Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., September 10, 2006 Elul 17, 5766 | | Israel Time: 08:47 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate
Shopping
 
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The curse of living by the sword
By Gideon Samet

There are all kinds of commissions of inquiry about wars, even ridiculous ones, such as Ehud Olmert's. There is never an inquiry into the failures in negotiating peace. Their victims, after all, are not quantifiable. Yet, the prime minister's political behavior at present is no less dangerous than the way he ran the war. It is paving the road to another war. Olmert's attitude toward negotiations with the Palestinians and with Syria and Lebanon is fraught with mistakes and pretense. What's absent from the prime minister's head, and wasn't there before the war, too, is an iota of true intention to conduct a serious discussion about the future of the territories.

How do we know this? Because time after time he declaimed a promise of withdrawals if negotiations did not succeed and did everything to prevent dialogue with the Palestinian Authority. His predecessor, who is now acclaimed because of his disappearance and the quality of his successor, at least evacuated the Gaza Strip settlements. Olmert is not budging even one millimeter. In the meantime, he is approving more building in the territories. All this is tiringly familiar, but was obscured by a cruel war. While getting bogged down in Lebanon, he sent the Israel Defense Forces to shell, kill, torture and further impoverish the population of the territories. This insane summer shunted aside the continuing rampage of the army in some Palestinian region that we are tired of hearing about.

The tragic truth is that Olmert is now preoccupied mainly with Ehud. There is no point in giving him advice that, he assumes, will accelerate his nosedive in the polls. He does not want to hear that the right thing to do now, for the needs of the nation - as opposed to his needs - is to launch a comprehensive political initiative. Why does he need that headache when he might have to shift the coalition rightward and after the muscle-flexing he did in declaring the Golan Heights Israeli forever? But despite this pressurizing personal difficulty, the time is right - as it has been since the failure of Ehud Barak at Camp David - because there is no other way to extricate Israel from the grip of threats of hostility in the territories, from the direction of Iran, and again Lebanon.

Advertisement

Despite Olmert's bombastic demand to get back the abductees before a discussion about the release of prisoners, negotiations are under way (though the prime minister denies their existence) for a mutual release in both sectors. The gimmick is that Israel, for the sake of some kind of dubious honor, will release hundreds gradually. This is a small sample of what is necessary and possible in the broad scope of the conflict.

Not for the first time, the 22 foreign ministers of the Arab League spoke last week about a peace conference along the lines of Madrid 1991, which, in the end, led to Oslo. The same decision was also made four years ago by the Arab League summit in Beirut, on the basis of the Saudi plan. Israel did not react then because of the clauses relating to the right of return and to Jerusalem. Is it that the Arabs, contrary to us, have to present their final stand at the outset? The initiative for a conference next spring will likely be presented this month at the United Nations. Our ambassador there will deliver a brilliant speech against it.

In the near future, after the prisoner exchange, Olmert may meet, despite everything, with PA Chairman Mahmoud Abbas. Apparently, it has not crossed his mind to prepare something for the meeting that will turn it into momentum toward a serious follow-up. He and his predecessor did not want Yasser Arafat; thereafter, they were contemptuous of his replacement; and after that, they wanted to topple Hamas and the star of the elections, Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh. No creative concept emerged in the Israeli mechanism of denial and refusal toward the Palestinians concurrent with bombing and starving them. The Qassam rockets on the Negev, like the rockets on the North, were not a spur to dialogue, to relieve the suffering in Gaza, to try top projects of the sort that even Shimon Peres has grown hoarse talking about. Instead, we fired thousands of pointless shells and killed hundreds in the past few months alone. The crossings at Karni, Erez and Rafah were shut down. Half the workforce in Gaza is unemployed. Per capital income in the territories is 1:300 in relation to in Israel. And they will keep up the shelling as long as this enables the conflict to be kept on the back burner.

The battered leader of the Labor Party has begun of late to talk a little about a political initiative. His status is even wobblier than that of the prime minister, he sounds like a poor man's dove. His threats to bolt the government are also empty. Behind all the spin-type badmouthing, Olmert and Amir Peretz know that they have to keep on hanging together, otherwise a cruel political reality will hang them separately. The upshot, too, is that it's impossible to give advice to Labor. It will continue to be dragged in the wake. As long as an interim report of a commission of inquiry doesn't say differently, the defense minister will insist, in pursuit of his lost honor, on continuing to play the part and spout the rhetoric.

It all sounds pretty terrible - and it is. Of course, there is no one of weight at the shaky top who will dare talk about an international understanding with Iran, with Europe's assistance, instead of brandishing empty threats. Why, for example, will Israel not agree to desist from its outdated policy of ambiguity and allow supervision of its nuclear program in return for international supervision in Iran? The British prime minister, who is due to arrive here at the weekend, will find a confused leadership, filling up its empty emergency depots ahead of future events, quaking at the thought of an investigation. Maybe it is possible to suggest to Tony Blair, at the painful end of an excellent tenure, to behave differently than Israeli leaders who are glued to their seats, to place all his prestige and the remnants of his term in office on the line for a shift in this accursed business of living by the sword.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Family Affair
Yafit and Noga, both disabled, have an independent lifestyle with Hirosha's help.
Kicking the coffee habit
A friend of mine decided to kick his habit after drinking 14 cups a day for eight years.
  1.   Israeli politicians are irresponsible 12:07  |  Dror 09/09/06
  2.   All Israel must read this and THINK 13:39  |  NeutralObserver 09/09/06
  3.   Hear, hear 14:51  |  Michael II 09/09/06
  4.   PM. Blair in support of Israel 17:37  |  X Time 09/09/06
  5.   Gideon Samet proves it`s possible to be left of Belin !! 17:59  |  Michael 09/09/06
  6.   #2 - think what ? That the writer needs to go buy some glasses ?! 18:02  |  Michael 09/09/06
  7.   #3 - consider a hearing aid - you`re not hearing Hamas ! 18:04  |  Michael 09/09/06
  8.   Typical Lefty Pap - Only Right about Olmert`s Character 19:09  |  Tod Zuckerman 09/09/06
  9.   The liver of Dror #1 20:03  |  Gerard Demoor 09/09/06
  10.   Unpopular things to say 20:31  |  Steph 09/09/06
  11.   Israel is a lost cause .... 22:37  |  John 09/09/06
  12.   Excellent piece 07:05  |  AUH 10/09/06
  13.   Hail the Two Gideons! 08:42  |  Peace Train 10/09/06
 Today Online
Editorial: Blair is paying the price for his support for Israel
Responses: 355
Bradley Burston: Only right to stop calling Katsav president
Responses: 80
Arab MK to Syrian officials: Beware of Israeli attack
Responses: 368
Yoel Marcus: Things are looking pretty awful in Israel
Responses: 206
U.S. Jews must ask questions about their relationship with Israel
Responses: 201


More Headlines
07:50 PM: I'm ready to meet Abbas without preconditions
08:01 PM will deal with coalition crisis once budget is approved
08:20 Katsav considers 'time-out' during Beinisch swearing-in
07:24 Russian, Italian FMs get cool welcome from Livni and Peres
07:15 Iran, EU to meet again on nuclear plan after 'constructive talks'
00:58 Thousands gather in Tel Aviv, call for state probe into war failures
06:13 Iranian Jews in U.S. sue Khatami, say his gov't totured their loved ones
05:39 Evangelists join green groups, try to save Jordan River from pollution
00:39 Report: Syria doesn't accept EU guards on Lebanon border
07:51 WSJ: Bush personally signed off on Khatami visit to U.S.
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Nahal Haredi
Defending Israel's homeland. Help support our troops
One year MBA in Israel
Taught entirely in English
Israelity
The reality of daily life in Israel
Babylon 6
Text Translation at a single click, from any desktop application. Try it Now
FREE REGISTRATION at JLove.com
Join The Fastest Growing Jewish Singles Community Now! Click Here!
ISRAEL-SHOPS ONLINE STORE
Gifts from Israel + FREE ISRAELI FLAG ON EVERY PURCHASE OVER $50
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
JOIN FREE AT JDate.com
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved