Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., October 29, 2009 Cheshvan 11, 5770 | | Israel Time: 20:50 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Jewish World Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Focus U.S.A. Strenger than Fiction Business Travel Magazine Week's End Anglo File Books
Share |
J Street conference: Some successes and some awkward moments
By Natasha Mozgovaya, Haaretz U.S. Correspondent
Tags: Israel News, J Street 
If this new lobby wants to become a serious player in Mideast politics, it will have to work much harder.

WASHINGTON, D.C. - On Wednesday, the "pro-peace, pro-Israel" J Street organization was set to wrap up its first national conference here with a political extravaganza on Capitol Hill. Three days in, there have been some successes and some awkward moments.

The conference has brought together some 1,500 participants for discussions on politics, media, faith and culture; they have praised and criticized Barack Obama, applauded a lot (such as for Congressman Charles Boustany for being the only Republican who dared to attend one of the panels) and also booed a little (Rabbi Eric Yoffie, President of the Union for Reform Judaism, for castigating Richard Goldstone).

Too many times panelists have sounded too apologetic for the movement that claims to represent "the majority of the U.S. Jews." The applause for Representative Jan Schakowsky (D-IL), when she said that she never considered dropping out despite some good souls' warnings, was too enthusiastic. On the whole, for a major conference aimed at tackling important issues, too much time is being spent on trying to establish the organization's legitimacy.
Advertisement

The conference may have gained some publicity over Israeli Ambassador Michael Oren's refusal to attend, but the open letter it sent in response was unnecessary. In the future, the lobby will have to deal with Israeli officials, not only former and opposition lawmakers.

The event has not so far made for many headlines, but Obama's National Security Adviser, General James Jones, gave J Street a lot of credit in his keynote speech on Tuesday by saying that he was "honored" to be there, that he was representing the Obama administration, and that the administration would be represented at future J Street conferences. If the J Street PAC which fundraises for Congressmen is successful, then there is a good chance that Oren will not be able to ignore the next conference.

The letter to Oren was a poor start to the relationship. Behind the scenes, Israeli diplomats bitterly expressed the opinion that J Street used Oren to score free publicity. Despite the obvious gap between the position of the U.S. administration and that of the Israeli Government, there is still an open phone line between the Israeli embassy in Washington and Obama's people. Furthermore, press releases and open letters often complicate real diplomacy.

There is a good chance that J Street will persist in trying to boost its standing and influence, in part because of the Obama administration's somewhat hesitant pace of progress on a range of intricate issues.
The tensions between AIPAC, the older and stronger pro-Israel lobby, and J Street are likely to continue. Although no one can be certain what truly is good for Israel in the long run, it is safe to say that the bitter under-the-table rivalry between the two lobby groups will harm the state.

We are unlikely to see any camaraderie between the two lobbies, but a more civilized rivalry may yet be established. The current situation, in which both groups officially ignore each other while privately denigrating one another, is untenable. There is no reason for the peace camp to demonize AIPAC, and little too can be gained from dismissing J Street as amateurs that will soon disappear.

Capitol Hill is too small and the problems too pressing for such petty mind games; besides, the recent electoral smear campaign was troubling enough for many.

But inclusiveness has its own limitations. There is an obvious problem at the J Street conference over establishing a clear vision and agenda considering the plurality of voices represented and the clear generation gap. The attempts to define important parts of the agenda as alternatives to AIPAC won't take J Street too far beyond heated discussions in nice hotel rooms.

Over the past 18 months, J Street has made its name recognizable, and controversial. This week alone, I received many letters from angry readers who wrote, among other things, that "J Street is 10 percent Arab money, and George Soros is out to weaken AIPAC and get Israel to go back to the 1967 borders; J Street is not pro-Israel. They are pro-Obama."

Over the next few months, if this new lobby wants to remove the second label and become a serious player, it will have to work much harder. Now that controversy has been exhausted, it is time for the real test. The people of the Middle East are happy to sustain numerous organizations with endless conflict, but they would be even happier if one of those organizations would help solve it.

At any rate, J Street has already succeeded in one aspect where AIPAC has failed. This week, the Arab American Institute tabbed its Fall Arab Leadership Summit as "historic" because of meetings "with J Street and other pro-peace American Jewish leaders to support what so many believed could never be achieved - a collaboration between organizations representing Arab Americans and Jewish Americans, a collaboration dedicated to peace, justice, and prosperity in the autonomous states of Israel and Palestine."

Related articles:
  • Michael Oren ducks the question of J Street
  • Sure, J Street is pro-peace - but is it pro-Israel?
  • Poet booted from J Street meet for comparing Guantanamo to Auschwitz
    • PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
    Bookmark to del.icio.us  
     
    Rockets target Israel
    Lebanese troops found, dismantled 4 rockets ready for launching near Israel border
    Anti-Semitic joke
    French court fines comedian 10,000 euros after he invited Holocaust denier on stage
      1.   news article or opinion? 20:19  |  Shlomo 28/10/09
      2.   J Street represents a hopeful sign 20:33  |  WHG 28/10/09
      3.   a bit of both #1 20:36  |  always interested 28/10/09
      4.   J Street and A Street! (A for Arab) 21:05  |  Ed Elhaderi 28/10/09
      5.   J Street AIPAC and the rest of it. 21:22  |  Samuel Getz 28/10/09
      6.   J-Street should change their name to Joke Street. 21:35  |  4:20 28/10/09
      7.   a #2 proves, J-Street is hopeful sign for anti-Israel crowd 21:47  |  McQueen 28/10/09
      8.   J Street won`t last, even as you prop them up 21:53  |  henry 28/10/09
      9.   Big Success 22:01  |  Steve 28/10/09
      10.   Oslo`s Failure 22:04  |  Ron 28/10/09
      11.   J Street Stands for JOKE Street .. get it #2 22:21  |  disgusted 28/10/09
      12.   Civility 22:31  |  WHG 28/10/09
      13.   j street is like pizza hut, no one wants to eat there, ever 22:35  |  Pavel 28/10/09
      14.   #5, henry. Disappear? 22:43  |  zmogus 28/10/09
      15.   #5, henry. Disappear? 22:44  |  zmogus 28/10/09
      16.   J-Street or Jews into the street.. Another name for homeless? 22:50  |  Edward 28/10/09
      17.   I wish J-street all the best! 23:46  |  Jaap 28/10/09
      18.   Arab American Instititue Conference 00:04  |  Harry Gwizdowski 29/10/09
      19.   Isn`t it interesting 01:37  |  A TRUE American 29/10/09
      20.   J-Street The Best Hope For Peace...You don`t want peace don`t you 02:55  |  Ed 29/10/09
      21.   A bunch of Jews on their way out, embarrassed by IL`s struggle 03:37  |  G Marcus 29/10/09
      22.   Success: suckering leftists. Failure:Reality of Iran, much more 04:49  |  Jstreethasnosupport 29/10/09
      23.   J Street`s and Obama`s New Language 05:14  |  isaac 29/10/09
      24.   Boustany (an Arab American) seems more pro-Israel than J Street 05:19  |  Publius 29/10/09
      25.   J street 08:14  |  Sam the Muslim 29/10/09
      26.   Shameful to pretend it represents "the majority of the US Jews"!! 08:50  |  S 29/10/09
      27.   Why do Jews call other Jews "Self-Hating" if there`s Disagreement 16:11  |  Stephen 29/10/09
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Eldan Rent a Car
    Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
    Date Local Jewish Singles
    Ready to meet your match? Join Jdate today!
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
    More Headlines
    20:35 Gunman wounds two in attack on L.A. synagogue
    20:36 ADL voices 'deep concern' over L.A. synagogue shooting
    19:53 Obama to tell Rabin memorial: U.S.-Israel alliance is unbreakable
    19:30 At Rabin memorial, Netanyahu vows to fight political violence
    19:49 One person killed in suspected Mob 'work accident' in Bat Yam
    18:54 Iran hands over response to UN-proposed nuclear deal
    17:26 Poll: Anti-Semitic views in the U.S. at a historic low
    00:10 TV ROUND-UP: Rabin murder commemorated; child abuse suspect extradited
    17:37 Qaida-linked group in Lebanon claims rocket attack on Israel
    14:28 Are there 20,000 or 20,000,000 refugees in Israel?
    16:22 Turkey envoy: Good ties with Israel part of our global aspirations
    16:47 73 years later, row erupts over discovery of Beit Shearim caves
    Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
    | Advert: Recommended Restaurants | Makom: Engaging on Israel
    | Search engine marketing
    Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved