Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., December 25, 2006 Tevet 4, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:05 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The problem that disappeared
By Haaretz Editorial

A month after the war in Lebanon ended, the time has come to ask what the Olmert government has to offer, now that the unilateral withdrawal plan is off the table. Beforehand, though, we must ask if more time, thought and planning is dedicated to policymaking than to coming up with a casual answer to journalists' questions. If the decision to go to war was made in a moment, in reaction to the abduction of the soldiers, it is questionable whether anyone even decided to put the realignment plan back in a drawer.

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert mentioned it in a speech, Interior Minister Roni Bar-On said the realignment was being frozen temporarily, and Shimon Peres said there would be no withdrawal from the territories in the next 10 years. The impression is that the government has lost its way.

Over the last two days, a chance rolled around for Olmert to recall the road map, in honor of British Prime Minister Tony Blair's visit. It is difficult to understand why Olmert waited for Blair's arrival to discuss a meeting with Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas (Abu Mazen) or to promise the release of prisoners, just as it is difficult to understand why the Israeli government ignored Abu Mazen and then remembered him only after Hamas had taken power. The political vacuum generated by the government leaves a wide opening for those who have a clear agenda: the Hamas military wing, which is taking control of the Gaza Strip; and the settlers, who have already announced that the cancellation of the unilateral withdrawal will lead to a push for new construction in the West Bank.

Advertisement

Everyone in the Sharon government talked about the "demographic problem" to convince people of the justness of the pullout. Now the Palestinians have been forgotten and demographics have been forgotten - all because the data can't be used for political ends. But the apartheid regime in the territories remains intact; millions of Palestinians are living without rights, freedom of movement or a livelihood, under the yoke of ongoing Israeli occupation, and in the future they will turn the Jews into a minority between the Mediterranean Sea and the Jordan River.

The unfinished separation fence has become a monument to the shortsightedness of the Israeli policy to neither swallow nor regurgitate. The fence was meant to serve the unilateral withdrawal, but it has become clear that more outposts will be erected wherever the fence has not been completed, now that the Justice Ministry has suggested "laundering" the existing illegal outposts. When we want to withdraw, we will have to contend with more settlers.

If the incumbent cabinet expands rightward to survive, it will not be able to set out a new political agenda. Even in the current situation, the cabinet does not appear capable of developing policy, only of reacting to the day's events from the gut and using force. The unilateral release of thousands of Palestinian prisoners sitting in our jails - with and without blood on their hands, with and without a trial, with and without a reason (some are held as bargaining chips) - could serve as a gesture that sets in motion a process of building mutual trust.

