Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., September 17, 2006 Elul 24, 5766 | | Israel Time: 02:40 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate
Shopping
 
Bookmark to del.icio.us
IDF reservist troops returning to Israel after fighting in southern Lebanon earlier this month. (AP)
Last update - 17:58 21/08/2006
TEXT: Protest petition by IDF reservists back from the war
By Haaretz Service

The following is the text of a petition signed by IDF reservists who served in the Spearhead Brigade in Lebanon, sent to Defense Minister Amir Peretz and IDF Chief of Staff Dan Halutz in protest at the handling of the war by the government and senior military officials:

We, fighters and commanders at the Spearhead [Hod Hachanit] Brigade, were called up to enlist under an emergency mobilization order [Tzav 8] on July 30, 2006. Our attendance was complete in all battalions.

As we were signing on the battle equipment and weapons, we knew that we were signing for much more. We left behind wives and children, girlfriends and families. We put aside our jobs and livelihoods; we were prepared to carry out our mission under the most difficult of conditions, in heat, thirst or hunger.

Advertisement

At the back of his mind, each and every one of us knew, that for the just cause of protecting the citizens of Israel, we would even put our lives on the line.

But there was one thing we were not and would not be willing to accept: We were unwilling to accept indecisiveness. The war's aim, which was not defined clearly, was even changed in the course of the fighting.

The indecisiveness manifested itself in inaction, in not carrying out operational plans, and in canceling all the missions we were given during the fighting. This led to prolonged stays in hostile territory, without an operational purpose and out of unprofessional considerations, without seeking to engage in combat with the enemy.

The "cold feet" of the decision-makers were evident everywhere. To us the indecisiveness expressed deep disrespect for our willingness to join the ranks and fight and made us feel as though we had been spat on, since it contradicts the principles and values of warfare upon which we were trained at the Israel Defense Forces.

The heavy feeling that in the echelons above us there is nothing but under-preparation, insincerity, lack of foresight and inability to make rational decisions, leads to the question - were we called up for nothing?

We are now on the day after, and it seems that the immorality and the absence of any shame are the fig-leaves to be used in order to cover up for the blunders. The blunders of the past six years and the under-preparation of the army have been carried on our backs - the backs of the fighters. In order to face the next battle prepared - and this may happen soon - a thorough and fundamental change must take place.

The crisis of confidence between us as fighters and the higher echelons will not be resolved without a thorough and worthy investigative commission under the auspices of the state. When the commission completes its task, conclusions must be drawn both on the level of strategic planning and national security, and on the personal level of the parties involved.

We paid a heavy price in order to fight and come out of the battle victorious, and we feel this has been denied of us. We will all attend calls to enlist in the future for any mission we will be required to complete, but we would like to know that these missions will be part of a clear objective and will be carried out by striving to engage in combat.

As soldiers and citizens we expect a response at your earliest convenience,

We the undersigned

Fighters and officers of the Spearhead Brigade

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Bon(ito) appetit!
Nothing goes better in sashimi than this salty little relative of the tuna.
Eating Well
There's a tendency to isolate an element and use it in the expectation of a miracle.
  1.   Weak-hearted Politicians are undermining Israel`s potential... 08:21  |  Mike 21/08/06
  2.   Soldiers Complaints 09:00  |  Jack 21/08/06
  3.   Something missing 09:10  |  S 21/08/06
  4.   The blunders of the past six years 09:19  |  sh 21/08/06
  5.   to the IDF 09:20  |  Gus 21/08/06
  6.   Petition 09:24  |  RAE 21/08/06
  7.   OLMERT SAVED ISRAEL 10:22  |  Han Barboot 21/08/06
  8.   Tactics 10:38  |  David Latter 21/08/06
  9.   Ari Shavit could not to say better. We need clean our elites 11:03  |  Zehava B. 21/08/06
  10.   protest by killers back from the slaughter 11:06  |  raymond deane 21/08/06
  11.   With peretz in command ! 11:10  |  SJ 21/08/06
  12.   This is a military? 11:11  |  Natallie Durson 21/08/06
  13.   Mr Han barboot thank you 11:11  |  Gus 21/08/06
  14.   Reservists insurrection 11:17  |  Davis 21/08/06
  15.   "the just cause of protecting the citizens of Israel" ?????????? 11:27  |  fritz 21/08/06
  16.   Soldier`s letter 11:31  |  Proud Zionist 21/08/06
  17.   "historically the best peace can be made with a strong adversary" 11:33  |  fritz 21/08/06
  18.   What a shame, no David-Star over Beirut ?? 11:36  |  Dino 21/08/06
  19.   Reservists 11:37  |  fk 21/08/06
  20.   look on the bright side: isnt it good to "lose" in a small scale? 11:42  |  Albert Fischer 21/08/06
  21.   gus#5 better pause for breath 11:46  |  harzion 21/08/06
  22.   gus i understand what you are saying 11:49  |  harzion 21/08/06
  23.   War for all the wrong reasons. 12:00  |  John 21/08/06
  24.   Stalling for time on expense ofl lives 12:02  |  annonymus 21/08/06
  25.   DINO In your haste to denigrate,you become incomprehensible. 12:07  |  PETER SM 21/08/06
  26.   soldiers-norrow minded as they are needed 12:17  |  michael 21/08/06
  27.   Valid criticisms and demands 12:45  |  Dror 21/08/06
  28.   FRITZ Those Israeli is are too dumb,give your priceless advice to 12:47  |  PETER SM 21/08/06
  29.   reservists 12:55  |  Mike 21/08/06
  30.   25 Peter SM Dear Peter SM, a little bit of mockery should.... 13:09  |  Dino 21/08/06
  31.   These are the true heroes of Israel!! 13:38  |  Ben Uziel 21/08/06
  32.   Most of Israel no under attack 13:56  |  Marilyn 21/08/06
  33.   this is what is called courage! 14:10  |  Observing Historian 21/08/06
  34.   John 14:19  |  sh 21/08/06
  35.   Dino."A little bit of mockery etc"Try it with the Arabs 14:25  |  PETER SM 21/08/06
  36.   Natallie Durson 14:29  |  sh 21/08/06
  37.   To sh 14:48  |  John 21/08/06
  38.   PETER SM! STOP MOCKING EU AND DINO 14:48  |  Albert Fischer 21/08/06
  39.   To Mike 14:50  |  John 21/08/06
  40.   EU-mocking: i forgot 14:52  |  Albert Fischer 21/08/06
  41.   be patient 15:15  |  nasser 21/08/06
  42.   text 15:19  |  Alan Stulman 21/08/06
  43.   Excuses for failure 15:29  |  bc 21/08/06
  44.   Olmert Has Gotta Go 15:35  |  CHGODMK 21/08/06
  45.   This isn`t World War II - diplomacy is also a weapon 15:45  |  Karen R 21/08/06
  46.   A DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVE 15:47  |  abram epstein 21/08/06
  47.   democracy at work 15:51  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 21/08/06
  48.   too many loonies post here 15:53  |  Dror 21/08/06
  49.   John 15:59  |  sh 21/08/06
  50.   Were these boys prepared?? 15:59  |  Francois 21/08/06
  51.   in Support of Spearhead Unit 16:03  |  Moshe Dayan 21/08/06
  52.   Chgodmk #41 16:08  |  Gabe1 21/08/06
  53.   @ 12 Natallie One question... 16:09  |  Karl 21/08/06
  54.   THIS IS THE MOST CHILLING INDICMENT OF THIS INEPT GOVERNMENT. 16:22  |  another physicist 21/08/06
  55.   Mike 16:23  |  fk 21/08/06
  56.   to Cipora Julianna Kohn 16:31  |  Observing Historian 21/08/06
  57.   Citizen Soldiers 16:32  |  Don 21/08/06
  58.   Need more Jews than Zionist 16:36  |  steve 21/08/06
  59.   don`t you people never reflect? 16:39  |  Guy Willems 21/08/06
  60.   Peerhaps Israel Could Solve This Whole Thing 16:42  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/08/06
  61.   response to too many idiots post here 16:59  |  Jeff 21/08/06
  62.   Petition 17:07  |  Blane Burns 21/08/06
  63.   All of this was quite apparent during the war 17:07  |  Mark Lincoln 21/08/06
  64.   Cipora - true, and an old Israeli tradition 17:08  |  Mark Lincoln 21/08/06
  65.   protest petition 17:13  |  Roberto 21/08/06
  66.   They dont get it do they? 17:18  |  Lubnani Yehudi 21/08/06
  67.   #21 and #22 Harizon 17:30  |  Larry 21/08/06
  68.   Racism 17:31  |  Ethan 21/08/06
  69.   Nobody likes to lose 17:35  |  Dave 21/08/06
  70.   Protest petition 17:38  |  Patricia J. Baldwin 21/08/06
  71.   Weak souls = Weak hearts 17:39  |  Michael 21/08/06
  72.   Punked out by weekend warriors 17:40  |  Judas 21/08/06
  73.   Re: moshe dayan n.48 18:12  |  007 21/08/06
  74.   Give it a break!! 18:12  |  Rufus 21/08/06
  75.   Resign 18:20  |  Niall 21/08/06
  76.   Liberal Elites 18:21  |  Big Dave 21/08/06
  77.   Stop 18:21  |  Todd 21/08/06
  78.   Natalie Durson 18:22  |  Niall 21/08/06
  79.   Nasser 18:34  |  Salonius 21/08/06
  80.   Complaining about the complainers complaining 18:43  |  Berndt 21/08/06
  81.   Were these boys prepared? 18:45  |  Mark Lincoln 21/08/06
  82.   Karen, Diplomacy was also a weapon in WW II 18:49  |  Mark Lincoln 21/08/06
  83.   Bring back Netanyahu! 18:56  |  SF 21/08/06
  84.   Chgodmk #41 18:56  |  Gabe1 21/08/06
  85.   No other country... 18:57  |  Aaron Levitt 21/08/06
  86.   In other words... 19:01  |  Nadir 21/08/06
  87.   Not strong enough and missing too much detail 19:04  |  ahb 21/08/06
  88.   Have they not learned from the war? 19:20  |  Rudy 21/08/06
  89.   Amen Brothers 19:30  |  Ben 21/08/06
  90.   The process of investigation 19:30  |  David ben Avigdor 21/08/06
  91.   blunders 19:33  |  tony 21/08/06
  92.   responses 19:34  |  Jim 21/08/06
  93.   Ha`aretz Loves It 19:45  |  the logical nemesis 21/08/06
  94.   raymond deane 19:48  |  the logical nemesis 21/08/06
  95.   Anti Semetic 19:51  |  Ben 21/08/06
  96.   I hope they get a response 19:55  |  btmb01 21/08/06
  97.   Until there is personal accountability to the electorate... 20:07  |  George Washington 21/08/06
  98.   Response to Spearhead Protest Petition 20:15  |  M G Cashman 21/08/06
  99.   libanese terrorists in germany 20:20  |  Axel 21/08/06
  100.   IDF Petition 20:24  |  Chris 21/08/06
  101.   ...well said... 20:27  |  Martin 21/08/06
  102.   Protest petition by IDF reservists back from war 20:32  |  Bob 21/08/06
  103.   yeah right?! 20:32  |  bob 21/08/06
  104.   next war 21:10  |  jehuda arieh veenman 21/08/06
  105.   Olmert saved Israel 21:13  |  Cynthia Foyles 21/08/06
  106.   the battle you did not do 21:14  |  ana 21/08/06
  107.   A to 69.. Basic Key..Stop the Occupation 21:18  |  David 21/08/06
  108.   #73, logical nemesis 21:26  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 21/08/06
  109.   Diplomacy? 21:27  |  Jeffrey A. Whittingt 21/08/06
  110.   David Ben Avigdor 21:30  |  Gabe1 21/08/06
  111.   Catholic killer Raymond Deane raises his voice again 21:33  |  Absolute Sweden 21/08/06
  112.   "Best Peace Made w/Strong Adversary" 21:33  |  Dave 21/08/06
  113.   Clear Objective 21:40  |  Melony 21/08/06
  114.   Soldiers complaining are just pathetic 21:40  |  marte 21/08/06
  115.   To Nr.78, Axel 21:47  |  Guenny 21/08/06
  116.   bob 21:47  |  the logical nemesis 21/08/06
  117.   you all dont no what your talking obout 22:01  |  josef 21/08/06
  118.   #70 David ben Avigdor 22:06  |  mariana 21/08/06
  119.   The end 22:07  |  Alfredo 21/08/06
  120.   Cipora Julianna Kohn 22:11  |  the logical nemesis 21/08/06
  121.   thank you soldiers 22:13  |  jacques 21/08/06
  122.   Next War 22:19  |  Mike 21/08/06
  123.   Nadir #66 22:21  |  Jon 21/08/06
  124.   Protest Petition 22:30  |  B.D 21/08/06
  125.   Yaffe Nefesh telling soldiers no tto think..shame! 22:35  |  Marshall 21/08/06
  126.   Protest petition by IDF reservists 22:43  |  Tony M 21/08/06
  127.   The UN, eu AND THE MEDIA 22:49  |  Chad 21/08/06
  128.   `The war`s aim ... 22:55  |  Karl 21/08/06
  129.   IDF Petition 22:56  |  Lt Col Barkdull 21/08/06
  130.   A bunch of angry soldiers playing right wing politics 22:57  |  Ibrahim 21/08/06
  131.   War 23:03  |  K 21/08/06
  132.   TO EVERYONE OF MY PEOPLE.WHAT AN INDICTEMENT THIS IS!! 23:17  |  Kathy 21/08/06
  133.   signatories will soon be gratified 23:18  |  boggled mind 21/08/06
  134.   To Israel 23:24  |  Christopher 21/08/06
  135.   Marc Licoln, this is why the boys failed 23:25  |  Dave 21/08/06
  136.   LET GENERALS RUN THE WAR 23:25  |  Joyce 21/08/06
  137.   # 1 Mike. Weak-hearted Politicians undermining Israel`s potential 23:26  |  Kathy 21/08/06
  138.   juliana #85 23:26  |  Gabe1 21/08/06
  139.   Ibrahim 23:32  |  Gabe1 21/08/06
  140.   # 16 Proud Zionist. YOU ARE BEING FAR TOO KIND IN YOUR RESPONSE.. 23:39  |  Kathy 21/08/06
  141.   Mr. Ben Avigdor - It has been shocking 23:39  |  Mark Lincoln 21/08/06
  142.   stand firm guys 23:40  |  Zack 21/08/06
  143.   Lt. Col Barkdull 23:44  |  Mark Lincoln 21/08/06
  144.   Listen to the Spearhead Batt. 23:58  |  Lee 21/08/06
  145.   #2 Jack was never a soldier 00:00  |  Lee 22/08/06
  146.   When the message is wrong, no messanger is right 00:01  |  Dave 22/08/06
  147.   We pray for Israel 00:08  |  R. Carney 22/08/06
  148.   Too bad US Units... 00:14  |  XZ 22/08/06
  149.   BB 00:21  |  dov 22/08/06
  150.   IBRAHIM the IDF expert.YOUR people started these hostilities 00:26  |  PETER SM 22/08/06
  151.   Dullbark sorry Lt.Col Barkdul 00:28  |  Shoshanna 22/08/06
  152.   Marianna #97 00:43  |  David ben Avigdor 22/08/06
  153.   IDF we support u! Bring back the Likud 01:11  |  Ryan Sou 22/08/06
  154.   David ben Avigdor #121 01:30  |  Gabe1 22/08/06
  155.   IDF Petition 01:46  |  Dwight 22/08/06
  156.   Soldiers Need More Involvement with the Political Process 01:52  |  Robert 22/08/06
  157.   Madness 01:56  |  The glass darkly 22/08/06
  158.   IBRAHIMHow much of Israel did the Army of Allah liberate? 02:14  |  PETER SM 22/08/06
  159.   to Cynthia Foyles - You Saved Israel 02:28  |  Catman 22/08/06
  160.   THIS IS A HOLY PROTEST AND BIBI IS NOT THE MAN 02:28  |  MEIR WEINSTEIN 22/08/06
  161.   RE 62 Agreement 02:33  |  Alan 22/08/06
  162.   Cynthia Foyles 02:35  |  Han Barboot 22/08/06
  163.   Re 52 balance 02:38  |  Alan 22/08/06
  164.   LT Col Barkdull.It is just the spinless hoping to save themselves 02:39  |  PETER SM 22/08/06
  165.   IDF should never have gone into Lebanon 02:39  |  peter 22/08/06
  166.   Exactly Dave 02:48  |  Mark Lincoln 22/08/06
  167.   Israeli Defense Force - Dave 02:57  |  Mark Lincoln 22/08/06
  168.   I har you Lee 02:59  |  Mark Lincoln 22/08/06
  169.   Joyce, I hate to explain that Santa Clause 03:07  |  Mark Lincoln 22/08/06
  170.   Mr. ben Avigdor - Greyscale and Ben Gurion 03:18  |  Mark Lincoln 22/08/06
  171.   Food for thought 03:18  |  Loco 22/08/06
  172.   IDF should never have gone into Lebanon? 03:25  |  Mark Lincoln 22/08/06
  173.   # 58 Judas. EXCUSE ME? PUNKED OUT?WEEKEND WARIORS,IS THAT WHAT... 03:48  |  Kathy 22/08/06
  174.   IDF`s deterioration; MARK LINCOLN 03:53  |  Oetis 22/08/06
  175.   Protest Petition-failure to attack the disease 03:53  |  pat moran 22/08/06
  176.   # 97 the logical nemesis.re: Cipora J.K .(YOU WERE CORRECT.)..... 03:59  |  Kathy 22/08/06
  177.   # 44 Cipora J.K. democracy at work.WHAT DO YOU MEAN ??... 04:18  |  Kathy 22/08/06
  178.   Men don`t kvetch 04:21  |  kumbayaaah 22/08/06
  179.   mark lincoln dont be naive 04:22  |  houndnose 22/08/06
  180.   Ground troops, not bombs 04:29  |  Patrick Marshall 22/08/06
  181.   David ben Avigdor #121 04:37  |  Gabe1 22/08/06
  182.   #141, Kathy 04:43  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 22/08/06
  183.   hizbullah has had more than enough of the IDF 05:18  |  peter 22/08/06
  184.   Professional Bloggers at Work on this Talkback - Bigtime 05:21  |  dave 22/08/06
  185.   Holy Land should be Holy, don`t you think? 05:43  |  Danielle 22/08/06
  186.   Civilians Should Petition 07:13  |  kumbayaaah 22/08/06
  187.   # 148=I couldn`t agree more with you! 09:41  |  Mark 22/08/06
  188.   governments vs military 16:27  |  gene 22/08/06
  189.   War only works when: 18:10  |  Steve 22/08/06
  190.   Danielle - #185 19:09  |  the logical nemesis 22/08/06
  191.   Worthless Petition: Part I 21:14  |  Michael 22/08/06
  192.   Worthless Petition: Part 2 21:26  |  Michael 22/08/06
  193.   Worthless Petition: Part 3 21:35  |  Michael 22/08/06
  194.   Protest Petition by IDF Reservists 21:35  |  Gizelle 22/08/06
  195.   To the writer of #131 "K" I couldnt agree more 22:55  |  Sapien 22/08/06
  196.   RE: #131 K 00:00  |  Chad 23/08/06
  197.   K - #131 02:39  |  the logical nemesis 23/08/06
  198.   Sapien - #195 02:45  |  the logical nemesis 23/08/06
  199.   Re WAR 03:48  |  K 23/08/06
  200.   K - #199 06:53  |  the logical nemesis 23/08/06
  201.   #105. Olmert saved Israel 12:32  |  Bryant 24/08/06
  202.   i support the petition 18:12  |  Arthur Sherman 26/08/06
  203.   Soldiers complaints 14:53  |  Rhoda 30/08/06
  204.   169- Mark Lincoln 01:53  |  Joyce 17/09/06
 Today Online
Why world jihad is doomed
Responses: 231
U.S. diplomats begin viewing Lebanon war as success
Responses: 198
Pope 'sorry' speech on Mohammed seen as hurtful to Muslims
Responses: 635
Israel must be made to conform to international law
Responses: 207
Yossi Sarid: Shimon Peres is Ehud Olmert's poodle
Responses: 34
Rosner's Domain
* The Ethiopian roller coaster: can you decide already?
* New poll: Should Israel negotiate with Syria?
* Mid-term diary: Terrorism is more important
* A dialog with Charles Bronfman


More Headlines
01:21 Pope 'sorry' his speech is seen as hurtful to Muslims
01:44 U.S. tells Abbas aides it won't abandon Quartet demands of PA
00:52 Another Katsav associate under investigation in pardons affair
01:05 Shas spiritual leader in hospital for second time in a week
00:52 Israeli Arabs file appeal for equal war compensation
20:22 Islamic Movement head: J'lem destined capital of caliphate
17:07 Red Cross says it met Hezbollah guerillas held captive in Israel
20:52 Report: Russian battalion to spend up to 3 months in Lebanon
23:53 Haniyeh sees 'lots of movement' in talks on Shalit's release
18:03 Jordan's Abdullah warns U.S. mistakes since 2001 fueling terrorism
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Nahal Haredi
Defending Israel's homeland. Help support our troops
EZER MIZION
Help those that need it most!
One year MBA in Israel
Taught entirely in English
LEUMI
During your visit in Israel Bank Only With the Leader
JOIN FREE AT JDate.com
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
ISRAEL-SHOPS ONLINE STORE
Gifts from Israel + FREE ISRAELI FLAG ON EVERY PURCHASE OVER $50
Isrotel Chain
Eleven quality hotels in Israel's best locations
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
FREE REGISTRATION at JLove.com
Join The Fastest Growing Jewish Singles Community Now! Click Here!
Babylon 6
Text Translation at a single click, from any desktop application. Try it Now
HAARETZ SMS
Register Now to receive your daily news by SMS
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved