Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., September 17, 2006 Elul 24, 5766 | | Israel Time: 16:55 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 17:38 14/09/2006
Hezbollah lawmaker says group targeted civilians only in reprisal
By Yossi Melman, Haaretz Correspondent and DPA

Hezbollah acknowledged targeting civilians in rocket attacks on Israel, but said it fired in response to Israeli attacks - rejecting an Amnesty International report Thursday that accused the guerrillas of "serious violations of international humanitarian law, amounting to war crimes."

Lebanese legislator Hassan Fadlallah of Hezbollah said his group targeted civilians in Israeli cities in response to Israeli attacks that killed Lebanese civilians.

During the conflict, Hezbollah fired nearly 4,000 rockets into northern Israel, killing 43 civilians, seriously injuring 33 others and forcing hundreds of thousands of civilians to take refuge in shelters or flee.

Advertisement

"We do not deny that we have bombarded Israeli cities, settlements and infrastructure. But this was always a reaction," he told Al-Jazeera television. "It was a natural reaction. When a state is invaded, it must defend itself."

Fadlallah said Amnesty International probably came under American and Israeli pressure to issue a report critical of Hezbollah's actions during the 34-day war, after issuing a similar report against Israel last month.

The London-based human rights group issued a call for a United Nations inquiry into war crimes possibly committed on both sides, but Thursday's report focused on the actions of the Lebanese militants during the conflict.

The firing of rockets into urban areas in northern Israel violated international laws that call for distinction between civilian and military targets, Amnesty said.

"Targeting civilians is a war crime. There's no gray area," said Larry Cox, Amnesty's executive director in the United States.

But Fadlallah rejected the charges.

"The act was begun by Israel," he said. "How could we confront the Israeli aggression? With roses? The resistance (Hezbollah) said that the bombardment of Haifa was in response to the bombardment of Dahiyeh (Beirut's southern suburbs)."

Haifa, Israel's third largest city, was one of Hezbollah's prime targets during the fighting. Israeli air raids repeatedly hit Dahiyeh, Hezbollah's major stronghold, where Hezbollah leader Sheik Hassan Nasrallah and other officials had their homes and offices.

The report is Amnesty's most extensive condemnation of Hezbollah since the conflict began in July, and comes after Amnesty accused Israel of violating international law with indiscriminate and disproportionate attacks on civilian targets in Lebanon.

The human rights group previously called on Hezbollah to release two kidnapped Israeli soldiers, whose July 12 capture sparked the fighting, and abstain from targeting civilians.

The report indicates that international law forbids the targeting of civilians and reprisals.

Approximately a quarter of all rockets were fired directly into urban areas, including rockets packed with thousands of metal ball bearings.

"The scale of Hezbollah's attacks on Israeli cities, towns and villages, the indiscriminate nature of the weapons used, and statements from the leadership confirming their intent to target civilians make it all too clear that Hezbollah violated the laws of war," Amnesty International's Secretary General Irene Khan said in a comment on the report.

"The fact that Israel has also committed serious violations in no way justifies violations by Hezbollah. Civilians must not be made to pay the price for unlawful conduct on either side."

Combined with its earlier publication on Israel's targeting of Lebanese civilian infrastructure, the latest findings underlined the urgent need for the United Nations to establish a full and impartial investigation into violations committed by both sides.

The Amnesty report on Israel was severely criticized in Israel and by Jewish groups abroad, who accused the organization of bias. These same critics maintain that Amnesty should have waited and issued the two reports simultaneously.

Haaretz learned that the decision on the timing of the report's release was made in London.

The director of the Amnesty International office in Tel Aviv, Amnon Yarden, will present Haifa Mayor Yona Yahav with a copy of the report Thursday.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Bon(ito) appetit!
Nothing goes better in sashimi than this salty little relative of the tuna.
Eating Well
There's a tendency to isolate an element and use it in the expectation of a miracle.
  1.   AS well they should..... 02:50  |  T A Sheppard 14/09/06
  2.   LETS NOT FORGET THE BUENOS AIRES BOMBING! 03:01  |  A JEW 14/09/06
  3.   what does one expect,,, 03:36  |  alan 14/09/06
  4.   hmm does the leb govt agree with this?? 03:44  |  vik 14/09/06
  5.   Amnesty International and Hezbollah 03:50  |  Dunjam 14/09/06
  6.   HIZBALLAHS EXISTENCE IS A VIOLATION OF HUMANITARIAN LAW 03:57  |  Mitch Iginer 14/09/06
  7.   Hezbollah care less about amnesty report 03:57  |  Joseph E . 14/09/06
  8.   RE: #1 04:32  |  Well Said 14/09/06
  9.   erratum 04:53  |  Yechezkel 14/09/06
  10.   Buenos Aires bombing 04:53  |  Jorge Schussheim 14/09/06
  11.   #2 Buenos Aires 04:55  |  Johnboy 14/09/06
  12.   I guess Amnesty is swell now? 04:55  |  Int`l community 14/09/06
  13.   #5 Dunham - Typical twisting of reality 04:58  |  David 14/09/06
  14.   RE 5 Biased response 05:02  |  Alan (the original) 14/09/06
  15.   Firing from civilian areas 05:03  |  Steven 14/09/06
  16.   Firing from civilian areas 05:04  |  Steven 14/09/06
  17.   You want `moral equivalence`? 05:08  |  Hank N Tennessee 14/09/06
  18.   what about israel?? 05:21  |  Anoymous 14/09/06
  19.   Whose to blame: Israel? Hizbollah? 06:02  |  Dave 14/09/06
  20.   I as Muslim and as Lebanese respect the finding. 06:06  |  gus 14/09/06
  21.   TA sheppard, thank you and God bless you 06:08  |  gus 14/09/06
  22.   Israeli officials initiated civil targetting first. 06:10  |  Robert 14/09/06
  23.   Where are all the angry and outraged Talkback posters? 06:11  |  Timothy 14/09/06
  24.   to Number two, 06:16  |  gus 14/09/06
  25.   Too bad none of thier followers can read this 06:17  |  Frank 14/09/06
  26.   Alan, IAF are also cowerds 06:21  |  gus 14/09/06
  27.   Jorge, that was shameful and this muslim denounce it 06:22  |  gus 14/09/06
  28.   TWO WRONG DO NOT MAKE A RIGHT. 06:28  |  Loyal Lebanese 14/09/06
  29.   David IT IS TYPICAL! 06:31  |  Frank 14/09/06
  30.   !!! READ THE FACTS !!! 06:31  |  Loyal Lebanese 14/09/06
  31.   What was the role of the government of Lebanon? 06:35  |  Ish Shalom 14/09/06
  32.   #1 I SALUTE YOU 06:37  |  Loyal Lebanese 14/09/06
  33.   Proportionality 06:42  |  Victor 14/09/06
  34.   (2) HIZBALLAHS EXISTENCE IS A VIOLATION OF HUMANITARIAN 06:47  |  Daniel 14/09/06
  35.   This was only an afterthought on their part 06:59  |  Dani 14/09/06
  36.   Lebanon is missing from the report! 06:59  |  Avraham Golan 14/09/06
  37.   COMEDY INTERNATIONAL:HEZBOLLA FIRED 3750 KATYSHAS AT CIVILIANS AI 07:10  |  -VOICE of MOSHIACH)) 14/09/06
  38.   #7 Joseph E ...Who`s pointing the finger? 07:13  |  maoriboy 14/09/06
  39.   Dave your statment is not true 07:17  |  gus 14/09/06
  40.   Jokers at Amnesty have no credibility after Israel report 07:31  |  not fooled at all 14/09/06
  41.   Let us not Forget Sabra & Shatila Massacre 07:57  |  Bill 14/09/06
  42.   Talk about diconnected from reality 08:10  |  Marilyn 14/09/06
  43.   That`s nice Gus, that said 08:20  |  Jacob Blues 14/09/06
  44.   #16 You``ve read the report, of course? 08:20  |  Johnboy 14/09/06
  45.   To # 13 Dave, Cnada is near North Pole not Hezbollah 08:22  |  Stevenson 14/09/06
  46.   When everybody is guilty, no one is 08:29  |  Danny - Israeli one 14/09/06
  47.   Worthless report, Amnesty still ignores the cassus belli 08:30  |  Jacob Blues 14/09/06
  48.   Wonder what Kofi thinks of this report 08:33  |  Dale 14/09/06
  49.   #5 and this post, Haaretz, is why reports need to checked 08:39  |  Danny - Israeli one 14/09/06
  50.   WHERE Is the INSTANT VITRIOL&INSULTS that would be at Israel 08:45  |  PETER. S.M 14/09/06
  51.   #7 to joseph e.. who`s pointing the finger? 08:52  |  maoriboy 14/09/06
  52.   voice of moshiach 09:02  |  ralpf 14/09/06
  53.   to Voice of Moshiach, 09:12  |  gus 14/09/06
  54.   Announce it the war that ended all wars 09:30  |  Smith 14/09/06
  55.   To Jacob Blues No. 21 - When the Time Comes 09:34  |  Karim 14/09/06
  56.   #23- I have read the report, and also see that it`s way too late 09:38  |  Dani 14/09/06
  57.   # 19 Maoriboy , hezbollah`s arguments are Rebuted by Amnesty 09:39  |  Joseph E . 14/09/06
  58.   Amnesty International is now fair 09:47  |  Willy 14/09/06
  59.   Gus and T A Sheppard 09:47  |  Maral 14/09/06
  60.   Amnesty International is 09:50  |  Realist 14/09/06
  61.   Okay, SO What`s NEXT ??? 09:54  |  Sandra 14/09/06
  62.   Answer to number 33. 10:01  |  David Nigel Braham 14/09/06
  63.   # 20 .What`s a Moshiach anyway???? 10:05  |  Sandra 14/09/06
  64.   To Gus and T A Sheppard 10:12  |  Maral 14/09/06
  65.   To the "Voice" 10:16  |  Maral 14/09/06
  66.   War Criminals to stand trial by ICC 10:21  |  Miriam 14/09/06
  67.   Amnesty under fire? some people cannot be pleased 10:30  |  Mario 14/09/06
  68.   Amnesty International 10:33  |  NEUTERED OBSERVER 14/09/06
  69.   MAORIBOY Re Ponting finger.Re Apologists for Islamic terror 10:40  |  PETER SM 14/09/06
  70.   #50 Joseph E - being selective, don`t you think? 10:44  |  Johnboy 14/09/06
  71.   maoriboy-#35-leave Israel alone 10:46  |  Daniel Leopold 14/09/06
  72.   Zionesty International ! 10:48  |  Lebanese citizen 14/09/06
  73.   Sandra, about the "Voice" 10:55  |  Maral 14/09/06
  74.   To # 29 10:56  |  Ish Shalom 14/09/06
  75.   #14 hank of tennessee 10:59  |  spud 14/09/06
  76.   who is guiltyof war crimes?? 11:04  |  gary 14/09/06
  77.   maral xdural? sounds like a contraceptive 11:11  |  thucydides 14/09/06
  78.   Jorge Shussheim (Post No. 2) 11:17  |  Johnny Weintraub 14/09/06
  79.   Hezbollah DID instrumentalize lebanese civilians 11:19  |  Julien 14/09/06
  80.   HEZBOLLAH DID NOT HIDE IN CIVILIANS 11:20  |  Marilyn 14/09/06
  81.   thucydides 11:21  |  Maral 14/09/06
  82.   Bill (Post No. 38) 11:22  |  Johnny Weintraub 14/09/06
  83.   maral is so humorous 11:25  |  thucydides 14/09/06
  84.   a jew and the buenos aires bombing 11:28  |  shylock 14/09/06
  85.   #8 Well Said 11:31  |  ChanahS 14/09/06
  86.   # 9 Erratum 11:32  |