Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., December 01, 2009 Kislev 14, 5770 | | Israel Time: 18:33 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Painting depicting captured Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit in Jerusalem.
(Reuters)
Share |
Last update - 21:09 29/11/2009
Excuses to let Gilad Shalit die just don't hold up
By Zvi Bar'el
Tags: Hamas, Middle East peace 

Like after every leak about the fate of Gilad Shalit, they're back in the public square, like deflated beach balls that got a shot of some air, singing their same old songs. "Releasing terrorists will bring terror," they warn. "Hamas will grow stronger," "Israel has been vanquished," they say, frothing at the mouth. Each has impressive data on terror attacks carried out by released prisoners: 30, 60, even 70 percent of these terrorists return to killing Jews. Grim figures indeed, enough to make one decide, "Let Shalit die - just don't let civilians be killed." Staff Sgt. Gilad Shalit is like the finger in the dike - as long as he's in captivity and the prisoners are locked up, our lives are secure, the prestige of the State of Israel has been upheld and Hamas will continue to wallow in its misery.

The thousands of Qassams and mortars fired on Sderot and its environs can be forgotten, as long as Shalit stays where he is and the prisoners are behind bars. Also forgotten are all the terror attacks in Jerusalem, Netanya and Hadera long before Shalit was seized and while thousands of Palestinians were already imprisoned. Those ominous statistics about freed terrorists do not indicate how many attacks were executed by those who had never been jailed, or were jailed only after staging attacks. How easy it is to present a false, distorted picture showing the profound connection between freeing terrorists and terror attacks, one that ignores the fact that for 42 years, the motivation for such attacks was not freeing prisoners, but ending the occupation.

The voices in the public square demand a "public dialogue," "open debate," "transparency." They want to know how much blood is on the hands of each prisoner set to be released, as if there were a direct link between the amount of blood a terrorist has spilled and the amount he will spill in the future. And where were they over the last three and a half years? Did no one know that it wasn't exactly Bratslav Hasidim slated to be freed? And how about their sudden demand to differentiate between those who killed one Jew and those who killed 10, between a little blood and a lot?
Advertisement
But if the mathematics of terror attest to the difficulty in understanding its rationale, perhaps the argument against strengthening Hamas is even more amusing. This line of thinking holds that negotiations over an exchange for Shalit are merely a Hamas stunt. The very existence of talks over his release, they say, grants the group cachet it never had, all the more so if Israel accedes to its demands.

Is that really so? Hamas proved its prestige in 2006, when it won a large majority in the Palestinian general election. Back then, it did not need an Israeli captive or a prisoner release. It seized authority in Gaza because no party - not Israel nor Fatah, nor the countries of the Quartet - agreed to recognize its esteemed position. Hamas continued to grow stronger as it became clear that without it, there was no point in holding diplomatic discussions on any part of Palestine. Reconciliation talks between Fatah and Hamas, plans to create a new Palestine Liberation Organization including Hamas as a senior partner - all of these testify to Hamas' power.

The movement's influence rose further with its Qassam war on Israel, its reticence in the face of Israel's cruel sanctions on the Gaza Strip, and during Operation Cast Lead. Hamas essentially became the axis around which disputes were played out between Egypt and Syria, and Saudi Arabia and Iran. All of these are independent of Shalit. There is no doubt that the release of Palestinian prisoners will significantly enhance Hamas' prestige, but that is ultimately another matter altogether - Israel will pay a dear price for dragging its feet. And what did the chatterers in the public square do to bolster Hamas' rival? For an answer to that question, ask Mahmoud Abbas why he has decided to resign.

The real question now is not what kind of victory Hamas will come away with, but what Israel is likely to lose. If Shalit is not freed because of Israel's inspections of bloodied hands, if he continues to suffocate in his dungeon, Israel will lose a living soldier, a living human being. His blood will be on the government's hands. But Shalit will not disappear - every day he will be lost all over again, and these talks will turn into an endless discourse, just one confined to the public square.
PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
A new peace plan
Palestinian-American journalist Hanania proposes a plan that swaps settlers for Palestinians.
Top Israeli gadgets
They keep your legs smooth, back up your files, and upload your photos.
  1.   Looks like the Shalit deal is dead! 08:22  |  MARK KLEIN, M.D. 29/11/09
  2.   Any Price? 10:39  |  ERSB 29/11/09
  3.   What Price? 10:48  |  ERSB 29/11/09
  4.   Correct, Zvi Barel 11:41  |  sh 29/11/09
  5.   above 12:13  |  moishe 29/11/09
  6.   Not Very Convincing 12:19  |  Dani 29/11/09
  7.   shalit freedom 12:44  |  arye 29/11/09
  8.   phrases like "frothing at the mouth" disqualify your point 12:54  |  Eli 29/11/09
  9.   Where were they over the last three and a half years? 12:56  |  Roby Buzaglo 29/11/09
  10.   What other country has agreed to a similar exchange? 13:16  |  David 29/11/09
  11.   Gilad is Our Son: All Are Sons, Bibi! 13:29  |  Moshe Chertoff 29/11/09
  12.   Zvi Barel has good points but his argument has flaws as well - 13:51  |  ivo 29/11/09
  13.   Who have blood on their hands? 14:38  |  Jacob 29/11/09
  14.   Shalit deal will encourage more abductions 15:01  |  Eytan Dayag 29/11/09
  15.   Zvi Bar`el - Short Sighted 15:28  |  Yisroel 29/11/09
  16.   Shalit Deal is About Shalit! #6 Eytan 15:59  |  Moshe Chertoff 29/11/09
  17.   "let Gilad Shalit die" - The left does not use 16:12  |  17 29/11/09
  18.   #4 Get the facts right 17:03  |  Keeping u honest 29/11/09
  19.   Bar`el the terrorist apologist 17:38  |  Proud Israeli 29/11/09
  20.   answer to 17 17:43  |  flo 29/11/09
  21.   # 20 Flo - thank you for an answer. What was the question? 18:05  |  17 29/11/09
  22.   Before another is captured 18:32  |  Mark Lincoln 29/11/09
  23.   # 14 Eytan 18:38  |  Joel 29/11/09
  24.   Just encouraging kidnapping 19:39  |  Shimon 29/11/09
  25.   Of course, a living human being is a living human being. 20:09  |  sandra chitayat 29/11/09
  26.   Excuses to Let Gilad Shalit Die 20:53  |  Yosef Leibowitz 29/11/09
  27.   DO NOT FREE SHALIT 21:27  |  Jewish Guy 29/11/09
  28.   not freeing prisoners, but ending the occupation. 21:38  |  Jerry 29/11/09
  29.   Zvi Bar`e``s article and the good of the country 00:22  |  eaglesfanforever 30/11/09
  30.   One for one 04:29  |  Jordan 30/11/09
  31.   Release Gilad Shalit now. Achshav! 05:48  |  S.Saks 30/11/09
  32.   Bring Gilad Shalit home to his family 13:54  |  richelle 30/11/09
  33.   logic trumps sentiment 17:17  |  jon 30/11/09
  34.   Have mercy bring Gilad home, do not live for vengance 20:43  |  Jonathan 30/11/09
  35.   Where is the spirit of Entebbe? 21:46  |  L Foster 30/11/09
Special Offers
Advertisement
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
Award-Winning 'Obsession'
Watch 'Obsession: Radical Islam's War Against the West' Online FOR FREE!
Protea Hills
A Retirement Village in Nature Nestled in the Foothills of Jerusalem
Date Local Jewish Singles
Ready to meet your match? Join Jdate today!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
More Headlines
18:09 Court: Details of Shalit deal must be kept secret
18:20 Israel: EU stance on Jerusalem harms peace talks
17:46 Haaretz Exclusive: EU draft document on division of Jerusalem
18:20 Prosecutors: Demjanjuk willingly participated in the Holocaust
18:21 Settlers block Israeli inspectors enforcing West Bank freeze
18:18 IAEA to tell Iran: Explain plan for more nuclear facilities
15:45 How does the U.S. help fund pro-settler IDF troops?
15:42 David Makovsky / Obama and Netanyahu: Lessons of 2009
15:39 New IDF unit to fight enemies on Facebook, Twitter
00:15 TV ROUND-UP: Demjanjuk trial begins; settlers vow to prevent freeze
18:03 Ex-IDF officer: I claimed to be a pedophile to get out of army
18:14 UN nuclear watchdog gets new chief, amid growing Iran crisis
15:42 Jewish youth lightly hurt by Arab protester in East Jerusalem
14:01 Police question 70 schoolkids in Haifa drug bust
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
| Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
| Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved