  23.   better safe than sorry 14:57  |  Harry 14/09/06
  24.   #3 I told him yesterday to try to go beyond one line graffiti ! 14:57  |  Michael 14/09/06
  25.   Clickfool: Help us resurrect Dur Sturmer 14:58  |  Streicher 14/09/06
  26.   #4 - you can read much more into one line posts than I can ! 15:05  |  Michael 14/09/06
  27.   #5: The world is JEALOUS of the USA!! 15:07  |  Yaakov K. 14/09/06
  28.   Idea let Iran go nuclear and then nuke it!!!!!! 15:14  |  arthur 14/09/06
  29.   Mobile Labs 15:14  |  John DOWN THE WALL 14/09/06
  30.   #11: Be glad it`s America you`re facing 15:16  |  Yaakov K. 14/09/06
  31.   Thank god they have more B.. than the UN 15:20  |  fatima 14/09/06
  32.   You mean like the IAEA statement Iraq had no program in`91? 15:21  |  David Teich 14/09/06
  33.   If Iran Has To Foreswear Nuclear Weapons, then Does Israel... 15:38  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/09/06
  34.   The boy who cried "wolf" 15:39  |  alanM 14/09/06
  35.   #23 15:47  |  Maziar 14/09/06
  36.   IAEA highly recommended 15:49  |  Kym 14/09/06
  37.   Well the US supports IDF terrorism 15:59  |  Stephen Murray 14/09/06
  38.   Another Spin Doctor pls? 16:02  |  Tarif-es-Zaid. 14/09/06
  39.   To lies, lies, and damned lies: 16:05  |  Ray 14/09/06
  40.   Iraq II 16:10  |  Hamannah 14/09/06
  41.   Maybe Powell can read the report at the UN... 16:14  |  John 14/09/06
  42.   We`ve seen this before in 2002-3 and in the `30s 16:23  |  George 14/09/06
  43.   great satan indeed?? 16:25  |  yo 14/09/06
  44.   The same lies from the same guys 16:25  |  Mark Lincoln 14/09/06
  45.   Remember 16:28  |  Mark Lincoln 14/09/06
  46.   What about highly enriched uranium traces ? 16:42  |  Julien 14/09/06
  47.   Yaakov K. in Eretz Yisrael 16:54  |  Cynic 14/09/06
  48.   I will not support attacking or harassing Iran. 17:08  |  Timothy 14/09/06
  49.   America is not true deemocracy. 17:10  |  Steve 14/09/06
  50.   to yaakov 17:14  |  nasser 14/09/06
  51.   Iran bought nukes from Pakistan 18:18  |  Jack 14/09/06
  52.   If we are so bad 18:59  |  Noel 14/09/06
  53.   George 19:27  |  Richard Sharp 14/09/06
  54.   49: Steve, my child, there`s no true democracy 19:27  |  David Teich 14/09/06
  55.   Amir #11 is either blind or a raging hypacrite 19:37  |  Chris 14/09/06
  56.   Well said Noel 19:41  |  Chris 14/09/06
  57.   dsm 20:13  |  Kalle 14/09/06
  58.   to David Teich 20:42  |  Steve 14/09/06
  59.   55. 20:55  |  Steve 14/09/06
  60.   This is how the US did it for the past 5 years (2nd try) 21:00  |  MS 14/09/06
  61.   US/Iran 21:16  |  Rachel 14/09/06
  62.   Steve 21:21  |  Chris 14/09/06
  63.   US is not a democracy 21:34  |  Travis 14/09/06
  64.   62. Chris 21:47  |  Steve 14/09/06
  65.   #5 22:16  |  Karla 14/09/06
  66.   Who are we to say? 22:16  |  ConcernedAmerican 14/09/06
  67.   U.S. Report 22:56  |  P. J. Casey 14/09/06
  68.   Steve 23:08  |  Chris 14/09/06
  69.   US Iran Report 03:41  |  devin 15/09/06
  70.   what is your definition of public good? 15:08  |  Noel 15/09/06
  71.   DEJA VU 00:59  |  Knave Dave 16/09/06
  72.   # 71 18:11  |  DSM 16/09/06
  73.   to Yakov K. in Eretz 23:58  |  Joseph 17/09/06
  74.   58: You`ve yet to shown the fraud is systematic or biased 08:38  |  David Teich 18/09/06
  75.   68: Chris, of course he doesn`t understand sarcasm 08:42  |  David Teich 18/09/06
  76.   63: Travis, and Shrub didn`t stay there either 08:46  |  David Teich 18/09/06
 Today Online
Danny Rubinstein: Recognize the PA government
Send response
Ala Hlehel: Azmi Bishara, enemy of the people
Send response
Daniel Ben Simon: Far-right nightmare hovers over France
Send response
Israel must work out a way of living with the Arabs on this land
Responses: 158
Will we see a shift in U.S. policy on Israel?
Responses: 68
Rosner's Domain
* New poll: Was the Papal apology sufficient?
* The Ethiopian roller coaster: can you decide already?
* U.S. diplomats begin viewing Lebanon war as success
* A dialog with Charles Bronfman


More Headlines
07:28 Probe: MI knew Hezbollah was about to nab troops
08:22 Israel signals caution over reports Shalit to be freed soon
09:29 Winograd Committee to begin probe of Lebanon war Monday
08:05 Report: Militants freed from Israeli jails are behind 14 attacks
08:54 China to increase presence in Lebanon to 1,000 troops
04:32 U.S. security official: Improving Gaza commerce is essential
07:49 IDF arrests ten wanted militants across West Bank in overnight raids
08:20 Australian Muslim clerics vow to keep away from violence, militancy
05:22 Police investigators probing Katsav to present AG with findings
05:29 Critics respond to police, prosecution's handling of Ramon affair
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Nahal Haredi
Defending Israel's homeland. Help support our troops
EZER MIZION
Help those that need it most!
One year MBA in Israel
Taught entirely in English
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
JOIN FREE AT JDate.com
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
ISRAEL-SHOPS ONLINE STORE
Gifts from Israel + FREE ISRAELI FLAG ON EVERY PURCHASE OVER $50
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
FREE REGISTRATION at JLove.com
Join The Fastest Growing Jewish Singles Community Now! Click Here!
Babylon 6
Text Translation at a single click, from any desktop application. Try it Now
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved