Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., November 03, 2009 Cheshvan 16, 5770 | | Israel Time: 02:13 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Share |
Swedish reporter in Israel: Not all criticism of you is anti-Semitism
By Gideon Levy, Haaretz Correspondent
Tags: Sweden, Israel News 

Donald Bostrom didn't know he needed this. With Moses, a gigantic bodyguard in a suit and tie watching over his Tel Aviv hotel room with an earpiece and a concealed gun; with a handful of demonstrators who greeted him in the wee hours of the morning at Ben-Gurion International Airport; and with the program for his visit to Israel, in which it is explained that during his trip to attend the Dimona Media Conference, he will be accompanied by two bodyguards, that the details of his visit will be "classified" and that he will wait in a "security room" before and after an interview to be conducted with him today by Yair Lapid.

Donald Bostrom didn't know he needed this. He arrived here Sunday, in an attempt to explain to Israelis what he meant in his scandalous article about alleged organ harvesting by the Israel Defense Forces - a brave step on his part and a no-less-brave step on the part of the organizers of the Dimona conference - who were already attacked by Minister Silvan Shalom, who decided to boycott the gathering and withdraw the money his ministry had pledged to the conference.

"Is it possible here to retroactively cancel an allocation for a conference?" asks the musician and exiled artist Dror Feiler, who is accompanying Bostrom on his visit, and who also had a scandal in his past, the scandal of the blood in the "Snow White and The Madness of Truth" installation he exhibited in Stockholm in January 2004.
Advertisement
Bostrom seems a little embarrassed about the reception he is getting. We ate breakfast at his hotel, which borders on Am Yisrael Hai ("the people of Israel live") Street, and then we went up to his room which overlooks the sea. There he showed me the pictures he had taken of the body of the stone thrower, Bilal Ghanan, from the village of Imatin in the northern West Bank who had been shot by IDF soldiers on May 13, 1992.

The mortally wounded Ghanan was evacuated to the hospital by an Israel army helicopter and his dead body was returned to his family five days later, sewn up along its length, while Bostrom was in the village. Bostrom says the family is entitled to know what happened to their son, why his body was autopsied without his family's permission and whether the rumors are correct that his internal organs were removed at the Abu Kabir Institute of Forensic Medicine.

This legitimate demand was presented by Bostrom in a very problematic article in which he hints that Palestinians were abducted and their bodies were returned without organs. The context in which he published the article, apropos of the trade in body organs by some Jews in New Jersey, also added a problematic and loaded dimension to the article. Bostrom says he published Ghanan's story in a book he wrote several years ago and also tried to have it published in the Swedish newspaper Dagens Nyheter which rejected it. He finally published it in the tabloid Aftonbladet in its daily cultural supplement, when the story about the New Jersey Jews broke.

He apparently understands that the connection between New Jersey and the suspicion, which Bostrom does not prove, of garnering organs from the Palestinians, can provide inflammatory material for anti-Semitic groups.

Bostrom says he did not like the headline given to the article: "Our sons are plundered of their organs", but he understands that the responsibility for the article lies with him. He says that dozens of Palestinians believe their family members' organs were stolen.

You have already had scandals at your forensic institute with other bodies, he says, and there is illegal trade in organs, so there is a need to investigate.

This experienced photographer and journalist who has visited Israel more than 40 times, who has published many of his photographs in the journal of the Swedish Palestinian solidarity movement, who once before also aroused a similar uproar after an article about mass killings in Ethiopia, understands that he made some mistakes in his article.

It is doubtful whether he agrees that the call for an investigation should have been directed first and foremost at him before he published the suspicions. Their publication without any factual support is not professional journalism. That is why it is good he was invited to come here and that is why it is good that he came.

Are you sorry about anything?

"I'm sorry there are so many lies about me. Like for example that they say I wrote that the soldiers hunted for youths so as to take their organs. It's obvious that's a lie. Even the Palestinians don't make a claim like that. And the other side attributes anti-Semitism to me. I'm sorry about that. I'm sorry I've become a political tool. I'm sorry the article caused damage to the struggle for human rights here. And above all, I'm sorry that no one took the article seriously and that they did not examine the suspicions. In Sweden too they didn't take it seriously."

Would you write it differently now?

"If I were writing it again, I would stress that the IDF liquidates so many youths without a trial and that they take bodies and conduct autopsies on them without the permission of the families. My article created confusion and was incorrectly interpreted. I admire your democratic courage to invite me to explain myself here."

Do you think the IDF killed people to get body organs?

"I don't think soldiers behaved like that. I don't think they killed in order to gather organs. The truth is that they kill them without a trial and their bodies are taken to Abu Kabir. We don't know whether they take out the organs. That has still to be further investigated. No one opened up the bodies after they were returned and only one man knows the truth, Prof. Yehuda Hiss, the director of the forensic institute.

So why did you publish baseless accusations?

"I think the article led to good things and bad things, but now it is on the table. Israeli journalists must investigate. You have done good things in the past. Haaretz gives better coverage of the conflict than the Swedish papers, so go on investigating this. There are a lot of question marks."

Are you anti-Semitic?

"Of course not. I am sad. I am angry that my article has been used for political purposes. Not every criticism of Israel is anti-Semitism. Like all the Swedes, I support Israel's right to exist, but I want a more just Israel. We have a tradition in Sweden of standing by international law and when you violate it, it arouses anger. Take this article seriously. The Palestinian families are entitled to know what happened to their loved ones. I am talking about compassion and human rights."

Related articles:
  • Rightists confront 'IDF organ trafficking' reporter at Israel airport
  • Swede who reported on 'IDF organ trafficking' coming to Israel
  • Swedish paper behind IDF organ theft claims warns against Muslim threat
    • PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
    Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Obama? No thanks
    Why, despite high percentages of support for peace, do most Israelis dislike Obama?
    Oshrenko killer found
    Man killed three generations of Rishon Lezion family after they fired him from their restaurant
      1.   criticism 03:53  |  Shmuelshachor 02/11/09
      2.   More than Dozens of Pals think 03:56  |  Brad 02/11/09
      3.   But why bother, I mean the WORLD is full of things to Criticize?? 04:35  |  David P. 02/11/09
      4.   Liquidate this 04:39  |  David K 02/11/09
      5.   Bostrom hasn`t changed my opinion of him much 04:51  |  dave 02/11/09
      6.   Like all swedes?? 05:31  |  Notatallconvinced 02/11/09
      7.   A "gang up" on Israel is still a gang up. It is anti-Semitism 05:45  |  Jason 02/11/09
      8.   Two equally false propositions 06:14  |  The Prophet 02/11/09
      9.   What about compasion on Gilad - 06:24  |  Alfred 02/11/09
      10.   Not every criticism is antisemitism, your baseless accusation is. 06:25  |  Eve 02/11/09
      11.   He caused huge damage to Palestinian cause 06:37  |  Angry Arab (As`ad) 02/11/09
      12.   But libel is!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 06:39  |  Dan 02/11/09
      13.   If you think Jews unlike all other dont deserve state, you are!!! 06:43  |  Dan 02/11/09
      14.   Basic fact: Human organs cannot be taken from dead cavaders not 07:07  |  on life support 02/11/09
      15.   This has to end 07:19  |  Nicholas 02/11/09
      16.   He is a complete anti-semite and all his writings are racist. 07:29  |  Alan 02/11/09
      17.   Bolstrom`s Stonethrower 07:32  |  Stan 02/11/09
      18.   To Angry Arab 07:50  |  Indeed... 02/11/09
      19.   He is pure 07:56  |  Rory 02/11/09
      20.   Swedish Reporter Should Eat Vegetarian In Israeli Restaruants 08:51  |  Anonymous 02/11/09
      21.   bostrom and international what ?? 09:39  |  vhardman 02/11/09
      22.   We, the Jews, know better about the science of anti-semitism... 10:38  |  S 02/11/09
      23.   Swedish insect got opinion 11:11  |  17 02/11/09
      24.   Gideon an expert on all things antisemetic 11:27  |  Chaim Ben Kahan 02/11/09
      25.   israel is not arbiter of what is antisemitism and what is not 11:52  |  mehmet 02/11/09
      26.   As an editor 14:01  |  Jackie 02/11/09
      27.   David K, do you dispute his observation in the face of the facts? 14:03  |  BBSNews 02/11/09
      28.   Not even Haaretz ... 14:05  |  Motic 02/11/09
      29.   antisemite? 14:48  |  Stan 02/11/09
      30.   Dror Feiler 15:31  |  Sarah 02/11/09
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
    Date Local Jewish Singles
    Ready to meet your match? Join Jdate today!
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    More Headlines
    23:39 Abbas tells Obama envoy he's adamant on settlement freeze
    23:23 Clinton says nuclear proposal to Iran `will not change`
    23:45 'I have no proof the IDF harvests Palestinians' organs'
    21:59 'Russian who spied on Israel shot dead in Moscow'
    17:11 Israel frees six Hamas leaders arrested after Shalit abduction
    23:04 In wake of family murder MKs seek death penalty for child killers
    19:49 Why do Israelis dislike Barack Obama?
    21:45 Twitter co-founder Biz Stone expected to visit Israel
    07:19 TV ROUND-UP: Jewish terror suspect arrested; Turkey FM: No Israel alliance
    14:26 'There are Jewish terrorists still at large in Israel'
    11:06 Why I'm still a proud West Bank settler
    13:35 One in every four Israelis lives below poverty line
    18:25 Settlements are fertile ground for Jewish terror
    14:38 Report: Mossad hacked Syrian computer to uncover nuke site
    13:56 How Israel caught the suspected Jewish terrorist
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
    | Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
    | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved