Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., November 04, 2009 Cheshvan 17, 5770 | | Israel Time: 10:39 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Share |
Last update - 10:32 30/10/2009
How can J Street support and question Israel at the same time?
By J.J. Goldberg, The Forward
Tags: zionism, J Street 

The first national conference of J Street, the self-described "pro-Israel, pro-peace" lobby, convened October 25 in Washington, D.C., with all the understated reserve of a new iPhone launch or the christening of the Queen Mary. Gathered in a swank hotel a short walk from the White House, some 1,500 activists from across the country sat through hours of speeches by big-shot politicians and diplomats, earnestly debated tactics and philosophy, handed out awards over chicken dinners and jabbered excitedly in the corridors. Outwardly it looked like any other major Jewish organization rallying its troops and flexing its muscles.

But this was, as J Streeters boasted and critics complained, no ordinary Jewish convention. These conventioneers were rallying not to defend Israeli actions and reaffirm Jewish virtue but to challenge and question. It's no easy trick these days to convince 1,500 Jewish liberals to pay their own way to Washington for the purpose of fighting over Jewish values. J Street's success in pulling it off surely earns them some bragging rights, whatever one thinks of their positions.

Up to a point, that is. J Street's conference was an impressive feat, but it's not quite the game-changer it's been made out to be - at least, not yet. On examination, this shiny new vehicle turns out to have a few kinks built into its design. They'll have to be addressed if the organization hopes to succeed.
Advertisement
The core problem is that J Street has two main stated goals, and they don't really fit together. The first goal is to "broaden" the definition of what it means to be pro-Israel, to open up Jewish community discourse to a wider range of acceptable opinions. The second goal is to lobby for an Israeli-Palestinian peace accord that leads to a two-state solution. It became evident during the convention that you can't do both.

By advertising itself as a forum for free and open discussion of Israel, warts and all, the conference predictably attracted a contingent of Jews who are ambivalent or hostile toward Israel. They weren't on the program, but they spoke up in breakout sessions and gathered in clusters in the hallways. Some came to paint Israel as the guilty party and argue for sweeping Israeli concessions without regard for Israel's security. Some opposed the very idea of Jewish statehood. Most came to Washington expecting to help shape J Street's goals and gain political influence for their views.

What they found was an organization that defines itself as wholly committed to Israeli security, that favors an Israeli-Palestinian accord as a way to ensure Israel's security as a Jewish state. If that wasn't obvious beforehand, J Street's architect and executive director, Jeremy Ben-Ami, pointedly drew a line in the sand in an October 23 interview with journalist Jeffrey Goldberg (full disclosure: not me) on the Web site of The Atlantic.

Sounding more hawkish than he had in the past, Ben-Ami ruled out cuts in American military aid to Israel, endorsed the Law of Return, denounced the so-called "one-state solution" and repeatedly distanced himself from individuals and groups on the left that reject Zionism. Arriving at the conference two days later, the outliers - let's call them "un-Zionists" - were in an ornery mood, feeling duped and gobsmacked. In one breakout session on how broadly to define "pro-Israel" (full disclosure: this was moderated by yours truly) one audience member emotionally protested the very idea that she should define herself as pro-Israel. At another session, a participant objected to the suggestion that advocates of territorial compromise should emphasize their love of Israel. Some greeted Rabbi Eric Yoffie of the Union for Reform Judaism with boos when he criticized the Goldstone report.

All this left J Street in a ticklish position. By calling for unfettered debate, it had essentially invited the un-Zionists to come and participate. Objecting to their presence would undercut its declared commitment to open discussion. But embracing them would undermine its credibility as a pro-Israel organization advocating compromise as a means to strengthen Israel's security, not weaken it. Ben-Ami and others argued that a firm pro-Israel stance would make the un-Zionists want to leave. But the un-Zionists gave no sign that they would leave willingly. J Street could be in for a fight that will leave it tainted with a McCarthyite image in the eyes of some liberals it needs to recruit.

The hard truth is that both of J Street's goals are important. Growing numbers of American Jews are struggling with their relationship to Israel. They shouldn't be cast out. The community urgently needs a forum for members to engage over their differences rather than turn their backs on one another. It also needs a strong voice for security through peace and compromise. But they're two different jobs. One vehicle can't do both.

Related articles:
  • Sure, J Street is pro-peace - but is it pro-Israel?
  • Michael Oren has no right to snub J Street
  • J Street, ADL launch war of words over Obama Israel policy
    • PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
    Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Perils of anti-Semitism
    Is the West ignoring Islamist hatred of Jews as much as it did Nazi manifestations?
    From Iran to Hamas
    Hamas has reportedly test-fired a missile - supplied by Iran - capable of hitting Tel Aviv.
      1.   How question and support at the same time? Very simple:... 11:25  |  S 30/10/09
      2.   very simple answer 21:09  |  michael 30/10/09
      3.   The Mixed Multitude. 18:11  |  JMK 31/10/09
      4.   J Street is Advocacy for Americcans and Amer. Jews 20:48  |  Stephen 31/10/09
      5.   Simple 21:07  |  Bazmann 31/10/09
      6.   love and criticism 22:04  |  Arieh Zimmerman 31/10/09
      7.   Support Jewish Values, Not Nation-State Values 22:43  |  Vladek 31/10/09
      8.   Anti-Semitic "Jews" 00:27  |  Frank 01/11/09
      9.   ill formulated 01:27  |  zeev 01/11/09
      10.   Excellent rebuttal of JStreet 05:20  |  John Brown 01/11/09
      11.   Is J Street being honest? I don`t think so 08:34  |  Joe Sittizen 01/11/09
      12.   Attending the J Street conference 15:14  |  Ussishkin 01/11/09
      13.   j street---support and question Israel at same time 22:51  |  paul stock 01/11/09
      14.   who said that questioning is lack of support?? 00:04  |  kat 02/11/09
      15.   # 8 Frank from Oakland 17:16  |  Stephen 02/11/09
      16.   J Street 23:19  |  Misaac 03/11/09
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
    Date Local Jewish Singles
    Ready to meet your match? Join Jdate today!
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    More Headlines
    10:33 Navy commandos storm arms-laden ship off Israeli coast
    05:19 U.S. House backs resolution to condemn Goldstone Gaza report
    09:42 Iran police clash with thousands of anti-Ahmadinejad protesters
    02:59 'Jewish terrorist' suspected in murder blamed on Palestinians
    10:31 B'Tselem: IDF probes alleged cases of harm to civilians in Gaza
    04:55 ANALYSIS / Israel preparing public for a new war in Gaza
    04:21 Iran twitchy since Israel strike on Syria nuke reactor
    22:04 TV ROUND-UP: Hamas missile can reach Tel Aviv, 'Taliban mother' sentenced to prison
    05:48 Will Israeli schools hop on the anti-obesity bandwagon?
    03:44 Keys to Kafka's Tel Aviv safe handed to estate executor
    06:08 Lador blasts Neeman: Splitting AG post will harm rule of law
    10:11 UN chief to Israel: End 'provocative actions' in East Jerusalem
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
    | Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
    | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved