Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., October 10, 2006 Tishrei 18, 5767 | | Israel Time: 05:51 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Chabad doesn't recognize the State of Israel, but in former Soviet Union, it teaches Zionism
By Amiram Barkat

Ilya Pozhidayev, 13, immigrated to Israel several years ago with his parents from Lugansk, an industrial town in eastern Ukraine. However, about a year ago, employment problems forced his parents to send their only son back to Lugansk to be raised by his grandmother. The grandmother, who works for the local branch of the American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee, registered Pozhidayev at the private Jewish school Or Avner, which is run by Chabad movement rabbis, emissaries of the Federation of Jewish Communities of the CIS.

Conditions at the school are much better than at Israeli state schools. There are between 10 and 12 children per class. The school day ends at 3 P.M. in the lower grades and at 5 P.M. in the upper grades. Schooling is free and parents are not required to pay fees for such extra expenditures as school books and class trips.

In a conversation with him last week at his school, Pozhidayev said that being an Israeli gave him an edge over local students. "When they teach Hebrew or about the State of Israel, then obviously I know better than everyone, almost as much as the teachers."

Advertisement

Besides the government school program, Or Avner pupils get six to eight hours a week of studies in Hebrew, Jewish tradition and geography of the Land of Israel. The State of Israel is felt almost everywhere in the school. At the entrance to the building stands an Israeli flag, and the hallways are adorned with pictures from Israeli life - soldiers praying at the Western Wall, coffee shops in Haifa and the Eilat beach.

So striking an Israeli presence is not a negligible matter in an ultra-Orthodox non-Zionist school network. The late Lubavitcher Rebbe, Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, forbade the government to give the Arabs any part of the Land of Israel, but was careful to refrain from showing sympathy for the state and recognizing its institutions. The president of the FJC CIS, tycoon Lev Leviev, speaks cautiously when asked about the role Israel plays in the curriculum. "We teach about the Land of Israel and love of Israel because we believe it is a central part of Jewish identity," Leviev said during a visit to the school in Lugansk last week.

Leviev, himself a Chabad disciple who received the blessing of the Lubavitcher Rebbe, founded the Or Avner network in 1995 to fight assimilation in states of the former Soviet Union. "The criteria for success from our standpoint is stopping assimilation," said Or Avner Director Rabbi David Mondshine. "We will be delighted if our graduates will be religiously observant, but even if that doesn't happen it will be alright, so long as they marry Jews."

There are 14,000 Or Avner students enrolled at some 100 schools across the former Soviet Union. According to Leviev, the fathers of over 90 percent of the pupils are not Jewish. The Zionist organizations operating in the CIS, the Jewish Agency and the Nativ liaison agency, previously viewed Or Avner as a rival element that was encouraging Jews not to move to Israel. Today, some Or Avner schools have Zionism teachers who are employed by the Jewish Agency and Israeli Education Ministry.

In recent years, hundreds of Or Avner students have come to Israel on annual organized trips. The ministry program, known by its Hebrew acronym Heftziba, takes the visiting students to Jewish holy sites, but also on jeep and kayaking trips, and even to experience Bedouin hospitality.

This past year, the Jewish Agency expanded its cooperation with Or Avner to other areas. JA Chair Ze'ev Bielski likes to say that as far as he's concerned, Or Avner is a Zionist entity.

Or Avner officials explain that familiarity with Israel is the best way to strengthen the students' Jewish identity. "In the students' eyes, the Israeli flag is the most Jewish thing there is," said Rabbi Pinchas Vyshedsky, FJC-Ukraine representative to the city of Donetsk. "We were very pleased with our students' visits to Israel. The visit worked miracles in terms of their interest in Judaism and desire to belong to the Jewish community."

This is important as Or Avner schools face competition from non-Jewish private schools that have cropped up in recent years across the CIS, catering to the nouveau riche.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Heads must roll
If a leader does not take responsibility, he must be forced to do so.
Fit for the new year
How to stay on your fitness regimine after the holiday resolution wears off.
  1.   The Title Express Habad Innocent Belief 02:35  |  Joseph E . 12/09/06
  2.   Chabad doesn`t recognize the State of Israel???? 05:25  |  Yehi Ha Melej 12/09/06
  3.   HABAD does`nt regognize Israel 07:55  |  DONBOM 12/09/06
  4.   Are you sure ?! 08:15  |  Yankelowitz 12/09/06
  5.   Pleae check ! 08:18  |  Yankelowitz 12/09/06
  6.   Miracle worker 09:12  |  Yerushalimey 12/09/06
  7.   eye catching headline 09:51  |  joe 12/09/06
  8.   chabad 10:00  |  chabad chassid 12/09/06
  9.   Eretz Yisrael? - yes The State - not really 10:25  |  Physicist 12/09/06
  10.   Chabad 10:47  |  Nik Miller 12/09/06
  11.   ChaBaD 11:44  |  Moe Chile 12/09/06
  12.   Chabad`s Israeli position... 16:21  |  Nik Miller 12/09/06
  13.   ChaBad Is Cabal 16:33  |  Tomas 12/09/06
  14.   cynical and shameful headline 17:13  |  avi 12/09/06
  15.   Does not recognise Israel? Huhmmm??? 17:35  |  Thomas Caetano 12/09/06
  16.   #14 There is nothing cynical about truth 17:42  |  Tomas 12/09/06
  17.   To # 15 18:13  |  Tomas 12/09/06
  18.   chabad doesnt support israel?!!? 18:22  |  jana 12/09/06
  19.   Chabad isn`t Zionist 22:25  |  Dr. Neal 12/09/06
  20.   Haarezt hit another hot button, I guess 22:32  |  Mordant Observer 12/09/06
  21.   Chabad on Israel 22:51  |  Isaac Haskiya 12/09/06
  22.   Chabad 23:26  |  MR 12/09/06
  23.   TO: Thomas 23:44  |  Mendel 12/09/06
  24.   #19 Dr. Neal 00:42  |  Tomas 13/09/06
  25.   regarding response to #19 01:06  |  Tomas 13/09/06
  26.   pope paul visited israel, WHY NOT THE RABBI SHENERSON 07:10  |  REUVEN 13/09/06
  27.   ...cont To #21 & #22 09:04  |  Johnie 13/09/06
  28.   HAARETZ - CHECK YOUR FACTS 09:30  |  rudi 13/09/06
  29.   amiram ,come out of the 18 century!!! 13:35  |  harry 13/09/06
  30.   Chabad is not Judaism 17:45  |  Tomas 13/09/06
  31.   RE: Chabad is not Judaism 18:59  |  JB 13/09/06
  32.   To #26 19:45  |  Michoel Dobry 13/09/06
  33.   To#31 and others 21:49  |  Tomas 13/09/06
  34.   Charity and Good deeds 22:02  |  Tomas 13/09/06
  35.   Chabad is Kabbalah 22:27  |  Tomas 13/09/06
  36.   I think it`s Haaretz that doesn`t recognize Israel 22:30  |  Jake 13/09/06
  37.   What is a Jew? that is the Question. 00:12  |  Tomas 14/09/06
  38.   Haaretz manipulating public opinion again? 00:15  |  Bennie 14/09/06
  39.   Rabbi Shneerson And Israel 07:45  |  Dr. Y. Ronib 14/09/06
  40.   No Haaretz recognizes Israel ... 07:53  |  Abe Sarousi 14/09/06
  41.   Chabad on the front line 12:14  |  joel 14/09/06
  42.   Chabad on the front line 12:22  |  joel 14/09/06
  43.   chabad and judaism 13:06  |  gogo 14/09/06
  44.   RE: Chabad is Kabbalah 05:20  |  Jack 10/10/06
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: The great blood libel of September 11
Responses: 251
N. Korea says it held nuclear weapons test
Responses: 232
Danny Rubinstein: If Hamas falls, things could get even worse
Responses: 179
Avi Beker: Allen and Albright, the 'forced converts'
Responses: 74


More Headlines
03:44 Israel worried North Korea will pass nuclear know-how to Iran
04:28 Analysis: A nightmare scenario of living under a nuclear threat
03:52 Qatari FM proposes six-point plan on PA unity government
02:11 Yom Kippur War journal shows Dayan mulled abandoning Golan
01:02 Police present data on Katsav case, but do not call to indict
05:19 Education council angry over decision to upgrade Ariel College status
01:19 Assad says Syria ready for peace talks if 'impartial arbiter' found
02:31 French embassy cancels N.Y. book launch over author's Israel views
02:41 Four top doctors arrested over illegal human experimentation
22:24 Druze resident of Golan Heights arrested for praising Hezbollah while in Syria
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Nahal Haredi
Defending Israel's homeland. Help support our troops
EZER MIZION
Help those that need it most!
JOIN FREE AT JDate.com
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
ISRAEL-SHOPS ONLINE STORE
Gifts from Israel + FREE ISRAELI FLAG ON EVERY PURCHASE OVER $50
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
One year MBA in Israel
Taught entirely in English
FREE REGISTRATION at JLove.com
Join The Fastest Growing Jewish Singles Community Now! Click Here!
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved