Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., September 10, 2006 Elul 17, 5766 | | Israel Time: 03:30 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate
Shopping
 
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A still image of Ron Arad taken from footage aired this week on Lebanese and Israeli television. (Channel 10)
Last update - 13:22 09/09/2006
German FM: It is premature for talks on release of 2 IDF soldiers
By Jack Khoury, Haaretz Correspondent

German Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier said Friday it was premature to talk of negotiations for the release of two Israel Defense Forces soldiers abducted by Hezbollah in July, but said Germany would be prepared to help in mediation if asked.

Speaking at a joint news conference with Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni in Tel Aviv, Steinmeier said he had raised the issue of abducted soldiers Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev with Lebanese officials.

The abduction of the soldiers in a cross-border raid sparked 34 days of bitter fighting between Israel and Hezbollah. Three other soldiers were killed in the attack, and five more died in an initial rescue operation.

Advertisement

"In my talks with the government in Lebanon I discussed this issue of the abductees," he said, speaking in German translated into Hebrew. "I don't know if the time is ripe, here in Israel and in Lebanon to start the process, but if we are asked to help we would be interested in doing so."

He did not elaborate.

Germany's intelligence chief, Ernst Uhrlau, who helped mediate a 2004 prisoner swap between Israel and Hezbollah, visited Lebanon last week but details of his trip were not made public.

Earlier Friday, a senior Hezbollah official said the group will not release the two soldiers unless Israel frees a Lebanese terrorist jailed for the 1979 murders of four people in Nahariya, a senior official of the group said Friday.

In an interview to the Nazareth-based newspaper A-Sinara published Friday, Mahmoud Kamati said that if a prisoner exchange was to be carried in stages, Israel had to ensure that Samir Kuntar was freed in the first stage, as his release had been one of the aims of the abduction of the two soldiers.

Kuntar led the group of terrorists who broke into a Nahariya apartment and took hostage Danny Haran, 28, and his four-year-old daughter, Einat. The two were later killed by the terrorists.

A policeman was also killed in the attack, and Haran's two-year-old daughter was accidentally smothered by her mother who held a hand across her mouth so that she would not give them away as they hid from the terrorists.

Kamati also said that the soldiers would not be released with negotiations between Israel and Hezbollah. He added that although United Nations Secretary-General Kofi Annan had expressed support for indirect negotiations between the sides, Hezbollah had yet to receive a formal approach from the UN.

Regarding the broadcast of a film showing missing Israel Air Force navigator Ron Arad, aired by Lebanese and Israeli television, Kamati said that Hezbollah had no fresh information on the issue and that the footage did not indicate a breakthrough in news on the airman's fate.

The clip of Arad was shown as part of a Lebanese program about prisoner exchanges between Hezbollah and Israel, which also included footage of the abduction of three IDF soldiers in October 2000. Israel received the bodies of the three soldiers in a January 2004 prisoner swap. Hezbollah also returned kidnapped Israeli businessman Elhanan Tennenbaum as part of the deal.

Kamati said that Hezbollah did not have a hand in the release of the footage, and that the decision to air the video had been made by producers alone. He stressed that while Hezbollah had supplied footage to the director, it had not played a role in the editing of the program.

Related articles:

  • Hezbollah: No deal without Kuntar (10/11/03)
  • Free the monster Samir Kuntar (04/09/06)

  • Bookmark to del.icio.us
    Family Affair
    Yafit and Noga, both disabled, have an independent lifestyle with Hirosha's help.
    Kicking the coffee habit
    A friend of mine decided to kick his habit after drinking 14 cups a day for eight years.
      1.   Proof of Life 16:12  |  J K 08/09/06
      2.   Israel Don`t Do It! 16:40  |  Sam The Sham 08/09/06
      3.   No way! 16:42  |  Michael 08/09/06
      4.   judging from past actions 16:52  |  Harry 08/09/06
      5.   Kintar? 16:59  |  Leb 08/09/06
      6.   gitmo 17:02  |  vik 08/09/06
      7.   What about releasing Jonathan Pollard 17:03  |  Avrum 08/09/06
      8.   Let this be the learning lesson for all 17:03  |  rick 08/09/06
      9.   if you do release 17:07  |  ross 08/09/06
      10.   Different values of life 17:07  |  ScotGuy 08/09/06
      11.   The Release of the 2 Soldiers is the Hands 17:11  |  Joseph E . 08/09/06
      12.   HOW MANY PEOPLE ON THE PLANET COULD SMASH A CHILDS HEAD IN ???? 17:12  |  Mitch Iginer 08/09/06
      13.   Post #2 the Release of the Prisonners 17:13  |  Joseph E . 08/09/06
      14.   Kutnar solution 17:15  |  Learsi 08/09/06
      15.   Hezbollah official: We won`t free soldiers: Keep The Blockade 17:17  |  Steve 08/09/06
      16.   Free Him 17:17  |  Adam 08/09/06
      17.   Re: Kuntar and other murderers. DISPROPORTIONATE EXCHANGE!!! 17:22  |  Steve L. 08/09/06
      18.   Life is not for sale 17:23  |  mb 08/09/06
      19.   NO DEAL 17:24  |  ALAN 08/09/06
      20.   Hezbollah promises 17:26  |  Jack 08/09/06
      21.   No, thank you! 17:27  |  Spoon 08/09/06
      22.   Don`t release Kuntar 17:28  |  Szaulo 08/09/06
      23.   Ransom, what and when? 17:33  |  Mark Lincoln 08/09/06
      24.   Kill Kunter, then release him 17:36  |  bf 08/09/06
      25.   Free Kuntar, but send him back in a bodybag 17:37  |  Alex 08/09/06
      26.   Kuntar should be Imprisoned in Lebanon 17:45  |  Yaakov Sullivan 08/09/06
      27.   MURDER, MURDER, MURDER 18:00  |  Fred 08/09/06
      28.   Kuntar Release 18:01  |  Lev 08/09/06
      29.   #6&8 GREAT IDEA!! Let Kuntar RUN but not HIDE 18:04  |  Ben 08/09/06
      30.   Why not? 18:04  |  Pope 08/09/06
      31.   Better to swap 18:07  |  Natallie Durson 08/09/06
      32.   Alan 18:09  |  #11 08/09/06
      33.   Jack Geneva, Pacify this region?? 18:14  |  Mike 08/09/06
      34.   To Sullyvan 18:14  |  Jake 08/09/06
      35.   Amazing 18:16  |  Lebanese 08/09/06
      36.   Time to take a stand 18:18  |  steve 08/09/06
      37.   To Fred re: kids on a beach 18:23  |  Pope 08/09/06
      38.   Terror Islam , Terror Lebanon , Terror Hezbollah 18:26  |  Joseph E . 08/09/06
      39.   #6 18:31  |  From the Moon 08/09/06
      40.   Post # 1 The Release of the 2 Soldiers is the Hands 18:35  |  Joseph E . 08/09/06
      41.   Israel killed more arab civilians than Kuntar. Don`t be hypocrite 18:41  |  John 08/09/06
      42.   WHO IS THE TERRORIST???? 18:42  |  ANWAR 08/09/06
      43.   Israel should have destroy continue on with thw War! 18:59  |  Moniroth You-Bell 08/09/06
      44.   The Trap Behind The Deal. 19:03  |  Tony Anthony 08/09/06
      45.   Kuntar 19:04  |  Omar 08/09/06
      46.   Good choice of country, Herr Nasrallah 19:06  |  From the Moon 08/09/06
      47.   The trivial case of Kuntar 19:06  |  Ben Gurion 08/09/06
      48.   A way for Olmert to save his political career 19:12  |  rick 08/09/06
      49.   #15, MarkL 19:17  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 08/09/06
      50.   samir kuntar 19:21  |  georges 08/09/06
      51.   let him go back in a bodybag!!! then we know hes freed! 19:29  |  zunga 08/09/06
      52.   Israel & Kuntar 19:31  |  noname 08/09/06
      53.   1701 " ... unconditional release ..." 19:32  |  steve dill 08/09/06
      54.   Yaakov Sullivan - A question 19:40  |  Gil 08/09/06
      55.   Re: 21 19:41  |  Steve 08/09/06
      56.   How disgusting! 19:42  |  Jonathan S 08/09/06
      57.   John in Sweden - who is dumb? 19:49  |  Gil 08/09/06
      58.   Not good odds here 20:02  |  Claudia 08/09/06
      59.   So all they need to do is kidnap soldiers to bust a terrorist out 20:11  |  Rob 08/09/06
      60.   VALUE & EXECUTION OF U N DECISIONS! 20:49  |  H.H.M 08/09/06
      61.   The Soldiers May Not Be Alive 20:49  |  Joseph E . 08/09/06
      62.   PRISONER SWAP IS ANOTHER VICTORY FOR HIZBULLAH!!!!!! 20:52  |  OLMERT + KADIMA OUT 08/09/06
      63.   John from Sweeden 20:54  |  David Israel 08/09/06
      64.   To John from Sweden ... 20:57  |  len 08/09/06
      65.   What?! 21:02  |  Ari 08/09/06
      66.   The only thing that was premature was the cease fire! 21:13  |  Ken 08/09/06
      67.   This talkback 21:29  |  vdH 08/09/06
      68.   Gil and his quetion on Kuntar #32 21:35  |  Yaakov Sullivan 08/09/06
      69.   israel 21:42  |  boris 08/09/06
      70.   Sam the sham so was the Piolts of the IAF, 412 L. children 21:44  |  gus 08/09/06
      71.   It`s funny how.. 21:49  |  Canadian 08/09/06
      72.   kuntar 21:52  |  amnon 08/09/06
      73.   Mitch Iginer, Isreali did the same 21:53  |  gus 08/09/06
      74.   dead penalty 21:55  |  amnon 08/09/06
      75.   Release of Israeli Soldiers 21:58  |  Clausewitz 08/09/06
      76.   if you free him.... 22:00  |  ross 08/09/06
      77.   EXCHANGE 22:07  |  GOLDA 08/09/06
      78.   Cipora Shalom re Kuntar the Freak 22:21  |  Danite 08/09/06
      79.   DEATH PENALTY FOR TERRORISTS! 22:22  |  MAJOR DANI 08/09/06
      80.   Premature !!! How about each day that passes by is too late 22:22  |  Joseph E . 08/09/06
      81.   Samir Kuntar 22:29  |  Me 08/09/06
      82.   Why don`t you volunteer to take the place 22:32  |  Mark Lincoln 08/09/06
      83.   What about Jonathan Pollard- 3rd time sending 22:33  |  Avrum 08/09/06
      84.   What Kuntar did is no worse than israeli atrocities 22:43  |  Isaac Hassen 08/09/06
      85.   Israeli businessman Elhanan Tennenbaum 22:44  |  Alex 08/09/06
      86.   Israeli businessman Elhanan Tennenbaum 22:44  |  Alex 08/09/06
      87.   DEAL OR NO DEAL? 22:54  |  Guy 08/09/06
      88.   #58 Soldiers understand the nature of war 22:55  |  Jack Cadillac 08/09/06
      89.   Those who admire and defend Kunt-ar 23:07  |  Jack Cadillac 08/09/06
      90.   mark lincoln,since you know so much, 23:39  |  rick 08/09/06
      91.   to Joseph E. re:#72 23:43  |  jeff atkinson 08/09/06
      92.   "The time is not ripe" 23:56  |  KUTW 08/09/06
      93.   Exchange Sami Haggar for Sami Kuntar - Fair trade 00:07  |  Paul Trembly 09/09/06
      94.   omar in beruit,more arab idle threats 00:08  |  rick 09/09/06
      95.   the lie of equivalence 00:23  |  peter 09/09/06
      96.   To What about Jonathan Pollard 00:23  |  Jim 09/09/06
      97.   70. Danite: Kuntar the Freak 00:23  |  KUTW 09/09/06
      98.   Reverse the ransom 00:28  |  peter 09/09/06
      99.   Dear Tony Anthony... 00:40  |  marios polycarpou 09/09/06
      100.   TO OMAR wich 7 millions re you refeing too? AND REPLY TO LEBANESE 00:52  |  Gabriel 09/09/06
      101.   Dear len from ny... 00:54  |  marios polycarpou 09/09/06
      102.   to all israeli citizens 00:58  |  lebanese 09/09/06
      103.   Samir Quntar 00:59  |  CM 09/09/06
      104.   Dear Ari... 01:01  |  marios polycarpou 09/09/06
      105.   Dear Gil from Philadelphia... 01:14  |  marios polycarpou 09/09/06
      106.   KUTW Hello! 01:20  |  Danite 09/09/06
      107.   Kuntar 01:25  |  Tired of the Arabs 09/09/06
      108.   Dear Ken from LA... 01:27  |  marios polycarpou 09/09/06
      109.   Dear Isaac Hassen... 01:36  |  marios polycarpou 09/09/06
      110.   Ben Gurion #39 emotionalists, or believers in crime & punishment 01:47  |  Jack Cadillac 09/09/06
      111.   for 74 Lincoln not #58 Soldiers understand the nature of war 01:56  |  Jack Cadillac 09/09/06
      112.   Thank you Yaakov - What about.... 01:56  |  Gil 09/09/06
      113.   Fred and others 02:08  |  ChanahS 09/09/06
      114.   Lebanese 02:12  |  ChanahS 09/09/06
      115.   Steve in New York 02:14  |  ChanahS 09/09/06
      116.   NONAME AND NO SENSE 02:18  |  ChanahS 09/09/06
      117.   vdH 02:25  |  ChanahS 09/09/06
      118.   Isaac Hassen 02:29  |  ChanahS 09/09/06
      119.   marios polycarpou # 86 02:33  |  ChanahS 09/09/06
      120.   Big mistake! 03:01  |  Nechama 09/09/06
      121.   #80, MarkL 04:11  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/09/06
      122.   marios polycarpou - Sticking to the issue at hand 04:32  |  Gil 09/09/06
      123.   Cipora Julianna Kohn - Hi! 05:02  |  Gil 09/09/06
      124.   #78, Danite 05:41  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/09/06
      125.   Canadian infantilizes Palestinians 06:35  |  Laura 09/09/06
      126.   #123, Gil 06:48  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/09/06
      127.   Cipora - I agree and hope we know the score 07:11  |  Gil 09/09/06
      128.   Cipora Shalom 07:25  |  Danite 09/09/06
      129.   #128, Danite 09:35  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/09/06
      130.   to John of Sweden #41 10:13  |  Ari ben Yisrael 09/09/06
      131.   O`sullivans stoopid response to Gil @ #68 10:22  |  Ari ben Yisrael 09/09/06
      132.   To # 120 Nechama , Sydney , Australia 13:17  |  Joseph E . 09/09/06
      133.   LET JEWISH PRISONERS DIE...... 14:39  |  horace vanderveldt 09/09/06
      134.   Dear ChanahS... 16:15  |  marios polycarpou 09/09/06
      135.   To # 59 , Rob, Edmonton,Alberta. Twisred Islamic Clerics 19:04  |  Joseph E . 09/09/06
      136.   umm...and you thought otherwise? 20:40  |  Christian Lebanese 09/09/06
      137.   Dear marios polycarpou 00:17  |  Gil 10/09/06
      138.   Emotions and reasons (Jack Cadillac #110) - 3rd try 00:36  |  Ben Gurion 10/09/06
      139.   Dear Gil from Philadelphia... 02:46  |  marios polycarpou 10/09/06
     Today Online
    Editorial: Blair is paying the price for his support for Israel
    Responses: 325
    Bradley Burston: Only right to stop calling Katsav president
    Responses: 73
    Arab MK to Syrian officials: Beware of Israeli attack
    Responses: 328
    Yoel Marcus: Things are looking pretty awful in Israel
    Responses: 190
    U.S. Jews must ask questions about their relationship with Israel
    Responses: 167
    Rosner's Domain
    * DC Notes: Factor, stupid mistake, favorite email
    * New poll: Is it time for Israel to resume talks with the Palestinians?
    * Syria's next stop is never
    * Mid-term diary: Chafee didn't want to confirm Bolton


    More Headlines
    02:16 Olmert tells Blair that he is ready to meet Abbas
    00:58 Thousands gather in Tel Aviv, call for state probe into war failures
    22:37 Balad MK Bishara in Damascus: Beware of Israeli attack
    00:39 Report: Syria doesn't accept EU guards on Lebanon border
    03:13 Iran, EU to resume talks on Tehran's nukes on Sunday
    02:19 Champion of the needy Yisrael Tuito dies at 41
    22:03 200 French troops arrive in Beirut for deployment in south
    18:38 Saudi tycoon: Arab investors launch bid to raise $2B for Lebanon
    22:13 70-year-old man critically wounded by cluster bomb in south Lebanon
    18:07 Earthquake measuring 4.4 shakes central Israel
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Nahal Haredi
    Defending Israel's homeland. Help support our troops
    One year MBA in Israel
    Taught entirely in English
    Israelity
    The reality of daily life in Israel
    Babylon 6
    Text Translation at a single click, from any desktop application. Try it Now
    FREE REGISTRATION at JLove.com
    Join The Fastest Growing Jewish Singles Community Now! Click Here!
    ISRAEL-SHOPS ONLINE STORE
    Gifts from Israel + FREE ISRAELI FLAG ON EVERY PURCHASE OVER $50
    Isrotel Chain
    Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
    Learn Hebrew Online
    Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
    JOIN FREE AT JDate.com
    The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
    HAARETZ SMS
    Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
    Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved