Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., September 04, 2006 Elul 11, 5766 | | Israel Time: 09:46 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate
Shopping
 
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Moshe Katsav is facing possible rape charges following claims by a former employee that he coerced her into sexual acts. (Archive)
Last update - 23:55 23/08/2006
Panel chair: Katsav dismissal not on agenda before probe ends
By Yuval Yoaz, Jonathan Lis, and Amiram Barkat, Haaretz Correspondents

The Knesset House Committee cannot convene to discuss the dismissal of President Moshe Katsav from his position before police complete their investigation into the allegations against him, chairwoman MK Ruhama Avraham (Kadima) said Wednesday.

Katsav is being investigated under caution for allegedly coercing a female former employee to have sex with him - a charge tantamount to rape - as well as violating laws governing sexual harassment.

Labor MK Yoram Marciano began earlier in the day to collect signatures from his colleagues calling on the House Committee to convene to discuss the president's dismissal.

Advertisement

Marciano said an individual subject to questioning by police under warning on suspicion of committing serious crimes cannot be serving as president.

According to Knesset regulations, the signatures of 20 MKs are required in order to appeal to the House Committee chairman to begin the process of debating dismissal of the president.

Avraham told Haaretz on Wednesday evening that even if she does receive 20 signatures, she will not convene the committee until the police have completed their probe.

Nevertheless, Avraham called on Katsav "to save the honor of the presidency and go on leave until the conclusion of the investigation."

Five hours over of questioning
Katsav underwent five hours of police questioning at the President's Residence in Jerusalem on Wednesday.

Investigators will resume quizzing the president over the affair Thursday morning. Katsav is suspected of carrying on a sexual relationship with "A.", a one-time employee at the President's Residence. Law enforcement officials also suspect the president committed a number of sex-related crimes.

The team of investigators is examining whether the nature of the former employee's relationship with the president was wholly consensual.

"The president cooperated in full and answered the investigators' questions," Katsav's attorney, Tzion Amir, said. "The questioning was done in a good atmosphere and was handled in a professional manner."

"The president never broke any law and didn't sexually harass anyone," Amir added. "The president is in an uplifting mood, and I want to emphasize that we are talking about a painful matter from his standpoint."

A senior police official told Haaretz that "the material that has been compiled thus far in the affair is more significant and dramatic than that which has been made public in the media.

Katsav will be questioned at least two more times in the coming days, police officials said Wednesday. Dozens of other workers in his office have also been questioned and more are to be interrogated, the officials said, speaking on condition of anonymity because they weren't authorized to speak to the media.

The officials said the questioning was being conducted in a "good atmosphere," but that it was still too early to say whether there was enough evidence to indict Katsav. Police have also not completed their work on computers seized from Katsav's office Monday, the officials said.

Katsav is being questioned "under caution," a legal term indicating that the subject of the investigation is a suspect, and that there is a significant chance that he may later face indictment.

During the Monday raid, which began at about 9 P.M. and lasted seven hours, police confiscated Katsav's personal computer, his office computer, several other computers and numerous documents.

Attorney General Menachem Mazuz approved the police's request to question Katsav under caution, thereby officially designating him a suspect in an affair that began with him in the role of victim.

Mazuz opened the investigation after Katsav told him that a former employee, A., was trying to blackmail him. However, the probe soon moved on to investigating two complaints made by A. against Katsav: that he forced her to have sex with him by threatening to fire her if she refused, and that there were improprieties in his process of granting pardons to prisoners.

Police sources said that the documents seized during Monday's raid, as well as the email correspondence on the computers, may help them determine the nature of Katsav's relations with A., as well as whether any employees of the President's Residence have attempted to sabotage the investigation. However, they do not expect this material to cast any light on the pardons affair.

The raid, they added, was planned several weeks ago.

Wednesday's interrogation, which is taking place in the President's Residence, is expected to focus mainly on the sexual harassment allegation, but will also touch on the pardons. In media interviews over the past few weeks, Katsav has repeatedly denied having sexual relations with any employee of his office.

Police sources said that Katsav's wife, Gila, is also likely to be questioned in the coming days. In addition, depending on the results of today's interrogation, the police may stage a confrontation
between the president and A.

To date, dozens of employees of the President's Residence have been questioned, but the investigation is expected to take several more months. According to a source familiar with the probe, "this is not a small case, but a ramified one whose investigation will last a long time. This probe is more complicated than it seemed initially."

A senior police official added: "The information that has accumulated in this affair thus far is more significant and dramatic than has been published in the media."

Katsav's office said in response that "the President's Residence announced from the start that it would cooperate with the investigation. Every document and bit of evidence is at the police's disposal for the sake of uncovering the truth. The president is interested in giving his version and proving the falsity of these grave leaks."

In addition, Katsav's lawyers, David Libai and Zion Amir, demanded that the police give the media access to a tape that Katsav made of a conversation between himself and A., saying that this was only fair now that A.'s version of the story has been leaked to the press. The lawyers said that the tape, which Katsav gave the police a few days ago, proves that A.'s alleged extortion attempt had nothing to do with sexual harassment.

They also demanded that Mazuz investigate "the source of the numerous and tendentious leaks from the police investigation." Finally, they protested the description of the police's Monday visit to the President's Residence as a "raid," saying: "The residence's doors are always open" to the police.

Sources in Mazuz's office Tuesday rejected speculation that the case might be closed if Katsav were to resign and retire from public life. In light of the gravity of the suspicions against him, they said, there is a clear public interest in continuing the probe.

Even if Katsav does not resign, however, the Knesset could begin proceedings to oust him, a development, Katsav's lawyers charged, that the leaks from the investigation are aimed at promoting. According to the Basic Law on the President, the Knesset may oust the president if "he is unfit to serve due to behavior unbecoming to his position as president of the state."

By law, such a process would begin with a complaint to the Knesset House Committee signed by at least 20 Knesset members. The House Committee would then have to approve the motion by a three-quarters majority. If it did, the motion would be sent to the full Knesset, which would have to approve it by a special majority of at least 90 MKs.

Should Katsav either resign or be ousted, his place would be filled by Knesset Speaker Dalia Itzik until a replacement is elected. Alternatively, Katsav could suspend himself temporarily on the grounds that he is "unable to fulfill his duties." Such a suspension, which requires approval by the Knesset House Committee, would be valid for a maximum of three months, but could then be renewed for an additional three months. In that case, too, Itzik would replace Katsav until he returned.

Should the police find sufficient evidence to indict Katsav, it may not be possible to do so immediately: A sitting president cannot be indicted, and even after he leaves office, he remains exempt from prosecution for any act carried out "in the fulfillment of his duties." However, Justice Ministry sources said that a claim that Katsav's suspected offenses were carried out "in the fulfillment of his duties" would not stand up in court.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Jewish Finns celebrate
Finland's tiny Jewish community marks its 100th anniversary this week.
Hungary probes past
Court to hold hearings for Jews trying to reposses their WWII bank accounts.
  1.   Mr. President 13:31  |  David 22/08/06
  2.   political rules of engagement 13:37  |  Kiki Bardot 22/08/06
  3.   Rotten nation 13:38  |  Joe 22/08/06
  4.   President 13:40  |  Lebanese 22/08/06
  5.   light upon mankind 13:52  |  Levy 22/08/06
  6.   Joe from the USA, talking about Rotten nation? 14:11  |  Tulip 22/08/06
  7.   Lebanese and examples 14:13  |  Tulip 22/08/06
  8.   no 5 14:18  |  melania 22/08/06
  9.   Israel changing from a Rapper - country to a "Raper" - country ?? 14:19  |  Dino 22/08/06
  10.   Why seize computers? 14:44  |  Pc user 22/08/06
  11.   The Executive, Legislative and Military..OOPS!! 14:48  |  Yaakov Sullivan 22/08/06
  12.   to tulip 14:48  |  lebanese 2 22/08/06
  13.   A country where a woman doesn`t have to fear the rulers 14:49  |  Jeroen de Jager 22/08/06
  14.   A country where a woman doesn`t have to fear the rulers 14:50  |  Jeroen de Jager 22/08/06
  15.   Re: Lebanese and examples 14:53  |  Salim 22/08/06
  16.   "and as long as muslims take 4 wives" 14:56  |  Gode Michele 22/08/06
  17.   joe no 3 15:02  |  michael 22/08/06
  18.   #2 To Kuku Bardot, Check your fact 15:02  |  Haham from Bat Yam 22/08/06
  19.   Muslim Rulers... 15:05  |  Leonard 22/08/06
  20.   To # 7, Tullip 15:07  |  Ahmad 22/08/06
  21.   # Joe, how about Bill Clinton or John Kennedy 15:12  |  Haham from Bat Yam 22/08/06
  22.   Tulip and her excuse for human weakness #6 15:17  |  Yaakov Sullivan 22/08/06
  23.   # 8 there can be love via internet 15:17  |  Haham from Bat Yam 22/08/06
  24.   # 5, Except Ramon they are all Likudniks and some Kadima by now. 15:19  |  Haham from Bat Yam 22/08/06
  25.   TO # 10 why seize computers? 15:34  |  Another Pc user 22/08/06
  26.   Police seize computer 15:34  |  Menashe Aron 22/08/06
  27.   What`s the big deal? 15:40  |  Alan 22/08/06
  28.   To Tulip 15:45  |  AB 22/08/06
  29.   President Katsav. 15:55  |  David Nigel Braham 22/08/06
  30.   groping 16:10  |  jorje 22/08/06
  31.   To: Nr 13 16:21  |  leon 22/08/06
  32.   To Lebanese 16:27  |  Rola THE Lebanese 22/08/06
  33.   To PC user (10)-It`s also related to the fixed pardons allegation 16:29  |  JustMe 22/08/06
  34.   police seize computers... 16:29  |  k.herzallah 22/08/06
  35.   Tulip on 4 wives 16:35  |  Nadir 22/08/06
  36.   common sense should prevail; 16:36  |  SAM 22/08/06
  37.   TMr President 16:37  |  Mick 22/08/06
  38.   To Tulip 16:44  |  Anwar 22/08/06
  39.   TULIP 16:52  |  Sylvia 22/08/06
  40.   Lebanese and examples 16:54  |  Mauritanian 22/08/06
  41.   #10, PC user 16:54  |  Naomi 22/08/06
  42.   Lebanese cannot lecture Israel about internal politics 17:07  |  Jake 22/08/06
  43.   Clinton: "I did not have sexual relations with that woman" 17:09  |  Jake 22/08/06
  44.   Katsav sex machine 17:14  |  commentator 22/08/06
  45.   Political Harassment by Post-Zionist Oligarchs 17:25  |  Ben Israel 22/08/06
  46.   Humans .. 17:44  |  Nazih 22/08/06
  47.   Re: Lebanese cannot lecture Israel about internal politics 17:46  |  Sly 22/08/06
  48.   our leaders need to take off kit gloves not underpants 17:47  |  luke 22/08/06
  49.   to Mauritanian 17:48  |  Nazih - Lebanese 22/08/06
  50.   Katsav 18:14  |  Fred 22/08/06
  51.   Isn`t Katsav Iranian originally? 18:25  |  Adam 22/08/06
  52.   That`s Silly FRED from Chicago 18:26  |  Lebanese 22/08/06
  53.   Don`t jump into conclusion 18:26  |  Brod 22/08/06
  54.   Adam #51, Yes, along with Mofaz-Iranians 18:40  |  Yaakov Sullivan 22/08/06
  55.   Lebanese 2 18:48  |  Tulip 22/08/06
  56.   You are right Jeroen de Jager, sex in the muslim world 18:50  |  Tulip 22/08/06
  57.   Ahmad, my neighbors in Abu Dis 18:52  |  Tulip 22/08/06
  58.   Aha, now I got it Sullivan 18:54  |  Tulip 22/08/06
  59.   President`s troubles 18:57  |  shula gross 22/08/06
  60.   To all men who think 4 wives is okay. 18:57  |  Tulip 22/08/06
  61.   Israeli President 19:01  |  Anna_Lucia 22/08/06
  62.   #11--absolutely correct 19:10  |  Paul Freedman 22/08/06
  63.   52 Lebanese 19:12  |  Fred 22/08/06
  64.   serious 19:21  |  netani 22/08/06
  65.   No Tulip, nothing here to do with conversions #58 19:22  |  Yaakov Sullivan 22/08/06
  66.   Tulip on four wives #60 19:25  |  Yaakov Sullivan 22/08/06
  67.   If Katsav is Iranian, then let`s invade Iran. 19:29  |  imho 22/08/06
  68.   Reverse "Wag the dog" 19:38  |  ito 22/08/06
  69.   imho #64 have no fear. its on the horizon 19:46  |  yaakov sullivan 22/08/06
  70.   a kiss is just a kiss 19:58  |  shurik 22/08/06
  71.   Evidence? 19:59  |  Shiran 22/08/06
  72.   The difference between theory and practice, Sullivan 20:00  |  Tulip 22/08/06
  73.   President katsav. 2 20:04  |  David Nigel Braham 22/08/06
  74.   Much Worse Sexual Harassment 20:06  |  David 22/08/06
  75.   Innocent until proven guilty 20:15  |  Rune F 22/08/06
  76.   tulip. as usual, you assume wrong #72 20:17  |  Yaakov Sullivan 22/08/06
  77.   To all the women posting here-on a lighter note 20:19  |  Tina 22/08/06
  78.   Nonsense, Sullivan? 20:27  |  Tulip 22/08/06
  79.   Tina, me too 20:28  |  Tulip 22/08/06
  80.   Yaakov Sullivan, Jewish monogamism is based in Genesis 20:38  |  Jake 22/08/06
  81.   Skittles 20:51  |  sh 22/08/06
  82.   Jake, your reasoning is erroneous #80 20:58  |  Yaakov Sullivan