But that is not enough. The least we can expect from a government that does not have a better solution to offer, and that has relinquished the solution for which it was elected, is that it tries to begin speaking with whoever is willing on the other side, that it involves Europe, that it suggests bringing an international force into the region - possibly with a United Nations mandate, to at least prevent deterioration. And perhaps this will be the way toward separation into two states.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Sanctions fall short
Despite UN sanctions, Iran's President has all the support for his nuke plan at home.
Time for change
Time magazine has declared the end of the age of great people and hero-geniuses.
  1.   Red Herring: Religious Jews Have FAR More Children Than Arabs 10:43  |  Yishai Kohen 11/09/06
  2.   red herring??? 11:20  |  NE 11/09/06
  3.   There is no demographic threat, only hasbara 11:38  |  John 11/09/06
  4.   yishai kohen 11:40  |  fagin 11/09/06
  5.   haaretz editor david landau 11:43  |  fagin 11/09/06
  6.   To fagin 12:09  |  John 11/09/06
  7.   fagin, the problem is not over Gaza and SL 12:24  |  sage 11/09/06
  8.   dutch john i sent you many messages 12:28  |  fagin 11/09/06
  9.   The palastinian state. 12:29  |  Neutered Observer 11/09/06
  10.   "Haaretz editorial" is not a signature. 12:39  |  Shlomo Kolsky 11/09/06
  11.   john you have major problems with your minorities 12:51  |  isaac singer 11/09/06
  12.   Shame on you for using "apartheid" 13:08  |  careful reader 11/09/06
  13.   No problem at all - the future is clear 13:17  |  Clickfool 11/09/06
  14.   #4 fagin, fagin... don`t be so scared 13:56  |  Edurne 11/09/06
  15.   careful reader i share your views 13:58  |  thucydides 11/09/06
  16.   Unfortunate choice of words! 14:05  |  Michael II 11/09/06
  17.   Swallow or Regurgitate? 14:10  |  Darren 11/09/06
  18.   Stagnation 14:14  |  sh 11/09/06
  19.   Haaretz psychological warfare against Jews 14:18  |  Moshe 11/09/06
  20.   #13 14:20  |  Cindyanna 11/09/06
  21.   NE: "We" (Israel) in LA, CA 14:21  |  Moshe 11/09/06
  22.   Haaretz, this problem is 40 years old 14:36  |  Jeroen 11/09/06
  23.   To carefull reader 14:40  |  Jeroen 11/09/06
  24.   Orthodoxy 14:57  |  James 11/09/06
  25.   No it was not 15:06  |  Gene 11/09/06
  26.   The "Other" Demographic Reality 15:19  |  Hank N Tennessee 11/09/06
  27.   The issue is be definition racist 15:20  |  Tim 11/09/06
  28.   But There has Been an Option Offered 15:27  |  Yaakov Sullivan 11/09/06
  29.   The arabs are a 5th column 15:27  |  Ron 11/09/06
  30.   to Jeroen 15:44  |  puhi 11/09/06
  31.   James, it was part of a bargain #24 15:51  |  Yaakov Sullivan 11/09/06
  32.   Ron Advocates Ethnic Cleansing as Moral Neccesity #27 16:06  |  Yaakov Sullivan 11/09/06
  33.   Re: "Go forth and multiply" 16:25  |  Hannah 11/09/06
  34.   To Puhi 16:34  |  Jeroen 11/09/06
  35.   To Isaac Singer 16:38  |  Hannah 11/09/06
  36.   To #12, Careful Reader 16:46  |  Hannah 11/09/06
  37.   To Darren 16:53  |  Hannah 11/09/06
  38.   To Darren 16:53  |  Hannah 11/09/06
  39.   hannah you have never had a useful thing to say 17:11  |  isaac singer 11/09/06
  40.   Rights for whom?Haaretz editorial proclaims 17:14  |  Sal 11/09/06
  41.   demography and killing and reproducing 17:22  |  John the puzzled 11/09/06
  42.   "apartheid regime in the territories", thanks for the clear words 17:59  |  fritz 11/09/06
  43.   23, whatever it is, it is not the same 18:01  |  fritz 11/09/06
  44.   5, there is an "open secret", that Israel will/must go further 18:06  |  fritz 11/09/06
  45.   re :#1 18:16  |  T A Sheppard 11/09/06
  46.   To Jeroen who needs to brush up language 19:21  |  Careful Reader 11/09/06
  47.   Hannah, Right On!! for # 31 19:32  |  Yaakov Sullivan 11/09/06
  48.   Aparteid? 20:06  |  Walter 11/09/06
  49.   Haaretz should just accept Israeli left is ideologically bankrupt 20:06  |  Dudu 11/09/06
  50.   threat?? 20:08  |  H 11/09/06
  51.   Left should accept that Begin was right: Land-for-peace is a myth 20:09  |  Ron 11/09/06
  52.   Are haaretz editors still clinging to failed disengagement idea? 20:12  |  Zebedee 11/09/06
  53.   So the Arabs will be the majority? Heard it before 40 years ago 20:18  |  Joe 11/09/06
  54.   to Jeroen 20:27  |  Puhi 11/09/06
  55.   to all respondents 20:30  |  Sebastian Santa-Cruz 11/09/06
  56.   pull down the fence & release prisoners 20:34  |  zionist forever 11/09/06
  57.   Ron, on land for peace #42 20:51  |  Yaakov Sullivan 11/09/06
  58.   to haaretz:apartheid regime? 20:57  |  wake up folks 11/09/06
  59.   Another John - and the numbers 21:02  |  John 11/09/06
  60.   #17 Darren 21:06  |  Boycott 11/09/06
  61.   For Dudu 21:09  |  Clickfool 11/09/06
  62.   #31 Hannah 21:13  |  Jimmy 11/09/06
  63.   #38 Apartheid 21:22  |  Boycott 11/09/06
  64.   Good Editorial 21:25  |  Fadi 11/09/06
  65.   Haaretz with its Boogeys... 21:28  |  Buzaglo 11/09/06
  66.   Ignorant Europeans 21:47  |  David 11/09/06
  67.   Hannah, it is an old tactic.. 21:47  |  Semirana 11/09/06
  68.   Current trends, indicate, Jews sig majority next 100 years. 21:51  |  David 11/09/06
  69.   to #58, Arab Apartheid, the truth 22:03  |  David 11/09/06
  70.   Olmert`s a loser. Went to war for 2 reservists! Where are they? 22:52  |  Yossi Cronenberg 11/09/06
  71.   Demographic threat of Jews settling Israel 23:05  |  Brian Bernstein 11/09/06
  72.   To Boycot, Apartheid, Clickfool and other fools 23:27  |  Barry 11/09/06
  73.   to #2: how naive you`re! 23:51  |  USA 11/09/06
  74.   Hannah 00:24  |  Danite 12/09/06
  75.   # 59 Boycott 00:33  |  Alan 12/09/06
  76.   #16 Not just unfortunate choice of words 01:23  |  syvanen 12/09/06
  77.   Demographic threat? Is the Dead Sea salty? 01:55  |  Joe 12/09/06
  78.   Demographic threat? Is the Dead Sea salty? 02:37  |  Joe 12/09/06
  79.   Demographic threat? Is the Dead Sea salty? 03:16  |  Joe 12/09/06
  80.   Israel is on slippery slope 05:15  |  Ah 12/09/06
  81.   Israel should have a 90% Jewish Majority 05:45  |  David 12/09/06
  82.   Israel should have a 90% Jewish Majority -Part two 05:57  |  David 12/09/06
  83.   C`mon, Darren 06:46  |  Ann 12/09/06
  84.   your "us," isaac singer 06:56  |  Ann 12/09/06
  85.   #81 and 82: David 09:24  |  USA 12/09/06
  86.   David 09:37  |  Indian 12/09/06
  87.   You have a small breathing space... 12:57  |  SD 12/09/06
  88.   Its too late 16:30  |  arun 12/09/06
  89.   #49 - How can they? Haaretz is PART of the Israeli Left! 19:27  |  Yaakov K. 12/09/06
  90.   Real demographic threat - religous jews will be the majority 07:48  |  malachai 13/09/06
  91.   This editorial is being circulated as defense of Carter`s book! 19:41  |  Susie Davidson 25/12/06
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: Jews aren't supposed to love Christmas
Responses: 182
Military Intelligence: Syria serious about talks with Israel
Responses: 76
Akiva Eldar: Time to fight terror, pursue peace
Responses: 27
Editorial: Olmert-Abbas meeting was too little, too late
Responses: 55
Few foreigners mark Christmas in Bethlehem
Responses: 174


More Headlines
19:01 PM approves removal of 27 West Bank roadblocks
19:13 Military Intelligence officer: Syria serious about negotiations with Israel
19:55 IDF arrests top militant in West Bank; Qassam hits Ashkelon
17:09 U.S., European officials visit Fatah training base in Jordan
19:27 Court reviews Klagsbald appeal in death by negligence case
17:47 Ex-Shas MK Ofer Hugi convicted of embezzling state funds
17:43 Court okays Ramon request for another hearing before verdict
19:25 Labor MK calls on gov't to hasten Falash Mura immigration
11:58 Court hears appeal of Hamas MPs banned from living in J`lem
14:26 In Christmas message, Pope expresses wish to visit Holy Land
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
ZAKA
Saving those who can be saved, honouring those who cannot
GoJerusalem!
See all that Jerusalem has to Offer. Click now!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Bar Ilan University
One year MBA Taught entirely in English
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Supporting Israel's Independence
Get Israel's Independence kit - A unique and unforgettable presentation pack
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved