Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., January 12, 2007 Tevet 22, 5767 | | Israel Time: 21:51 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Can you really not see?
By Amira Hass

Let us leave aside those Israelis whose ideology supports the dispossession of the Palestinian people because "God chose us." Leave aside the judges who whitewash every military policy of killing and destruction. Leave aside the military commanders who knowingly jail an entire nation in pens surrounded by walls, fortified observation towers, machine guns, barbed wire and blinding projectors. Leave aside the ministers. All of these are not counted among the collaborators. These are the architects, the planners, the designers, the executioners.

But there are others. Historians and mathematicians, senior editors, media stars, psychologists and family doctors, lawyers who do not support Gush Emunim and Kadima, teachers and educators, lovers of hiking trails and sing-alongs, high-tech wizards. Where are you? And what about you, researchers of Nazism, the Holocaust and Soviet gulags? Could you all be in favor of systematic discriminating laws? Laws stating that the Arabs of the Galilee will not even be compensated for the damages of the war by the same sums their Jewish neighbors are entitled to (Aryeh Dayan, Haaretz , August 21).

Could it be that you are all in favor of a racist Citizenship Law that forbids an Israeli Arab from living with his family in his own home? That you side with further expropriation of lands and the demolishing of additional orchards, for another settler neighborhood and another exclusively Jewish road? That you all back the shelling and missile fire killing the old and the young in the Gaza Strip?

Advertisement

Could it be that you all agree that a third of the West Bank (the Jordan Valley) should be off limits to Palestinians? That you all side with an Israeli policy that prevents tens of thousands of Palestinians who have obtained foreign citizenship from returning to their families in the occupied territories?

Could your mind really be so washed with the security excuse, used to forbid Gaza students from studying occupational therapy at Bethlehem and medicine at Abu Dis, and preventing sick people from Rafah from receiving medical treatment in Ramallah? Will also you find it easy to hide behind the explanation "we had no idea": we had no idea that the discrimination practiced in the distribution of water - which is solely controlled by Israel - leaves thousands of Palestinian households without water during the hot summer months; we had no idea that when the IDF blocks the entrance to villages, it also blocks their access to springs or water tanks.

But it cannot be that you don't see the iron gates along route 344 in the West Bank, blocking access to it from the Palestinian villages it passes by. It cannot be that you support preventing the access of thousands of farmers to their land and plantations, that you support the quarantine on Gaza which prevents the entry of medicine for hospitals, the disruption of electricity and water supply to 1.4 million human beings, closing their only outlet to the world for months.

Could it be that you do not know what is happening 15 minutes from your faculties and offices? Is it plausible that you support the system in which Hebrew soldiers, at checkpoints in the heart of the West Bank, are letting tens of thousands of people wait everyday for hours upon hours under the blazing sun, while selecting: residents of Nablus and Tul Karm are not allowed through, 35-year-olds and under - yallah, back to Jenin, residents of the Salem village are not even allowed to be here, a sick woman who skipped the line must learn a lesson and will be purposefully detained for hours. Machsom Watch's site is available for all; in it are countless such testimonies and worse, a day by day routine. But it cannot be that those who are appalled over every swastika painted on a Jewish grave in France and over every anti-Semitic headline in a Spanish local newspaper will not know how to reach this information, and will not be appalled and outraged.

As Jews we all enjoy the privilege Israel gives us, what makes us all collaborators. The question is what does every one of us do in an active and direct daily manner to minimize cooperation with a dispossessing, suppressing regime that never has its fill. Signing a petition and tutting will not do. Israel is a democracy for its Jews. We are not in danger of our lives, we will not be jailed in concentration camps, our livelihood will not be damaged and recreation in the countryside or abroad will not be denied to us. Therefore, the burden of collaboration and direct responsibility is immeasurably heavy.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Deaf ears
The deaf community is suing the News Company for failing to provide closed captions.
Worth the trip
The Terrine restaurant in Yavne is not at all pretentious, rather it is temptingly casual.
  1.   A Call in the Wild, 09:52  |  Igor 30/08/06
  2.   Why? 09:53  |  Maral 30/08/06
  3.   Thanks again Amira 09:54  |  John 30/08/06
  4.   THANKS GOD 09:56  |  Michael 30/08/06
  5.   Take off your blinders to "see" 10:01  |  bob 30/08/06
  6.   Turning a blind eye 10:05  |  Sean 30/08/06
  7.   The citizenship laws are a shame 10:05  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 30/08/06
  8.   Burden of Israel, Burden of the World 10:12  |  Brigitte Meier 30/08/06
  9.   Israel is blind 10:21  |  Sir Hani 30/08/06
  10.   Racist citizenship laws 10:21  |  DJStahl 30/08/06
  11.   HAARETZ: Couldn`t you find an impartial honest author? 10:23  |  Vittorio 30/08/06
  12.   AMIRA:an admirable drop of water in the desert 10:24  |  esperanza 30/08/06
  13.   Michael from Athens who`d burn Israeli prisoners with phosphor ad 10:25  |  Absolute Sweden 30/08/06
  14.   Ignorance was bliss; long life freedom of speech. 10:28  |  Tony Price 30/08/06
  15.   Thanks Amira 10:30  |  wadha 30/08/06
  16.   So far 1 out of 5 posts... 10:32  |  Moe 30/08/06
  17.   BRILLIANT 10:32  |  Louis P. 30/08/06
  18.   God chose us 10:33  |  Rolf 30/08/06
  19.   Palestinian propaganda again 10:38  |  Shalom Freedman 30/08/06
  20.   Good for you, Amira 10:42  |  Jules Kadish 30/08/06
  21.   Wrong Mrs Hass, YOU ARE NOT one of them 10:42  |  Andre 30/08/06
  22.   Your end is getting closer 10:44  |  Observor 30/08/06
  23.   we see but are only human 10:47  |  seesaw 30/08/06
  24.   Have you not noticed? 10:48  |  sh 30/08/06
  25.   In every Amira Hass article there`s a little bit of Hamas 10:52  |  TM (jewlicious.com) 30/08/06
  26.   Sick and disorientated? 10:59  |  skippy 30/08/06
  27.   Amira - Go find another cause, you are getting boring ! 11:01  |  Sick & Tired 30/08/06
  28.   The real reasons for it 11:04  |  Sami 30/08/06
  29.   amira haas writes as if the whole column is a headline 11:06  |  zadok the priest 30/08/06
  30.   Bob it is the other way around, treat them well first. 11:08  |  gus 30/08/06
  31.   Could it be.... 11:10  |  Maimon 30/08/06
  32.   RACISM should be condemned everywhere.It is racist to condemn it- 11:13  |  PETER SM 30/08/06
  33.   To Amira, thank you. 11:14  |  gus 30/08/06
  34.   Right on Spot - Israel is Apartheid state 11:15  |  tony adams 30/08/06
  35.   To SH 11:17  |  TM (Jewlicious.com) 30/08/06
  36.   Can you not see? 11:21  |  Proud Zionist 30/08/06
  37.   Amira were with you -no to Fanatic Zionist 11:23  |  Haytham 30/08/06
  38.   thanks again Amira 11:23  |  Sarah 30/08/06
  39.   Sad commentary on what is done before your eyes 11:23  |  RW 30/08/06
  40.   to Shalom Freedom 11:24  |  gus 30/08/06
  41.   observor thanks for advertising your presence 11:25  |  thucydides 30/08/06
  42.   Israel is the world`s burdern 11:25  |  Richard 30/08/06
  43.   Skippy Shame on you not on Amira 11:34  |  gus 30/08/06
  44.   One small difference 11:35  |  Xaxam 30/08/06
  45.   that`s why Israel will disappear, in time 11:45  |  Aboudi 30/08/06
  46.   MY TAKE ON THIS 11:45  |  DANIEL 30/08/06
  47.   TM (Jewlicious.com) 11:49  |  sh 30/08/06
  48.   Can you really not see? 11:50  |  Sauheil Nassar 30/08/06
  49.   Amira, your next article should give suggestions - what to do? 11:54  |  Sara 30/08/06
  50.   to Xaxam 11:56  |  gus 30/08/06
  51.   Why can`t Israelis see? 11:56  |  David 30/08/06
  52.   "we had no idea"-----"we didn`t know" 11:56  |  Osborne Reed 30/08/06
  53.   And once again... 11:59  |  Frantz 30/08/06
  54.   Amira Hass is living on Pluto - disconnected from any reality! 12:06  |  Ronni 30/08/06
  55.   AMIRA`S crediblity has been tested in a court of law 12:06  |  PETER SM 30/08/06
  56.   Ms Hass tells the truth. I fully endorse her opinions 12:07  |  Neville Chamberlain 30/08/06
  57.   Is Amira`s brain the size of a peanut or she simply evil? 12:08  |  Me 30/08/06
  58.   I see ... & don`t care 12:08  |  ziggurat 30/08/06
  59.   to gus 12:13  |  wadha 30/08/06
  60.   Bravo Amira!! 12:16  |  a Palestinian 30/08/06
  61.   If we kick out the enemy we will no longer be opppressing them! 12:16  |  Simple Solution Guy 30/08/06
  62.   Kadima, let`s take a look - Richard 12:20  |  sh 30/08/06
  63.   Ms. Hass, Are you asleep, willfully blind, or merely stupid? 12:22  |  Yaakov K. 30/08/06
  64.   Thank You Amira 12:22  |  Sal 30/08/06
  65.   Amira Hass is a great friend of our movement - I wish her well 12:24  |  Hassan Nasrallah 30/08/06
  66.   Zionist Oppressors 12:25  |  Abdoul 30/08/06
  67.   Bravo Ms Hass - more dollars will be sent to you soon! 12:26  |  Pres. Ahmadinajab 30/08/06
  68.   a brainwash society, a traumatised bully 12:27  |  Ernst 30/08/06
  69.   Absolute Sweden - but Amira`s text is an improvement 12:28  |  christoph 30/08/06
  70.   I`m as thick as pig sh**t but even I know Ms Hass talks no sense! 12:28  |  Bill Clinton 30/08/06
  71.   The Banality Of Evil 12:29  |  Hannah`s Student 30/08/06
  72.   ancient hebrew saying 12:29  |  pirkei avot 30/08/06
  73.   OBJECTIVE ANALYSIS 12:30  |  MARCO 30/08/06
  74.   Truth is that we are stupid & barbaric- Hass should realise this! 12:30  |  A Palestinian 30/08/06
  75.   a modern anti-semite 12:32  |  shegay 30/08/06
  76.   Yes SH, unilaterally 1 12:33  |  TM (Jewlicious.com) 30/08/06
  77.   Sn,peace with Germany was achieved by one side,the victorious one 12:33  |  Absolute Sweden 30/08/06
  78.   No Amira 12:35  |  Frank 30/08/06
  79.   Yes SH, unilaterally 2 12:39  |  TM (jewlicious.com) 30/08/06
  80.   Arabs are the enemy,or havent you noticed. 12:39  |  Leslie 30/08/06
  81.   Who does she mean by "We"? 12:43  |  FOX 30/08/06
  82.   Pulling out of Gaza - SH 12:45  |  TM (Jewlicious.com) 30/08/06
  83.   Can You Really Not See? Not Yet Unfortunately! 12:46  |  Dr. A. Wyman Walker 30/08/06
  84.   Israel`s best hope 12:48  |  JayUK 30/08/06
  85.   "others" 12:51  |  gybor 30/08/06
  86.   Jews,Christians,Muslims against racism 12:53  |  Michael 30/08/06
  87.   Sh is wrong 12:54  |  Richard 30/08/06