Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., September 08, 2006 Elul 15, 5766 | | Israel Time: 15:33 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate
Shopping
 
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Protest in the Rose Garden
By Ari Shavit

What do we need to do these days? Not much. To prevent the renewal of war in Lebanon and to win the war should it begin anew. To avoid the outbreak of war with Syria and to win a war against it should one break out. To prevent Iran from developing its nuclear capability and to deter the country should it become a nuclear power. To build the Israel Defense Forces from the foundations up, as fast as possible. To rehabilitate the political system immediately. To come up with a leadership from thin air. To formulate, overnight, a national strategy. To carry out a regime change. To initiate a revolution in values. To reestablish the Israeli republic.

The timetable is tight. Very tight indeed. The cease-fire in Lebanon is not stable and will not be. The truce is caught in the dilemma of whether to come to terms with Hezbollah's powerful presence or whether to take forceful action against the organization and chance an escalation. There is total uncertainty also along the Syrian border. The possibility of a sudden Syrian move on the Golan Heights is not out of the question.

On the other hand, on the Iranian front the picture is crystal clear: By wintertime the moment of truth will come. If the United States attacks Iran, Israel will be attacked. If the United States does not attack, Israel will be faced with the most serious challenge to its existence since the day of its establishment.

Advertisement

Those who say that there is no comparison between the situation at the end of the second Lebanon War and the situation at the end of the Yom Kippur War are right. The current situation is by far more dramatic. Indeed, the number of fresh graves in military cemeteries at the end of this summer is much smaller than that after the fall of 1973, but the situation at the end of the war is much, much more fragile and dangerous.

In the fall of 1973, Israel stood before the start of an era of no external attacks. At the end of the summer of 2006, Israel is faced with a high probability of an impending external assault. In the fall of 1973, Israel was perceived by its neighbors as a wounded but powerful bully. At the end of summer 2006, it is viewed by its neighbors as a scarred, impotent wimp. In the fall of 1973, the American superpower regarded Israel as a bleeding lion. In 2006, the U.S. sees Israel as a fat hound dog that has lost its nerve and its value.

In 1973, the IDF emerged from the war with chief of staff David Elazar and Major Generals Yitzhak Hofi, Yisrael Tal and Arik Sharon threatening both Cairo and Damascus. In the end of the summer of 2006, the IDF is emerging from the fighting with the head of Northern Command Udi Adam, Deputy Chief of Staff Moshe Kaplinsky and Chief of Staff Dan Halutz not even posing a threat to the Al-Khiam ridge.

In the fall of 1973, the Israeli leadership consisted of Golda Meir, Moshe Dayan, Yigal Allon, Abba Eban, Yitzhak Rabin and Shimon Peres. At the end of the summer of 2006, in Israel's leadership are Tal Zilberstein and Shula Zaken. In the fall of 1973, Israel was a powerful state that erred, was battered and got back on its feet. At the end of the summer of 2006, Israel is a country whose vital organs are rotting, afflicted by a corrupting virus.

This is the reason for which one must rush, at this very moment, over to the protesters at the Rose Garden in Jerusalem. Not because Ehud Olmert must go. He will go in any case. And not because Halutz must take responsibility. He will take responsibility, whether he likes it or not. We must rush to the protest at the Rose Garden because that is where Israel is beginning to deal with itself. That is where truthful people are beginning to tell the truth to a nation that forgot what the taste of truth is all about.

Today's agenda must concern one thing: Israel's power. There will be no peace and there will be no end to the occupation without restoring Israel's power. There will be no enlightenment and no free society without renewing Israel's power. Without renewing Israel's power there will be no start-ups here and no clubs. There won't even be a bubble.

However, renewal of Israel's power cannot take place without ethics and without truth. Without modesty and without substance. Without restoring faith and a sense of responsibility. Therefore, the Prime Minister and Chief of Staff of Arrogance must both go. Not only because they have been wrong all the way. Not only because they have been wrong, have been deceptive and have cooked up a disaster. But because getting rid of both will distance us from the distorted values that both of them represent. Separation from both of them will detach us from the evil spirit that tricked us for years.

Parting from Olmert and Halutz will not solve the deeply ingrained problem, but it will allow us to start dealing with it. It will allow Israel to embark on a long path toward a new beginning.

It's true: The protest in the Rose Garden is naive. It is not sufficiently focused or consolidated. It lacks clear tenets. But the seven reservist soldiers and the seven reservist officers who started the protest are the best among Israelis. They are exhibiting what is good about being Israeli. Therefore, it is necessary to go to them, to stand beside them and to support them. Indeed, it is necessary to rally near them in hundreds, thousands, tens of thousands.

Left, right, center - no one can oppose them. The protesters there are not orange and they are not blue. They are not interested parties and they have no hidden agendas. That is why the protest is now the most important place to be in Israel. This is the place where the great task of fixing Israel is beginning.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Long road home
Artist Michal Na'aman returns to her childhood home in Kibbutz Kinneret in the north.
Feed the birds...
Budget crunch threatens JNF's crane-feeding project in the Hula Valley.
  1.   Shavit, excellent analysis! Action Now! 10:15  |  Logician 28/08/06
  2.   israel needs a huge defense budget increase 10:17  |  zadok the priest 28/08/06
  3.   nasrallah issues profits warning.shares plunge. 10:23  |  zadok the priest 28/08/06
  4.   Priority 10:24  |  JW 28/08/06
  5.   Simply Confused 10:26  |  George 28/08/06
  6.   is nasrallah as ballsy as saddam hussein? 10:28  |  zadok the priest 28/08/06
  7.   Tears to my eyes 10:36  |  Dror 28/08/06
  8.   The country is numb 10:39  |  sh 28/08/06
  9.   note that armoured officers are busy defending the role of tanks 10:42  |  zadok the priest 28/08/06
  10.   System working well, Please send more money 10:44  |  Clickfool 28/08/06
  11.   5 "Simply Confused" - You are, ME lives by the Sword 10:56  |  Logician 28/08/06
  12.   Don`t play rhino 11:01  |  bschnider 28/08/06
  13.   Alarmist rhetoric 11:02  |  RW 28/08/06
  14.   when will you realise? 11:04  |  wally 28/08/06
  15.   THE END FOR ISRAEL. 11:13  |  NeutralObserver 28/08/06
  16.   The same old mistake 11:15  |  Andrew Watson 28/08/06
  17.   A bigger army 11:20  |  Salam 28/08/06
  18.   George 11:35  |  sweis Melbourne 28/08/06
  19.   Thank g-d for shavits conversion 11:35  |  Bill 28/08/06
  20.   And the name of the corrupting virus is....... 11:39  |  Clickfool 28/08/06
  21.   More brains not More muscles 11:45  |  Igor 28/08/06
  22.   Can a state like Israel survive? 11:50  |  Clickfool 28/08/06
  23.   We do need fundamental change but.. 11:56  |  Shalom Freedman 28/08/06
  24.   A Watson.Small problem mate.Israel does not exist according to 11:58  |  PETER SM 28/08/06
  25.   # 15, Bell 12:00  |  Jamal 28/08/06
  26.   if we continue to appoint corrupt officials 12:11  |  thucydides 28/08/06
  27.   should barak be the next leader? 12:18  |  thucydides 28/08/06
  28.   Nationalism is not a dirty word in proportion 12:25  |  Ben Uziel 28/08/06
  29.   Wrong again 12:33  |  Quentin 28/08/06
  30.   No Israel will NOT survive 12:37  |  Don Moreno 28/08/06
  31.   Finally, someone worth reading 12:43  |  Batya 28/08/06
  32.   correct assessment, but needs a bit more clarity 13:22  |  Ernst 28/08/06
  33.   Zadok the Priest 13:22  |  Ahmed the Sheikh 28/08/06
  34.   # 3 13:26  |  ChanahS 28/08/06
  35.   Clickfool # 10 13:29  |  ChanahS 28/08/06
  36.   Israel has no moral fabric 13:31  |  Ben 28/08/06
  37.   For Don Moreno - is Israel really a stooge of the USA? 13:46  |  Clickfool 28/08/06
  38.   This is article is written by a megalomaniac 13:51  |  Joe 28/08/06
  39.   The solution is clear 14:30  |  aCuban 28/08/06
  40.   Prescription from Shavit 14:31  |  Mark Lincoln 28/08/06
  41.   DEEPLY CORRECT WORDS 14:39  |  Vladimir 28/08/06
  42.   Clickfool likes to provoke 14:47  |  rich 28/08/06
  43.   Don Moreno 14:51  |  rich 28/08/06
  44.   Andrew Watson 14:52  |  rich 28/08/06
  45.   Ayn Rand warned us 50 years ago 14:56  |  Klaudia 28/08/06
  46.   Los Olvidados-the forgotten ones 15:06  |  Yaakov Sullivan 28/08/06
  47.   protesters in the rose garden have learnt nothing 15:07  |  tina 28/08/06
  48.   Protest with a goal 15:08  |  Bob 28/08/06
  49.   Ari Shavit: dying to lie 15:08  |  Froggie 28/08/06
  50.   Prepare for Any Possible Situation 15:20  |  Jane 28/08/06
  51.   the west is partly to blame klaudia 15:22  |  toni 28/08/06
  52.   One Step Behind 15:30  |  Karim 28/08/06
  53.   Ah, for the Good Ole Days of 1973! 15:33  |  Yaakov Sullivan 28/08/06
  54.   Igor Wise thinking 15:40  |  micon02 28/08/06
  55.   to tina 15:43  |  bob 28/08/06
  56.   No Regime Change In Israel 16:12  |  Messenger 28/08/06
  57.   Arrest the War Criminals and extradite them 16:29  |  Samuel Hirst 28/08/06
  58.   Tina in Jerusalem 16:38  |  Laura 28/08/06
  59.   Karim 16:56  |  Laura 28/08/06
  60.   To dror # 7- And tears come to my eyes too. 17:02  |  Kameel 28/08/06
  61.   Yes and No 17:08  |  Danite 28/08/06
  62.   Klaudia 17:15  |  Danite 28/08/06
  63.   War and peace plans 17:25  |  David ben Avigdor 28/08/06
  64.   How about a some more innovative diplomacy 17:40  |  Danny - Israeli one 28/08/06
  65.   Reply #62: Danite.SOS..a re-read of Ayn Rand is urgently required 17:47  |  Klaudia 28/08/06
  66.   Shatila, Sabra, Jenin, Qana 18:26  |  Marilyn 28/08/06
  67.   Steps for reconstruction 18:39  |  David ben Avigdor 28/08/06
  68.   Israel withuot power will only cause terrorist attacks 18:56  |  SHIMON 28/08/06
  69.   To # 45 Klaudia 19:02  |  philantrophist 28/08/06
  70.   Cleaning the slate 19:06  |  Otto Rand 28/08/06
  71.   For Shimon - poor little Israel 19:14  |  Clickfool 28/08/06
  72.   ONLY A NEWLY ELECTED GOV"T CAN "BEGIN" TO SOLVE ISRAEL"S PROBLEMS 19:15  |  another physicist 28/08/06
  73.   Peace is Israel`s only long term deterent, not military power 19:34  |  Pablo B 28/08/06
  74.   Marylin and clickfool...read history books 19:43  |  SHIMON 28/08/06
  75.   one undeniable fact 19:53  |  Joseph Palazzo 28/08/06
  76.   For Shimon, with the cheek to ask me to consider recent history 20:00  |  Clickfool 28/08/06
  77.   Klaudia(3rd try) 20:03  |  Danite 28/08/06
  78.   There is nothing wrong with the IDF 20:10  |  The Warrior 28/08/06
  79.   Power corrupts...... 20:15  |  mike lee 28/08/06
  80.   #36 - Israel has no morals 20:25  |  Disillusioned Jew 28/08/06
  81.   Live by the sword, by the sword you shall DIE 20:26  |  Beni 28/08/06
  82.   Value leaders 20:47  |  Jouko Piho 28/08/06
  83.   re:#15 20:59  |  jeff 28/08/06
  84.   Clickfool et al 21:03  |  Paul 28/08/06
  85.   Dude get a grip 21:17  |  Mario 28/08/06
  86.   #36 and #80...your wish to destroy israel 21:24  |  SHIMON 28/08/06
  87.   Two other things Mr. ven Avigdor 21:28  |  Mark Lincoln 28/08/06
  88.   Wrong analysis 21:44  |  anamerican 28/08/06
  89.   IDF in the Territories (Mark Lincoln #87) 21:53  |  David ben Avigdor 28/08/06
  90.   It Was Not Lack of Money, it Was Cowardice 22:04  |  Mr. Knowitall 28/08/06
  91.   Welcome to the 20`s Germany 22:04  |  Joshua 28/08/06
  92.   two interesting occurrences 22:25  |  thucydides 28/08/06
  93.   mark lincoln has not given us an explanation 22:28  |  zadok the priest 28/08/06
  94.   Power of Preseverving PEACE 22:42  |  Iranian-American 28/08/06
  95.   Time for peace 22:45  |  Lebanese 28/08/06
  96.   91Joshua: See Kissinger Joke in #11 22:54  |  Logician 28/08/06
  97.   Defense 23:07  |  P. J. Casey 28/08/06
  98.   To the logician - Come to boston 23:26  |  Joshua 28/08/06
  99.   Dear Ben Uziel... 23:31  |  marios polycarpou 28/08/06
  100.   #94 Iranian-American 23:39  |  Miguel 28/08/06
  101.   Zadok # 93 23:41  |  Another American 28/08/06
  102.   Bravo Tina... 23:45  |  marios polycarpou 28/08/06
  103.   Protest in the Rose Garden 23:50  |  RonH 28/08/06
  104.   reservist stand in the rose garden 23:52  |  sandra chitayat 28/08/06
  105.   THE 1st PART OF ANALYSIS IS RIGHT BUT.... 23:55  |  philosoph 28/08/06
  106.   David ben Avigdor - modes of corruption 00:01  |  Mark Lincoln 29/08/06
  107.   israel`s future 00:06  |  sandra chitayat 29/08/06
  108.   Dear Disillusioned Jew... 00:08  |  Marios Polycarpou 29/08/06
  109.   Israel`s Power 00:30  |  VAT INTERNATIONAL 29/08/06
  110.   An "other" American 00:40  |  jeff 29/08/06
  111.   Iranian-American 01:00  |  Laura 29/08/06
  112.   Israel`s power? 01:01  |  Hannah 29/08/06
  113.   Why the right wing is so anxious 01:23  |  Ex galil cowboy 29/08/06
  114.   To Danite # 77,, part 1 01:38  |  Klaudia 29/08/06
  115.   Ahmed the Shiek 01:42  |  Ehud the Prophet 29/08/06
  116.   Danite # 77...Part 2 01:58  |  Klaudia 29/08/06
  117.   to # 72 another physicist -absolutely correct! 02:02  |  Mike Levi 29/08/06
  118.   to Joshua in Boston 02:07  |  Joyce 29/08/06
  119.   My Dear Klaudia 02:12  |  Danite 29/08/06
  120.   #113- gali cowboy 02:15  |  Joyce 29/08/06
  121.   israeli power 02:17  |  sweis Melbourne 29/08/06
  122.   MARYLIN.Israel provoked SLA.Evidence please? 02:30  |  PETER SM 29/08/06
  123.   Mr. Knowitall from Frostbite Falls 02:34  |  rachel 29/08/06
  124.   Reply # 51 toni from Beirut 02:36  |  Klaudia 29/08/06
  125.   i,m sorry 03:11  |  ehud, the wrong 29/08/06
  126.   Tired Lauar and Miguel 03:17  |  Iranian-American 29/08/06
  127.   This is a tragedy of biblical proportion. 03:23  |  Dr. Ari Nir 29/08/06
  128.   My final response to Danite for today . 03:28  |  Klaudia 29/08/06
  129.   From whence ? 04:06  |  melchizedek 29/08/06
  130.   embeded with the dimwits 04:11  |  Michael N 29/08/06
  131.   to Zadok, Nasrallah showed his humanity, how about Olmert 04:13  |  gus 29/08/06
  132.   Danite #119 04:19  |  Gabe1 29/08/06
  133.   to Klaudia we are not perfect 04:24  |  gus 29/08/06
  134.   Hannah #112 04:28  |  Gabe1 29/08/06
  135.   #36 04:32  |  JOJO 29/08/06
  136.   Ari Shavit`s article 04:47  |  Joseph 29/08/06
  137.   #130 05:11  |  Hannah 29/08/06
  138.   z 05:24  |  x 29/08/06
  139.   The Lessons of History 05:32  |  Larry 29/08/06
  140.   The Lessons of History Part 2 05:35  |  Larry 29/08/06
  141.   Define Power? 05:38  |  Mark Lincoln 29/08/06
  142.   128- Michael N. 05:40  |  joyce 29/08/06
  143.   a 05:42  |  a 29/08/06
  144.   Zadock - the role of Armor 05:48  |  Mark Lincoln 29/08/06
  145.   Gus 05:53  |  Laura 29/08/06
  146.   Hannah 05:56  |  laura 29/08/06
  147.   Joseph of Toronto 06:00  |  Mark Lincoln 29/08/06
  148.   # 131 - Gus 06:13  |  Klaudia 29/08/06
  149.   joyce - no, you are wrong 06:21  |  Mark Lincoln 29/08/06
  150.   Joyce#120 06:21  |  Ex-galil cowboy 29/08/06
  151.   #112 Hannah and Her Sisters 06:27  |  Yonatan Netser 29/08/06
  152.   #76 To My Buddy Click 06:36  |  Yonatan Netser 29/08/06
  153.   #90 Cowardly Lions 06:46  |  Yonatan Netser 29/08/06
  154.   Israel have no choice 06:54  |  Willy 29/08/06
  155.   Ex-gali cowboy 06:56  |  joyce 29/08/06
  156.   #53 1948, 56, 73, 78, 82, 96, `06,Hike! 06:56  |  Liam Roth 29/08/06
  157.   Babarians will never survive 07:18  |  AYA 29/08/06
  158.   Israeli Ethics 07:19  |  Brigitte Meier 29/08/06
  159.   Little Help On All Fronts 07:21  |  Salama 29/08/06
  160.   #140 Joyce and #146 Mark 08:18  |  Michael N 29/08/06
  161.   146 Mark Lincoln -at least half wrong 08:22  |  logician 29/08/06
  162.   Israel`s Debacle. 08:23  |  stephen stout-kerr 29/08/06
  163.   98 To the logician - Come to boston: Been There... 08:42  |  Logician 29/08/06
  164.   For Yonatan Netser 09:14  |  Clickfool 29/08/06
  165.   Israel the only nation in trouble??? 09:33  |  Paul 29/08/06
  166.   peter sm-evidence 09:41  |  guiltyconscience 29/08/06
  167.   Ahmed #33, get a clue moron 10:23  |  Palestinian Prince 29/08/06
  168.   Stolen Land 10:33  |  US 29/08/06
  169.   Rose garden 11:00  |  007 29/08/06
  170.   #106 Hear, Hear! 11:28  |  Yonatan Netser 29/08/06
  171.   Re:Stolen Land -Needs to ck hist at local Library 19:17  |  Roy Galut 29/08/06
  172.   "Stolen Land" courtesy of US 23:51  |  Larry 29/08/06
  173.   Re 158 " Arabs now hate Israel." 01:29  |  DJStahl 30/08/06
  174.   Just face it 03:29  |  Eric 01/09/06
  175.   Why Indeed 12:41  |  Eric 01/09/06
  176.   Re:Stolen Land _ Needs to check history 15:29  |  Mike 08/09/06
 Today Online
Editorial: Blair is paying the price for his support for Israel
Responses: 86
Bradley Burston: Only right to stop calling Katsav president
Responses: 17
Yoel Marcus: Things are looking pretty awful in Israel
Responses: 40
U.S. Jews must ask questions about our relationship with Israel
Responses: 14
Ze'ev Schiff: It's wise not to show ingratitude to our army officers
Responses: 14
Arab MK: We don't see Syria as enemy state
Responses: 105


More Headlines
15:25 Israel: Lebanon sea blockade to end within hours
11:49 U.S. hoping for sanctions draft on Iran next week
12:59 MK on illegal trip to Syria: We don't see Syria as enemy state
10:31 Israel continues banning Gazans from studying in West Bank
08:24 Police raid office of Galilee group said used as Hamas front
12:35 President's Residence: Katsav doesn't plan to step down over sex probe
15:32 FM Livni says Israel should talk to Abbas without preconditions
14:49 Cyprus police check suspect cargo on Syria-bound ship
08:03 PM to meet Peretz, Hirchson in effort to tie up budgetary loose ends
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Nahal Haredi
Defending Israel's homeland. Help support our troops
One year MBA in Israel
Taught entirely in English
Israelity
The reality of daily life in Israel
Babylon 6
Text Translation at a single click, from any desktop application. Try it Now
FREE REGISTRATION at JLove.com
Join The Fastest Growing Jewish Singles Community Now! Click Here!
ISRAEL-SHOPS ONLINE STORE
Gifts from Israel + FREE ISRAELI FLAG ON EVERY PURCHASE OVER $50
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
JOIN FREE AT JDate.com
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved