Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., September 13, 2006 Elul 20, 5766 | | Israel Time: 18:27 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate
Shopping
 
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Itamar and the centrifuges in Natanz
By Aluf Benn

Since the end of the war in Lebanon, regional diplomacy has been conducted along two ostensibly unrelated tracks. One is focused on stopping the Iranian nuclear program, and the other on renewing Israeli-Arab talks about "land for peace."

The first process is being conducted between the major powers and Iran, which refuses to halt uranium enrichment and is ignoring a UN Security Council resolution on the subject. Israel is keeping its distance: Its leaders occasionally mention the existential threat from Iran, but since they are busy with political survival, they are devoting little time to it. A forum of past and present prime ministers, which Prime Minister Ehud Olmert established with great fanfare to underscore the seriousness and importance of this issue, met once and fell silent.

The chances of renewing the diplomatic process, which have sparked discussions in Cairo, Damascus and Gaza, have ignited an internal debate in Israel. There are those who want to talk with the Palestinians (Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni), with the Syrians (Defense Minister Amir Peretz and Public Security Minister Avi Dichter), with the Lebanese (Olmert), with everyone (Meretz Chair Yossi Beilin) and with no one (opposition leader Benjamin Netanyahu). As in the past, the discussion is being conducted as though we held the cards. One of the reasons for this is the feeling that the war in Lebanon and the battles in Gaza have put an end to withdrawals from the territories - at least as long as "there is nobody to talk to" and there is no security substitute for control over the West Bank and the Golan Heights.

Advertisement

But the regional situation is more complex, and the farther the United States slides down the slope toward confrontation with Iran, the stronger the demand will be for an Israeli withdrawal from the territories. Although Israel claims that Iran is "the world's problem, not only ours," experience shows that there are no free lunches. Every time America has operated in this region and needed legitimacy from the Arabs, it has demanded something from Israel in exchange.

In 1991, the Americans attacked Iraq in order to liberate Kuwait. The reason for the war was not connected to Israel, although Israel profited from the destruction of Saddam Hussein's army, missiles and chemical weapons. The administration of then president George Bush Sr. exacted its price in the form of the Madrid summit, which led to the Oslo Accords, to peace with Jordan and to negotiations with Syria.

Twelve years later, American planes returned to the skies of Baghdad, this time sent by George Bush Jr. This time, too, the reason was global, and Israel remained on the sidelines, but once again, it was required to pay - by accepting the road map peace plan, by freezing construction in settlements beyond the fence, and later also by withdrawing from Gaza and the northern West Bank.

We can assume that this time as well, the global problem and the local one will be linked. In exchange for a military or political solution to Iran's nuclear program, Israel will be required to evacuate additional settlements in the West Bank, and perhaps settlements in the Golan as well. As in the earlier Gulf wars, this time, too, Israel will be told that it must pay a territorial price in exchange for the removal of the threat.

The main difference between the situations then and now is Israel's leadership. Instead of prime ministers Yitzhak Shamir and Ariel Sharon, who tended to oppose withdrawals and evacuations, today, the prime minister is Olmert, who proposed evacuating 90 percent of the West Bank without any compensation. Why should he oppose evacuating the settlement of Itamar in exchange for halting the centrifuges in Natanz? And even if Olmert is no longer in power, his replacement will encounter the same demands. Netanyahu is calling for dropping the idea of evacuating settlers and concentrating on Iran instead, but he will also discover that these issues are interrelated.

Two days from now, British Prime Minister Tony Blair will arrive in Jerusalem. Blair is President George W. Bush's scout, and the person who linked the invasion of Iraq to the publication of the road map for a Palestinian state. After he exchanges stories of political woe with Olmert, it will be interesting to see what he has to say about the delicate connection between dismantling Iran's nuclear program and ending Israeli control over the territories.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Fueling deception
Fuel companies have been deceiving the public in their posted gas prices.
Museum of Polish Jews
Construction on the Museum of the History of Polish Jews will begin in Warsaw next fall.
  1.   It`s all very academic 11:01  |  Clickfool 07/09/06
  2.   Ones security is others threat 11:04  |  Ben 07/09/06
  3.   Aluf Benn ia an "analyst"??? 11:16  |  Z Lando 07/09/06
  4.   This is simply stupid Withdrawal makes no sense whatsoever 11:17  |  Shalom Freedman 07/09/06
  5.   perhaps taking out the man is the answer 11:21  |  fagin 07/09/06
  6.   if military intelligence thinks the man is serious 11:23  |  fagin 07/09/06
  7.   I`m proud of Tony Blair 11:31  |  Gaza Boy 07/09/06
  8.   Iran will have the bomb and Israel must leave the territories 11:44  |  KMS 07/09/06
  9.   A window of Opportunity 11:48  |  Adel 07/09/06
  10.   Reuven Pedatzur "Let Them Have Nukes" 11:59  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 07/09/06
  11.   Becoming part of the real world 12:08  |  sh 07/09/06
  12.   Bush will never demand anything of Israel 12:12  |  Freddy 07/09/06
  13.   Israel should nuke Iran before they nuke us 12:16  |  Zebedee 07/09/06
  14.   to those who believe they can fool everybody forever 1) 12:21  |  John and the truth 07/09/06
  15.   to those who try to fool us 2) 12:29  |  John the truth 07/09/06
  16.   Nuclear holocaust would be on Iran not on Israel 12:39  |  Aby 07/09/06
  17.   Âdel #9 12:51  |  Axel 07/09/06
  18.   Blair is Bush`s scout, all right 12:57  |  syllepsis 07/09/06
  19.   #10 Ovadiah, #13 Aby 13:02  |  Yonatan 07/09/06
  20.   For Gaza Boy, who`s proud of Tony Blair 13:16  |  Clickfool 07/09/06
  21.   For Zebedee 13:18  |  Clickfool 07/09/06
  22.   CLUCKFOOL 13:56  |  Star of David 07/09/06
  23.   n. 13 (bad luck number) zebedee 13:57  |  Always John 07/09/06
  24.   clickfool meltdown in oil prices 13:57  |  harzion 07/09/06
  25.   Clickfool: totally academic 14:00  |  Mushtaba Sayid 07/09/06
  26.   to Axel form ...!!!!! 14:23  |  the same old John 07/09/06
  27.   retire from West Bank with compensation?!!! 14:44  |  salim 07/09/06
  28.   sh -- You Are Absolutely Correct 14:45  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 07/09/06
  29.   The Chicken and the Egg 14:59  |  Yaakov Sullivan 07/09/06
  30.   WHY? 15:08  |  Pegasus 07/09/06
  31.   to Aby 15:08  |  Bob 07/09/06
  32.   Zebedee and his quest for a nuclear war #13 15:12  |  Yaakov Sullivan 07/09/06
  33.   #27 Salim Who are the thieves? 15:57  |  Murray of Montreal 07/09/06
  34.   For Clickfool re #27 16:02  |  Murray of Montreal 07/09/06
  35.   to Ovaadiah 16:11  |  john 07/09/06
  36.   The result of doing nothing 16:16  |  Ben Gurion 07/09/06
  37.   Ovadiah ben Avraham 16:21  |  sh 07/09/06
  38.   to all israeli jews 16:32  |  salim 07/09/06
  39.   TO MURRAY 16:45  |  salim 07/09/06
  40.   We could tell what the price of such is , not 16:50  |  Sal 07/09/06
  41.   Fagin 17:13  |  Sebastian Santa-Cruz 07/09/06
  42.   sh -- Still in Agreement 17:18  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 07/09/06
  43.   #29 17:20  |  Jihad 07/09/06
  44.   For Murray of Montreal 17:25  |  Clickfool 07/09/06
  45.   The Chicken or the Egg 17:27  |  Yaakov Sullivan 07/09/06
  46.   salim 18:33  |  Sebastian Santa Cruz 07/09/06
  47.   I have a good idea 18:35  |  Traveler 07/09/06
  48.   AND IF THE PRICE IS BYE BYE ISRAEL ?? 19:12  |  NeutralObserver 07/09/06
  49.   Irans not the threat Olmert is 19:18  |  zionist forever 07/09/06
  50.   KMS #8 19:27  |  zionist forever 07/09/06
  51.   Clickfool, again with the crap 19:59  |  Danny - Israeli one 07/09/06
  52.   Palestine`s real face 20:01  |  BP Diplomacy 07/09/06
  53.   Salim 20:15  |  Richard 07/09/06
  54.   are you in dream 20:21  |  mostafa 07/09/06
  55.   Like the peace talks were a bad thing 20:30  |  F 07/09/06
  56.   Peace with all the Arabs 20:35  |  Sam 07/09/06
  57.   Iran and the present day mosques on Temple Mount 20:37  |  Nehemiah 07/09/06
  58.   If they want to mess with Israel...Iran is the fool!!! 20:37  |  Ben Uziel 07/09/06
  59.   thoughts and ideas? 20:50  |  from the 07/09/06
  60.   What a bunch of BS 20:58  |  Iranian-American 07/09/06
  61.   Itmar, etc. 21:21  |  P. J. Casey 07/09/06
  62.   29 Yaakov Sullivan - Complex Questions 21:24  |  Mark of Lewiston 07/09/06
  63.   #54 --you do not fear anything --fine --time will 21:29  |  Sal 07/09/06
  64.   #60 Iranian -You`re making a lot of sense 21:36  |  Giora Sadman 07/09/06
  65.   Danny- Israeli One, chortling about the present price of oil 21:40  |  Clickfool 07/09/06
  66.   to Bob re:#31 21:51  |  jeff atkinson 07/09/06
  67.   To Iranian-American 21:53  |  Jeroen 07/09/06
  68.   Land For Peace 22:13  |  Hal Smith 07/09/06
  69.   yaakov..what does Iran have to do with "occupation"??? 22:21  |  SHIMON 07/09/06
  70.   Mustafa,re:#54 22:24  |  jeff atkinson 07/09/06
  71.   clickfool "iran will respond in the same way" 22:24  |  harzion 07/09/06
  72.   No, Shimon, I did not suggest that #69 22:55  |  Yaakov Sullivan 07/09/06
  73.   #54 Mostafa from Iran 23:30  |  Nehemiah 07/09/06
  74.   To: zionist forever 23:31  |  Chase 07/09/06
  75.   They are afraid 23:33  |  Omar 07/09/06
  76.   yaakov sullivan is a faded french tart 23:33  |  zadok the priest 07/09/06
  77.   TO SALIM 23:48  |  Murray of Montreal 07/09/06
  78.   to zionist-forever 23:51  |  anni 07/09/06
  79.   all the more reason for israel to do the job itself 23:55  |  open eyes 07/09/06
  80.   Pre Emption the only option 00:06  |  Sohail 08/09/06
  81.   Iran nuke program 00:46  |  Brod 08/09/06
  82.   That is not really true Mr. Ben Gurion 01:04  |  Mark Lincoln 08/09/06
  83.   Ethnicity Fact 01:25  |  Larence Kaldeck 08/09/06
  84.   ISREAL MUST STOP IRAN BEFORE THERE IS A MUSH ROOM CLOUD IS ISREAL 02:38  |  WAKE UP ISREAL 08/09/06
  85.   Where Israel is concerned.... 02:45  |  Jeff 08/09/06
  86.   THE CLICKFOOL SHOW 03:06  |  Brant 08/09/06
  87.   Iranian-American The FACTS 03:50  |  Mark Lincoln 08/09/06
  88.   #18 Syllepsis 04:02  |  Bonnie 08/09/06
  89.   What about Jonathan Pollard ??????????? 04:22  |  Avrum 08/09/06
  90.   Mostafa #54 ""Iran is not a arab country " 05:44  |  Mil-tiades 08/09/06
  91.   Is Mark Lincoln is running of things to do? 06:32  |  GAB1 08/09/06
  92.   #36 - Ben Gurion`s sweet dreams 06:46  |  Dr. Giora Sedman 08/09/06
  93.   #81 Bonnie 06:48  |  syllepsis 08/09/06
  94.   Shkoyach Avrum #82 07:01  |  Eli 08/09/06
  95.   To # 80 ???? 07:02  |  Ah 08/09/06
  96.   Iran is where our plains should fly next 07:12  |  Eli 08/09/06
  97.   Israel has to pay the price, ALL the price 08:20  |  American 08/09/06
  98.   clickfool & Arafat`s mysterious death 08:52  |  Cowboy Bob 08/09/06
  99.   `TERRITORIAL PRICE` !!!??? 08:57  |  Lebanese 08/09/06
  100.   Benn throws sand in the readers` eyes 09:01  |  Michael N 08/09/06
  101.   Jonathan Pollard? 09:13  |  Clickfool 08/09/06
  102.   Tip of the Day for Wake Up Israel 09:16  |  Clickfool 08/09/06
  103.   One hand washes the other 09:17  |  Third-eye 08/09/06
  104.   Why would 09:17  |  john 08/09/06
  105.   Why should the biggest aggressor in the region 09:20  |  Stavros 08/09/06
  106.   Freddy, Trusting Bush is like trusting Hittler. 09:25  |  gus 08/09/06
  107.   Zebedee Iran will never nuke Israel 09:31  |  gus 08/09/06
  108.   Pollard? That spy! 09:44  |  john 08/09/06
  109.   to so called "American"re:#83, 10:30  |  jeff atkinson 08/09/06
  110.   reaching above the subjective 17:48  |  Ron 09/09/06
  111.   THE WRITER IS RIGHT?..IN A SENSE 01:23  |  diana 10/09/06
  112.   for Ben Uziel 18:18  |  friendofIsreal 13/09/06
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: Let's change our name to No
Responses: 165
Editorial: Israel must not reject the new PA unity government
Responses: 45
Assad: Syria ready for peace, but Israel unwilling
Responses: 109
PA source: EU will lift boycott for unity gov't
Responses: 113


More Headlines
18:04 MK Ayalon calls on Peretz to resign as Defense Minister
17:07 Germany to send up to 2,400 service personnel to Lebanon
15:22 Military Police to investigate 8 cases of alleged abuse in West Bank
17:14 Knesset panel approves 16-hour leave of absence for President
18:10 Court releases 7 suspects in Shfaram lynch of Jewish gunman
18:26 Abbas to send delegation to UN General Assembly
17:54 Top lawyer to confess to causing death without plea bargain
17:03 German Jewish community to ordain three new rabbis, first since 1942
18:03 Youth dies of injuries after shooting himself with school guard's gun
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Nahal Haredi
Defending Israel's homeland. Help support our troops
EZER MIZION
Help those that need it most!
One year MBA in Israel
Taught entirely in English
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
JOIN FREE AT JDate.com
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
ISRAEL-SHOPS ONLINE STORE
Gifts from Israel + FREE ISRAELI FLAG ON EVERY PURCHASE OVER $50
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
FREE REGISTRATION at JLove.com
Join The Fastest Growing Jewish Singles Community Now! Click Here!
Babylon 6
Text Translation at a single click, from any desktop application. Try it Now
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved