Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., October 29, 2008 Tishrei 30, 5769 | | Israel Time: 01:07 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Peres Center Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 16:20 25/08/2006
Will Bush make Iran the only superpower?
By Bradley Burston

What if George W. Bush held your future in his hands?

He does.

Bush, who is fast nearing the mid-point of his second term, has yet to field a coherent policy regarding the grand dark-horse of 21st Century superpower politics, Iran.
Advertisement
Any move he makes will need to factor in a vast array of regional and global changes in the course of his presidency, among them, the vigor and influence of Al-Qaida, the sense of military and governmental momentum on the part of Hezbollah and Hamas, and the potency of the American armed forces in the long shadow of Iraq.

And then there is what may be called the Castration Clause.

Simply put, a government which is unwilling to use its power - and whose enemy knows of its unwillingness - has no power.

The sobering lose-lose coda:

A nuclear superpower that is unwilling to use the Bomb - and whose enemy knows of its unwillingness - has no bomb.

In a world in which a superpower may be unwilling or unable to exercise force, corollaries to the Castration Clause of deterrence say the following:

  • A side which is perceived by its enemy to be crazy, has deterrent power unavailable to the side which is perceived by its enemy to be rational.

  • A side which espouses, celebrates, rewards, enshrines martyrdom, which educates its youth toward death in what is couched as holy war, cannot be deterred by the same means that may apply to conventional nations and armies.

    This is especially true in nations, Israel among them, which over the years has placed a particular premium on preventing casualties to soldiers ? as a result, dithering at times over ground operations, and resorting to long-range bombing and shelling with high costs in civilian casualties and low rates of effectiveness.

  • A side which celebrates civilian deaths on its enemy's home front as victories, and which at the same time trumpets and exploits civilian deaths on its own home front as examples of war crimes [viz. Hezbollah, Islamic Jihad, et al.] will be much freer to make far-reaching military decisions and claim overall triumph than will an adversary with a free press and a different value system.

    Little wonder, then, that George Bush seems yet to have made up his mind.

    There was a time, much earlier in his presidency, when Bush seemed to have come up with a workable deterrent strategy - beating mentally unstable Middle East despots at their own game, by appearing to be even wilier, loonier and less predictable than they were.

    Conjuring a bottomless arsenal of Hollywood images of fast-drawing Texans, coupled with a legendary record of executions approved while he held the state house in Austin, Bush was able for some time to give pause to the likes of Muammar Ghaddafi, arguably the least stable member of the region's leadership cohort.

    But that was then.

    In recent years, the doomed neo-conservative grand design of fostering democracy among people who not only disagree with you, but revile your very existence, has given new meaning to the word backfire.

    The Iraq campaign, the target of a degree of bloodshed unimaginable even in Middle Eastern terms, undermined by premature claims of allied victory and tardy acknowledgement of intelligence failures and misrepresentations, has tapped into the ever-available American reservoir of isolationism.

    If America has had its fill of involvement in the Middle East, as many Americans already freely declare, George Bush may be politically incapable of going to war.

    If he is - and you can bet that none of the European or Asian nuclear powers have any plans to move against Iran - then Mahmoud Ahmadinejad may just fine himself effectively in charge of the world's only remaining superpower, the only one, that is, actually willing to go to war.

    Should that occur, Iran has made little secret of the likely first target.

    As early as December, 2001, one of Ahmadinejad's predecessors, Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani, was quoted as declaring, "If one day, the Islamic world is also equipped with weapons like those that Israel possesses now, then the imperialists' strategy will reach a standstill because the use of even one nuclear bomb inside Israel will destroy everything.

    By contrast to total annihilation in Israel, he said, a bomb "will only harm the Islamic world. It is not irrational to contemplate such an eventuality."

    On August 15, 2004, an Iranian military chief said that Israel and the U.S. would not dare to attack his country, since it could strike back anywhere in Israel with its latest Shehab 3 missiles.

    "The entire Zionist territory, including its nuclear facilities and atomic arsenal, are currently within range of Iran's advanced missiles," the ISNA students news agency quoted Yadollah Javani, the head of the Revolutionary Guards political bureau, as saying. "Therefore, neither the Zionist regime nor America will carry out its threats" against Iran, he said.

    Israel, which is some 1,200 kilometers from Iranian rockets, and more than 10,000 kilometers closer to Iranian rockets than New York or Washington are, has been watching Tehran's march toward technology - and Bush's response - with understandable interest.

    If Iran's shuck-and-jive dance with UN inspectors and negotiators can go on long enough, the entire dynamic could shift dramatically. A little more time, a lot more oil revenue, and the bomb goes Iranian.

    In the meanwhile, at least one thing has been proven beyond doubt. Bush, in fact, spent the summer learning this:

    A lack of policy is, in itself, a form of policy. And in the present world, it may also be the worst form. Failure to move through lack of policy, may, in fact, turn out to be your last move. Just ask Ehud Olmert, Amir Peretz, or Dan Halutz
    • Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Livni ahead in polls
    Netanyahu loses lead he has held for two years, while Labor heads for election debacle.
    The frozen chosen
    In staunchly Republican Alaska, a Jewish Democrat may take state's lone seat in Congress.
      1.   IN SUMMER 2008 10:40  |  indrajaya 25/08/06
      2.   Do you know what Iran wants? 11:31  |  fritz 25/08/06
      3.   To be able to foster democracy abroad 11:40  |  sh 25/08/06
      4.   Israeli territorial expansionism and nuclear hegemony 12:07  |  KMS 25/08/06
      5.   Bush`s masters are the Oil barons, and Saudi royals 12:15  |  Nannette 25/08/06
      6.   Who set the train in motion? 12:19  |  Rod from Oz 25/08/06
      7.   Burston is the most effective deterrent 12:26  |  Efraim 25/08/06
      8.   It is after all Israel that 12:29  |  Osborne Reed 25/08/06
      9.   Fight Your Own Battles! 12:31  |  Torrance 25/08/06
      10.   well this was just tested 12:38  |  surprise 25/08/06
      11.   Civilian Deaths 12:38  |  Wael Hendawi 25/08/06
      12.   SUPERPOWER 12:51  |  NeutralObserver 25/08/06
      13.   Nuclear.... 12:53  |  Darin 25/08/06
      14.   In my prediction... 13:21  |  Edith 25/08/06
      15.   Strong Defense of Israel and World Will Deal With Iran 13:27  |  Jane 25/08/06
      16.   You have woken up also Bradley Sort of 13:33  |  Shalom Freedman 25/08/06
      17.   Bush and Iran 13:40  |  Shalom Freedman 25/08/06
      18.   Iran, a superpower is doubtful 13:54  |  Kiki Bardot 25/08/06
      19.   A preemptive strike is a bad idea 14:08  |  Rachal Corrie 25/08/06
      20.   Bush gelded himself in Iraq 14:38  |  Mark Lincoln 25/08/06
      21.   to #5 - Flawed logic 14:43  |  Kangaroo 25/08/06
      22.   Indeed, take crazy people seriously 14:49  |  NotNaive 25/08/06
      23.   Civilian death, you got all wrong Mr Burston! 14:51  |  Sam 25/08/06
      24.   If Israel has the right to possess hundreds of nuclear bombs, 14:51  |  Karren Ayyoub 25/08/06
      25.   rationalized hysteria ? 15:05  |  Froggie 25/08/06
      26.   US drivel... 15:05  |  marios polycarpou 25/08/06
      27.   What exactly are you calling for? 15:32  |  Michael N 25/08/06
      28.   Iran, a sharp splinter, not a sowrd 15:49  |  Ali 25/08/06
      29.   Pre-emptive Strike = backwards 17:22  |  aCuban 25/08/06
      30.   US may yet connive.... 17:25  |  Zardos 25/08/06
      31.   Iran, a `superpower`? 17:25  |  Mark Lincoln 25/08/06
      32.   Armchair analysis about Iran 17:36  |  Alfred 25/08/06
      33.   Sam, that Wikopedia 17:46  |  Mark Lincoln 25/08/06
      34.   Response Details 17:49  |  Frank 25/08/06
      35.   Nuke `em 17:51  |  Mark Lincoln 25/08/06
      36.   mark lincoln 17:58  |  carol 25/08/06
      37.   Castration?! 18:01  |  George W 25/08/06
      38.   to Mark Lincoln (and Kiki Bardot) 18:09  |  Efraim 25/08/06
      39.   Primary Process Illogic 18:09  |  Dr. A. W. Walker 25/08/06
      40.   #31 Iran won the War? Hardly. 19:14  |  Zardos 25/08/06
      41.   More psychotic detachment 19:37  |  Mark Lincoln 25/08/06
      42.   IRAN THE DARK HORSE CAN BE NUKED 20:14  |  Larry Klein 25/08/06
      43.   same Zionist scare tactics 20:49  |  hollingsworth 25/08/06
      44.   #21 Kangaroo - Hamas desires genocide? (4th try) 21:07  |  Bor de Wolf 25/08/06
      45.   re:#9"fight your own battles" 21:13  |  jeff 25/08/06
      46.   Psychotic response Lincoln #41 01:13  |  Zardos 26/08/06
      47.   Osborne Reed 01:39  |  Sarah 26/08/06
      48.   Iran a superpower 01:43  |  Larry 26/08/06
      49.   #44 Bor De Wolf. Still sounds like Genocide to me. 01:51  |  Zardos 26/08/06
      50.   Psychotic response Lincoln #41 01:52  |  Zardos 26/08/06
      51.   #49 Zardos - PLO charter and genocide 03:11  |  Bor de Wolf 26/08/06
      52.   the bomb goes Iranian 03:23  |  RW 26/08/06
      53.   George Bush may be politically incapable of going to war. 03:37  |  RW 26/08/06
      54.   How to put a bully in his place 03:46  |  Mark Lincoln 26/08/06
      55.   Garbage by any other name 03:51  |  Mark Lincoln 26/08/06
      56.   Zrdos, you made no points. 03:54  |  Mark Lincoln 26/08/06
      57.   I admit it. I don`t like George Bush 04:06  |  Mark Lincoln 26/08/06
      58.   RW if he orders, the military will go 04:16  |  Mark Lincoln 26/08/06
      59.   Israel Should Worry About Getting Rid of Its Covernment 05:26  |  Tod Zuckerman 26/08/06
      60.   Re 71 News at 11 05:48  |  Alan (the original) 26/08/06
      61.   If Democrats gain power in 2009 05:51  |  Roy Galut 26/08/06
      62.   RE 35 Guess why 05:56  |  Alan (original) 26/08/06
      63.   Real threat to world peace 08:18  |  Jose Vidal 26/08/06
      64.   No 5 Bush`s masters 09:39  |  Jackie Jaidy 26/08/06
      65.   Roy & US elections 09:48  |  Rod from Oz 26/08/06
      66.   People get the leaders they deserve because u guys are the voters 10:19  |  lennybruce 26/08/06
      67.   Too much adrenalin 11:02  |  Brigitte Meier 26/08/06
      68.   # 17, SHALOM FREEDMAN 11:50  |  indrajaya 26/08/06
      69.   # 61, ROY GALUT 11:57  |  indrajaya 26/08/06
      70.   Michael 12:00  |  Ernie 26/08/06
      71.   Solid Article, Burston 12:57  |  Dror 26/08/06
      72.   Iran wants a deterrent not a war. 13:35  |  Microraptor 26/08/06
      73.   Israel needs cool thinking; 13:37  |  A Khokar 26/08/06
      74.   Very sad.... 13:47  |  microraptor 26/08/06
      75.   #60 Alan - Hezbollah, Hamas and German language 13:48  |  Bor de Wolf 26/08/06
      76.   Lincoln. From psychotic to pathological. 13:50  |  Zardos 26/08/06
      77.   #62 Alan - chemical and bio weapons 13:56  |  Bor de Wolf 26/08/06
      78.   #58 Mark Lincoln - Generals` obedience 14:05  |  Bor de Wolf 26/08/06
      79.   Zardos and Wikipedia 14:18  |  David 26/08/06
      80.   Nuke Them Now 14:57  |  Asian Observer 26/08/06
      81.   YOU GIVE BUSH WAY TOO MUCH POWER! 15:48  |  Virginia 26/08/06
      82.   AND HE (BUSH) KNOWS IT FULL WELL. 15:53  |  Virginia 26/08/06
      83.   Bor de Wolf - careers and toys 17:08  |  Mark Lincoln 26/08/06
      84.   YOU GIVE BUSH WAY TOO MUCH POWER! - Virginia 17:10  |  Mark Lincoln 26/08/06
      85.   "Absolute" military? "Surpreme" military? Surely you jest! 18:00  |  Virginia 26/08/06
      86.   Torrance- Keep your American Aid 18:33  |  The Cid 26/08/06
      87.   Was it the military that parted the Sea? 18:45  |  Virginia 26/08/06
      88.   BOR de WOLF 20:26  |  Chaval 26/08/06
      89.   THE HYPE MEISTERS AT WORK 23:06  |  Cyrus the Great 26/08/06
      90.   I don`t put any faith in the Supreme Junta 23:49  |  Mark Lincoln 26/08/06
      91.   Bor De Wolf #51 00:11  |  Zardos 27/08/06
      92.   68 de Wolf (2nd try) - Hezbollah, Hamas, Hitler & Genocide 00:18  |  Logician 27/08/06
      93.   5Wael Hendawi - Civilian Deaths & Hezbollah 00:37  |  Logician 27/08/06
      94.   Bor de Wolf 01:02  |  Danite 27/08/06
      95.   Mark Lincoln 01:03  |  Danite 27/08/06
      96.   Neo_Con Nightmare 05:06  |  Fred Goepfert 27/08/06
      97.   In The Land Of Bad Dreams 05:10  |  Anthony 27/08/06
      98.   #80 Danite - General`s obedience (3rd try) 07:01  |  Bor de Wolf 27/08/06
      99.   to mark lincoln and zardos 07:36  |  maoriboy 27/08/06
      100.   Bor de Wolf Hello 07:51  |  Danite 27/08/06
      101.   Bor the expert 08:26  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 27/08/06
      102.   #80 logician - hezbollah; hitler 08:41  |  Bor de Wolf 27/08/06
      103.   I like George W. Bush, but 08:56  |  Darren 27/08/06
      104.   #88 Danite - democracy and obedience 09:00  |  Bor de Wolf 27/08/06
      105.   KEEP DEMANDING UNTIL SLAPPED 10:13  |  arab 27/08/06
      106.   @ 52 You think religious fanatics to be rational... 15:25  |  Karl 27/08/06
      107.   To Bradly Burston.FOR WHAT IS WORTH.... 20:22  |  Kathy 27/08/06
      108.   America`s military is the most lethal on earth, but... 00:45  |  Devin Leonard 28/08/06
      109.   # 63 Jacky Jaidy. GEE WHIZZZ! YOU DECIDED TO JOIN THE HUMAN RACE? 01:28  |  Kathy 28/08/06
      110.   # 41 Mark Lincoln.re: Iran`s Survival??? 02:26  |  Kathy 28/08/06
      111.   # To Bradley Burston. I RE-READ THE LAST 5 PARAGRAPHS......... 02:59  |  Kathy 28/08/06
      112.   To Mr.B.Bradley. JUST SENT YOU ONE NOT OUT YET.JUST AN ADDENDUM.. 03:37  |  Kathy 28/08/06
      113.   Re:65 -Roy & US elections 08:21  |  Roy Galut 28/08/06
      114.   Re69# 61, ROY GALUT 08:29  |  Roy Galut 28/08/06
      115.   Re: Summer `08 #1 18:23  |  mosahommesus 28/08/06
      116.   Doomsday Superpowers 00:28  |  Ylurnu `jorge` Jarvi 29/08/06
      117.   The West Is Craven 04:07  |  Zoog 29/08/06
      118.   Warmongering in the name of self-defense 05:30  |  Reader 29/08/06
      119.   Iraq beat Iran??...not really... 05:47  |  Josh 29/08/06
      120.   Thinking much the same thing recently 06:34  |  Jason&Freddymeetalla 29/08/06
      121.   Peace Lovers Have Bigger ... 08:20  |  Timothy 29/08/06
      122.   NUKE IRAN NOW! 22:57  |  kill or be killed 29/08/06
      123.   To # 122 kill or be killed 09:48  |  Adel 31/08/06
      124.   Pakistan is very islamic and has nukes 07:35  |  omolll 01/09/06
      125.   YES YES SEND MORE AMERICAN BOY`S TO DIE-4-ISRAEL 07:12  |  CHEEWAWA 02/09/06
      126.   how to disarm Iran 00:56  |  francois pelletier 03/09/06
      127.   all nukes are bad... ours or theirs!! 07:30  |  Joshua Green 06/09/06
      128.   LIES 02:30  |  LORI 25/03/07
      129.   Bradley Burston 17:28  |  Satar 04/01/08
      130.   rationality vs. intelligence; craziness vs. stupidity. 01:01  |  Kaveh 29/10/08
     Read & React
    Sources: Sarkozy views Obama stance on Iran as 'utterly immature'
    Responses: 101
    Moshe Arens: It's the IDF, not the security fence that stops terror
    Responses: 38
    Yoel Marcus: Tzipi Livni deserves to win
    Responses: 39
    U.S. agents foil neo-Nazi plot to assassinate Obama
    Responses: 130
    Israeli ambassador meets Palin, as Republicans rally for Virginia
    Responses: 53


    More Headlines
    00:52 Joe the Plumber: A vote for Obama is a vote for the death of Israel
    23:21 Syria demands UN action against U.S. over raid
    20:18 Witness in Hirchson graft case: I handed Olmert a fat envelope
    23:04 IAEA: Samples from alleged Syria nuke site justify further probe
    23:56 Jewish Arab aide to Moroccan king urges Israel to adopt Saudi peace plan
    21:51 Palestinian student campaigns for Obama from Gaza refugee camp
    23:17 Legendary singers gather in Tel Aviv to celebrate Peres Center
    23:28 General elections to be held in Israel by middle of February
    22:46 Ex-Meretz chairman Beilin announces he's retiring from politics
    15:38 Peres: Israel is closer to peace than ever before
    22:49 Biden voices 'unshakable commitment' to strong Israel-U.S. ties
    14:10 A chance to yell at Yossi Beilin
    13:24 Saudi luxury car sales seen rising despite global crisis
    12:02 PLAY THE NEWS / Can you beat OPEC at its own game?
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Fattal Hotel Chain
    Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
    Living in Israel Studying in English
    Click & Meet our students from all around the world
    Dial 013 for your long-distance calls
    and get all your money back
    US CITIZENS
    Vote for real change. Request your ballot today!
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
    Jewish Singles Personal Ads
    Find the love of your life on JDate.com
    Israel's Premier Real Estate Website
    www. israel-property.com
    Hebrew Summer courses
    From $39.95
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
    Real Estate in Israel | Travel to Israel with Haaretz | Hotels Israel | Restaurants Israel | Tourist attractions Israel | Shops Israel
    birthright Israel | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved